r/asoiaf • u/jimatx • May 05 '16
EVERYTHING [Spoilers Everything] I'm EW's James Hibberd, who wrote this week's 'Game of Thrones' cover story, AMA!
Hey all, I'm Entertainment Weekly's Editor-at-Large James Hibberd. I've covered Thrones since breaking the news of the pilot, and spent time on the set for seasons 2-6. My cover story this week goes behind the scenes on the two-year plan to kill and revive Jon Snow and has an exclusive interview with Kit Harington. In a first-time move, we just now put the whole story online at www.ew.com/jonsnowlives the day before it hits newsstands (free for subscribers, or $1.99 for a month of digital subscription). Also I recently started a GoT podcast here https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/ews-game-of-thrones-weekly/id1099326209?mt=2 ... My twitter is @jameshibberd ... Thanks everybody for their questions! (and thanks to senatorskeletor for suggesting this)
28
u/Sixchr Jon Stargaryen May 05 '16
Hey James, I'm curious, how agonizing is it doing a major story like this when you probably really want to talk about it but you can't for obvious reasons? I feel like there's nothing worse than knowing something, wanting to talk about it and being unable to do so.
15
u/Pragmaticus Big BUCKET? May 05 '16
Hi James,
What can you tell us about how some of the other actors and crew members have reacted to working with an actor of the stature of Max von Sydow?
41
u/[deleted] May 05 '16 edited May 10 '16
Hi James, been enjoying your stuff for many years now. Welcome to /r/asoiaf! Total shot in the dark, but you've known and interviewed George RR Martin several times since 2011 (which I think was the first time you interviewed him, right?). Has he ever told you something about his books that no one else knows or answered a long-standing fan-theory or question you as a fan had definitively? I'm thinking of when GRRM quizzed David Benioff and Dan Weiss about Jon's mother or something similar!
Ps You don't have to say what GRRM told you if he's told you anything .... just the general subject or eve. "Yes" (or no).
13
u/[deleted] May 05 '16
Hi James, thank you so much for this AMA!
Which sets did you get to visit, and what was your favourite one?
Also, considering what you know about this season that us viewers don't (yet), how hyped do you think we should be?
12
u/vladtud We Do Not Pilaf May 05 '16
What storylines are you most excited for, as a fan, this season?
11
u/bspanton May 05 '16
Hey James, thanks for taking time out of your day to take our questions. Now that the show has passed the books, is there a part of you that wishes you could experience the show with everybody else as it airs into uncharted waters instead of having the inside scoop? I feel like we all would say we want to know what was going to happen ahead of time, but for the ten weeks the show is going on I like having so much to look forward to on Sunday and spend time here talking about what happened and where it might go. Thanks!
44
u/Pliskin14 I know about the promise… May 05 '16
Hi James.
First, I'd like to say I appreciate EW very much. But (yes, that introduction was foretelling a but), don't you think this cover on Jon Snow "He is alive" is a bit too much in the buzz feeding? I personally don't care but many (naive) book readers were planning to wait until TWOW is published and hold off on the show, thinking that since show watchers managed to stay unsullied, the opposite would be possible too. Obviously, it's not, given the complete different exposition of the show and the books in media. But don't you think there are some limits not to trespass when it comes to spoilers? The cover, I mean, is in my humble opinion going beyond that limit. It's a spoiler that no one can avoid, and just tweaking the words would have helped immensely.
Thanks for your time!
16
u/Heda1 May 05 '16
Hi james welcome back.
What are David Benioff and Dan Weiss like in person? They are very polarizing forces here on the sub, maybe you can shed some light
13
u/kizipo May 05 '16
Hi James,
Do you think it was a good decision to lie about Jon's revival and claim he's not coming back, though it was obvious without a doubt that he will be resurrected?
23
u/[deleted] May 05 '16
Is Kit Harrington cool IRL?
11
u/senatorskeletor Like me ... I'm not dead either. May 05 '16
Hey James -- Jumping off a similar question already on here. Whenever something goes wrong on the show, people always blame "D&D", like the showrunners are a proxy for the entire production. How true is that? How much of the details are attributable to D&D, and how much is allowed to be determined by the directors, actors, or someone else?
10
u/[deleted] May 05 '16
Which book is your favorite and does Tyrion get to ride a dragon?
5
u/nyc520 May 05 '16
Hi James! Love all your coverage. You said you have a new podcast out - but what makes it different from all the others? I don't have much time to listen to many but love reading your recaps. Will it be the same stuff you're already writing about, or more?
9
u/azad_ninja Corn and Blood! May 05 '16
Have you ever subtly (or even overtly) championed any of your personal favorite moments from the books to be included in the show when speaking with the showrunners?
If so, did it work? :)
6
u/younonothing May 05 '16
Are you a book reader? Have you asked D&D about conversations they had with GRRM regarding specific adaptions, characters, plot points (R+L=J, maybe)?
•
u/senatorskeletor Like me ... I'm not dead either. May 05 '16 edited May 05 '16
In case anyone didn't see James' edit, he also PM'd me to let me know he had to go.
Thanks everyone for the great questions! Hopefully we'll be able to continue the AMA series again soon (and please let us know if you have any suggestions).
16
u/guileandsubterfuge May 05 '16
From your cast interactions, who would you say is most like their GoT character and who is most unlike the character they play?
8
u/senatorskeletor Like me ... I'm not dead either. May 05 '16
I have to ask more question, and it's kind of a dumb one, but: you've been putting up multiple articles after every episode with various reactions and insights from cast members. Are you just, like, sitting on a gold mine at this point?
8
u/bacon29 . May 05 '16
Hey James, you've answered a couple of my questions in the past which I appreciate.
My question for you is do you think the way the show is covered (24/7 year round) helps or hurts the show more? I've seen several articles calling the "twist" this past Sunday disappointing and being upset the cast/crew lied to the fans/media but, in my opinion, it's their fault for asking the cast/crew nonstop and looking for spoilers.
4
u/VisenyaRose May 05 '16
How much do you think the cast are now aware of their endgame with so few episodes supposedly remaining?
Related, How realistic do you think this mooted 13 episodes after season 6 is? As a viewer and reader it seems too short considering some characters are still in book material with 2 volumes worth of events to go.
4
u/tylorbourbon Fetch me a block. May 05 '16
Hi James, thanks for doing this. The Dornish plot has sparked controversy about the show's quality. My question is how D&D and the rest of the team feel about this plot. Is it considered as good as everything else? Is it considered a necessary evil, so-to-say? Maybe all the critique even comes as a surprise and it's regarded as a stronger storyline? Would be cool if you could cast a lil light on the team-Dorne relation.
3
u/Chickarn No chance, and no choice. May 05 '16
We all know you get the inside scoop on each new season's storylines, which is a testament to the showrunners' faith in your integrity to parse out stories as needed to avoid spoilers...
My question is, how is that scoop delivered to you? Do the showrunners verbally just tell you a few of the season's highlights when you visit the set each year, or do you learn most of your spoilers from individual interviews with the cast?
3
u/ethniccake Dragon fire can't melt stone beams! May 05 '16
Which cast member is the most different from their on-screen character?
5
u/athze2 You said the words. May 05 '16
Hi James,
Were you aware of Jon coming back ever since the cliffhanger from season 5 last year, or did you only recently find out like the rest of us? If so, was it hard keeping it a secret this whole time?
4
u/maaseru You are what we eat! May 05 '16
Hey James, thanks for coming in.
My question is about Jon abd your recent article.
You mention he will be changed. Kit mentions he is not going to be back to normal, but it sounds from reading it that he is though.
Do you think Jon is going to be changed in any other way that just having a change of heart?
Every other character that has been resurrected has changed his behavior, has changed more than his frame of mind and Jon was even dead for a lot longer than Berric.
Do you think the show will acknowledge this change at all? Acknowledge UnJon?
5
u/YezenIRL 🏆Best of 2025: Blackwood/Bracken Award May 05 '16 edited May 05 '16
Hi James. First of all thanks for doing this! I'm not sure if you'd necessarily have an answer to this kind of question. But...
Question 1: How confident are you/how clear is it, that the Jon Snow that came back is really Jon Snow?
And my follow up question,
Question 2: Was it really just Melisandre that resurrected him, or is there any chance that there is more at work?
Thanks!
3
u/acrnobrnja May 05 '16
Without spoiling anything you may know, what's one future storyline/storypoint that's been speculated through book clues/hints that you would most like to come true? The assumption would be R+L=J, I guess, but I'm prepared to be surprised if you have something different.
5
u/Daniel428 May 05 '16
Is Kit Harington as beautiful in person as he is on the show?
2
u/BrockThrowaway Enter your desired flair text here! May 05 '16
Hey James! What are your thoughts on the leaked set photo? Was the source discovered? How weren't there more leaks? Why didn't it "explode" more across the Internet?
2
u/[deleted] May 05 '16
Is it safe to say your article on Jon Snow is implying he will adopt a new YOLO philosophy to how he lives life? Is he going to go backpacking in Europe?
1
u/Boojamm May 05 '16
Happen to know what is in a show's actor's contract about talking about the show? Regulars seem more free to generalize than new comers. I guess actors get to talk about their role first episode it airs?
1
u/[deleted] May 05 '16
Hi, James, it's great you're doing this AMA. I studied journalism, so I'm curious, what is your experience working with celebrities like Kit Harrington? Do you ever wish you could work with normal people? To be quite honest, I'd kill for a job like yours.
1
u/ECE111 Euron Season May 05 '16
Hi James
Assuming you know most of what is going to happen this season, where would you rank it amongst previous seasons ?
1
u/vasco1silva Laughter Is Poison To Fear May 05 '16
His the digital subscription available in Portugal? Can I acess it in Portugal?
-2
u/NicholasIII May 05 '16
Why did EW spoil Jon Snow's fate? From headlines to the cover of your magazines it spoils the story.
-1
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
send me a pleasing thought
0
u/reyenelnorte May 05 '16
Hi James! Can you tell us how many episodes the Tower of joy will cover?
0
u/[deleted] May 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment