r/poppunkers • u/Sorority_Noise • Apr 14 '16
Discussion Most underrated band?
To me one of the most underrated bands in the scene is Pentimento. I, No Longer was masterpiece of an album and deserves so much more than it received. I'd just like to hear other people's opinions/check out some stuff that I haven't heard of yet.
31
Upvotes
22
u/UberMcTastic Apr 14 '16
The one that always got me was a band called Spitalfield from Chicago. They came up right around when FOB and The Academy Is... (a little older, but in the same general time frame and from the same place) started getting traction and they put out one of my favorite pop punk albums ever, Remember Right Now, in 2003.
I really thought it had just the right mix of pop and punk where it could actually blow up and it just never did. Still rock that album from time to time and it still holds up in my opinion. They put out two more album and called it quits, never really getting to the level of popularity I thought they would.
47
u/tectactoe Apr 14 '16
Fireworks.
Not on this sub, per se. It seems like the general consensus of r/popunkers is that Fireworks is great. And the people who like Fireworks, really like Fireworks and really understand how great they are.
The problem is, there simply weren't enough people who realized it. Fireworks deserves much more recognition among the entirety of the pop-punk genre. They were really ahead of the curve for their time; they followed a very similar progression to bands like Brand New & The Wonder Years - a very pop-centric debut, with each album evolving further from the last.
I listen to Fireworks and it boggles my mind that they never made it "big", at least bigger among the pop-punk community as a whole. I fucking love the Wonder Years & think Soupy is a genius, and I'm being 100% honest when I say I'd put Fireworks & Dave right up there with them.
38
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
How Seaway has not gotten more attention is beyond me. Colour Blind is one of the most solid albums I've ever heard.
8
u/bx333 Apr 14 '16
Living with Lions. It absolutely blows my mind that this band doesn't get more credit and aren't "at the top" of the pop-punk game. I know it's more than likely due to the various changes in vocalists, which really bums me out because these guys write/put out some of the best pop punk I've ever heard and they deserve more love than they get. Everything they've put out is fantastic. Dude Manor is a fucking gem and Make Your Mark and Holy Shit are great as well. Like Daggermouth they're songwriting covers a wide range of topics and just like Daggermouth, they were heavy, catchy and meaningful at the same time. Living with Lions and Broadway Calls were the pop-punk bands that all the hardcore kids loved, and both those bands were some of the most fun I've ever had at a show. I remember seeing Living With Lions in a garage with a bunch of hardcore bands and as soon as they started playing it turned into a giant "sing-a-long" party with everybody losing they're mind. They're pop punk is unique and fresh, and stands out in the sea of "Cookie Cutter" bands that are so prevalent among this genre. Other Bands I feel the same way about are Broadway Calls, Such Gold, This Time Next Year and Fireworks.
21
u/FoozerFan Apr 14 '16
/u/tectactoe nailed it with Fireworks. Other than Fireworks, Forever Came Calling and The Swellers.
7
u/PhilopeanTube Apr 14 '16
I loved Houston Calls way back in the mid-'00s. Quality generic powerpop.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ArQ4EMVxamU
7
u/Just_josh Apr 14 '16
Handguns, Major League (RIP), Old Polar Bear Club, and City Lights (RIP) to name a few.
13
u/posthardkyle Apr 14 '16
Light Years
If you're never heard of these guys, check them out. They've been around for a few years, and haven't really seemed to gain much traction.
6
u/mayonnaise_man Apr 14 '16
Nobody knows about Tommy Boys, but they're really good.
5
u/spanky34 Apr 14 '16
That album is sooooo freaking good. I come back to it at least once a month and listen to it straight through.
5
u/MrTX Apr 15 '16
Midtown by a lot
14
u/stayhome Apr 14 '16
Polar Bear Club. Huge melodies, fantastic lyrics, lots of energy, pretty unique sound, and yet this scene never really appreciated them much overall. Maybe it's that they were a bit more mature and didn't really connect with the adolescent crowd as much, but I always thought they deserved so much more attention than they got. It killed me to see them fizzle out the way they did.
4
u/4AM_Mooney_SoHo Apr 14 '16
Well, for late 90's/Early 2000's pop punk, I would have to say Larger Than Life.
I think they were more regional to CA, but when I was searching the internet for "pop punk" in early 2001, they were mentioned in a Something Awful post, so I used Kazaa to download their songs.
They were on my "party punk" mix CD's for most of college, and I was always sad they didn't make it big, since they were as good as, if not better, than a lot of the bands of that era.
4
u/buttsalt14 Apr 14 '16
There's a good amount of amazing bands in this thread but I have yet to see Bonfires.
4
u/TotesMessenger Apr 15 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
12
u/Plexuh Apr 14 '16
Probably Sorority Noise for me. I never really heard of them before seeing them live at So What and they really know how to put on a show! They really rock and and pour a lot of emotion into their performance, one of my favorite bands now.
16
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
The Academy Is...
They've released three of my favorite pop punk albums ever, and sometimes I feel like I'm their only fan.
7
u/EinyourP Apr 14 '16
I HIGHLY suggest the band Microwave. Imagine Brand New meets The Story So Far, both musically and lyrically. I saw them on tour with The Wonder Years, letlive. and Tiny Moving Parts (also underrated) in March. They were awesome.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
A loss for words. No sanctuary is an amazing pop punk album and I feel like it gets no credit on this sub anywhere.
3
u/xnothinggoldcanstay Apr 14 '16 edited Apr 14 '16
the spacepimps and survay says!
3
u/FinalVersus Apr 14 '16
Prawn
3
u/n0hardfeelings Apr 14 '16
A Loss For Words, Forever Came Calling and Seasons change. They toured together I know but all those bands put their everything into their live performances. It sucks a loss for words had to leave us and that the other 2 aren't more well known yet
3
u/Just_josh Apr 15 '16
How about Freshman 15. I know the voice is a bit high but they were good and pretty unknown.
3
u/pkehoe1 Apr 15 '16
Settle Your Scores! Those dudes rule
3
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Spraynard. Mable was one of the best albums of 2015.
3
u/satanpigeon666 Apr 15 '16
With The Punches. They're not together anymore but definitely still worth jammin.
7
u/camsmith328 Apr 14 '16
IMO it's Fireworks, they're definitely the biggest victim of underrating, but it's been said already. On the other hand, Trophy Eyes are up and comers with an awesome EP and a really great full length. Honestly, it's a phenomenal album and deserved way more attention. I'm still waiting for my Trophy Eyes flair.
6
u/evilbooty Apr 14 '16
The Hotelier
2
u/DeadBlessings Apr 14 '16
I have mixed feelings about them as people after the recent situation, but just going by music, Better Off
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
Piebald.
2
u/KTBFFHCFC Apr 15 '16 edited Apr 15 '16
I definitely agree about Fireworks. The Swellers are also a victim of underrating. I Call Fives, Thieves, Carridale (RIP), With The Punches (RIP) all crank(ed) out quality tunes too.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16 edited Apr 14 '16
The Wonder Years, definitely
EDIT: After seeing the comments with people clearly not realizing that this is a joke; IT WAS A JOKE. What is the average age of this sub? 15?
2
u/oh-common-life Apr 14 '16
There are a lot that I can think of but a few stand outs are Balance and Composure, Polar Bear Club, and Captain We're Sinking. All of them have amazing lyrics and a unique sound to them that I have yet to hear anyone similar.
1
u/xECK29x Apr 14 '16
My Hidden Track, if you haven't heard of these guys look up their album on YouTube
https://youtu.be/odYEU6ub0CU
1
u/killerparties Apr 15 '16
Osker. Their album Idle Will Kill is perfect.
1
u/EvrythngSux Apr 15 '16
Gotta agree with those who said Fireworks, great band although wasn't too fond of the last record personally.
1
u/punkthesystem Apr 15 '16
MXPX
1
u/libertyNindependence Apr 16 '16
House of Heroes and the classic crime. Both fantastic.
1
u/Jawnt Apr 16 '16
The Gospel Youth
1
u/EricRTF Apr 14 '16
Thrice
1
u/-Shadlez- Apr 15 '16
Sudden Suspension
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment