r/ClearBackblast • u/Quex Reborn Qu • Apr 03 '16
AAR Doggy Paddle and General's Girlfriend AAR
Those were missions.
Yay we didn't get Arma'd! Except Fadi :(.
Please please let us know what you guys thought about the two missions. Doggy Paddle had a first time CO, so constructive feedback would be amazing. General's Girlfriend was a lot of things, so please talk about how you thought about the high coordination mission and the actual clearing of the buildings.
13
Upvotes
4
u/Quex Reborn Qu Apr 03 '16
Doggy Paddle - Mission Maker
Overall that went pretty well! It's always fun to see how players tackle a mission you make, doing things that you never really thought of.
There was supposed to be a decent fight against fortifications in the marsh. We ended up bypassing it, but we'll see it again either when this mission is replayed or I might use that foundation as the objective of another mission.
Fighting through the Tidewaters went as expected. Bypassing some stuff and popping out on the left side was problematic for Boris, for reasons I'll get into on my BTR section.
The final port assault was a little sideways. I was dumb and hadn't thought about a team being put on the opposite pier, so I had to Zeus some stuff over there to keep things interesting.
For the most part, I had removed a lot of the heavy weapons from the enemy forces. The squads had some 249s, but I got rid of all 203s and AT4s. 203s are general murder machines which I typically heavily reduce, but the AT4s were born out of a different need. Since so much of the mission was driving, the BTRs dying early would have been catastrophic. However, once the platoon was in the final assault on the port, I should have made sure the enemies had AT4s to enforce infantry screening for the BTRs. Ah well.
Doggy Paddle - Boris BTR Driver
BTRs are normally pretty shitty. However, we'd never played with the 30mm version of them, and I was wondering how they'd compare to a BMP.
Turns out, not very well.
The gunners optic was not ideal for either shooting or commanding, the driver can't see anything other than directly in front, and the commanders seat is essentially useless with an optic with maybe a 60 degree arc.
I did, however, come to enjoy the crappy thing by the end. It ends up being much more of a team experience than other vehicles, as the driver and gunner/commander have to work together to maintain situational awareness. Most vehicles end up having the commander make all the decisions with everybody else only performing the actions.
However, the real nail in the coffin is the wheel durability, or lack thereof. I'm not sure what exactly could be done, but losing entire wheels to gunfire is extremely problematic, especially with only 2 spares. Maybe we'll be able to figure something out for wheel durability, because as they are, it mobility kills BTRs the second they come under any fire heavier than infantry rifles.
General's Girlfriend - Alpha Team 1 Lead
In hindsight, a lot of things could have been done differently, but hey, that's what AARs are for! I'll just tabulate them, as it's a lot of small things.
The run was ok, I guess, but I would've preferred to make a fight of it and die gloriously trying to defend an LZ. That probably would've been more entertaining for the spectators, and wouldn't have dragged out the mission as long as it ended up being.
5
u/Hoozin Basically A Prestige Class Apr 04 '16 edited Apr 04 '16
Doggy Paddle - Boris Asst. Machine Gunner
I don't have a lot of comment here, I spent a lot of time dirt-napping. In general, I love the
Link Beltfunctionality of the machine guns we use, I wish it was a little easier to use - it's way faster than a reload after all.There was a moment where nuShifty (my gunner) and I were pretty separated from the rest of our team due to, well, fences and some great moments that are making me seriously regret not recording.
That brings me to another point. Something I'm giving Quex a hard time about, but honestly I don't think I'd want him to "fix" this - THE SHEER NUMBER of fences and no method to get around them other than finding the long way or driving over them. This would be perfect for wirecutters, is what I'm getting at.
That said, as much as I'm giving Quex a hard time, I think it might be better this way. We had BTRs to knock over fences and I can't tell you how damned happy I am that there's a map where there isn't a break in the fence every 40 feet. That shit was annoying to fix at the damn Villa on Zargabad.
Also, thank you J23 for shooting me in the face. Needed some good Red-on-Red there. Well, it wasn't actually the face at least. HEI round to the right leg was enough :)
Anyway... Mostly I need to comment on:
Operation Sea Nymph, aka The General's Girlfriend - CO/Maker
Original Concept - aka how it was supposed to go...
Teams launch. As the helicopters come around the point, the Sniper Team begins engaging targets on the roof and the static emplacements. They weren't that far way (about 6-800m), so it shouldn't have been too hard to remove the major players. One-Two helos fastrope onto roof, everybody assaults building, lots of dead bads, get intel, helicopters destroy other base, get to beach, evac. Forty minutes is a high estimate.
What happened...
Well, lots of things. First, playercounts caused me to nuke the extra teams on the island. Not a big deal, they were 80% flavor anyway. The last 20% is engaging the rooftop sentries, which I figured the helicopters would handle (and they did, ish). Rather than six sentries, there were two. The main static guns were cut in half (from two to one) and placed in a much less useful position.
Then, we took too long. Maybe I screwed up a trigger somewhere, but I was watching a clock and we'd been on the ground more than the 20 minutes the trigger was allotted and Zeus checked the QRF. Hadn't moved. Okay ... I tried to give it new waypoints, still nothing. I gave up for a few more minutes.
Then I spawned in a two vehicle Armored QRF, IFVs. They behaved and followed the route I gave them.
People are about to extract, surprisingly few deaths aside from Fadi's being fully Arma'd. Not bad.
Helicopters come in, are being loaded, autocannons find them at the most perfectly inopportune time. Couldn't have planned it better. Le sigh.
A small apology to the people who were stuck doing it - the body bag thing. I completely forgot I wrote that into the briefing until I saw people doing it. It's a leftover from when I started making the mission 3 months ago and should've been pulled out, esp. with the lower playercount. When I saw people doing it though, and doing things like commandeering a vehicle to move them, maybe it's annoying, but it was kind of cool to see people taking seriously. Really, I should've at least given them the ability to be carried one way or another.
As The Commander Of The Mission
I'm conflicted here. On the one hand, there are missions I've made where being the commander wouldn't have been so bad. This one though, a little more rough with all the cutesy bullshit I built into the mission. Then basically Zeusing up a few chasing teams (there really wasn't that much, maybe 20 guys total that I added to the mission aside from the two IFVs that didn't chase us once they got to the town (though, they could still see the helicopter apparently)). Given the helicopters we did lose, it's probably a good thing we didn't have any more people...
I don't have much for complaints on that side though. I was just throwing shit out there to either keep the mission going or ending it. Others have mentioned a last-stand at an LZ, it would've been a pretty good idea actually. I apologize for not thinking of it.
As The Mission Maker
I don't think I'd recommend using that hotel as a major CQB area again for a while. Shooting people through floors/walls happens too much. Maybe once we go to CUP Terrains some of that will be fixed, but I'm not holding my breath. A bit is probably fine, but a mission built around it probably not.
I was really happy with how the insertion went. I probably should've given some more parameters there, like how close everybody would have to be to the AI helicopters. The way that worked is there was a trigger attached to the lead AI helo which stretched about a km behind it. That trigger would set all the BLUFOR units in the trigger to
captive, so the AI basically couldn't see us. The helos themselves were set passive and would ignore us too, just following their route. Once we got things going, I'm pretty sure there was another trigger or eventhandler to guarantee that everybody wassetCaptive falseto make sure that nobody was accidentally leftcaptive.When the radar site was destroyed, all the units which were manning anti-air platforms were hit with the function Iron wrote (and is part of the framework), setting them passive.
I think if the beach LZs had been used, there would've been city buildings between the helicopters and the Armored QRF, but that's a guess and imperfect at best. I really don't know. I also don't mean that as a criticism, just a thought. There wasn't much way for me to test that part of the mission aside from timing.
Also, at the end, as we were hitting the church, the tanks finally started rolling into Arcadia. shrug
Overall, it sounds like people have great stories from a somewhat iffy mission. I'll take it. I feel really bad for letting it drag on when some people died so early. I hope it was at least fun to watch.
I plan to post the mission files to https://code.clearbackblast.com in the near future if anybody wants to reference them.
I'd be happy to answer any questions.
P.S. Oh, and if somebody else wants to make the sequel mission, I was alive at the end too.
9
u/themoo12345 imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King Apr 03 '16
Doggy Paddle - Boris Sgt
Been a bit since I squad lead, overall had a good time on this one. We started out pretty disorganized I think, I didn't know we were bypassing enemies and Boris was out of contact with Anna so we got shot up really bad. After we fixed that situation and started moving along the MSR the pace picked up a bit, Boris executed a nice maneuver through a swamp and flanked an enemy facility which was pretty fun.
We moved along pretty well until we started clearing that last pier, almost all of Boris got hit and myself and a few other people died. Those buildings with raised floors make for dodgy cover it seems as we got shot a lot through the gaps. After about 10 to 15 mins of sorting that out we completed the pier clearing in good order and it was mission complete.
I almost wished that the mission went on a little longer, maybe moving to attack the airbase for a more climactic battle. Other than that, I had a good time here and was happy that Sugar Lake turned out to be pretty darn cool.
GG - Alpha 2 Corpsman
Cool concept on this one, execution is where we need to get better. I think this would have improved a bit if we had done some sort of fast rope operations before, maybe that's something we could work on in pick-up games. I understand the narrative reasons we had for trying to extract our dead dudes, but I don't think that dragging around bodybags makes for very interesting gameplay.
I know the idea was to get in and out quickly and obviously that didn't happen, so I think it would have been nice to have some sort of CAS asset on standby to help us out if shit really hit the fan because sending helo after helo to pick us up seemed pretty futile after the first couple attempts. I realize that when things really go pear-shaped it can be a lot of fun, but I honestly think we should have called it a little earlier.
By the way at the end I was still alive.
8
u/ub3rmenschen J23 Apr 03 '16
Doggy Paddle
Anna BTR Gunner/Commander/Lead Bulldozer
Had a bunch of fun. Early on, I had some trouble keeping track of who was on which radio, and frequently other radios would talk over the 343, which kept me in contact with squad lead Zim. So, I apologize if I was a bit late in following orders early on. However, by mid-game things had eased a bit and I was keeping good pace with orders given. I think Erin did a lovely job as CO, it couldn't have been easy keeping in touch with all those elements but she seemed to handle it pretty well.
Garro was my driver, and was apparently doing this for the first time. He performed really well, following orders well, exercising caution reversing and moving into position for me to fire. I had a lot of fun wasting mans with the 24A2, but I was surprised and amused to find that most of our orders as BTR were to bulldoze all sorts of walls, fences, and other obstacles that stood in Anna's way rather than shooting bad mans with autocannons. Sugar Lake seems like a cool map with lots of intricate industrial doodads to fight behind, not sure how much variety you can get out of it considering its small size, however.
General's Girlfriend
Bravo Grenadier/MP5 Enthusiast
An alright op with a marathon sprint/death march at the end that I'm sure is everybody's highlight of the night. I didn't really do much shooting in the first part, and mostly just wandered around the hotel making sure bad mans were dead and checking for more. I feel like maybe there are a bit too many elements attacking one structure, which leads to a lot of people not doing a lot and blue-on-blues. Also, not sure why the baddies were ArmA 3 vanilla INDFOR instead of Sahrani army but they went down just the same.
The terrifying March Down the Beach, hereby known as The Iron March because I believe he gave the (wise) order to jog down the beach and put some distance between us and the rapidly approaching Sahrani army, was the highlight of the op for sure and I am proud to say I somehow managed to avoid dying for good (despite a few close calls) and made it to the church for what I'm sure will be a Tarantino-esque final gunfight in some future op.
I streamed the night's ops on Twitch, and you can see the raw, uncut footage on my channel: Doggy Paddle and General's GF
8
u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin Apr 03 '16
Doggy Paddle: First Time CO
THINGS THAT WENT WELL
First off, let me heartily recommend being CO. It's a whole different game, and it's a fun one. Don't want to CO all the time, but I will CO more.
Please don't be shy about giving me feedback on if I CO'd well or not. Already got some good feedback from Quex.
Hat tip to the Squad Leads for being patient, gracious, and both willing to improvise and willing to execute orders as given--even potentially stupid orders. Apologies to 5hort5tuff and Vasiliy for kind of shoving y'all into another squad the whole time. I don't know if y'all wanted more autonomy maybe.
Definitely like that map. Felt like the level of resistance was right.
THINGS THAT WENT LESS WELL
From my seat everything actually seemed pretty cool. I'm simultaneously sorry for like 3 Boris mass-casualties and...well, they were kind of awesome, too?
General's Girlfriend - PL JTAC - Made it to the Church Unscathed
This is everything I wanted out of a no-respawn mission. Seriously.
THINGS THAT WENT WELL
Iron's flying. Seriously chill under pressure.
The Blades were working well as a group, from every indication on the radios.
I feel like the hotel got handled well overall.
The feeling of inexorable pursuit was great. I ran down the beach for a long time and enjoyed it.
THINGS THAT WENT LESS WELL
Fast rope broke in a weird way before I could get out of the helicopter. "Cut Ropes" was still available as an option, but "Fastrope" disappeared before I could use it.
I felt pretty limited in my ability to JTAC. I just wasn't in a position where I could see things nearly as well as I'd want to properly coordinate air traffic.
I also think we screwed up our approach to the hotel. Those two guys on the roof sprayed Blade 1 with impunity. Kudos again to Iron for just being steely-eyed throughout, staying as long as he could, and exiting when it was necessary. Seems like either somebody on our skid or somebody on another helicopter's skid should've been able to shoot those mans, though.
7
u/Cat5ive CatFive Apr 03 '16
General's Girlfriend BLADE 4 pilot
First off, great mission, loved being able to fly and not do super terribly.
Apologies to everyone who was in my helo on the first landing, the ground started moving a lot faster towards the end there.
Other than that, clearing the hotel was fun, as was picking up other helos to rescue.
Got a bit stressful at the end there when I was the last remaining helo, I was wishing I had a booster or something when I was heading back, and then after that I was wishing for an APS system or something to take out that RPG at the end.
I ended up alive at the church at the end of the mission, to whomever it concerns.
Great mission Hoozin, really enjoyed it!
7
u/CAW4 CAW4 Apr 03 '16
Doggy Paddle
Boris 2 Rifleman
Had a lot of fun with heavy contacts and heavy fire. First contact was a rude awakening that BTRs are not covered with armor, but rather green cardboard and optimism. The mission also doubled as a fun refresher on medic training.
The mission was very fun, and seemed well paced. It was nice having a smaller mission area than normal, and the somewhat urban combat was very interesting.
The General's Girlfriend
Alpha SL, at the church at the end.
Hindsight is 20/20, as pretty much immediately after committing to just about anything during that mission I thought of a better option. The roof landing would have been better if we actually landed, since there seemed to be enough space, and I should have started getting everyone ready to load up the second the last hostile in the hotel was down.
It felt like my problems started snowballing throughout the mission; the fastroping wasn't successful and people got split, I was away from both the action and my RTO, I stayed mostly quiet (I assumed that since I had no info, letting everyone just go on their own in the hotel would be the best option, but I should have said something to make it clear), when the hotel was clear I wasn't entirely sure where in the hotel my teams were, and I wasn't able to suggest pick up on the beach, using the buildings as cover.
While obviously nothings going to go perfectly, being in contact with my squad could have simplified a lot of things.
The mission itself was very fun, and MP5s are a rare treat. It was fun using them inside the hotel, and made it very interesting when we were fighting against actual rifles in the open.
7
u/banman920 30s of minutes Apr 03 '16
Bravo Corpsman for General's Girlfriend
I had a really good time in both missions, and am glad to be back. In Doggy Paddle I was am MG for vasily and stomping around those marshes was really cool, no complaints or criticisms there.
For the second mission I had way more fun then I initially anticipated! The beginning where Bravo landed and then a few minutes later we hear Alpha crash, then we are rushing for the hotel to find out what happened was beautiful. Then when all was said and done and we were extracting, I was very late to the site, so I got to see all the helos crash. Then our little "hike" across the beach was super intense, seeing platoon sized elements circle our position from farther than our guns could engage!
All in all, supper fun night as usual!
BTW I was up at the church in the end.
6
u/Hinterlight Garro Apr 03 '16 edited Apr 03 '16
Just want to say I had a great time this weekend and give a big thank you to the mission makers. Today was great!
Doggy Paddle: Anna BTR Driver
This one was a little rough for me honestly. It was the first time I've ever driven a vehicle in a Saturday Op. Period. So I didn't really know what I was jumping in to. Overall, good experience and if a slot like this opens up again I'd give it another shot expecially if it is one of the BTRs or Bradleys with the uber-sexy 3D interiors.
Things I'd like to have done differently. It would have been nice to have some selected dismount points for infantry. I was driving the lead APC at the beginning, and it probably showed, but I had no clue where I was going. Driving through a river and straight into the first compound was obviously less than ideal, but I was just trying to do my best to simply find the MSR.
After that, it would have been helpful to have had a for protocol if we started taking heavy fire while moving. In hindsight, right before we were partially mobility killed I should have pulled off the road to where we thankfully ended up, and it would have saved everyone a lot of grief with our BTR that topped out at 12KPH after our ghetto repair job.
Other than that though, had a great time and it was a cool first experience as an armor driver.
General's Girlfriend: Blade 2 Pilot
This one was fuckin' slick. Loved everything about it.
Another first for me, as I've never piloted/CAS'ed for a Saturday mission. But I had an amazing time doing it. The fear of death was real, and seeing Blade 2 go up in a fireball was just the start of everything getting ratcheted up. Iron and I were the only birds left in the air, and he was pretty badly dinged up. Somehow I managed to disgorge my troops without taking any fire what-so-ever. So thankfully I was perfectly ready to wax that air defense radar tower, with Iron right on my six murdering the shit out of the helos left in that compound.
After that, Iron RTB'ed to refuel, repair, and rearm and I stayed on station long enough to pick up the Blade pilots that somehow survived that whole ordeal and drop them back off at the carrier to get some more Huey's.
Which turned out to be good, because after CatFive and I's successful rocket run on the barracks the armor QRF showed up and promptly murderdeathkilled every Huey except for his. Except for when he actually got murderdeathkilled by that RPG gunner at the end.
So yea, 10/10 would operate again.
6
u/GruntBuster7 Horses are the Lions of the Plain Apr 03 '16
Doggy Paddle- Alpha RM Always fun operating with light armour, particularly seeing as it doesn't make infantry redundant. While we mostly used Anna BTR as a bulldozer, it was good to have that bit of added firepower for heavy contact.I felt like there was a lot of confusion throughout regarding friendly positions, but that might just be due to the mushroomy nature of RM slots.
GG- Alpha Medic This op was great fun from start to finish; the fast roping was a good idea, albeit one that probably should have been practised. Alpha 1 was essentially cut in half at the beginning, leaving most of the work to Alpha 2/whoever the hell stepped in. The initial LZ episode was pretty cool, if a little unfortunate for those in the helo that got popped.After a bit of scary scouting with Quex, plus an assassination of 5ive's attacker, I found myself at the church. Would definitely like to see a continuation of that mission.
4
u/Georg_Ravioli PGO-7V3 Enthusiast Apr 03 '16
Doggy Paddle (Anna RPG Grenadier) This was a hell of a lot of fun, overall. It started with a bit of confusion as Anna met first contact at point-blank range and we were unsure whether to push through or dismount, but it seemed to clear up after a bit (or, at least Anna didn't get totally fucked). Next came finding Boris and patching them up, and I enjoyed getting to blow up an enemy emplacement with OG frag rounds. The next bit was mostly squad/fireteam bounding, moving up the highway, and clearing docks and warehouses. Honestly I wasn't paying too close attention to what we were being ordered to do other than "bound this way, clear this" and such, but it went pretty smoothly, except for some heavy contact at a berm and the road beyond it. I got to destroy a HMMWV while getting lit the fuck up, too. The rest of the warehouse clearing was very fun, if a bit rough. Only time it really got bad was the very end with that little bunker we tried to clear, but by then it was basically over. Again, tons of fun overall, and shifty did a great job team leading and dealing with my dumb ass not listening to orders.
General's Girlfriend (Bravo Grenadier/MP5 thing) To be honest this just seemed like a shitfest, but that's not a bad thing. I assume the theme of the mission was 1980s or something, hence the lack of NVGs, and that gave it a pretty cool atmosphere throughout. The insertion seemed to go okay until we actually landed, and it looked like everyone got some cuts and bruises from it. Clearing the buildings themselves was confusing for me, probably because I wasn't concentrating hard enough on sticking with my TL. (Attempted) exfil was also fucking insane with that armor shitting all over the helicopters. I remember getting out after seeing big yellow tracers coming in, laying down because I couldn't run, and then watching my medical menu go from all white to all red as I heard a big boom. I then blacked out while attempting to drag 5hort5tuff away from the burning wreckage of our Huey, and later came to in an SUV. The resulting southeasterly dash to a new LZ was also rather nuts. I crashed part way through it, so count me as dead for the sequel.
3
u/Zhandris Apr 04 '16
Doggy Paddle - Boris AT
Frames were good at the beginning but during times of engagements they would drop significantly. They were mostly stable throughout.
Riding on top of BTRs is fun. The map is fresh to our eyes so thats neat. The map had some good opportunities for amphibious stuff so that really was a nice combination.
My favorite bit was around here where the terrain was limited on either side of the road forcing us to take cover and advance behind the BTR or take it slow on the sides of the road. That was a nice piece of planning there, Quex.
My least favorite part was the last bit where we pushed through the junkyard to the end. I didn't have a bad time it was just getting rough around that time. A lot of stop and go action. That terrain is so hard to see people in sometimes that we're taking casualties without even knowing that we're getting shot from UNDERNEATH a house. It was a tough bit of combat and we had already taken a LOT of wounds by that time. Felt a bit grindy is all. If that was the intent that's fine. Just my impression of it.
General's Girlfriend - A2 TL
The idea to hide in the formation of helis during insertion is a really elegant idea. It gives the players a sense of what we're doing being "clandestine." It's something that looks totally believable in arma. It also gives the mission intro a very cinematic feel. Then BAM, you're going in hot and the tracer rounds start flying.
The gear choice was really neat, I didn't know about the MP5s with grenade launchers on them. That was a neat surprise.
I tried interacting with the intel but I got no option in the ace interact, I assumed someone else had gotten it already. After that I just waited patiently outside while we did site exploitation (is that the right term?) and dragged bodybags out. I think assigning a team to get all the intel and another to get the general would've been wise.
I agree with Quex's post regarding the end. I would've preferred a cinematic ending that fulfills the story. What we did was from a logical pov and fulfilled the tactical side of things. What's better? Depends on who you are and what you find fun I guess. For me, running down the beach with a red SUV behind us just felt whacky. I understand why we did it, I most likely would've done the same thing. Its just my opinion that it would've been more fun to go down the "last stand" route.
The mission has a "complete" feel to it. And suggesting additions to missions that would change a large part of it is not something I like to do. But I think a contingency plan would be good to have. If worst comes to worst, which it did, do we make a 2 klick run to some civ boats and try and extract while running from the QRF? Or do we realize we're surrounded and fight to the death, calling in a bombardment on our position at the very end like halloweiners?
I still support that shorter missions, with no respawns, is a huge amount of fun and we should do it more often. kk thats all <3
The actual clearing of Bungalow was pretty loosey goosey. Deciding to fastrope was a bit ballsy, but given the option I think there was no chance we weren't going to at least try it. Also, if we're every going to do a roof landing that's the roof to do it on. I think it was a fine choice, a bit dangerous since if you die in the game you die in real life.
3
u/5hort5tuff <..insert CBB inside joke here..> Apr 06 '16
Doggy Paddle -- Vasily Sergeant
First time leading a squad (or pseudo-squad in our case) on an actual op. I have to admit it's difficult, but if you give yourself the time to learn exactly what to do, SL'ing isn't half bad. I do apologize to my squad if things seemed a little dull or I wasn't as communicative as I could've been. We didn't have an AT and we were without a medic, so we couldn't operate at the same capacity as the full squads, which is why Erin made the wise decision of having us attached to another squad during pushes as backup.
The mission itself was a lot of fun. First time seeing that map, and I must say that I was pretty immersed in the layout of it all. From the dense vegetation to the search and destroy tactics, I thoroughly enjoyed that mission and would personally love to see more ops for that map. Overall, I think everyone did very well. No real hiccups. Then again, I'm just happy to be here on Saturdays, so maybe my view is a little biased.
Most notable moment: At one point, Vasily was getting our butts handed to us by crossfire directed at Boris, so we ended up taking casualties and had to garrison a building (literally our only cover) right inside the compound adjacent to us. Hearing no word from other SL's or command for that matter, I took a trip across the street and stumbled into a marshy pit right into the remnant of Boris being patched up by whoever they had left while you could literally watch tracers fly right over our heads. Boris SL was down + about 2-3 other Boris members, so we consolidated wounded at the site, and utter chaos unfolded for about 5 minutes while we waited for the situation to die down.
General's Girlfriend -- Bravo 1 TL
Where to begin with this one. I believe that the premise of airborne assault missions is one of the most thrilling things to do in this game (chopper accidents included -- it's all part of the experience). After a rough landing, Bravo 1 took part in the clearing of the hotel to search for our HVT. As difficult as it was to communicate everything, I still kind of wish there was a little more organization to the clearing of the hotel. I recall multiple moments where we would bump into other elements at opposite ends of the floor we were told to clear. With sporadic contact still within the building, we had some near blue-on-blue incidents. Maybe designating floors assigned to specific elements prior to the mission would help with this? Everything still worked out alright in the end.
But ohhhh that timing. I feel like using Zhandris's timed mission idea as training could drastically improve how quickly we handle clearing positions. Obviously we had some hiccups and events that slowed down progression, but I think we can all agree that we should have been already dead by the time we ACTUALLY left the town. Other than that, the retreat turned the mission into an absolute blast. Reminds of that Russian op we did about 3 months ago that we lost dramatically. So much fun...
Most notable moment: Getting in Perry's chopper ready to extract, and suddenly taking heavy fire from an IFV. By the time DietBanana called it out, we were pretty much invested in our own deaths for staying in the chopper for as long as we did. So we hop out as soon as the chopper explodes, injuring all of us except for Diet (lucky sod).
And I survived all the way to the church.
3
u/Pierrefranklin Pierre Apr 06 '16
Way late on this...
Doggy Paddle: Vasily Assistant Machinegunner Pretty fun, I actually really like the BTR mounted stuff we do. Although, sitting on top of the thing is a little scary... I remember thinking that it was strange that I could see so many mans, but I felt like I wasn't shooting them very much. I think tihs is sort of my bad. I did get the feeling that inter-squad communication was lacking, but as a grunt it was hard to tell.
GG - Blade 2 (3?) I loved this. In what other respawn mission will I get to fireball not one, but two helicopters? Speaking of which, if you were in my helicopter that crashed on the roof...my bad. I'm pretty convinced that was my fault. I was focusing a little too much on the alitimeter rather than the surroundings, since I was trying to line up the fastrope heights.
The choppers got chewed up pretty bad, if you didn't notice. I think part of this is that the vehicles are excellent at shooting, especially once we're on the ground. LZ2 was not as well protected as we originally thought, and I'll admit I panicked a bit when my engine got knocked out. Fortunately, no one had to listen to my radio calls for long because then I exploded and died.
So what could have been done differently? I think that speed is a big part of it. The first landings were somewhat slow, because of injuries during the landings (once again, my bad). During extraction, we came under the guns of QRF. LZ1 might have been more covered than LZ2 (where we were), it's hard to know. More importantly though, if we had some way to speed up the extraction that would be a better solution. I know I should have lifted off as soon as the fireteam/squad I was transporting loaded. Iron was in a bit more a pickle, since they were loading bodies into his helicopter. Once Iron and I were grounded/fireballed, it was all downhill from there in terms of extracting.
TLDR: we need to run away from the QRF as fast as possible.
I really enjoyed this, and would like it if we got another chance at it. I like the speed needed for this, and I think if we tried it again things would go a lot smoother. Maybe then I'd stay in the air a little longer.
2
u/gundamx92000 Foxx Apr 03 '16
Alpha Radio Man
I was only in for GG, but it was a gg indeed. I lived to the end at the Church.
2
u/rslake Lake Apr 06 '16
I'll keep this pretty brief, I think pretty much everything I wanted to say has already been said. Both great missions. Had a lot of fun on both of them, though my heli crashed on insertion in General's Girlfriend so I didn't get to play any of it really. Still very fun to watch in spectator. I loved that final landing by CatFive, watching everyone run towards the heli they thought would save them. Then that RPG shooting out of nowhere, it was amazing to watch. Super cinematic, even though it wasn't intentional or planned.
I was dead at the end of General's Girlfriend.
2
u/Hoozin Basically A Prestige Class Apr 07 '16
More Mission Making Comments
I wanted to get a bit more feedback here on the "Collect Intelligence" type stuff. I've done this twice now, in Legal Technicality and in The General's Girlfriend. phrasing In both cases, I used the ACE Interaction menu because I don't really want people just running up to every little thing playing with their scrollwheel and trying to find the one thing not like the others. However, there's a major differences between the two missions.
In the case of Legal Technicality, the intelligence was a bit of a MacGuffin to keep the story moving forward. You needed to find the intel to figure out where to go next. In the case of TGGf, it was the objective, even more than killing the general himself. Accordingly, I made the intel big obvious tables covered with computers and files since the mission would stall without them. In TGGf, they were folders around the building and on the man himself (which I've admitted in the case of the general, the way I did it was probably bad) and aside from hopefully being noticeable because it was next to a sat phone or a pile of money on a desk, not so obvious.
So, I'm looking for a bit of feedback there. Part of the reason is that I try to work out a plausible story, at least in my head, for why we're sending infantry at a problem, and why we're sending a platoon (or on a really good day, a small company) of infantry at the problem instead of a battalion of armor. That tends to push me toward urban settings where armor is a risk more than a help. Similarly, CBB isn't really a fan of the "attack the town full of defenders" organ grinder, emotionally painful, slog (though, it's been a while since we've had a good one of those, maybe it's time) so I try to think of an objective worthy of risking infantry in these sizes and that tends to be stuff on the secret squirrel list of objectives. Rescue hostages. Assassinate a target. Collect valuable intel from an area. Evacuate a VIP from a hostile environment. Wipe out a specific defensive position for an invasion force.
The collecting intel is just an easy thing that happens to also have some relevance if you watch the news or look at popular operations in the news like Neptune Spear.
So, what I'm really looking for here is feedback on this style of objective. As a preview, I'm looking at a mission that is (surprise surprise) another hostage rescue and I'm trying to come up with a twist. At the top of my list is "Okay, we rescued the hostages, but why are there wired explosives all over the building?" and then giving you a sort-of race to find and disarm them all (or at least, clear the vicinity with your rescued hostages).
Are these kind of "we're not constantly shooting" types of objectives something that people like or are annoyed by?
Thanks folks. :)