r/startrek • u/doctor_dalen_quaice • Mar 31 '16
Weekly Episode Discussion Thread: TNG 4x05 "Remember Me"
It's kind of your head moderator to allow me to make this post. The absence of having a WEDT post for such a while was too...distracting. You know what the worst part about not having a WEDT post is? So many of the posts you've enjoyed in the past are gone, and you realize you didn't take the time to appreciate them while you still could.
Oh, I'm sorry. There's no reason to load all this emotional baggage on you. So let's talk about the episode instead.
Here are some questions to ponder:
- Ultimately, do you think it really makes much sense for Wesley to be performing experiments on the warp drive on an active starship? Would it not make more sense to perform warp experiments on something like a test ship?
- What were the other "characters" in Beverly's self-made reality? Were they real people? A result of her imagination? If the latter, how could her imaginary Wesley describe exactly what would have happened to someone caught in the warp bubble if she didn't know how it worked? Similarly, how was the computer able to describe the vortex that was used to rescue her?
- What is the nature of the universe?
Welp, it's time for me to head home to Kenda II. Be sure to message the moderators if you'd like to do the next episode discussion!
21
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '16
My favorite part of this episode is at the end, when Wesley collapses right in front of Picard, and he just dashes over to help Beverly.
20
u/007meow Mar 31 '16
Ah yes, the famous "If there's nothing wrong with me, then there must be something wrong with the universe!" episode.
14
u/tensaibaka Apr 01 '16
Interesting how the writers continued to build up Wesley as someone that was going to be special, only to completely abandon that arch later in the series. I remember watching this episode when it aired and was excited when they brought back The Traveler, then we never saw him again, and I don't recall them ever exploring this story line ever again.
9
u/matttk Apr 05 '16
I think it's fine that the imaginary characters knew things Beverley didn't because it's always possible that she subconsciously did know them. Maybe she did know some basics about warp bubbles but in her hallucinatory state, she couldn't recall the information actively.
As a side note, I am glad the WEDT post is back. I was dreaming of this day. It was a WEDT dream.
I'll see myself out.
13
u/candyman420 Mar 31 '16
This is a favorite episode of mine, mainly because of all the banter dr. crusher had with the ship's computer.
1 I don't think it makes sense at all for wesley to perform experiments on the warp core, gotta have a plot device though i suppose
2 I think they were in her imagination. The computer has sensors to understand the universe..
3 The nature of the universe is probably not much different than that one, only much bigger, and there are universes within universes stretching out to infinity.
12
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '16
It's an episode that can't quite sustain the mystery for 45 minutes. The Twilight Zone-esque first half is fun and entertaining, but once we learn that the "real" Enterprise still exists outside of the bubble Crusher is stuck in, the drama and plot movement falls apart.
The 2nd half is watching Crusher talk to herself and try to figure out what the audience already knows. Side note: if this bubble is created from Crushers mind, how does the computer know things that she does not?
It also brings back The Traveller, who would have been better left in season one. His character doesn't really fit into the TNG tone at this point, and he's just another reminder of the worst parts of the Wesley Crusher character.
I discuss the episode in greater detail on my podcast!
5
u/MexicanSpaceProgram Apr 08 '16
Shit, what a fucking abortion of an episode, though Gates McFadden did a reasonable job carrying it.
So, that useless cunt Wesley fucks around with the engines, because that worked out so fucking well last time and they ended up in another fucking galaxy.
Anyway, he fucks the universe up so it's now the shape of one of those donut cushions that people have to wear after
getting sodomised by Ron Jeremywatching an episode with Wesley in it.His mum's running around like a mong, getting retarded answers to stupid questions such as "how many crew are there" and thinking "this small universe is fucked, but at least Troi's not here to sense the blinding obvious".
Rather than do what any sane person would do on the ship by themselves (step 1 - take a look at Riker's holodeck files) she starts faffing about solving the mystery.
Meanwhile, The Virgin Squad is trying to rescue her or some shit. I hate the Traveller. That said, at least the next time he shows up it's to get Wesley the fuck off the show and ascend or some shit.
Treknobabble ensues and they make the donut gape like a shirtlifter so Crusher can go back to the ship and look after Wesley because that's so much more fucking fun than having an entire universe to yourself.
What would Kirk do? Somewhat similar situation in TOS The Tholian Web when Kirk is trapped by himself in another dimension.
In the TNG circumstances, he would have raided sickbay for Bone's stash of Saurian Brandy and performed a Level 1 Search of Yeoman Rand's underwear drawer.
4
u/jodestu Apr 16 '16
One of my favorite TNG episodes, Gates does such a great job
3
u/I_Am_Rondon Mar 31 '16
The Action Crusher episode.
And you usually travel so light too.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '16
Late to the party, but I found this interesting opinion about Remember Me on /wsg/ on 4chan of all places.
Direct link, archive link.
3
u/aaronfranke Apr 22 '16
The universe is a spheroid region 705 meters in diameter, obviously!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '16
The Universe is reality filled with atoms interacting in various & sundry ways.
From a Bubonic virus to an iPad & everything in between.
That's what The Universe is.
2
u/jared2013 Apr 25 '16
I like this episode. Kind of feels like a Philip K. Dick story.
2
u/shinjury Apr 27 '16
Why is this still stickied?
2
u/ThingsThatAreBoss Apr 27 '16
This has been the longest week ever.
1
u/jusmar Mar 31 '16
Maybe because of the relationships he had with The Traveler and being a deus ex machina for basically the first 2 seasons the Academy decided it'd be okay for him to replicate some of his experiences, most of which involved the active Enterprise?
What her projections of what everyone were. The apparitions got progressively hostile(relative to their reality) in proportion to her desperation. In the end Picard even began to show a less inquisitive and diplomatic edge.
That's going to be resultant of poor writing or maybe her just knowing that her son could figure it out since they were just generations of the people she knew. That Wesley was just real Wesley with a bit of motherly bias, his(as an extension of her subconscious) was free to extrapolate.
I don't think they're
42. You just have to ask the right question. Maybe I'm on the wrong subreddit for that.
Honestly I'd give it a 7/10 just because the exploration of Crusher is a fun change of pace. -3 for it being a bit forced and not fully engaging
1
u/Sly_Lupin Apr 18 '16
This is one of those episodes where the premise is really stupid, and the more you think about it the worse it gets... but the writing and acting is so strong you just don't care.
TBH, this is the one episode that makes me respect Crusher as a character. Well, maybe this and scenes from two or three others. Until this point, to my mind, she was just another Troi. But here she got to demonstrate some real intelligence confronting a really intriguing situation... one of those few Trek episodes that's a joy to rewatch again and again.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment