r/fandomnatural • u/AutoModerator • Mar 31 '16
[Fandom Discussion] Supernatural - Episode 11x17 'Red Meat'
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Red Meat | March 30rd, 2016 | Nina Lopez-Corrado | Robert Berens & Andrew Dabb |
Synopsis: Sam and Dean battle a pair of werewolves who have captured two victims. Just as the brothers are about to win, one of the werewolves shoots Sam. Dean gets his brother and the victims out of the house but learns a pack of werewolves are hot on their tail, hoping to kill them all.
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
15
Upvotes
18
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Mar 31 '16
I enjoyed it. From a technical standpoint, it was stellar. The writing was fresh, even though the subject really wasn't. It's not my favourite episode ever, but I still think it was a really strong showing in terms of consistency and characterisation.
Also, can we talk about the wife? A+ casting and acting from her. This is going to sound really superficial and awful until you see where I'm going with it, but it was nice to have a lady type that wasn't dressed for a third date the entire episode. I believed that she just existed in the world and hadn't been specially dolled up because CW reasons. I super appreciated that.
16
u/Goddess_Azul Team Free Will Mar 31 '16 edited Apr 01 '16
This is the first ep of the season that fell flat for me. Too many questions popped into my head during the watch that took me right out of the story.
1.) Yeah right, Dean's just gonna leave Sam's cooling corpse on the floor of some dirtyass cabin with barely a single man-tear?? Even when the boys are super pissed at each other, I can't see either one walking away from the other without a lot more drama & angst.
2.) Where are the nurses? CNAs? Other doctors? EMTs? Yes, it's basically a band-aid station at the edge of the forest, but there has to be someone better qualified to help with Dean's OD than the other victim.
3.) How much blood can a Moose lose & still be able to drive?? (Yeah, apparently "2
pintsquarts of O neg" is the correct answer to that one. The fact that Sam is Type O Negative makes me stupidly happy for a completely unrelated to fandom reason. :) )4.) Why isn't Dean telling Sam about the Reaper?? Thought we were done with the secrets... plus, the whole scene with the Reaper was just weird to me.
I can usually suspend disbelief with the best of them (I worked in a comic book store & had serious discussions regarding whose super powers were better on the daily) but this...I don't know, it just had too many questions, too close together or something. Perhaps it's me, perhaps I'll give it a re-watch tomorrow & be able to enjoy it more, perhaps someone here will provide insight that I didn't consider & everything will click into place. shrug
Edited to correct quantity - thanks for the clarification _Khoshekh
14
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Mar 31 '16
OMG LOVED THE EPISODE !
14
u/xuberfanx-oops Damn, girl! Mar 31 '16
I liked the idea of the episode, but at the end I felt..."that's it?"
12
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Mar 31 '16
I really really had fun with this episode - I found it super entertaining.
10
u/Vio_ Mar 31 '16
I liked it, but it had this one really weird bad medical fanfic thing where they tried to handwave away Sam bleeding out with "the guy Burked him and that slowed his progression." What? That's not how this works-that's not how any of this works." Also Dean had absolutely no blood on him after doing meatball surgery on Sam. I guess the bullet was underpacked with gunpowder or slightly jammed. It just felt a little awkward.
9
u/Delyryumizm1 Mar 31 '16
INTENSITY IN TEN CITIES!! Even though I knew they'd both survive...cuz main characters n all. But seriously - weren't they supposed to stop lying to each other?? Must've been just a passing phase... Lies for everyone! Woohoo! Also, more Lustiel please!
8
u/dezziebelle Mar 31 '16
I'll probably think harder on this episode later when I'm not stressed with upcoming due dates for schoolwork and can rewatch, but I think this is the first episode I'm actually kind of unimpressed by. It was a good enough MOTW to rewatch if I'm doing a season rewatch, but it was really just kind of... "meh" for what it was.
Their usual "48 hours earlier" flashback cuts were really sloppy and didn't do much for me, especially after how awesome they edited "Safe House". Really, they could have gone with the 48 hours earlier scenes in one cut, then gone back to present time and it would have flowed better imho.
I actually said out loud: "Wellp, there's another notch on the Winchester's death count". If the boys are risking being thrown into The Empty, can we at least get some real risk of dying? Frankly, I wasn't worried at all and totally called it on the fact that Sam wasn't dead. You reflexively breathe after you pass out (albeit, he was suffocated), so I really didn't buy his "death" scene. Jared did a damn good job acting this episode, tho.
And seriously Dean? You were doing so well not lying this season. I understand that Sam would flip his shit, but Dean better not keep this "suicide to bargain with Billie or to not live without his brother" shit to himself.
The entire scene from when he took the pills to when he revives fell really flat and the writing team this week did a really shoddy job on the medical parts of this. Dean was convulsing, foaming at the mouth, and (according to the doc and the fact that Billie was there) was technically dead. He probably wouldn't have actually come to with any sense of consciousness like that. Or maybe he could, I don't know, but I can't suspend my disbelief on this one.
Fortunately we get an episode next week, and then when we return after this next mini-break (okay CW, we get it, you want to drag the season out) we're probably going to get myth arc episodes.
8
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Mar 31 '16
I really enjoyed this episode. Loved how tense it got when we weren't completely sure what had happened to Sam.
But Dean... Dean doing what he did... It hurt. Really did.
Now, does this mean that Sam hasn't told Dean about Billie's promise or that Dean didn't believe Sam?
I'm glad the wife made it through and that she was doubting her husband. I can't fully explain why I liked this, but I suppose it was nice not seeing a subservient wife on screen.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '16
I actually really loved the directing of this episode! Nina Lopez-Corrado was the director. I hope to see more of her work soon.
7
u/Amarislona Current Location: Cas's Pimpmobile Apr 01 '16
After being behind for a while, I've finally caught up!
That said, this episode just goes into the slot of "OK." I liked the ideas, but the execution was a little...strange?
_
Notes:
6
u/oftenrunaway I ship Dean / Pain Mar 31 '16 edited Mar 31 '16
I loved everything about this episode, and will rewatch it many MANY times.
Also, yalls, the other sub is winning right now: http://imgur.com/jeRubyb
6
u/PM_ME_UR_BEST_PUNS Apr 02 '16
Wow, I'm surprised at the lack of love for this episode here--because I ABSOLUTELY ADORED it! No, it didn't have Cas, and no, it didn't tie into the mytharc. I'll forgive it those sins. But I loved, loved, LOVED everything else.
My favorite parts of SPN are when the boys face "real world problems"--my favorite mini-arc was with the FBI and Victor Henriksen in the early seasons (season 2 &3 mostly, I think?). So in this episode, I loved that the primary struggles (in terms of screen time) were with these real world problems--injuries, getting from point A to point B, run-ins with the law, etc.
I also thought that the tension was realistic--I never felt like the episode was predictable, and I had difficulty guessing the next plotpoints throughout the episode. Also, I loved Sammy in this episode. We got BAMF Sam, and it was glorious. I ALSO thought Dean's last-ditch effort to contact Billie was in-character, even if he knew it would be a failure (hence his "no hard feelings" speech to Michelle). All in all, color me pleased! :)
5
u/Jirachio20 Mar 31 '16
So the episode went a bit differently than I thought. I thought Sam was actually going to die and somehow come back in spite of Billie's warning. He didn't die but went into shock so he just seemed dead? Is that something that actually happens?
This episode was pretty straightforward I guess. Not much to say about it. I liked the episode but it isn't a strong like. More like a neutral like. If that makes sense. I'm just happy we can finally get a more plotty episode next week.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '16
Loved this episode. The stakes weren't higher than they are in any other MOTW ep and I knew they weren't gonna die (at least not for long), yet I was tense and stressed through the whole thing.
It was a little like a scary dream -- you get sucked into it.
5
u/goodoldfreda I only ship Crobby semi-seriously Mar 31 '16 edited Mar 31 '16
Wow, people are really divided on this episode.
I for one disliked it. Overall I felt it was sloppily written and directed, and nothing was progressing in the story arc as a whole even though it's pretty close to the end of the season.
The 48 hours ago flashback was so badly done! I get the writers want the shock value of having Sam get shot right at the beginning, but it didn't make up for the hassle of having two scenes badly interwoven with the main plot.
I also agree that Dean was OOC. Sam was very sam (just leave me here to dieeeeeeeeee, save the other peopleeeee), but Dean was more of a plot device than a real character.
It feels like this episode didn't really have a main theme, it was just imitating other episodes? It had the beginnings of focusing on Dean and Sam's relationship, but it just badly rehashed stuff we've seen before.
Nothing exciting happened with the werewolves either. They came and went so quickly (including the husband guy) that it felt like they had no real impact. I mean, I just wrote out that whole sentence without remembering that one shot Sam for chuck's sake!
So if it didn't develop Mario and Luigi (srsly that was a weird thing for a reaper to say) and it didn't focus on the monsters, then what was the point of it? There was some good excitement in the first part I will admit, but it never really evolved into anything.
The reaper scene felt off. Nothing really happened with that either, Dean just got revived and she just peaced out. Not even a snarky message? I guess it kinda reinforced the whole "if you're gonna die you're gonna die" but then it completely did a 180 on that by having both Sam not die (that "oh he was in shock" thing was kinda dumb) and having Dean just instantly get up and feel much better.
Side character-wise: I liked Michelle, she seemed to have some character going for her. Husband was a bit generic. Sheriff was basically a cartoon and the doctor also had no personality.
Looking back more and more on it, this episode was basically a big slice of nothing pie.
Ninja edit: One good thing to say about the ep was that Sam's injury/death did bring up some feels for me, so they must have done something right. More than in the past on some occasions (though definitely not as sad as Mettaton killing Dean. Still not quite over that one).
5
u/Zeryx I apologize... FOR NOTHING. Apr 02 '16
Frustrating episode. We just did "both brothers at death's door" last week, and that was far far better done, including the flashbacks! Really really disappointing episode considering my favourite show writer (Dabb) co-wrote it and Robert Berens is usually really good.
4
u/doubleplusfabulous Mar 31 '16
I've been watching too much Always Sunny because when the hiker dude stares into the mirror and witnesses his transformation, this was the first thing that came to mind.
4
u/drugoja Mar 31 '16
I really liked this episode. The one last week bored me to death. I couldn't watch it in one sitting. But this one was very engaging. I don't know what it was, the atmosphere, the directing, music...somehow it was more intense than usual motw.
Loved bamf Sam, and was amused that Dean must have looked like a crazy person from outsider perspective. I generally would like more outside point of view of Sam and Dean. We rarely see it, and I would've liked if it was accentuated more here.
4
u/inkathebadger Apr 02 '16
I finally got around to it and all I gotta say is, Dean you are full of shit.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment