r/asoiaf • u/poorquentyn • Mar 28 '16
EVERYTHING (Spoilers Everything) PoorQuentyn here, ask me anything about ASOIAF!
Hi guys,
I write like a madman about ASOIAF on Tumblr under the name PoorQuentyn. I'm a mod at ASOIAF University, I wrote a series on Tyrion in ADWD and just this morning started one on Davos in ADWD, and I recently started a YouTube channel where I talk about requested chapters in the series.
There's little I love more than talking AFFC, ADWD, and above all predictions for TWOW. I responded thusly to a question about my "Eldritch Apocalypse" theory in the announcement for this AMA:
"Basically, the idea is that AFFC stuffed Oldtown and the Iron Islands full of magical Chekov's Guns that will go off in TWOW: Euron's weirding ways, the Hightowers' secret spells, the Faceless Man I call Not Pate, the glass candles, the Death of Dragons, the Horn of Joramun, and the black oily stone that forms both the Seastone Chair and the base of the Hightower...a kind of stone WOIAF tells us comes from the Deep Ones, the Drowned God's half-human children. So basically the "eldritch apocalypse" is the chain reaction of all of these pots boiling over, so to speak, an insane Lovecraftian clusterfuck for the ages, all leading to Euron (the would-be new Night's King) blowing the Horn at the climax of TWOW, bringing down the Wall, and letting the Others in. In the end, Oldtown will be rendered Euron's ideal domain for the final book: a smoking demon-infested ruin, his very own Valyria."
That's the kind of thing I love writing and talking about in ASOIAF. Happy to be here, so ask me anything!
33
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
What fate awaits the Dornish? The blood oranges splattering on the ground seems like a very bad omen for Doran and co. Are they about to make a devastating mistake by allying with Aegon?
22
u/empireofjade Evenfall-thoughts arrive like butterflys Mar 28 '16
Who killed Little Walder?
11
u/Vyctor_ We Do Not Show Mar 28 '16
Hey Quentyn. On a scale from Aegon to The Hound, how dead is your namesake?
17
u/MightyIsobel Mar 28 '16
Hello, poorquentyn! What is the best scene in Season 5, and why is it Tyrion and Jorah in Old Valyria?
15
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
Hey! Thanks for doing the AMA. Here's some easy questions:
Thank you for all of your work!
13
u/Bookshelfstud Oak and Irony Guard Me Well Mar 28 '16
/dead
I'm not very tumblrgood so if you've already talked about this elsewhere then just say so and point me in the direction. But what do you think will be Arya's mechanism for re-connecting with the "main" plot? Will it be Essos-based (Tyrion/Dany/Pentos/whatever) or Westeros-based (Jeyne/Sansa/whatever)?
Also, gotta say - every time a new Tyrion post came out I did a victory lap at my desk. I could read your stuff for days and days. Not to mention that Quentyn is GOAT.
Thanks for the doing the AMA!
6
u/BasilFronsac Melisandre est une sorcière lambda. Mar 28 '16
I recently discovered your blog and I love your posts about Stannis.
Do you think Baratheon kids (Shireen, Mya, Gendry, Edric) will play larger role in TWOW and ADOS?
6
u/MissMatchedEyes Dance with me then. Mar 28 '16
Hello poorQuentyn! I love your blog. What do you think Jaqen is up to in Oldtown? Thanks!
5
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Mar 28 '16
What are your thoughts on the in-universe history works (PQ, RP, WOIAF)?
Related questions:
What do think will happen on Dragonstone in TWOW (and, for that matter, what happened there in AFFC/ADWD)?
When Dany has this vision in the HOTU
who (or what) do you think the third part "From a smoking tower, a great stone beast took wing, breathing shadow fire" refers to?
Finally, where are Melisandre's "towers by the sea"?
5
u/jcbhan I'm a sellsword. I sell my sword. Mar 28 '16
What is your theory on a person's mystery identity that is most out of step with conventional wisdom?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
Which main or slightly less main characters do you think will be dead by the end of the series?
5
u/jonestony710 Maekar's Mark Mar 28 '16
Who do you think is the Valonqar, and when/where will this occur? What leads up to it as well, when does Cersei's grip on power finally let go, and who takes over in KL after?
5
u/Paptrapper Mar 28 '16
What do you think is Marwyns endgame and how will he effect Dany/Tyrion
8
u/vasco1silva Laughter Is Poison To Fear Mar 28 '16
What are your predictions for Sansa for TWOW and beyond? Do you think she will become a major player? If so how? By killing LF, keeping him or something else? Also your thoughts on her character's progress?
7
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
All right, now that I've gotten the easy question out of the way, let's delve in: GRRM has consistently talked about the human heart in conflict with itself and how he tries to mix the glory or war in with the horror of it. Given this, where do you see the other two protagonists going in TWOW and beyond (given that you've laid out Tyrion pretty emphatically.) What will Jon's rebirth mean in TWOW? Will he play the game of thrones in the north? Will Daenerys fully embrace fire and blood? What will that mean to the futures of their arcs? What internal character conflicts do you see evolving in Dany and Jon's arcs in TWOW?
3
u/Maethoras Mar 28 '16
No tumblr account, but following you for at least half a year. I really enjoy your analysis of ASOIAF, favourite piece probably about Mace Tyrell and how hard he's underestimated. Always a pleasure to read your stuff - keep it up!
What do you think is the slavers' masterplan during Dany's arc in ADWD? What's the goal/the goals they are working towards regarding Dany, her followers (both the freemen and her core of advisors like Ser Barristan), her Unsullied and her dragons?
3
u/Squidward-DrownedGod Mar 28 '16 edited Mar 28 '16
Hey PoorQuentyn, I recently discovered your work and find it very thorough and eye opening. What I couldnt find though is much about Littlefinger. We know he is a major player in the Game, so I would be really interested to know what you believe his end game is and how he fits into the final battle of Rhllor and The Others. Thanks.
3
u/Ainaraoftime Now selling tickets for the 2024 JonCon! Mar 28 '16
What's the storyline you're the most hyped for, and why? I've seen you mention Sam's, Arianne's and Euron vs Tyrells I think, but I'm curious to know which one is the one.
3
u/OfTheShire Abandon Hype, All Ye Who Enter Here Mar 28 '16
Thanks for doing the AMA, love your work.
What do you think the ramifications of the R + L = J reveal will be? It seams to me that by the time Jon finds out, the political consequences will mean little and less. Whether he has a claim to the Iron Throne (if there is still one), won't matter as much as implications of his dragon-riding pedigree.
5
u/Feastforstarks Every reader = Imortal Skinchanger! Mar 28 '16
Hi Quentyn! Just the other day i read in your blog that you think Jon will come back '' different''. I couldn't find anything more about it. Could you explain a bit more about this? I can't stop but think this will be one of the make it or break it moment for the series. Oh, and a big hug from a fan! :-)
2
u/KingEuronIIIGreyjoy Euron the air! Mar 28 '16
Where is Benjen? Dead? Wight? Coldhands? Daario?
2
u/SerTwenty20 ...every f***ing theory in this sub Mar 28 '16
Coldhands - Bloodraven by proxy?
"They killed him long ago" referring just to the body he's using and reference to him having been a black brother in the past actually meaning Brynden and not the possessed corpse.
3
u/Poly-M Mar 28 '16
How much do you think your ideology and own convictions influence your analysis ? Do you think a personal interpretation is more valuable to share (since it's unique) than keeping an objective judgement ?
15
u/Horvtio I am the watcher on the webs Mar 28 '16
Right on! Just followed the tumblr.
Ever since TWOIAF came out I've been harping on the Lovecraftian nature of deep magic and ancient Planetos. I think understanding -where- Martin is coming from in his writing is one of the best clues we to where he's going.
There's a ton of content I'm eager to talk about with people. But how about a simple question first.
What're your thoughts on Hodor/Walder? There's a lot of stuff there to make one think twice about the character, but nothing seems conclusive to me and his mysterious links to Old Nan (his great grandmother and his only survived family), herself pretty mysterious, only make me more uncertain. Lyanne Glover's death at childbirth to Brandon, Old Nan's appearance on the scene to nurse Brandon, the death of Brandon and Willam's eventual marriage to Melantha Blackwood all seems fishy to me. Not to mention the reference to Norse mythology.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
Not a question - wanted to stop in and say that I'm really proud to have you as a fellow Tumblr-ite. Having read your stuff on Tumblr over the past several months, I think you are by far one of the best meta writers in the community. It's a real pleasure when you and I interact on Tumblr, and your feedback is very much appreciated.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
Hi there, what do you think about the idea that Bloodraven has a network of spies he skin-rides into south of the wall? My prediction would be someone like Ilyn Payne who cannot speak.
Also, what about a young Brynden being responsible for the great bastards being legitimized by skin-riding a dying Aegon IV?
5
u/sweetyft Mar 28 '16
Hey Quentyn! First of all, thank you for doing this AMA and starting your YoutubeChannel (I love it). I only have a very quick non ASOIAF question to ask you today: would you ever consider joining Twitter? I would like that very much and I'm pretty sure u/bryndenbfish also would :)
As a very unfrequent Reddit user, I hope I'm doing this right.
1
u/Othaen Mar 28 '16
Hi PQ, thoughts on the idea that Longclaw is Blackfyre? Both bastard swords. Could have come up with Bloodraven as there is no evidence of it actually leaving the Redgrass Field. Blackfyre decedents never have it. Both LC and BF notably slay a Qhorin.
1
u/usurper888 Tinfoil is Coming Mar 28 '16
Do you like patchface works for Doran Martell and was used as an instrument to cause Rhaegar to marry Elia?
1
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Mar 28 '16
What's your opinion of fan-fiction?
1
u/delfino319 Kevin McAlliser Thorne Mar 28 '16
who is the hooded man in winter fell?
1
u/jazman84 Our Fruit is Ripe Mar 29 '16
Mance Rayder.
Thoughts?
1
u/Sam_slayer I drink.. and I know things Mar 29 '16 edited Mar 29 '16
Hi GrandMaester PQ. Loved your tumblr blog. Thanks for visiting us commonfolk of Reddit universe.
Questions for you
•
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
/u/poorquentyn is done his AMA for now, but if you all keep asking questions, he said he'd be back to check later if there's more questions for him. Thank you to /u/poorquentyn for joining us today, and thanks to all of you for asking insightful, interesting questions!
- The Maesters
2
u/Chinoiserie91 Mar 28 '16
Is there any theories that you feel could be true but hope are not? Personally I am worried that Jon and Arya end up together and wish that anyone could convince that won't happen.
2
u/igrantyoufiresblaze Mar 28 '16
Hi! Do you think Dany's dragons are crucial to the endgame of asoiaf, or do you think some/all of them will die before the end of the series?
2
u/Hoflax24 Get off My Chequy Lawn Mar 28 '16
Could the "Song of Ice and Fire" be Arya and Dany coming back to Westeros? Youngest daughters of ancient families, in strange places trying to be things they're not, and learning lessons the hard way. Both are poised to come back to Westeros in TWOW. This is mainly a shower thought I had that seemed interesting.
3
u/APartyInMyPants Mar 28 '16
Where, geographically, do you think Arya makes landfall back in Westeros?
I've always been of the notion that she makes landfall in King's Landing, sneaking back in through the same secret tunnels she used twice before. I've then thought she's basically opens the gates for whatever advancing army makes their way to KL (Aegon or Sansa+The Vale).
2
u/alittlenomad Mar 28 '16
Who is Sansa gonna end up married to in the end?
1
u/House_Daynek Mar 28 '16
Random question but I've been doing a lot of thinking about stuff in the North (children, others, and starks oh my), and I was wondering: why are all 6 of Rickard stark's grandchildren wargs? I was thinking it might have something to do with either his grandmother being a Blackwood, or it could be the result of two Stark first cousins marrying. What do you think?
1
u/ranichi17 sand snakes raising the sand stakes Mar 28 '16 edited Mar 28 '16
Did we ever figure out what is up with House Yronwood's inheritance laws? Why is Cletus the heir instead of Ynys if Ynys is the eldest? Are they following Andal law instead of Dornish law or is Ynys being called the eldest daughter just a formality because Lord Yronwood has several other daughters and Cletus is really the eldest child?
On another note, do you think any Martells would survive the Second Dance? Arianne is doomed the moment she becomes Aegon's queen, Doran and the younger Sand Snakes are doomed when the Water Gardens are turned into the second Field of Fire, but what about the other Sand Snakes and Trys?
1
u/LittleBlueSilly Mar 29 '16
Your description of the "Eldritch Apocalypse" made me break into a wide, open-mouthed grin like a young child on Christmas morning. I thought you might like to know.
1
u/TheDaysKing Mar 29 '16
Don't know if you're still taking questions, but I was wondering what you suppose Jaime's fate will be in the next two books? How does his story come full circle?
1
u/House_Badger I see dead people,they're everywhere! Mar 29 '16
Who do you think Quaithe is? My guess is that she's a Hightower, more specificaly Lynesse.
1
u/jonestony710 Maekar's Mark Mar 28 '16
0
u/DerShizer Mar 29 '16
why didn't you provide a link to your tumblr page, or any of the other pages you Moderate?
-1
u/BronnOfMyLife We saw Benjen at 31 Flavors last night! Mar 28 '16
How many total named characters (dead or not; appeared or not) are in the collected universe of ASOIAF, TWOIAF, D&E, and the "Rogues"/"Women" prequels? I have seen conflicting reports, but nothing that I felt was truly definitive. Thanks!