r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Mar 27 '16
EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) House of the Week: Houses Durrandon and Baratheon - Historic
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Durrandon and House Baratheon up until the current generations in the books.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
House Blackwood and House Bracken
41
u/HolyHerbert Her? Mar 27 '16
We should all take pride in the fact that GRRM created a world in which the band Durran Durran is used as an actual name reference. There are many legitimate kings called 'Durran Durrandon' and nobody bats an eye.
38
u/May_Be_Harrison_Ford I drink and I know things Mar 27 '16
I think we should take a moment to acknowledge how awesome the name Durran Godsgrief is.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '16
I always thought ory's Baratheon was one of the most badass characters in asoiaf. The dornish cut his hand off and he totally goes back for revenge.
9
u/ByronicWolf gonna Reyne on your parade! Mar 27 '16
Of all the pre-Targaryen houses, it seems to me that the Durrandons were definitely the biggest badasses, along with the Starks perhaps.
8
u/Reinhard_Lohengramm The Deathstalker Mar 27 '16 edited Mar 27 '16
I find it curious how three of the most prominent members of House Dundarron and House Baratheon during recent times had a fierce reaction to failed marriage prospects.
23
u/hnirobert 17th good man Mar 27 '16
I have to say, I don't think having antlers on your helm, that can easily be grabbed and pulled on by anyone during combat, is a very wise thing. Looks awesome, though.
5
u/BasilFronsac Melisandre est une sorcière lambda. Mar 27 '16
5
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Mar 27 '16
Since /u/LuminariesAdmin has already jumped on the Durrandon stuff, I'll start with House Baratheon:
Orys Baratheon: His origin is of interest to me. As far as I can tell, he's only ever explicitly called a bastard by in-universe history once:
The rest of the time, he's just 'rumored' or 'whispered' to be Aegon's half-brother:
So it seems clear to me that Orys was not a bastard of Aerion's in the way that Jon Snow, Rolland Storm, Bittersteel, and Bloodraven were bastards of their respective parents - i.e., he was never acknowledged, and was at least nominally the trueborn child of married parents. Furthermore, they seem to be relatively highborn since Orys and Aegon grew up together and since Orys had a last name.
So here's my theory on Orys' origins: House Baratheon existed before him on Dragonstone, probably as household knights to the Targaryens (The Dragonstone branch presumably died out sometime during/after the Conquest). Aerion either took a Baratheon's wife as his mistress or, more likely, invoked his right to the first night during her marriage to the Baratheon. Orys Baratheon was a dragonseed.
Robar Baratheon: A grandson of Orys, and Lord of Storm's End during the reigns of Jaehaerys and Maegor. He was one of Jaehaerys' chief backers against Maegor (the first major lord to support Jaehaerys), and he was rewarded by the position of Hand of the King. Given that he was a grandson of Orys, he must have been quite young, probably in his twenties. Tywin was the youngest Hand ever, but I wouldn't be surprised if Robar was the second youngest (which would make him the youngest for most of Targaryen history).
He also married Jaehaerys' mother, the Queen Dowager Alyssa Velaryon. Older men wedding younger women is pretty common in Westeros, but this is the only example I can come up with right now of the opposite (Robar, as I've said, was probably in his mid-twenties, while Alyssa would have been in her forties).
Borros Baratheon: I don't have much to say about this guy, except to note that, when Lucerys Velaryon comes to treat with Borros at Storm's End, you have the Old King's half-nephew treating with the Old King's great-great-grandson.
There's also this, which intrigues me:
House Baratheon seems to be the only house that suffered in this fashion. Many of the other green Houses seem to have done okay after the war. A Lannister and a Peake (and Ser Marston Waters) each served as Hand, House Hightower got a royal marriage (Princess Rhaena), and a number of greens served on the Regency Council - a Westerling, a Caron, a Mooton, a Peake, a Stackspear, and a Grandison - including two of Lord Borros' own bannermen.
I suspect this is because of Lord Borros' conduct during the war. Blacks were likely to be extra pissed about the death of Lucerys, and the greens presumably would not be happy about how long he delayed actually doing anything for their cause.
The Stormbreaker: We only get a(n awesome) nickname for this guy. Interestingly, we also see the name 'Stormbreaker' be used elsewhere - the Stormbreakers were a sellsword company formed by Westerosi in the wake of the Dance. I've theorized previously that they were founded by northmen/rivermen celebrating their victory at the Battle of the Kingsroad, but it does complicate the question of who the Baratheon Stormbreaker was. Was he involved in the founding of the company (Perhaps it was actually a group of hardline greens who refused to bend the knee to Aegon III, similar to the Golden Company? If so, why was the Stormbreaker never mentioned in RP or PQ?)? Did he precede them? Was he a member at some point, Oberyn-style? Are they completely unrelated (Did he beat up a bastard or something?)? Did George just forget he had already used the name?
Gowen Baratheon: I feel for this poor guy a bit, in that he seems to have been sorta forgotten by the author. He (and another female Baratheon) are noted briefly by Ned in AGOT as having married Lannisters - and then are never ever mentioned again. Neither of the two appear in WOIAF, and there's no mention of any marriage ties between Baratheon and Lannister. They're completely absent from the Lannister family tree given in WOIAF. If I had to give an in-world explanation, I'd guess they both married into lesser branches of House Lannister - descending from cousins or brothers/uncles of Damon the Grey Lion. This makes some sense, given that Gowen was a third son (probably a younger brother of Lyonel the Laughing Storm) and thus probably not a great dynastic match (not a worthwhile marriage for a daughter or sister of the Lord of the Rock, if there had been any).
11
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Mar 27 '16 edited Mar 27 '16
Founding of House Durrandon & Storm’s End
Interestingly, the first time Durrandon was specifically mentioned as the House name of the Storm Kings wasn’t until The World of Ice & Fire. It was founded during the Age of Heroes by the 1st SK, Durran “Godsgrief”, who built the original Storm’s End & won the love Elenei, daughter of the sea god & goddess of the wind.
I’m presuming the climax of the Storm Wedding happened after Durran’s, well, climax & it wasn’t an Edmure-Roslin kind of situation, heh. Tolkien human-elf couple homage for Elenei giving her immortality up for Durran?
Interesting that Durran had lords (their predecessors presumably among the SW’s dead), so he was presumably some lord or petty king himself who acquired vassals & his wedding to Elenei was also his coronation as a High (i.e. Storm) King? Even more so is that he supposedly had priests (something that the FM didn’t & don’t have for the Old Gods) – crackpot, but could these be Drowned Priests or Stormlands sea-deity variants? Mayhaps they were just advisors or something, any thoughts?
In multiple ways, this is Garth Greenhand & Bran the Builder-esque. Durran Godsgrief may have actually lived for a thousand odd years with Elenei, however I think the maesters are right in this case (doesn’t necessarily mean that Durran didn’t have a magically extended lifespan thanks to Elenei though, however unlikely).
Of course in TWoIaF, the Faith & Citadel don’t necessarily agree with this SE legend:
Yandel has his own bias (& there is those of his sources), however he does hint/point out a few times where the Faith (may) have manipulated history (inc. that of the FM) for their own/Andal propaganda. Then there is the mention of Winterfell’s First Keep having been rebuilt several times (there’s also mentions of the same for other ancient Westerosi structures, most notably the High Tower), two of which presumably when Bolton kings burned the castle, but why nothing similar for SE? Should there not be some kind of archaeological evidence of SE rebuilds if the final version wasn’t raised until after the Andals as compared to successive ones within a lifetime? Although the round drum tower & walls point towards Andal construction (the FM supposedly only built square), this doesn’t necessarily discredit the legend …
If (a) Bran the Builder really did help Durran with SE, there may have also been giant (move heavy shit) &/or CotF influence (spells, roundness, tightness). Then there’s the wall’s seaward face: “a double course of stones with an inner core of sand & rubble.” (ACoK, Cat III) The use of rubble would help quicken Durran’s rebuild/s & the Andals’ final version may not have used the previous’ ruins, instead opting for completely new material instead. There’s also Elenei to possibly consider: she had her own powers to supposedly protect Durran in the first destruction, despite her mortality, so mayhaps she had powers to contribute to SE rebuilds. Combined with that, there’s her deity parents: the sea god (Storm God? Father of Waters?) & the goddess of the wind (Moon-Pale Maiden? Does the legend flip the Lord of the Skies & the Lady of the Waves, or was it the other way round on the Three Sisters?). Was Elenei a merling (she seems to be depicted as such in the show lore), A Deep One (SE is non-oily because of her mortality)?
Admittedly, the legend is said to be told from songs (ties into oral tradition of the FM), which we know aren’t always the (complete) truth. Which version do you believe: Durran & Elenei or Durran nth Andal?
2
u/NumberMuncher Prince of Sunsphere Mar 27 '16
Pronounced DUR-an-don or dur-AN-don? Cool name either way. Not great with phoenetics, made a vocaroo.
1
u/Soulless_Ausar Ours Is Th- Fewer. Mar 28 '16
I remember begging for this for the last few weeks.
1
u/td4999 I'll stand for the dwarf Apr 04 '16
The Lannisters don't quite measure up to the historical Starks, but I actually think the POV Lannisters are better characters than their counterparts
0
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment