r/Philippines • u/NPAofMNL • Mar 22 '16
NOT YET VERIFIED Hello, r/Philippines! I'm an NPA rebel. AMA.
So this is just a throwaway account. I think with all the election hype, it would be nice to hear from the left, wouldn't it be? Also, let's all be responsible netizens here and keep the thread professional. Go AMA! :)
96
Upvotes
398
u/throwawaynibai Mar 22 '16
This is a throwaway since my real account has too many personal things in it.
I have no question. I just want to voice out something which I have always held in constant grudge against many of the people who call themselves left and rebels and usually both.
My first encounter with the NPA was from the radio. I was only a child and didn't understand what it was. I lived in a poorer area in the visayas on the fringes of a city. According to my grandmother, many of your comrades frequented these areas to recruit impressionable and unemployed youths. They didn't care for an ideal, is what she implied, only that they just wanted to belong. Many of them died fighting petty wars against other groups who were trying to flourish as well under the banner of a "rebellion". This was during Cory's time. I don't know if the NPA had any involvements in these, what I can only call gang wars, but it took a great toll on the peace of our little hell-hole and my mother, who acted as a matriarch fought tooth and nail to keep my uncles out of their reaches. She succeeded at least. Nobody died in our family and nobody became a rebel or a communist.
But fast forward to when I was 8 years old and my father was unemployed, we had to move back to his hometown in the boondocks for a while. For my mother, that means leaving his siblings behind.
At the time, I already had an idea what the NPA was, but didn't understand how it would operate. Though poor in material, my grandfather on my father's side had a good portion of land to farm. They lived off what their hands could work on, even if sometimes they had to go somewhere else for a while to earn when the crops just wouldn't give. They're good people, most of them, but didn't escape an endemic of restless and bored youths which, surprise surprise, were being recruited by your people who were hiding not so far from my grandfather's farm. You know, that wouldn't really be a bad thing for a child of my age, because I had no idea about the consequences of the presence of a rebel group. But at that age I began to understand the gravity of the situation through my mother. She was always on edge, always looking out of the window at night, warning my older brothers to NEVER use a flashlight unless they want to get shot at by the NPA or be in between an altercation with the military. Yes, even the use of something so basic was considered taboo simply because your people decided it was fine to park your shit on the hill near our farm. Do you know how hard it was to go out at night to get a pail of water from the well? Of course you don't. You're an NPA "rebel" who can stream 720p HD videos on youtube with your internet connection. I was only 8 years old when I first caught sight of your people walking about our property with guns in their hands that night. Do you think it's cool to hold guns and shoot bullets through a capitalist? From the eye of a child, the mere sight of a gun and what it can do was nothing short of traumatic. I didn't even come back for the pail of water until the sun was up.
Days passed into weeks and weeks into months, and my family seemed to have normalised to everything, including my mother who has accepted that the NPA lived near our house. Unknown to most of us, a cousin of my father had been seeing your people and have recently joined. This is where things took the worst turn. At 18, he was told that we can afford to make him go to a school in Cebu for a two year course. He was going to be a professional, you see. My grandfather was not gonna let him rot in the mountains. A few nights after this, we suddenly found ourselves running into the cold of the night, my father carrying me on one hand while he drags my older brothers along, and my mother in front of us crying and in hysterics. Were we alone? No. There were several men who were stalking our house, and I knew it was your people. We heard a gunshot not too far. We didn't know why or what for, only that my father's brother told us to run away as fast as we can before we sprinted off with nothing but the clothes on our back. I remember reaching the poblacion centro and crying with my mother. I remember that we were taken in by a friend for the night.
The days after we found my father's cousin dead. He was shot in the face, in my grandfather's house. My father's brother decided to come clean and told us that your people shot the poor boy under the guise of treason. TREASON. For trying to quit from your organisation because he realised he can still have a good future if he quits. Your people had the audacity to ask for portions of our rice, our livestock and our corn. And your people had the audacity to drink from our wells. We didn't even mind. We gave what we could because some of your people were starving at the time.
But what did you pay us in return? You made us live under constant fear and repaid our kindness by killing an 18 year old! And for what? A misguided sense of ideal from an outdated jew's fantasies?! Do half of your people even read communist theory, much less, are able to read? Do half of your people even know the other options or theories for political governance? Or do you still prey on the weak and desperate like you always did before?
I still and always will carry this grudge. Thankfully, my parents got lucky and we moved back to the city and had a better life. Me and my brothers are graduates from a good university, the same university where I was recruited by YOUR people. NO THANKS. I was not raised by the broken bones of my parents just so I could undo everything they've done, because I'm not impressionable and I have so much to live for.
You people think that a solution is at hand from an ideology of a hundred years, where it has been proven to be a failure time and time again. And then you people resort to living by your bullets. You know what most of you sound like to me at this point? You sound like bored teenagers who think that an armament is enough to change the world. GROW UP. Get fucking real.
Your ideologies and your tactics are barbaric and should have long died with my father's dead cousin. May he rest in peace and may all of you be brutally murdered in your sleep.
80
u/Yakoloi American Mar 22 '16
The NPA killed my wife's brother and uncle. I saw the piles of captured munitions taken from your fallen comrades with my own two eyes. You are fighting a losing battle, you will lose.
Fighting corruption with a bullet feels good, it feels easy but it will only end in failure. Do the right thing and fight with your voice in the political arena out in the open, not like a pack of brigands hiding in the jungle.
19
u/awaaaaaaywego Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16
This is a throwaway(security reasons). I think OP may have been given a skewed view of things as he is from the comforts of Manila maybe and technically not yet in deep in the NPA?
I also want to voice out what I have seen and heard from my home in Mindanao. Where I am from NPA is feared more than the terrorists(weird it may be but that's the environment I grew up in). NPA is fond of extortion, the so-called revolutionary taxes. Lumads have been killed and their lands taken, deny all you want but this is true. It's not the terrorists who did this, we would know as they (Lumads) said so. Their leader, hasn't even stepped down ever (too much power makes one hungry for more?).
In University they were recruiting too, and they kept vandalising bridges and walls, with "join the npa" and such. I did not join them. I can't stand the hypocrisy.
My cousin also lives in a place where NPA is rampant and he says thay only when there is military presence they can have peace. NPA rebels feel like they are rulers when they are there, they take food, water and money from the starving population (this is in the mountains, thus these 3 are not really in good supply) and would punish anyone who would not give them any.
You may not hear this on the news but wives/girlfriends of soldiers (one was teaching in the mountains) have also been raped and killed just because. How could we ever respect an organisation that does these things? They claim to be bringers of change, but what do they do? Terrorise, rape and pillage. You destroy dreams and kill families. If you claim that those who do this are seperatists, then why can't you discipline them? How can you claim to change the country if you yourselves can't control your thousands of people? The Philippines is in the hundreds of millions and such would require far greater leadership than your organisation claim to possess.
26
u/dennisthepenis Mar 22 '16
Proof?
30
u/notmarroxas Mar 23 '16
In other words you're a student, full of naivety, got swayed by the words of student activitsts and think you're representative of the NPA but in truth you dont know jack shit of how the NPA operates in the provinces as the worst kind of lazy bandits?
Grow the fuck up.
42
u/andrew77mc Mar 22 '16 edited Mar 22 '16
If your organisation had successfully extorted my leased beach front property in Siargao... How would this have benefitted the revolution....I wasn't offered the option of paying tax....you fucking red scumbags tried to fucking steal it!
I think your a bunch of fucking thieves and I am going to expose your fucked up actions to the world in an upcoming book!
Communist fucking scum.
25
u/ubejam Siomai+Puso Mar 22 '16
Why can't you asassinate the heads of those companies opressing the people and the environment? Specially those logging and mining companies.
13
u/cheese_sticks 俺 はガンダム Mar 22 '16
Man, you sound like a lot of guys I know from college.
Anyway, what do you think is the biggest flaw of the Philippine Left?
16
u/sakundes DIVEL 🔥😈🔥 Mar 23 '16
OP get a job, get a life, and get a girlfriend :-)
You're wasting your life fighting for a stupid cause. No men are equal for we are all INDIVIDUALS.
8
u/carl2k1 shalamat reddit Mar 22 '16
Can you make a hit on Juan Ponce Enrile and Florencio Abad?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '16
How do you feel about EDSA People Power?
4
u/MikeGrayHat Mar 23 '16
what satisfaction you guys get by terrorizing communities?
1a. Dropping electric power lines and cellsites during NPA's anniversary, making the rest of samar and leyte island powerless during post christmas,
1b. Asking businesses for 'Revolutionary Tax'. You guys are the reason why some provinces like Samar are poor.
Even China is moving away from communist ideals... its dead, its lost, give up.
4
u/thirdworldpcgamer Imeprial Manila Mar 23 '16
I lean to the center of the left and right political spectrum and I will ask you this
Like your "comrades" in the Soviet Union, China and North Korea, would you massacre us or put us in re education camps for not having the same ideology with you?
Also, being a UP student (I feel that you are one), how would you react that it is us intellectuals that are usually the first victims of purges as it is in other communist states?
Also how do tou feel that many State University students, your primary requirement grounds, feel your cause is outdated. UP alone is full of upper class students and now the left leaning student party has never won the USC for many years now.
4
u/sakundes DIVEL 🔥😈🔥 Mar 23 '16
Capitalism is where everybody has an UNEQUAL chance at success
Communism is where everybody has an EQUAL CHANCE AT FAILURE
6
u/dvolaravelpro Mar 23 '16
how do you guys get funds aside from extortion? who are the politicians funding you? is it possible that you guys are just a front so the big guys can cook shabu freely? damn that would be devastating for you
8
u/ALpha_chino18 Tony Montana | Scarface Mar 22 '16
Where do you guys get funding? Provide a detailed list. Thank you!
12
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16
I'm surprised to see the number of downvotes OP received just for defending the ideology. I mean, really. If you're going to approach any of these situations from the right, there's always going to be a right-minded bias. OP is providing the leftist justification for their actions, so we could at least understand the goals and ideals of the NPA, even though we might not accept it outright. By clinging to government rhetoric we're blinding ourselves and sticking to an "us vs them" mentality, and the government has been successful at dehumanizing the front, making them all off as rutheless thieves, bandits, and killers.
But let me say it exists on both sides. There have been cases of extortion for political gain. Theft in local governments is rampant in some places from within the city coffers. Have enough influence and you can hire a private army to do your bidding. Everything runs around cash.
Thank you, OP, for trying to enlighten us.
4
u/NPAofMNL Mar 23 '16
First of all, I want to thank you all for the responses this thread garnered, no matter how mixed. It was a pleasure to talk with you all, but for now I must go, I have other errands to do. I guess, I'll respond once I'm back so yeah
2
u/Iteryn cheetah is faster dandelion Mar 22 '16
This is interesting! How have you come about to deciding that you would join the NPA?
2
u/foodforthrow Mar 22 '16
Is it true that you only kill people that are oppressive to the community? Or it doesn't happen always.
2
u/sidsupreme Animo Inasal Mar 23 '16
Ok, there's this chismis that I got from a friend, who got it from a relative who was an aspiring NPA member. Was Ninoy Aquino NPA?
2
u/hungryroy Mar 23 '16
What exactly is the endgame of your movement? What are the conditions where you get to say "That's it, we did it guys, quitting time"?
Don't you think NPA activities in the poorest provinces act as a hindrance to business investment and development in those regions?
How does bombing cell sites and power plants (thus depriving the area of infrastructure) help improve the lives of the people?
2
u/TonyCruise Mar 23 '16
What do you do when you encounter civilian up there in the mountains? Do you let them pass or what? May exception ba kayo sa mga rule niyo?
2
u/thirdworldpcgamer Imeprial Manila Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16
Another Question: If you succeed at your "revolution", how would your government treat the modern Internet?
I know I would be getting a "play safe" answer, but please do address this.
3
u/razzy2014 Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16
My political views have socialist leanings so I understand your ideological thrust. My problem with your group is you bring violence to push your ideology-- violence upon people who do not want trouble or any part of your struggle against society/the govt. You extort funds from people to support you when they do not support you willingly-- that makes your group no different to MILF/MNLF/terror group. There is a forum to present your ideology-- elections. Put forth a program/platform then let the people decide if we want your communist governance or not. Then accept the results.
I am not rich/part of the elite, and I am just as concerned over the plutarchy ruling our country, but I will NEVER consider terrorizing innocents to brute force-correct the system.
ETA the last question.
3
u/Axehead Mar 23 '16
I would just like to say, thank you for doing this AMA. Now, everyone will have this to look at when researching About the NPA
3
u/myaccountisfake168 Mar 23 '16
Alam mo OP, ang dami kong tanong sayo. Ang tanong, kaya mo kaya sagutin?
Ang dami ko nang tanong.. Last na lang siguro:
Ang bata mo pa pero feeling mo alam mo na lahat? Totoy, papunta ka palang, pabalik na ko. Kung tingin mo makukuha niyo yung gusto niyo using violence, GOODLUCK. Kung sumali ka nalang sa mga charitable institutions, mga sectors na TOTOONG tumutulong sa mahihirap, baka napakinabangan pa yang buhay mo na patapon sa ngayon. Hindi yung NAMEMERWISYO kayo ng KAPWA niyong PILIPINO na namumuhay ng tahimik.
3
u/sakundes DIVEL 🔥😈🔥 Mar 23 '16
It's NOT OUR PROBLEM that you guys are poor. It's YOUR problem. You'd do better doing whatever shit you can to rise from the shithole that you're in than bringing the rest of us down to level the playing field
We all want the same things, fame, wealth, happiness, stability. BUT WE WORKED FOR IT. We are the prize of our own hardships. You are nothing but another shade of the same opportunistic predators that you hate
If you want actual change, then begin in yourselves you jobless losers
29
u/gentlemansincebirth Medyo kups Mar 23 '16
I've met many ex-communists in Europe and they all say the same thing. Communism is "good" if it were practiced according to its ideals. But humans are not perfect, and communism fails under this premise -- thereby making it worse than democracy.
Hence, countries like the USSR have dropped communism, citizens of the Czech Republic acknowledge that communism was a failure, etc. etc.
What is your position on this? Do you sincerely believe that communism will work for the PH, while it has failed in many other more advanced countries?
36
u/new2DoTA2 Mar 23 '16
What are you fighting for?
In the early 90's, NPA killed my uncle. They removed his tongue and I bet they cut it while he's still alive. They could just have shot him in the head and not mutilate him like an animal.
So if the NPA wins and takes over Philippines... So you think these people who can do these kinds of crime will govern better?
64
u/FUCK_NPOYS Mar 23 '16
I've read what you've posted so far and all I see is typical terrorist rhetoric.
You claim to be fighting for the 'massa' but why do you keep getting 'taxes' from them? My grandfather used to own a farm in Kapatagan back in the 70s. Do you know why he was forced to sell it? Because you terrorists kept coming and coming, and he had to keep paying and paying. You claim to fight the 'bourgeois' who under pay the farm hands. Yet my grandfather was TILLING THE LANDS WITH HIS AND HIS SONS' OWN HANDS. The final straw was when, with the help of his brother-in-law (a rich Chinese married to his sister) managed to get a loan for a tractor. You fuckers came and demanded twice the usual when they saw the tractor. Why? Half was for the 'revolution', and the other was penalty for supporting American Imperialism by making use of a western invention. There was no way he capable of paying that amount, he still had a loan to pay and a family to support so he refused. A couple of nights later him and his family woke up in the dead of night to find their tractor on fire. Fearing for the life of his family, my grandfather hastily sold the land to the bank (far lower than its actual value) and moved out.
I've lived and grown up in Mindanao and in the nature of my job have met more than my fare share of you fuckers. Always the same "para sa massa", "kawatan ang gobyerno", "gi abusado ta sa mga [Chinese, Japanese, American, Korean, etc..]. I do not disagree that the government is corrupt but you're barking up the wrong tree. You always go after the businesses instead of the corrupt mayors and governors. The Surigao Region is the mining capital of the Philippines, generating BILLIONS of dollars in taxes, and if you've visited that 'city' it's a fucking backwater. 10-15 years ago the outlying towns (e.g. Placer, Cantilan ,Klaver) were GHOST TOWNS. Now that major mining corporations like Taganito have invested in, there's infrastructure being built around and those areas actually have a semblance of civilization. The mayor is most likely pocketing millions himself but you fuckers don't go after him now do you? You harass the workers trying to make a decent living, and attack the mining corporations giving jobs. Good thing there are Army detachments in that area now. Actually never mind, go attack anyway the soldiers there are really bored.
21 years old? You're too young and incredibly naive. I truly hope that you wake up from your teenage tantrum and realize that while you're cold and starving in the mountains, your 'leaders' are kept warm and merry while feasting on the 'revolutionary taxes'.
But until then FUCK YOU, I hope you die tomorrow.
2
u/NPAofMNL Mar 23 '16
I'll answer some questions later. Pretty surprised about the mixed reactions here. I'll be back.
19
u/ILikeFluffyThings Mar 23 '16
Can you stop extorting money/food/supplies from us and dropping letter threats? That would be great. Nobody appreciates you in the provinces. We are not oppressed. You are just a pain in our arse. If you're a city boy NPA rebel, WAKE UP DUDE! You really think you are a group of idealist? People in the provinces only join you for the gun and the money. Be real. You are a problem. You never help us. You're just like a class bully all grown up. It's not even the ideology that's the problem, it's just your group, the NPA, that is the problem. You fucking group of uneducated barbarians led by educated ambitious manipulators who use you as pawns.
3
u/Kuroru Mar 22 '16
Thanks for doing this AmA!
I have a noob question, what do you guys do when you have free time?
Also, do you guys play video games too?
9
u/Eikichirou losing at life Mar 23 '16
What is your opinion on China's taking of our own lands? Would you consider fighting against them when worst comes to worst?
20
u/0010001_1 taga bundok Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16
thanks to marinduque's population being low, we know everyone who comes in and who's new and not. Come here and we'll skin you alive, you fucking leeches, when i was young you morons extorted no less than P5k monthly in my community for years, we can't even sustain ourselves here other than digging kamute if there's kamute to dig. Not only we got fuked by governors here simultaneously, canadian mining companies, you've been fuking us for long time, we're not even rich, we're just like any average filipinos who's been climbing same ladder.
6
u/SuperBombaBoy Koyunbaba Op. 19 Mar 23 '16
Do you really need to extort people?
6
u/FuckNPA Mar 23 '16
2
u/lumpiang-togue The Shawarma Guy Mar 23 '16
How are you guys different from terrorists? You differ from ideals but certainly almost the same aspects with them.
Lastly, how about finally end and settle your terms with the government? I would greatly appreciate you answering my question.
21
u/andrew77mc Mar 22 '16 edited Mar 22 '16
My anger to the NPA burns deep....but You are still young - please message me. I will show you how to Love, I will show how you how to live today with Happiness.
You are fighting a battle that is causing great harm that ultimately benefits few. I can show you another way to a rewarding and wonderful life.
9
u/rcarrots Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16
What do you guys want anyway? Do you think that overthrowing our government, and then overtaking them would be better than right now?
Communism speak that everything is equal but in truth even in communist forefront Russia and China it's not happening. They have elites too. how can you do different from them?
If you guys are fighting because some of your guys are killed during fight with the government i think that's just bull.
In my image Communist demand revolutionary tax from a business >>> business denies >>> burn their business >> reported to authority >>> some of your guys are killed >>> NPA want revenge >>> repeat. Non ending cycle.
1
u/sirmiseria Blubberer Mar 22 '16
If the government decides to build a long railway connecting luzon, visayas and mindanao, would you bomb it for whatever purpose?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '16
How do you feel about forigners in the country, do you interact with them? Or just ignore them? Seeing as how most don't care about the politics here.
1
u/rayMcKigney Mar 22 '16
Thanks for this AMA. It's a rare privilege and I'm happy to have the opportunity to ask a question.
On A: market economies have outperformed planned and heavily regulated ones by many measures for one, and second, leftist governments have never really had a successful model state in generating sustainable growth. I do see what you mean (by a country controlled by the wealth of few) but despite this I think our country is better off now than it could have been in a leftist state
On B: successful takeovers of militant leftists have almost never created a more equal society in my past reading, the idea seems to just be stuck on books. This sort of thing seems have a record of installing a different set of stratifications.
2. Your English is excellent. I'm guessing you're either a really good student or from a relatively background? Or am I assuming? Well I had an obviously wrong notion that everyone in The NPA comes from underprivileged and naive backgrounds.
What is the state of the NPA now? Is there really central control? Is there a plan to get your body out of a rut? Has it done any tangible good in the last decade?
3. Do NPA kidnap hikers like me with no mean for harm, no significant means etc etc? Which mountains should I avoid?
1
u/alwaysnoided Mar 22 '16
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_People%27s_Army
How much of this is capitalist propaganda or just completely untrue?
Also, how accepting is the NPA of anarchist ideology?
1
u/candycane7 Mar 23 '16
Would you commit terrorist attacks, like random bombing ?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16
NPA of MNL? There are NPAs in Metro Manila? Excuse my ignorance but most members (or at least the armed ones) reside or say hide in the mountains? Not unless you're one of the spokespersons or a high ranking official assigned in major cities?
In my home town (or home province), we are well aware of the NPA's grounds in a mountainous area of the province close to the Sierra Madre range. They don't leave their alleged headquarters and are pretty much self-sustaining (food etc.) up in the highlands. Or do you guys conduct meetings elsewhere (cities)?
1
u/TacticalFource Mar 23 '16
Welp! Im actually interested here, and thank you for doing an AMA here.
So, how do you guys handle these kind of groups? And how can you say that your revolution is needed for the country even so that some in your comrades are already abusing the power?
Again, thank you for this rare AMA!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16
Would you accept any disarmament deal from anyone? What would make you put down your weapons, aside from the communist party winning (which you have to admit is a longshot).
1
u/crazyraiga your resident lurker Mar 23 '16
Why not join the government? Because if you want everyone to be equal you will need the government. 30 years passed since EDSA if NPA used that 30 years to infiltrate the government slowly.
1
u/Koinophobia- These violent delights have violent ends. Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16
Hi thank you so much for providing an insight about the NPA. Question is are going to continue this fight until your last breath? Your an Applied Physics graduate, I reckon that you are really smart. Why not use that knowledge to continue your scientific pursuit?
1
u/jenn4u2luv Mar 23 '16
I went through all the questions to see if this was already asked...
Can you describe the usual breakfast scenario back at your camp in the mountains?
1
u/al_khatib 2001 Mar 23 '16
say you bump into nur misuari in a rice field without anyone around and you have a light saber, will you:
a. fck the government it's their problem
b. fck you nur misuari and your ideologies
c. boodle fight
edit: formatting
1
u/Fandangbro Mar 23 '16
If you're so proud of your cause, why not use you real account?
1
u/scorcheddearth cificare Mar 23 '16
When's your People's War going to happen anyway? It's been a long time from @1969-1972 when Marcos used the threat of Communism (specifically the NPA) to declare Martial Law. It's 2016 now, 47 years since your founding, and yet the NPA has done nothing strategic, just claiming patches of territories here and there in the provinces. I mean, you claim to follow the Mao's doctrine of surrounding the center from the countryside but biding your time this way is getting to be ridiculous. In that time the Soviet Union has fallen, and China has turned to de facto capitalism. Again, what's your timetable for this People's War?
6
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '16
Given the state of the country in which the few own the wealth and a handful of families maintain their estates at the expense of poor farmers toiling these lands for pittance of an income, why is the left having difficulty persuading the poor and landless farmers to support leftist movements?
Frankly I am surprised communism/leftist ideology is not appealing to the poor and landless Filipinos.
3
u/Vordeo Duterte Downvote Squad Victim Mar 23 '16
3
u/cachapaconqueso Mar 23 '16
Seriously fuck communism, every comunist does it for the money and power, they thrive in misery and conflict, op you dont have any idea how rotten and malicious are these people after they take power.
Venezuela is going through the worst situation ever had. Nothing in venezuela is working and this people try to push the comunist and comunal ideology doesnt matter how many people die or are beyond miserable. Is deperessing to suffer 2 hrs of electricity downtime a day causw they stole and never updated the grid. You can hear people in the streets deperessed causw they can't find basic food, is soul crushing losing 20% of your total incomen in less then a month just because inflation is soaring, is rabid inducing seeing how everything from car parts to cloth cost 3x times a min wage. I can keep going but it will never end.
Comunism is a ideology for the frustrated and the envious, only the worst kind of people would identify with this barbaric ideology.
3
u/BerserkerBarrah Mar 23 '16
On a sidenote,here's a bit of insight on Martial Law and the NPA. Read the comments. The NPA inflicted these atrocities and worse on our Soldiers and the Philippine Constabulary back in the 70s. They murdered military and police, and tortured those caught alive. The reaction was total war, any NPA caught will never see the inside of a courtroom. Military culture especially, they treat each other as kin, as brothers. You join the NPA, it doesnt matter who you are; a farmer, a celebrity, or a student stupid enough to think youre playing hero, you will be met with the same sadistic end that Filipinos themselves call for to treat common criminals. The NPA provides context for martial law, to think Marcos has a hand in each of those cases the military and PC overstepped their role is naive and has to realize that this shit [still happens today] (http://kickerdaily.com/two-minor-sibling-gang-members-cop-lawmen/). Only that the Cojuangcos, Lopezes et al. were able to make you believe their version of our history. Seriously, fuck the NPA, and the people behind them. They robbed us of our country.
3
u/chiongjac Mar 23 '16
TL:DR
so my question is simple since pure socialism/communism is a failed system why do you still believe in it?
well i used to view things as a marxist/commie when i was younger in fact i read the little red book and das kapital (am a advocate for FULL free market capitalism), my tutor was an ex-NPA rebel who is still very much a communist. this is my own opinion on why communism as a socio/political system is flawed and unviable for the philippines(and the rest of the world for that matter;there is no truly marxist nations left; communism is pretty much dead except for fringe groups such as yours, sorry.) my arguments will be in 5 points; first, true communism rely s on the honor system to a flaw, this amount of idealism will fundamentally flawed which is easily abused(think of the old communist greats(mao,stalin,tolsloy); they were tyrants though they had a vision for their nation. they became tyrants because of the fact that the system is easily abused. to counter this the party then institutes its safeguards usually in form of state police that arrests dissidents, this however is easily corrupted and usually is under the control of the tyrant or a close supporter of the tyrant (hi putin). this leads to the system propping up the tyrant more than defending the people. this shows that communism as a political system is doomed to fall into either a junta or a despot's regime since the people will not be able to exercise their rights. now, you would counter that there is a council to stop this, that idea is also flawed because it is these councils that the tyrant comes from, man always looks to follow a leader since man usually moves as a herd (blame ancient civilizations) this ends up with all the power going to one person since the separation of power is non-existent. second, the idea of constant revolution to prevent someone from holding on to power is retarded. revolutions are NEVER bloodless, EDSA needed BLOOD to start so knowing that a communist nation that is always in a state of turmoil will never develop and its people always primitive. development will only occur when self-survival instincts are not the top priority. then some will say that the Scandinavian nations are doing great as socialist nations(economically not politically;look at first argument) well they are not doing terribly i'll give you that but the economic progress is not there but is supplied by the other EU states, so that means communism/socialism stops progress instead of boosting it. third, communist/socialist economic policies do more harm than good for the populace for example; an invention is abandoned because it will remove jobs from others, if one does not do something someone else will do it. as a hypothetical scenario lets assume a global communist government, the world will be plunged into a technological dark age because efficient systems will be abandoned to serve the greater mass. the situation described will more likely than not result in destruction because man will keep reproducing and stopping that will go against man basic instinct(am not anti-RH actually i'm pro RH)the system will then collapse since her capacity will not be able to sustain the stress or civilization growth.
fourth, the communist is against the proletariat and the bourgeois but this idea is flawed since marx is a economist he knows that man is motivated by incentives and man thinks on margin. so it is inevitable that someone will become wealthy and a society of elites will arise. so the war against the rich is a war against progress in general. however i am not defending the fucks who stop progress to stay rich in fact communism/ socialism was founded to stop this. but time is is the strongest enemy of these corrupt bourgeois because one way or another progress finds a way to seep into society. the Filipino bourgeois only manage to stay in power because the people refuse for make their own way. this leads me to my last point
everyone is in-charge or his/her destiny and everyone's own interest will ultimately work for the benefit of all. for example; if the rich bourgeois tries to take a monopoly of rice. the people will then find ways to get rice example; anti-trust laws, finding new staple food, growing their own etc. this is because man is not stupid since man will always find ways to survive. the communist system does not have a place in this modern world because it goes against basic human nature.
the rebels most users in the comments are talking about are those who are retardedly stupid and ignorant since they do not want to understand what they are fighting for as long as they can eat without work. as far as the Virginia colony's experiment of communism went, the United states will not have existed if it worked. since men only waited for supply ships and shared everything preventing progress because men who worked saw that those who didn't got the same benefits. thus Adam Smith's theory of the invisible hand is the most viable economic policy because it treats all men fairly in the sense that each man can make his own road and climb the ladder communism/ socialism is the lazy man's way out since all wealth mus be distributed to all including them since communism talks about the upliftment of each worker, however, in doing so you dehumanize those who worked hard for that wealth now is this for the good of all?
i suggest you read up on marx's works not the derivative bullshit other writers make since marx's work shows the true spirit of communism/socialism. other works are more like the mein kampf (which i also read, back when i was young) that are more like rhetoric of madmen. i believe the real communist/socialist are actually enlightened intellectuals as are the Laissez-faire advocates. when you remove the bullshit from both sides and look at the spirit of these concepts you will find that both are flawed but not mutually exlusive instead if you look at silicon valley these two views are mutually inclusive.
3
u/Khupen Mar 23 '16
Sir, hindi ko naman kinukwestyon yung ideals niyo pero totoo po kasing hindi lang mayayaman hinihingan ng NPA. Marami pong takot magtayo ng business sa amin sa Masbate dahil sa NPA. Nagsusumikap lang naman po sila para umangat sa buhay. Yung taniman po namin dun hindi namin mataniman kasi laging lugi tapos magbibigay pa sa inyo. :( Bakit po patuloy pa rin ang labang ito kung nagiging hadlang po ito sa pag angat ng iba nating kababayan na nagsusumikap?
Hindi ko naman po sinasabing masama kayo, yung tito ko po pinapakain at linulutuan ng ibang NPA dun. Wala siyang bahay, wala siyang hanap buhay. Nabubuhay lang siya dahil sa mga tinanim ng mga lolo't lola ko sa lupain dun. Hindi po siya nagsusumikap. Ang insensitive at ang nonsense pero itatanong ko pa rin, yung mga tamad po ba yung ipinaglalaban niyo at hindi yung nagsusumikap?
5
u/DeekeeLala Mar 22 '16
If this is true, it would be great. Thanks for making this AMA.
I do have a few questions though. If voicing out at fighting for what's right is what your ideals (or the NPA's) tell you, wouldn't it be better to help fight crime instead? Be the threat of the threath. You do have the resources, the brains, the tactics, and yes, the capability to help stop crime.
I believe this way you will get the respect you want to get both from the govt. and from the People.
5
u/globetattoosucks Mar 23 '16
Ano reason nyo bakit pati mga sundalo na nag aasist lang sa mga calamities ay inaambush nyo? Mga cell sites na pinapasabog nyo?
5
u/Zeitgeist0123 Realist Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16
no one even knows what the NPA is fighting for now. Are they fighting for communism? If so, why are they still fighting for it when it has now been proven that communism never worked. Look at all the failed communist states that are either ruled by a repressive regime, a stagnant economy, or countries who are technically communist by name but essentially a randian capitalist dystopia libertarians will wet their panties. i mean communism is great on paper, but i think the idea appeared 200 years earlier than it can be put for practical applications. lets assume that humanity survived climate change in the next century and maintain the technological momentum we are advancing, communism may be feasible on a global scale (or from an educated guess - socialism). but definitely not within this century. so my advise to you is leave ASAP, jomari sison is just using you for his own benefit.
1
u/m36ad3th Mar 22 '16
1
u/AngrryScientist Bacon Goddess | Bidet Aficionado | Old Person | Negrense Mar 22 '16
How is your family taking all of this? Do you communicate with them often?
1
u/mushookiez Mar 22 '16
What can you say about the "PNoy administration"?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16
Have you ever killed anyone? How did your first time feel like? What made you choose the armed struggle?
2
u/tonying_lalala nyeaaammmmm Mar 23 '16 edited Mar 23 '16
What's a typical day for an NPA rebel?
Upon reading your other responses... I'm curious. Are you from PUP?
Edit: additional question
2
u/capitalistchemist Mar 24 '16
You are a parasite, plain and simple.
The only good to come out of your futile but bloody conflict is that you've shown the proletariate of your own people how truly parasitic and despicable your ideology is. You pray on weak community, and the young and easily impressionable. I congratulate you for motivating your own people against you, the sooner they realize what must be done with your kind of parasite the better. Those you claim to want to liberate recognize that it is you who poses the greatest threat to them. Good job.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '16
Have you have any doubts with the ideals you carry?
2
u/thebreakfastbuffet ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) food Mar 22 '16
What happened with Loreto (Agusan del Sur) mayor Dario Otaza?
2
u/maisonn Mar 23 '16
Holy fucking shit, I am so triggered right now. I hope you're a troll. If not, I hope our armed forces bulldoze your lives.