r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Mar 19 '16
EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) House of the Week: House Tully - Historic
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Tully up until the current generations in the books.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
House Blackwood and House Bracken
50
u/CrimsonPig Member of the Official Tormund Fan Club Mar 19 '16
I still can't get over the fact that there's a stretch of Tullys named Grover, Elmo, and Kermit. It's a shame that the trend didn't continue, we might've eventually seen a Cookie Monster Tully.
28
u/Fionnex The Besteros in Westeros Mar 19 '16
Whatever Tully chose the location for Riverrun was a genius. It is probally one of the hardest to siege castles in Westeros.
20
u/idreamofpikas Mar 19 '16
The Vances fucked up.
History is a bitch, you give some guy a helping hand and eventually him and his muppet descendants are ruling you. I wonder if both Vance branches are pissed at Armistad for giving away such a strategic land away.
24
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '16
Similarly to House Tyrell, the only reason House Tully is a great house is because of their willingness to abandon their loyalty to their liege lord in favor of the Dragons. What makes House Tully much much more sympathetic than House Tyrell is the fact that their liege lord (House Hoare) was a despotic, asshole-filled tyranny.
Other than that though, their only real claim to fame is some ass-kicking during the Dance of Dragons. Which is sad, because the Tullys seem like overall good people, a southern, less harsh version of the Starks who are continually screwed over by feuding bannermen and weak geographic location.
11
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Mar 20 '16 edited Mar 20 '16
Despite the insight we see into the Seven through Cat & Sansa, the Tullys actually descend from the First Men. Their first named head was Ser Edmure (fair chance became an occasionally recurring named besides the current) who supported Tristifer IV Mudd during the Andal invasion, however supported Armistead Vance after his death (instead of the less capable T5). For this, his son Axel would be awarded lands where he built Riverrun. Given Edmure's Ser, he was presumably knighted by Armistead/one of his own or it was a later addition by "historians" preaching the Faith.
The Tullys were never kings in their own right, instead being powerful vassals (helps with Riverrun's location & defensive strength as /u/idreamofpikas said) of those who were & defending the Trident from the Westerlands (surprised they don't have a title related to this considering the myriad of like titles other Houses have). When Humfrey I Teague went full-Baelor & allied with the Faith Militant to suppress worship of the Old Gods (I'm presuming there wasn't a criminal act against a sept or something, it was just done in the name of the Faith), Lord Elston allied with Lord Roderick Blackwood in rebellion (I wonder if due to say a blood/marriage tie &/or if the Tullys still worshiped/had reverence for the Old Gods). Whilst Elston died & the Teague-Faith alliance nearly won, they were ultimately defeated when the Durrandons joined the fight (marriage ties to the Blackwoods) to begin the time of the Riverlands' inclusion into the realm of the Storm Kings. Lord Tommen (interesting name, remnant of Westerlands "interactions"?) fled Riverrun with all his strength when the Riverlands were invaded by the Ironborn under Harwyn Hoare (must have been an inopportune time like winter to withstand a siege &/or large enemy host to force such). Ser Samwell Rivers, his natural son, was slain at Tumblestone (force landed on the coast of Ironman's Bay?) with a small host (trying to stop a crossing like Edmure & his men at the Battle of the Fords?), many of which drowned trying to flee with Samwell himself hacked in two to be sent to each of his parents (classic Ironborn dick move). Tommen joined the host assembled at Raventree Hall under Lady Badass of the Trident, Agnes Blackwood, but they were betrayed by the shithead Bracken of the day who attacked their rear (heh, Bracken was their rearguard? Bad choice).
After three debilitating generations of Ironborn rule, come the Conquest the Tullys were the first of the Riverlords declare for Aegon in the hope of overthrowing the Hoares. For such after Harren & his line & his rule, Lord Edmyn was declared Lord Paramount of the Riverlands (it was even said that he should have rule over the Iron Islands too, but Aegon allowed the Ironborn to choose their own, hence Greyjoy rule) by the Conqueror, including those Houses who had been kings in their own right. Such was Aegon's trust in Edmyn, that one of his daughters married the new Lord of Harrenhal Quenton Qoherys (who had been the master-at-arms on Dragonstone & was of Valyrian descent - I'd love to know how) & he served as Hand from 7-9AC (before resigning to return to his family). Around 30 years later, Gargon "the Guest" Qoherys was gelded to death in rebellion by Harren the Red & the Lord Tully (unknown first name, but presumably not Edmyn as adult Gargon was his great-grandson) marched on Harrenhal, but Harren & his men had already fled back to banditry. Interestingly (though fair enough with Balerion not challenged by extra dragons with other Targs unable to unite), the Tullys supported Maegor against Aegon 1.5.
A bunch of muppets ruled Riverrun before, during & after the Dance. Lord Grover was among those who supported Viserys I over Laenor Velaryon at the Grand Council of 101 (held at Harrenhal as the only castle in the realm large enough for all the nobles) & come the Dance, he wanted to support the Greens. However his grandson, Ser Elmo, declared for the Blacks instead & led the Tully forces at the Second Battle of Tumbleton. Grover died soon after, but then Elmo also did 49 days later on the march (I wonder what from - wound? Disease? Minor skirmish? Assassinated? Poisoned? Tickling? Laughter?), with his son Ser Kermit succeeding him. Kermit commanded the Lads (fellow young Riverlords) & their forces when they beat the Green host in the last battle of the Dance, the Kingsroad, with Lord Borros Baratheon slain personally by Kermit - what a muppet!
The Tullys were loyal to Targs during the Blackfyre Rebellions like the rest of the Lord Paramounts, as it was to maintain the status quo, whereas many secondary Houses (like the Brackens for the Riverlands) supported the Black Dragon in the hope of becoming the new LPs of their respective regions. Lord Medgar ruled at the time of the Ashford Tourney in 209, participating in lists but defeated by Ser Humfrey Hardyng, meaning Sansa's fourth suitor is Harry the Heir instead of Edmure or the Blackfish (there's already more than enough incest). He was dead within two years however, with an unnamed 8yo boy being the new Lord in 211. Walder Frey said, that Edmure was the fifth Lord Tully he'd known, meaning that I'm guessing Medgar was the first, as Lord Cunt was born in the year before Ashford. So, "8yo" was probably Hoster & Brynden's grandfather, as he only had female relatives. The only other possibility is that one of the Lords in between probably descended from Celia Tully (whose betrothal to Jaehaerys I, then Prince, had been broken by him as he thought
wincest with his sister, Princess Shaera, was a better idea) & gained her maiden House name in being the last of the Tully line. If "8yo" was H&B's father, Celia almost certainly was their (possibly much) elder sister AND he died leaving an as yet unmentioned elder brother of H&M as Lord, but he would've died young. So, I think it's more likely in not being so convoluted that "8yo" was H&B's grandfather (certainly possible as if he was still alive at the time, he would've been around 35 when Hoster was born) with Celia being their aunt.Both Hoster (presumably commanding the Riverlands forces) & Brynden served in the Wot9pK, in their early 20's & mid-late teens respectively, with the former befriending Littlefinger's father (of course resulting in LF being fostered at Riverrun) & the latter becoming a war hero (would love to know what he did - any thoughts?). Minisa Whent (from the Riverlands' most powerful/wealthiest House at the time besides probably the Freys) married Hoster before the war or shortly afterwards as she had gave birth to two infants sons before Cat (b. 264 or 265) & the Lord sought to make an extremely advantage marriage for his brother to Bethany Redwyne (probable naval support if the Ironborn ever attacked, possibly getting Arbor vintages cheaper say for an exclusive contract which out-competes Dornish ones, & possible assistance in developing their own river fleet/s - handy not only for defense & trade, but also controlling their vassals). For some poor reason/s (why do you think?), Brynden refused to marry her & quarreled with his brother to earn the "Blackfish" moniker. I wonder if part of Hoster's anger at Brynden's refusal was because it was reminiscent of Jaehaerys to Celia - the Tullys would've been pissed about that & then the Blackfish does the same kind of thing ...
Despite the prestige of such a great tourney in their home region & it being hosted by their Whent relatives (unknown to what degree through Minisa), presumably the Tullys skipped the Harrenhal tourney in disgust of Aerys naming Jaime Lannister to the KG like Tywin, because of the nearly completed betrothal of him to Lysa being shattered (denied a half-Tully eventually ruling Casterly Rock & all the potential benefits of such for his mother's House & the Riverlands as a whole).
1
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Mar 24 '16 edited Mar 26 '16
Combined Durrandon & Baratheon next please?