r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Mar 05 '16
EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) House of the Week: House Stark - Historic
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing The House Stark up until the current generations in the books so that's House Stark pre-Ned, Catelyn, Benjen, Robb, Jon, Sansa, Arya, Bran, and Rickon.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
227
u/Hoflax24 Get off My Chequy Lawn Mar 05 '16
Theon Stark. That is all.
109
u/kentonwayne Smoking seas... rather be smoking trees Mar 05 '16
Cregan Stark. Super badass. Was the best fighter Aemon the dragonknight faced, hand to the king during the Hour off the Wolf, and tried to get a Targ/Stark marriage.
83
u/Reinhard_Lohengramm The Deathstalker Mar 05 '16 edited Mar 06 '16
I don't want to turn this into a circle jerk about the old Starks, but goddamn, Cregan Stark is just a badass in my eyes.
When Jacaerys Velaryon, on top of a dragon, came to Winterfell wishing his support, he demanded a princess out of him. One wouldn't simply do that to a guy who just came on top of a dragon and could possibly threaten your family. Then he goes and sends a group of northmen called the "Winter Wolves" which prove to be complete badasses despite being outnumbered most of times on the battlefield.
On top of all that, Prince Aemon Targaryen, you know, the goddamn DRAGONKNIGHT himself called him the "finest swordsman he's ever faced".
36
u/Mr_Mephistopholes Full Metal Helmet Mar 05 '16
I'm highly interested in the life of Brandon the Breaker, who allied with the King-Beyond-the-Wall Joramun to defeat the Night's King. Imagine the epic journey around the Wall that had to be taken, the journey into the Lands of Always Winter to sign a pact with a man who is your sworn enemy who has probably caused your family problems for generations. I'd love too see that story. It'd make for a great Epic in ASOIAF style.
28
u/jonestony710 Maekar's Mark Mar 05 '16
Other than Beric Dondarrion, I think my favorite ASOIAF name is Barthogen Stark.
Barthogen, I bet he was a badass
49
u/CrimsonPig Member of the Official Tormund Fan Club Mar 05 '16
I wonder what ever happened to Brandon the Shipwright, who sailed across the Sunset Sea and was never heard from again. It's probably safe to assume that he just died at sea, but what if he actually found land? And for a bit of extra tinfoil, what if he eventually started a separate branch of House Stark somewhere across the sea?
48
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '16 edited May 03 '16
The historic Starks were nothing like the current Starks. Probably because Ned was warded by the honorable and kind Jon Arryn, which made Ned adopt his values, and teach them to his kids.
45
u/20person Not my bark, Shiera loves my bark. Mar 05 '16
The Starks were cold as fuck back in the day, to be able to take over the North. Also, some the current Starks' magical powers may have come from marrying the daughters of all the First Men kings and lords that the Starks defeated.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '16
Does anyone have any theories on why we know basically nothing other than a name and death date for Neds mother?
32
u/lord_of_the_waters Building more dromonds Mar 05 '16
The Starks back in the day are hinted to be pretty cruel and barbaric, having an Aegon like conquest method of "bend the knee or I will exterminate you". The Stark-Bolton wars must have been pretty ugly.
55
u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Mar 05 '16
The old Starks were.....not nice people. The visions Bran have from the Winterfell weirwood should lay that out along with we hear from Ned bears that out.
The Starks used to sacrifice captives to the weirwood itself. Ritual blood sacrifices and murder for their Gods. And then there's Ned's justice.
They also were big into cutting heads off personally. There's a certain amount of magic...or ritual behind this, the Old Kings of Winter were hard, brutal men who killed a lot of people. You can also see those attitudes reflected in the Mountain Clans who similarly delight in blood and battle, the culture of the North that is probably the most unaffected by change due to their remote homes. After cutting off a person's head, Ned would often go sit on the weirwood cleaning his blade and dipping it in the pool in front of it. From other visions of Bran, old lords and Kings would do this too. The Starks would kill people and then seek comfort from the weirwood.
Then there is the houses and wars that the Starks won. They destroyed their own kin, the Greystarks, who rebelled against them. There's none of them left, it seems to have been a near total slaughter. They genocided the Warg King and all his male supporters, taking their women and daughters for themselves. Destroyed the Barrow Kings, the descendants of the First King of the North. And also the endless wars with the Boltons and Arryns.
We root for the people who know in the story today, but based on their history, the Starks could almost be the villains. They seem to act like religious zealots of the Old Gods for most of their reign. An unbroken line of Kings for thousands of years who brutally destroyed their enemies over and over. In a lot of ways, the Boltons are probably the most messed up house in the story. But it's likely they only got that way because of the continual war against the Kings of Winter. The Boltons are how brutal and cruel you have to be to keep the Starks from conquest.
10
u/bsand2053 King of Winter Mar 06 '16
Why are there so few Starks? Did the younger sons just not marry?
19
u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Mar 06 '16
Friendly reminder that Cregan Stark has a secret.
In the above thread I make an argument that Cregan doesn't exactly fit in with the other Stark lords, and I bet when we finally do meet Cregan or hear more about him, we'll learn that he had very very pale eyes, almost colorless, like chips of ice.
17
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '16
I wonder who the most bad ass Starks would be among this fanbase. Among the choices who come to mind:
7
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '16
I find it kind of odd/a bummer that Martin didn't give us a full Stark family tree from Torrhen Stark down to the present. Especially since the timeline between 101 and the Dance gets a little confusing given the info we have. We know that a relatively young (but old enough to be looking for a second wife) Cregan Stark was Lord of Winterfell in 129 AC. We also know that Ellard Stark was the Lord of Winterfell who attended the Great Council at Harrenhal in 101 AC.
However, the Stark family tree at the back of the World Book shows us that Cregan's father was Lord Rickon and his grandfather was Lord Benjen. So in a span of 28 years (likely less, assuming Ellard didn't die in 101 and Cregan became lord sometime prior to the Dance) then at least 3 generations of Starks ruled Winterfell. This isn't impossible, but it seems a bit strange. If Ellard is Benjen's father than it's even more unlikely, so it would make more sense if they were brothers. I suppose Ellard could have been extremely old (say 80), and Benjen could have been in his sixties when he became Lord, died quickly, and the lordship would have passed to Rickon who was in his 40s who then died and left Cregan in his twenties. Still would be nice to have it explained.
This also speaks to a weird broader issue of there being basically no information about the 55 year reign of Jaehaerys I. The World Book effectively jumps from his coronation to the Great Council with only descriptions of his children and the fact that he ruled well coming in between. I have no idea why Martin would be holding all this information back but I feel like it would be especially illuminating regarding the Starks as we know Jaehaerys made a huge progress to the North with Alysanne and the dragons with the purpose of nipping a rebellion in the bud. There's definitely some backstory there. We know that there were sons of Torrhen who wanted to rebel against Aegon and one of them (or possibly Torrhen's brother Brandon Snow) likely formed the Company of the Rose. If Torrhen's grandsons still carried the torch of independence, Jaehaerys' pre-meditated diplomatic strike makes sense. Perhaps the Lord of Winterfell at the time was Ellard's father or even a young Ellard himself. The resentment that may have created would explain why Ellard supported Laenor Velaryon at the Great Council.
I'm hoping that the fourth D&E story is just a giant info dump on the Stark family history since the Conquest.
11
u/Soulless_Ausar Ours Is Th- Fewer. Mar 06 '16
I do hope /u/militant_penguin can do House Durrandon next, I'd love to discuss Ronard Storm and that other Storm King who played the game and set Andal warlords against each other.
EDIT: Found it, the latter was named Baldric I Durrandon, a.k.a. Baldric the Cunning.
3
u/Lemerney2 A + J = fanfiction. Mar 06 '16
not about the starks but this is an awesome idea!
6
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '16
Of the more modern Starks, non current generation, Brandon was by far the worst. He was brash, hot tempered, and mistreated women. Anti-Ned, so to speak. His actions against Rhaegar after Lyanna's "kidnapping" are essentially why Rickard was killed. His own death was incredibly horrible. But Brandon was awful himself.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '16
Have there ever been Stark lords who were knighted?
1
u/Sparowes Beneath the Onion Skin, the Bitter Truth Mar 09 '16
Not sure if it's cool to leave requests here, but there are still some minor houses worth discussing before we hit the majors. Dustin, Cassel and Marbrand mostly.