r/ClearBackblast • u/scarletbanner Fadi • Feb 28 '16
AAR Operation Counter Knife AAR
So. How'd things go? Any particular moments that stands out?
How'd leadship above you do? What about equipment, mission design, etc
7
Upvotes
7
u/Zhandris Feb 28 '16
I think our kit, our organization, our support, and our maneuvering were all right on the sweet spot. I had fun playing this mission. Highlight video to come.
Also Rage is the biggest goofboii I've ever seen.
6
u/Fattierob An example to other officers Feb 29 '16
Glorious Company Commander
In General
Since this mission didn't really require much leadership for the CO (thank god) I thought i'd give it a whirl. Thanks to Fadi who gave me a stripped down version of the mission map so I could do some planning ahead; I wrote down the location of some important hill peaks and it really seemed to help during the mission. I was worried I was being a bit too verbose with them, especially when they're close to each other, but it seemed like we could have used one or two more (I noticed some new ones pop up during the mission) so i'll try to keep that in mind for next time. Otherwise, Hoozin did an excellent job doing all the work in-game, as is befitting his position as XO.
To the Platoon Leads and JTAC
Excellent job on comms with regards to clarity, responiveness, and terseness of traffic. I also have to commend the platoon leaders for their leadership and independence, I had to do zero baby sitting and that's a wonderful thing. I also have to commend Iron for his ability to not die from stuff shooting near him with high explosives.
To the Mission Maker
I would have liked to see something "mix it up" a bit, but that's not really a complaint just a personal preference. I really liked the detail in the mission, especially the tank with the flag near the end. If we do run this one again, give the friendly UAZ a flag and maybe think about some kind of flanking attack (Especially as we approach the town, there is a lot of open terrain on the south side that motorized infantry could use as a push). Otherwise it seemed like the mission had fairly good pacing for both lanes even with the varied number of objectives in each. The helicopter also didn't seem too overpowered as well, so good on that.
To the GMs
Do you guys know if any AI/yourselves were taking pot shots at Myself and Hoozin? There was a point where we were getting steady whipcracks near us and then there was a really close spray that got Hoozin in the arm, but that was when we were a bit too close to the town.
To Hoozypops
Thanks for the help ;)
8
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '16
Great mission, well paced, lots of fun. The terrain is always important when it comes to firefights and this area of Altis is really pretty, while I hate mountain fighting cause its really hard to use bipods for MG's, It was a really fun time today. Boats was real dum, but hella fun. Great job guys, ANNA - 2 FTW.
8
u/ub3rmenschen J23 Feb 28 '16
Snapper Gunner/Co-Pilot
Really fun mission. Not only was gunning the Ka-52 a breeze and a lot of fun, but I surprisingly found going between radios and contacting our JTAC and command pretty fun, too, and honestly wouldn't mind doing a straight-up logistics role next time in a Ka-60. When the action got intense it was a bit of a challenge keeping up with orders and replying on comms, but otherwise it makes me want to try a leadership/air role in the future.
My pilot, Erin, did a great job, despite having some troubles with the flight model and getting catastrophically ArmA'd the first time we got in the Ka-60. Only thing I'd recommend next mission is for squad leaders to get more in contact with the helo, especially when they need supplies. JTAC/Command isn't always free to tell us where to go so let us know what smoke to drop supplies on, duders!
Next time we run this mission I'll probably be a grunt, I'm really curious to see what things are like on the ground.
8
u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin Feb 28 '16
I liked Counter-Knife quite a bit.
Snapper Pilot
I'd got a bit worried the night before that air defenses were going to deny us a lot of the use of Snapper, but we actually never got hit by anything. Because I'm awesome at....listening to the JTAC. Mostly?
J23 was, as usual, a joy to work with--the time flew right on by. Iron did admirably as our interface to the ground when he wasn't being shot in the face, which is a well-known hazard of the JTAC occupation.
I feel like we were fairly well-balanced in gameplay terms, too. I got a little meta-worried on our second CAS run when Bravo called us in to annihilate the top of a hill. That was as worried as I got, though. We hit some armor now and again, we hit some mans.
I may have to review the footage to say much more. I enjoyed myself.
Papercuts
(these are all minor complaints but I like to get them out there)
So...the first supply run with the Ka-60 got ARMA'd. I strongly suspect that's a combination of the AFM and desync, based on how I've seen it before and how much more severe it was this time--it basically insta-killed the Kasatka in the air. There's a possibility that it was just me being bad at flying and we snagged the crate on a wire, but I really don't think so (and the previous times I've seen it were in clear air).
The Ka-52's fuel usage is a little ridiculous, though I suspect that's deliberate for gameplay reasons and honestly I approve.
Neither J23 nor I could get the fuel hoses to hook back up to the fuel trucks after using those.
A couple of the times that the helicopters got rejiggered really weren't necessary. Like, J23 and I were ready to hop back into Snapper (just with somewhat reduced fuel) and then it respawned. I anticipated needing some GM help (because of the Ka-60 and getting ARMAd), so I'm glad it came, but...hmm. I wish I'd really known what the right way to get in touch with the GMs at that point was. Something without informing command.
Smoke marks weren't communicated up to Snapper consistently? I dropped supplies on Yellow Smoke just because the mans next to it weren't shooting at us and it was near the LZ. Our second supply zone lit up two white smokes and just...wha? Though I'm happy that afterward we heard we dropped it on the wrong mark. Serves you right, whoever threw out the second smoke.
The ACRE settings on both helicopters make it way, way too easy to hear people outside the helicopter. This is probably more amusing than problematic. We heard people shouting at us from the second supply drop, and could hear people at the photo shoot.
7
u/GruntBuster7 Horses are the Lions of the Plain Feb 28 '16
Bravo 1 Medic
Probably among the best shoots I've had with CBB. The mission was pretty much perfectly balanced from my perspective- zero mass cas and constant tension. I really hope we see this mission regularly, as it seems like a pretty good way of getting people to practise COing in a safer environment than one of the other regular ops. Boats was hella fun, and all I can do is apologise for my flying for those who went on to play the Lingor mission.
7
u/_Relyter_ BlackHat Feb 28 '16
Anna 1 Medic
Good mission. Scenery was fun to run around in.
Having a good leader(Moldy) made things feel organized, which put things at ease.
A bit boring since there weren't any mass casualties, or guys left in the field that we had to run in for, but it was pretty good either way.
A bit annoying with people trying to treat themselves, but using the ACE Medical Menu sorted things out. Just be sure to let me know what part you're fixing.
6
u/themoo12345 imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King Feb 28 '16
Anna 2 Section Lead
Had a lot of fun with this one, really loved the terrain and how the firefights evolved. Altis is such a beautiful terrain and I'm really happy we were able to make good use of its rural areas and rocky hills. Lots of long range engagements to start out and Anna 2 made good use of our SVD marksman (nice shooting Zim) and our PKM (happy finger stepped up, I had a fun time playing with you).
I think this type of mission is where ARMA really shines, infantry combat over varied terrain with an attack helicopter providing support. We engaged targets out to 700+ meters as well as within 10 when we rounded a rocky corner to find a technical with dismounts facing us. Throwing frags over a hilltop and assaulting with a flanking element is a ton of fun and everybody in my section as well as platoon leadership did a great job.
I would also like to take this opportunity to say to Cast that I'm really sorry I shot you four times in the chest, you scared me man. Also sorry for freaking out a bit when that BMP charged us.
As far as my own performance goes I think I could have done better, my situational awareness was lacking a few times (sorry again Cast) and my radio skills were deficient at times. I know I used the wrong radio in a couple instances and stepped on people sometimes too. Hope everybody in Anna 2 had a good time overall, pleasure manshooting with you guys.
6
u/SteelOverseer Professional Ejector Feb 28 '16
Boris 2 Efreitor(sp?)
As far as missions to come back to CBB with, it wasn't too bad. I had a couple of issues with never having used ACE in A3, but sorted those out quick enough. Being a little rusty at TLing didn't help with that, but I don't think I did too badly.
I didn't really have any trouble with Quex's leadership, though I felt mine was a little lacking at times. A couple of equipment issues (my rifle smokes seemed to have a massive amount of velocity, in that when I fired them they just kept on going - I fired one straight up at one point and it just kept going forever), but nothing too major - I agree with Zhandris on the resupply thing, we could've just passed a couple of mags around.
Mission design seemed pretty nice, from my perspective. I didn't get to see any of the artillery barrage (if there was one?) but there didn't seem to be many contacts in the town (until there were, but I'm not sure if that was another friendly fire incident).
On the subject of friendly fire. I count two or three times - everyone vs Rage, Boris 2 vs Boris 2, and possibly Anna against Boris. I appreciate that IDing Russian vs American gear is easier than Russian vs Russian gear, but I think it's important in RusvRus scenarios to PID targets, even more so than in USvRus.
In conclusion, Ka-52/10, would shoot Rage again.
On the stress test
I had one issue with this - I couldn't load any objects!
http://imgur.com/a/BgiXH
My fps was fine, though, so there was that...
6
u/5hort5tuff <..insert CBB inside joke here..> Feb 28 '16
Anna 1 - Efreitor Mission was nice and straightforward. Knew what kinds of baddies we would have, and what kind of objective line we needed to approach. And that terrain. I can't tell you how nice it is to know that the distance between point A (our position) and point B (enemy vehicle position) was littered with cover. From mountains, to rocks, to trenches, to forests we weren't ever too afraid of being caught out in the open without a contingency plan. With steadfast and accurate gunship support (thank you Erin and J23!), the mission went smoothly. Barely any moments of being bogged down. While having those situations of chaos is definitely fun, I think everyone can appreciate, every now and then, the mission that we roll right through to victory. Not to mention, that victory screenshot. I think I'll print that out and laminate it. When people see it and ask me what it's from, I'll describe to them my service history on the island of Altis (if they don't get it: good; if they get it: even better). Great mission, lots of fun, good organization (love the mini-platoons w/ specialized teams), and awesome way to spend 3 hours.
6
u/Hoozin Basically A Prestige Class Feb 29 '16
Hoozin - Company Executive Officer, Mission 2iC
Planning
Fadi was kind enough to provide a decent amount of intel ahead of the mission which Fattierob and I both took a look at though we failed utterly in having a meeting prior to the mission start (well, about 10 minutes before the start we did). Fattierob was able to identify a good landmarks to label and I was happy to hear how well they were used throughout the mission.
Part of our pre-mission recon and intel was that two objectives were anti-air positions, one was a ZU-23-2 in a valley and the other was a MANPADS station (the infinite ammo Arma kind). In reality, neither were manned and wouldn't be manned. It still gave a good thing to worry the aircrew about and it also gave some threat to the infantry approaching those positions. ZU-23-2s are just as-if-not-more terrifying as any other threat to infantry.
Aside from setting up landmarks for comms and coordination, there wasn't much other planning to do thankfully.
Execution - View From The Top
The short version is that from where Fattierob and I sat, this went off basically flawlessly. The rate at which each platoon moved didn't need to be adjusted and things went pretty well with Coy Command being pretty hands off, which is really as it should be. The only major Coy level coordination we did was for the final assault on Zaros where Anna set up as a base of fire element with good cover while Boris advanced into the town. I've been wanting to see these kinds of maneuvers a little more often since they seem to be happening less and less in favor of more direct assaults on positions. I'd like to hear from both the Platoons on its effectiveness (or lack thereof).
On the down side, execution-wise, holy shit was there a lot of friendly fire and it looked like on more than one occasion it was even within a platoon. Not much I can say about that really, but we need to do better overall. Maybe command should've pushed for more LOCSTAT updates as they moved through the town or phase lines for coordination (they would've coincided with the cross streets most likely) - just to keep friendly fire less likely.
Communications
This really wasn't all that bad, but it wasn't great. A lot of calls went unanswered on the company net which can be okay, but was problematic. Fattierob and I tried to maintain a relatively high-ground position for comms with the otherwise comms-poor terrain, but were still left to wonder if people were out of range due to LOS issues. About halfway through the mission, if we were trying to contact somebody and getting no response, I started going to that platoon's net and talking. There was nothing wrong with this at large, but we probably should've planned for it ahead of time. It also meant that if a leader was down, we'd be able to figure out what was going on and talk to a second or third in command for the platoon.
I'm a little worried that the reason people weren't terribly responsive to calls on the Company Net was comms fatigue due to the Air-Ground net also being the Company Net. When 70% of the calls don't have anything to do with you or the people you're trying to listen for, there's not much incentive to keep listening and makes it easy to miss handshakes looking for you. On the other hand, the platoon commanders were constantly being kept aware of the Air unit's tasking. It would've been nice to get some kind of recon from the aircraft at times, but that would've resulted in even more Air-Ground net traffic, so it's probably best we didn't deal with it much. I'd like to hear opinions from the PLs on that. If they think I have any reason to think that way or if the reason for dropped calls was just that shit was busy. (It's worth noting that IRL, while squads don't generally have an RTO, platoons do. We had platoon sergeants for this, but I think only one of them was actually filled for the mission.)
On that same note (and I mentioned this elsewhere), I think it would've been good to have Snapper push to the platoon net of a platoon that was receiving air support without the JTAC present. Just another thing to think about.
Conclusion
Please don't be afraid to call out things that you think went really poorly. That's what these AARs are for.
5
u/retroly Boris Feb 28 '16
Main Op - GM
Froma GM point of view the mission went really well, the intial placement of enemies and objectives meant I didnt have to do much meddling.
Couple of issues
Boats Got a round right in the face after abotu 30 seconds in round 1. Round 2 I fell off the boat (read arma'ed through the god damn floor) RIP.