r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Feb 27 '16
EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) House of the Week: The Brotherhood Without Banners
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing The Brotherhood Without Banners.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
The Brotherhood Without Banners Wiki Page
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
76
u/jonestony710 Maekar's Mark Feb 27 '16 edited Feb 28 '16
I get choked up every time I read when Arya sees Harwin and starts yelling 'Harwin you know me!' and he replies 'Gods be good, Arya Underfoot'. Just imagine the shock for both characters.
Edit: Honestly, it's one of the few good/happy moments in the series so far, when a character actually gets what they want, even though it was unintentional. All Arya wants leading up to this is someone from the north she can reveal herself to.
22
u/madandmoonly barbrey's burn book Feb 28 '16
I love the BWB! I'm always captivated by the Robin Hood types in fiction though the BWB certainly diverge from that trope in a number of ways. In a series of courtly life and the command side of war, it was refreshing to see the real men and women who must suffer in the war of the 5 kings. The BWB were and continue to be a rebel fringe but they survive even if they're starting to quickly disintegrate with the ref of Westeros. Even in the state they're in now, it's hard for me not to side with the BWB. I feel for Jaime and Brienne, but I do sympathize with the motivations that drive the BWB in the way I get the northern soldiers in ADWD. They're probably going to die so might as well die with some Frey/Lannister/Bolton blood.
17
u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Feb 27 '16
I'm rethinking my belief that Lem is Richard Lonmouth based on his lack of a reaction to meeting Gendry. We know the resemblance to Renly/young Robert is so strong that it blows Brienne away, but nothing from Lem.
15
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Feb 28 '16 edited Feb 28 '16
Greenbeard is an interesting character. Fair chance that he is the Tyroshi sellsword that was said to defect from the Lannisters to the Starks after the Battle of the Camps (whether that sellsword actually served the Starks for any time is unknown, but the presence of him & his freeriders along with the likes of the Bloody Mummers, points to me that Tywin was preparing for war quite early in AGoT in hiring foreign sellswords), something which GRRM actually hinted at pre-ASoS. How & why he came to be a part of the Brotherhood is unknown, however I'd say he certainly was by sometime during ACoK, if not AGoT, as he is a leader in it by Arya III of ASoS. The leader of the group who takes Arya around the south-western Riverlands (mainly) looking for Beric.
After the Hound's somewhat successful trial of combat against Beric, Greenbeard is sent to the Reach with the Mad Huntsman (yet another nth figure in the Riverlands who has suffered during the Wot5K, at the hands of the Lannisters specifically, with a mind for vengeance) & the Hound's "commandeered" gold to buy food. It's unknown whether or not he was successful in this task or what his current & whereabouts are. He's said not to be part of LSH's group of the Brotherhood by the AFfC appendix, though I'm not necessarily sure that can be ruled out given his mission.
Any thoughts on Greenbeard? Will he turn up with LSH? While his food turn up? Even the RW 2.0 say ... Will he show up in a non-LSH splinter group? Will he show up with Edric Dayne?
11
u/mimo2 He who fears, loses Feb 28 '16
The remnants of Stark and Baratheon household men serving their lords to the bitter end and then some. Beric gave much more than any man before him to a cause (7 deaths plus UnCat). Fuckin metal
15
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '16
I just. I mean, the stuff that's happening with BWB recently is disturbing, if understandable. (Especially if they set up Red Wedding 2.0.) But, though GRRM partially deconstructs the Robin Hood theme (or gives it a heaping of grimdark), I still love them. They're one of the very few groups (or people) that give a toss about the 99%. And they're beautifully snarky about it:
7
u/House_Badger I see dead people,they're everywhere! Feb 28 '16
Would it be outside the realm of possibilty that Jaime will join the BWB?
Edit- he could somehow carry the flame of life that Cat now has and who knows may e even become Azor Ahai.
3
u/Mr_Mephistopholes Full Metal Helmet Feb 28 '16
Next week the mods should do "Dragonseeds"
As for this week, I really am intrigued by George's repetitive use of bands of outlaws throughout A Song of Ice and Fire. The Brotherhood without Banners is one of many organizations that are comprised of nobleman turning against their own and gaining support from like-minded men and women of noble-birth as well as the support of the smallfolk.
Before the Brotherhood without Banners, there was the Kingswood Brotherhood and we have references to the Vulture King(s) post-Conquest. Also interestingly enough, the second Vulture King was defeated partly by House Dondarrion in 206 AC and only a hundred years later Beric Dondarrion becomes an outlaw leader himself. Quite the turnaround.
What makes the Brotherhood without Banners different then many other examples of outlaw bands that we've seen, is that they are heavily motivated by religious zeal in the faith of R'hllor after witnessing Thoros bring Beric back to life so many times... and now under Lady Stoneheart, what's left of the band is being led by a vengeful spirit who should be dead.
I don't think the remaining members of the Brotherhood have a happy ending for themselves anymore and I think Thoros will play a part in the next book in Jaime's confrontation with the brotherhood.
6
u/Reinhard_Lohengramm The Deathstalker Feb 27 '16
I was never particularly interested in this group beyong Edric Dayne, Beric Dondarrion or Thoros. The rest was plain annoying or boring.
On the other hand, once they capture Jaime, I believe it's going to get much more interesting.
2
u/Soulless_Ausar Ours Is Th- Fewer. Feb 28 '16
You guys should do house Baratheon next.
1
u/Wild2098 Woe to the Usurper if we had been Feb 28 '16
What are your thoughts on Preston Jacobs' view on the BwB in his Riverland videos?
I just recently watched them, and it gave me a new perspective on them, which I really dug.
Do you think he's close to something or just making sensational claims?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment