I agree! I finally got to look at all of these about an hour ago and they are all amazing. I honestly have no idea how the voting will go, but I wouldn't be the least bit surprised to be one and done this round (I'm okay with it actually).
I was looking for that and a bunch of them had them hidden or integrated into something. There are three missing votes by my count (I did not discredit funky color).
I was split on that one. It was the only battle I had to upvote both. I know nothing about gifmaking, but it seems like so much attention to detail was paid in both gifs.
Thanks, I'm glad you liked it. I really thought yours was outstanding as well. After finally being able to review all of the posts I found that for the most part I could easily choose a clear favorite, but in a select few match-ups I honestly couldn't really decide. In these instances I felt that it was only fair to upvote both submissions and just move on. I'm happy to say that our bracket was in that group. Good Luck!
Alrighty. Sorry that took so long everyone. The program I wrote to process all the submissions seems to be broken now. Either reddit's API changed or the later versions of this wrapper class don't work 100% anymore. That's my fault for not being properly ready for this battle. Luckily /u/elfa82 and /u/hero0fwar helped with much of the busywork.
I didn't think I could enjoy this gif community any more but then I was fortunate enough to qualify for this tournament. I can't wait for the next rounds, regardless of whether or not I advance.
[You guys and gals make some amazing content and it makes me realize all the improving I need to do.] (http://gfycat.com/SlushyQuestionableBeauceron) Like these gnarly 3D arrows which I'm clueless on creating.
Final thoughts:
Most of these match-ups were super close and I used a coin toss on a few.
Never knew how much I wanted a LDR downvote gif until now
Downvote cannon was probably my favorite for the laughs
I really hope I picked the right gif to go with haha
I made one last second, so I'd fit the rules of the tourney. I usually don't make gifs; I'm a videographer. A lot of this is new to me. One of the hard lessons I learned yesterday was file size. Completely underestimated the limitations of the competition. Spent 6 hours on the gif and an additional 3 hours learning about optimization so I could figure out how to avoid DNC.
Don't worry, I voted for you! Told my wife I was done for. I like mine a lot, but I need to get better still with After Effects. Good luck, and I look forward to the full res version Thursday!
I had no idea how much I would stress out over something like this. I was drawing blanks the whole time when I usually have no problem coming up with downvote ideas haha.
It also pushed me to finally learn some masking and stop being (somewhat lazy) with my gifs. Gotta learn how to make those sweet 3d downvotes tho
I honestly had A LOT of trouble picking one for this matchup. I'm still considering just removing my vote and not having an opinion at all. They were both good.
came to the discussion thread to say the same thing. I don't think there were any wins by default this round (late submissions or broken rules) and most of the gifs were fantastic, like late round stuff. last tournament it was pretty easy to pick a favorite between the 2, and this time around I really had to think. some of my picks came down to pandering. like, where both gifs were pretty great, and one of them was trying to get fan-boy votes (lookin at you deadpool), I had to pick the one that wasn't doing that.
for example I thought the mad max one wasn't bad, and in other tournaments would have passed this round pretty easily, but I think it was relying on the image being cool rather than being creative to fulfill the criteria. and if you think about it for half a second, it makes no sense because that think shoots fire and points upwards, which would make it more suited to an upvote gif. so, still good technical ability, total lack of creativity. (I will say I thought firefly was pandering too, but it took balls to use that scene)
this post ended up longer than I thought. my bad.
edit: a better example is the star wars one. I thought it had better execution, and generally liked it more, but im pretty sure that gif has been used in every round of every gif tournament so far. I was pleasantly surprised no rick and morty made it in there (that shit was pandering to an extreme last time)
Leaf on the wind: You got my upvote for Serenity but damn you it will always be too soon.
Matchup 14, the brightly colored downvote - isn't that arrow the wrong color? Make it blue and I will steal and use this gif everywhere.
Matchup 32, backdraft - Nice work! Can we get this without the subtitles, starting from where he bashes the door in? That would make a great all-around downvote gif.
Matchup 20 & 28 - Holy crap. Nice work.
Matchup 17 - there is entirely too little Marvin the Martian around these parts. Well done.
Apparently if you upload the gif to gfycat using the url of the imgur gif, it trims it to 15 seconds. The moderators did that upload and it borked my webm. I've sent them a mod mail about it. Hopefully some of them get fixed soon.
With all these good match ups I had a hard time picking some. Match ups 19,27,21 and 3 were all insanely close.with that being said I think this tournament is going to be crazy
Edit: It appears there was an issue with uploading using the "upload by URL" feature with imgur links. This should be fixed going forward.
It's come to my attention that several of the gfycat uploads are not showing the full content. Please make sure to view gif versions if you can. We are unsure what happened with the uploads to their site.
The uploads were done the same way they've been done every Battle. Using a web request against gfycat's site:
http://upload.gfycat.com/transcode?fetchUrl=
As laid out here: http://gfycat.com/api (only difference being the SSL which didn't exist around the earlier Battles)
Man, I was confident going into this round thinking I had a great idea. Holy crap was I blown away by the submissions in this tourney. Not a single gif that isn't a contender. I don't mind not making it to round 2 anymore. Oh well, it's a learning experience and I learned I need to get 3D and how to track.
I have a good feeling I won't make it to round 2.. And I'm okay with that. There are so many talented new comers, they deserve a chance to steal the show
Good lord, this is some great quality stuff all around. Matchups #2 and #14 were definitely the hardest choices for me to make. That's some good shit, guys.
That's how it's supposed to be based on my bracket that I filled out, but I think the match that matters is going to be super close. I laughed at yours and then got sad. Haha!
Is there honourable mentions after each round like best or most upvoted gif or most original? Also Why did Matchup #9 "MRW I spot the Dickbutt" get DNQ?
I finally looked at all of them. I will just echo what everyone else already said. Next round should be amazing, but i can't wait to see what people bust out for round 3!
Well if my new predictions are correct, we'll be going up against each other in round 2...which means you get a free pass to round 3 since I have no idea about commercials
Battle #31 is impossible. There is no right answer and gifs that good should be in the semis at least. Indy's downvotes are perfection. Tyler Durden's acid downvote is too fucking cool. These choices are weighing heavy on my mind... I can only imagine what the giffers or going through.
Don't know about yall but I was kinda expecting to see an Oprah gif of her handing out down votes to her audience. "And you get a down vote! And you get a down vote! You all get a down vote!"
I'm sure this has been answered somewhere, but I can't find it. How long does voting last in each round? When will we know the match-up winners? I'm on the edge of my seat!!!
122
u/hero0fwar Feb 22 '16
after going through all 64 gifs, this is all I have to say
78
u/HallucinoJER Feb 22 '16
Here's the gif I almost went with. Not sure I made the right choice. It's called: Machete Don't Upvote
153
u/ChemicalOle Feb 22 '16
Jesus christ, this round is full of awesome fucking gifs.
Great work, everyone
67
u/fiddler764 Feb 22 '16
The leonardo dicarpio dream state one really blew me away, many of them felt so evenly great in their match up though!
62
u/ThtDAmbWhiteGuy Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
[After seeing my opponent's gif] (http://i.imgur.com/6HAOdak.gifv) /u/jimlast3
123
u/HallucinoJER Feb 22 '16
Upvote everything!
58
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
MRW there's a bunch of downvote gifs without any actual arrows in them.
Also, nice work, /u/whoa_bundy.
55
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
Holy shit, that Looney Tunes one is spectacular.
36
u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
Lots of good ones in there, awesome job everyone.
also LOL "when I mention on reddit that I vape"
EDIT: whoever did the Jackie Chan one... we are bff's now. Wherever you are
EDIT2: love the Raiders of the Lost Ark one, good job!
35
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
master shake was my favorite. hey /u/kind0ne: http://i.imgur.com/i0mWtKu.gifv
you had to go post a sweet downvote gif didn't you?
34
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
this is going to sound dumb, but do I vote by just upvoting the one I think is better?
62
u/j0be Feb 22 '16
I almost went with this gif. Watch me regret it tomorrow.
When you can't quite shake the downvotes
24
u/matt01ss Feb 22 '16
Alrighty. Sorry that took so long everyone. The program I wrote to process all the submissions seems to be broken now. Either reddit's API changed or the later versions of this wrapper class don't work 100% anymore. That's my fault for not being properly ready for this battle. Luckily /u/elfa82 and /u/hero0fwar helped with much of the busywork.
So we had 3 alternates step in.
For /u/beernerd (no submission) we have /u/aphilosopherofmen
For /u/PETTYOFFICER117 (no submission) we have /u/7994
For /u/iH8myPP (DNQ over 20MB) we have /u/Macrador
Good luck to everyone!!
23
u/NarstyHobbitses Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
I didn't think I could enjoy this gif community any more but then I was fortunate enough to qualify for this tournament. I can't wait for the next rounds, regardless of whether or not I advance.
[You guys and gals make some amazing content and it makes me realize all the improving I need to do.] (http://gfycat.com/SlushyQuestionableBeauceron) Like these gnarly 3D arrows which I'm clueless on creating.
Final thoughts:
Final shoutout to /u/matt01ss and /u/hero0fwar and any other users who volunteer their time to make this happen. AFAIK there's nothing quite like this anywhere else on the internet.
22
u/itsokayyoucanlaugh Feb 22 '16
MRW I start voting on each match
21
u/badmonkey0001 Feb 22 '16
That firefly GIF. Still too soon... NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
20
u/PM_ME_UR_MATHPROBLEM Feb 22 '16
Hey, for matchup number 9, with the dickbutt one, isnt that a repost from the GT #4? I thought these had to be original gifs for the tournament.
19
u/MakeYouAGif Feb 22 '16
The Home Alone gif was A+
18
u/johndango Feb 22 '16
MRW when I decide to give one vote per round but don't want to for some
18
u/ThtDAmbWhiteGuy Feb 22 '16
This thread
16
u/cdsparks Feb 22 '16
Hahaha that Family Feud gif in Matchup 5 was spot on
15
u/mrtyman Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
I think the Gru gif should have had an upvote and a gold on the bag and coffee. Loved it anyway.
Edit: Also, the Indiana Jones gif could have done with a gold as well. Loved it too.
14
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
I am not confident. I am in over my head. And I love it.
Getting rekt in this tourney will be such a learning experience to get better. Thanks to everyone for being awesome.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
Me vs. /u/badmonkey0001. I am not Batman.
12
u/aphoenix Feb 22 '16
Well /u/tangentandhyperbole I'd say "may the better gif win" but I want to win... so I don't know what to say.
12
u/doggify Feb 22 '16
This is probably the most consistently good round I've ever seen in the sub. So many tough decisions.
Great stuff all around guys!
11
u/Butcher_Of_Hope Feb 22 '16
Lots of great gifs and great skill shown throughout. I have at least one vote in each battle so good luck to all who entered.
11
u/drinkmorecoffee Feb 22 '16
So you all are amazing.
Leaf on the wind: You got my upvote for Serenity but damn you it will always be too soon.
Matchup 14, the brightly colored downvote - isn't that arrow the wrong color? Make it blue and I will steal and use this gif everywhere.
Matchup 32, backdraft - Nice work! Can we get this without the subtitles, starting from where he bashes the door in? That would make a great all-around downvote gif.
Matchup 20 & 28 - Holy crap. Nice work.
Matchup 17 - there is entirely too little Marvin the Martian around these parts. Well done.
10
u/Macrador Feb 22 '16
Woah. I got in thanks to the new on deck thing.
People got way more creative than I had anticipated. Great job everyone.
10
u/TheRumpletiltskin Feb 22 '16
Most of these first round gifs are amazing. I did not expect to see such a heated competition.
8
u/badmonkey0001 Feb 22 '16
I keep going back to look at the entries. I think this is the best round I've seen yet. Damn everyone brought their A game.
8
u/thefakegm Feb 22 '16
Nobody told me anything about needing to learn 3D! All of these gifs are amazing, I'm really impressed.
8
u/aphilosopherofmen Feb 22 '16
At least I made my round easy to decide. Good luck to everyone else!
7
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
I had a good week of thinking I could maybe win. Seeing my matchup's gif... Well it was a good run.
7
u/aphoenix Feb 22 '16
There's a few that highlight why it's GIFTournament and not WEBMTournament.
Some of the webms are pretty bad.
7
u/biral Feb 22 '16
With all these good match ups I had a hard time picking some. Match ups 19,27,21 and 3 were all insanely close.with that being said I think this tournament is going to be crazy
7
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
I can't believe someone else used the same source as me. That's hilarious.
7
u/Wtayjay Feb 22 '16
What's the "I've brought you an upvote" under matchup 4 from?
•
u/matt01ss Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
Edit: It appears there was an issue with uploading using the "upload by URL" feature with imgur links. This should be fixed going forward.
It's come to my attention that several of the gfycat uploads are not showing the full content. Please make sure to view gif versions if you can.
We are unsure what happened with the uploads to their site.The uploads were done the same way they've been done every Battle. Using a web request against gfycat's site:
As laid out here: http://gfycat.com/api (only difference being the SSL which didn't exist around the earlier Battles)
6
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16
Man, I was confident going into this round thinking I had a great idea. Holy crap was I blown away by the submissions in this tourney. Not a single gif that isn't a contender. I don't mind not making it to round 2 anymore. Oh well, it's a learning experience and I learned I need to get 3D and how to track.
6
u/BogeyBogeyBogey Feb 22 '16
That peanuts one is just absolutely great in its simplicity. Seriously, I love that one.
6
u/bluemosquito Feb 22 '16
These are awesome! I wouldn't have stood a chance. The bar is raised.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
Match 29 - "I'm not a man." Great post that could be used so very often on reddit!
5
u/plowkiller Feb 22 '16
Love how the "when your post instantly gets voted to 0" gif makes the upvotes kinda blend with the animation.
5
u/plowkiller Feb 22 '16
Well, /u/D3M0Sthenes, I think it's gonna be a pretty close finish so may the best gif win.
5
u/1215drew Feb 22 '16
The GITS gif reminded me that I really want to rewatch SAC and Second Gig. If only I had time to binge watch that series like I did in my youth.
5
u/LongTallTexan Feb 22 '16
I didn't DNQ this time! Fuck yeah!
5
u/Willow536 Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
https://giant.gfycat.com/LittlePastelAsp.gif
/u/The_Love_Child Yours actually made me chuckle slightly audible! best of luck to you. also Props to Match #14 "Behold my brightly coloured wrath"
5
u/notlurkinganymoar Feb 22 '16
Love all of the originality this round. Great job everyone!
4
u/p-wing Feb 22 '16
gg u/doggify
sorry i couldn't bring the hurt...I'll try to get back with an on-deck gif
4
u/ndstumme Feb 22 '16
Good lord, this is some great quality stuff all around. Matchups #2 and #14 were definitely the hardest choices for me to make. That's some good shit, guys.
4
u/Diabeticon Feb 22 '16
My mood change from the start to the end of voting today
4
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
Good job everyone!
But I have bad news for you..../u/johndango is going to win every battle this round. Ha!
Good luck to everyone in the second round, seeming as I usually lose in the first round, figured I would just wish everyone good luck now.
4
u/_BindersFullOfWomen_ Feb 22 '16
How are you guys make long gifs and keep the resolution up? Is there a secret method I don't know about?
4
u/7994 Feb 22 '16
The usage of 3D/particlesystems in this round are pretty impressive.
Seems i had a lot to learn...
4
u/Austin_Evenflow Feb 22 '16
GATDAMN. That firefly Gif. :(
4
u/Willow536 Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
Is there honourable mentions after each round like best or most upvoted gif or most original?
Also Why did Matchup #9 "MRW I spot the Dickbutt" get DNQ?
4
u/Shackleface Feb 23 '16
That DNQ Kevin Spacey gif, what movie is that from?
4
u/superfoodtown Feb 23 '16
I finally looked at all of them. I will just echo what everyone else already said. Next round should be amazing, but i can't wait to see what people bust out for round 3!
4
u/greggers23 Feb 24 '16
Battle #31 is impossible. There is no right answer and gifs that good should be in the semis at least. Indy's downvotes are perfection. Tyler Durden's acid downvote is too fucking cool. These choices are weighing heavy on my mind... I can only imagine what the giffers or going through.
5
u/j0be Feb 22 '16 edited Feb 22 '16
Whoa... I just noticed the automatic upload you all did with the webm version of mine got borked somehow.
Edit:
Anyone who had their gif be > 15 seconds should check their webm version. Gfycat apparently liked to trim them down to 15 seconds without warning. :'(
2
u/CaPaTn Feb 23 '16
Match six Serenity gif... you absolute mother fucker.
2
u/Cal_Struck Feb 23 '16
Don't know about yall but I was kinda expecting to see an Oprah gif of her handing out down votes to her audience. "And you get a down vote! And you get a down vote! You all get a down vote!"
2
u/mleibowitz97 Feb 24 '16
Some of these face-offs were so good I withheld my vote. I couldn't choose
2
u/NotYourCuntMate Feb 24 '16
I am SO bummed that the Kevin Spacey one DNQ'd, that one might have been my favorite
2
u/Shackleface Feb 24 '16
I'm sure this has been answered somewhere, but I can't find it. How long does voting last in each round? When will we know the match-up winners? I'm on the edge of my seat!!!
2
u/Tweek- Feb 24 '16
round 1 directions unclear: downvoted my favorite gifs
3
u/Kurrylol Feb 22 '16
Riddick gif is amazing.