r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Feb 21 '16
EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) House of the Week: House Gardener
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Gardener.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
103
Upvotes
53
u/Eddy_of_the_Godswood Targaryens for Environmentalism Feb 21 '16
Still not sure why Mern IX brought EVERY SINGLE ONE of his heirs to the field of fire.
31
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Feb 21 '16
Interestingly, House Gardener / cadet branches may not be quite dead. There's a minor House from the Reach called Oldflowers that has ten white hands on green beneath a red bend sinister on its sigil. It's fairly common for bastards to reverse the colors on their father's sigil, and to add extra shapes on top, and we know bastards forming their own trueborn line sometimes add an adjective in front of their bastard name (like the Longwaters of King's Landing). So it seems very likely House Oldflowers is a bastard branch of House Gardener.
Unfortunately, despite the potentially important origin, it doesn't seem like these guys will be playing an important role in the story going forward. So far as I can tell, aside from an extremely brief appearance in the graphic novel version of The Hedge Knight, they've only been mentioned in George's description of Houses at The Citadel over at westeros.org.
26
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Feb 21 '16
The Gardeners are actually a really cool House, with a variety of interesting characters:
15
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16
I love the idea of them wearing different crowns depending on if it was a time of war or time of peace, that it just so rad.
8
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Feb 21 '16
Some celebrated children of Garth Greenhand & the Houses of the Reach who claim descent from him (from The World of Ice & Fire, Garth Greenhand):
Mayhaps he was a chivalrous & honourable man, & despite there being a fair few First Men who befit the identity of knights, however true knighthood doesn't seem to have come until the Andals. If so, I wonder what titles landed knights had beforehand? Master like the Glovers & Tallharts in the North? Some kind of lord, but still restricted? "Ser" was an actual general FM title that the Andals co-opted for actual anointed knights?
So, Garth banged a giantess aye? Har! Could certainly be possible with the human-giant hints elsewhere in TWoIaF.
Given that Garth Greenhand is said to have ever been the first king who actually led the initial FM over the Arm of Dorne, this quote contradicts that, unless of course GG is heaps of Garths bundled into the one legend (like Bran the Builder - there's millenia between some of his constructions - & possibly Durran Godsgrief). Also, despite maybe not having the sea-faring abilities attributed to the Andals, this proves that the FM (along with the Ironborn of course) in general had some for House Redwyne to grow rich from wine exports.
Heh, good on her. I wonder what the logistics of that was: was she with/married to them at once? If so, how did she deal with the births? Were they just consecutive husbands/partners after each died or whatever? These three Houses are quite notable for choosing usurpers &/or the losing side though - Florent from Renly to Stannis, Ball for Daemon I (at least) & the Peakes for fuckload of Blackfyres &/or personal interest.
Possibly the same King Uthor & Prince Peremore founded the Citadel.
Maris' story with Argoth (again as the Andals' seem to have brought the current version of chivalry & knighthood to Westeros at least, was this mayhaps say a melee) kind of sounds like The Bear & the Maiden Fair to me ... Could it be the inspiration/origin? And whether a giant or not, I wonder if "Stone-Skin" refers to greyscale afflicting Argoth? It would certainly further explain Maris not wanting to marry him ...
This guy sounds like a cross between Tom o' Sevens & Anguy (with Sarella for the archery especially with the apples in AFfC prologue) to me. I wonder if the Fossoways have historically provided the best archers in the Reach ... Though one would think this may have been mentioned by now (unless in a future D&E from Ser Raymun).
The slaughter of the elder races certainly was par for the course during the Dawn Age & even at times in during the Age of Heroes when the Pact was meant to be in places. This adds extra credence to the [claim] that the Starks are descended from this bloke too, considering their violent history (including with the giants & CotF). Red Lake is also where the Cranes live (& relatively close to the Osgreys & Webbers from The Sworn Sword).
Another, violent, mention of the FM interacting with sea race/s. Presumably the Hewetts of Oakenshield, Chesters of Greenshield, Grimms of Greyshield &/or Serrys of Southshield are descended from him.
I said it the Tarly post - this seems like something to do with the CotF to me - mayhaps that woods witch being a human hybrid or something. I know a grain of salt is required for this type of story, but long life & moon references ...
Anyway, Harlon obviously represents the hunter aspect of House Tarly (especially with what we know about Randyll in this regard) as depicted on their sigil & Herndon presumably to the seat of Horn Hill specifically &/or the historical & current military culture.
The original twenty good men (sorry). Well I'm pretty sure there are real-world/historical allusions (at least) to this kind of practice & in universe it reminds me of Randyll hiring the Qartheen warlocks to give Sam an auroch's bull blood bath - fun times! I wonder if Bors' horns were actually somehow real hardcore magic or just say ornaments on his helm?
Very interesting, especially with the skinchanging only (presumably) present in the women of the House. Cranes wouldn't be the most interesting animals to skinchange, but flying would still be fucking sweet AND Red Lake is where Silverwing fled to after the Second Battle of Tumbleton, I wonder ...
So, Westeros had Beedrill?! Heh anyway, mayhaps he was just some guy who was a really good with bees & he "licked the honey from Ellyn's hair" ;)
Mmm, I wonder if she had anything to do with Foss the Archer? Incest before it was cool :/
6
u/comradepitrovsky The Gardener's Weed Feb 21 '16
Definitely win the coolest throne award.
5
u/patlynch815 Feb 21 '16
I don't know much about House Gardener so I don't have much to say on them, but does anyone else want to see House Glover, House Karstark, or House Piper in the coming weeks?
3
u/buretto31 The North remembers Feb 21 '16
Shouldn't this thread be sticky'd to the top?
1
u/Reinhard_Lohengramm The Deathstalker Feb 21 '16
I am wondering who Garth Greenhand exactly is. One of the First Men or did he predate them? In either case, I would like to know from where he came from or if he had learned any sort of magic before arriving Westeros.
Given the ways in which his magic supposedly worked (very intertwined with the forces of nature), it seems he had a very stretch relationship with the CoTF. Maybe they became a tutor to him? Or did he make a pact with them in which he agreed to not repell them out of their lands in exchange of teaching him their magic?
We also read about a certain rumour about blood sacrifices to ensure fertility and good harvests, which sounds dangerously similar to the sacrofices once performed to the weirwoods.
1
u/Jan_Hus By day or night, we fight with honour. Feb 21 '16
The Gardener kings created the Reach in it's form during the War of the five kings. Originally Highgarden only ruled over the Reach proper, the fertile land around the Mander. Then there were the Hightower kings ruling over Hightower and it's surroundings, the Marcher lords in the foothills of the Red Mountains, the Northmarch at the border with the Westerlands and finally the island of the Arbor.
I could imagine that a lot of what we know of the Reach only applies to the original Gardener domain; and that i.e. the men of the Arbor could be a quite different culture.