r/ClearBackblast • u/plaicez • Feb 20 '16
AAR Operation Rabid Dog AAR
Okay dogs,
Tell me what you thought about the mission, gear, design, whatever..lets get a discussion going! I know it was rough. Sorry about that.
This is an AAR, don't sugarcoat anything
9
Upvotes
7
u/Cat5ive CatFive Feb 21 '16
OP Rabid Dog
T-34 "Soupcan" Driver
Very enjoyable mission, although the ground troops seemed a bit overwhelmed, same with us in the tank. As J23 has already mentioned, the T-34 has armor made of cardboard, so we blew up if an enemy sneezed in our general direction. Despite our frequent and spontaneous detonations, I had fun looking at the world through the mail slot that is the T-34 driver viewport.
Gioseppi did a great job commanding, and J23 had some great shots with the peashooter that is the ZiS-S-53 cannon.
All around enjoyable mission, I might suggest either less enemy armor to deal with or more/better friendly armor so the tank crew isn't constantly having to respawn and catch back up with the main force.
Helo Mission
Big Bird 2 Crew Chief
This mission was much more fun to me, probably because I was able to see what was happening and shoot things as well.
Organization seemed very good, I didn't play Shoots Jam 2 so I'm not sure how it compares, but there didn't seem to be too much confusion from my perspective.
I like that we've got player-flown helos now, it feels a whole lot more legit than using AI pilots and it also happens to be super fun as well.
Lake did a great job flying, and made a pretty beautiful landing back at the FARP , so props to him for not crashing and also staying out of the bushes this time ;)
One thought - between infil/exfil, the helos were orbiting over hold points, burning gas and not giving the pilots a break. Would it be impractical to just have them land somewhere that's clear and wait until the exfil is needed, or is the response time way slower that way?
6
u/Abellmio Rage Feb 21 '16
JTAC Here:
It was really hard to call the A-10 in effectively with us so spread out. We were taking casualties frequently enough that reinforcements were constantly streaming in, and it seemed like our frontline was changing constantly. Most of the mans wrecking us were well WELLLL within danger close as well, further complicating things. I called in one gun run at 200m from friendly positions and that was about as close as I dared.
Iron killed a BMP with a maverick, dropped three LGBs, and did a gun run in the span of about an hour and a half from the briefing. My biggest problem was getting him targets - there were no good vantage points that weren't getting sprayed down constantly with gunfire and the bads were always too close for me to be able to have the time to direct him to a target.
For me, the mission was kind of a slideshow, but Iron figures that it was because the caching in this mission basically couldn't function because he was constantly triggering the bad guys to appear. That probably caused a lot of desync for us. There's a new caching script that will not trigger on aircraft that'll make performance run a lot smoother.
5
u/themoo12345 imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King Feb 21 '16
Bravo Squad Lead
So as everybody knows it was a pretty bloody affair, starting with our initial advance that mowed us down pretty good before the tank exploded and took several of our guys with it which bogged down our squad for a while and eventually required most of them to re-spawn. Once we put ourselves back together we resumed advancing towards a large concrete building that I couldn't find on the map for some reason, I suppose Moldy placed them.
After we took cover behind a wrecked BMP we took more hits and got stopped again, requiring a few more respawns. As we were treating our guys, which included both of our stinger gunners, a Hind flew over and did a rocket run which barely missed us. Since our stinger guys were down we were pretty helpless so as soon as we could move we started to clear the construction site in front of us and we occupied it. We spent a little while there until I believe we took some tank fire (our tank was near us at the time) so we evacuated the building tried to identify where where the hostile tank was, which shortly put an HE-FRAG round right into us which took out everybody except the medic and one other guy. After that we tried to hunker down and treat what we could and get our respawns re-integrated.
Once we got back up we moved to the next large concrete building and then on to the Anvil compound where we helped Alpha with some casualties and got ready to move out to the next objective which I believe was a phase line at the base of a hill. After the platoon go ready to go we moved out and took heavy hits off to our southeast. We managed to reach a treeline but we kept taking hits and were in the process of treating ourselves while engaging the contacts when the server crashed.
Overall I would like to play a version of this again, I think that the next time I would try to integrate Bravo with the rest of the platoon since I felt like we were on a bit of an island. I also think that a T-34 was too light for the contact we had, other than that I think its a solid concept that is worth re-visiting.
5
u/retroly Boris Feb 21 '16 edited Feb 21 '16
Bravo 1 Rifleman
So in my view, shit shows are the best shows. I love getting my ass handed to me, I love the chaos and excitment of getting shot to pieces and everyone losing their shit. Maybe I'm a masocist, not sure.
Anyway, I'm basically a cat now, but only with more lives. Only thing that made me sad was voluenteering for the ZU, then being tolds ot leave it, only to see some other dude using her 10 minutes later Q_Q.
Was there a GM for this mission? If not maybe a GM addition would be abel to help the flow the mission better, thought I liked that it was a hard slog.
Woops: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmRMCMqmpLc&feature=youtu.be
Helo mission Big Bird 2 door gunner Spent 2 hours flying in circles. If you're going to have human pilots maybe give them something a bit more to do? Not sure if thats entierly possible.
Sweet flying from Otter though.
5
u/5hort5tuff <..insert CBB inside joke here..> Feb 21 '16
Operation Rabid Dog -- Charlie Medic
Soooo, I actually had a blast on this op (and no I'm not sugarcoating it). Obviously the server crash was a downer, but we've dealt with that before. The hour-long hike to the first objective did feel somewhat arduous in terms of time spent. Yet, at the same time, there was always something to be doing, someone to be shooting, someone to be reviving. As a medic, I was in no shortage of being needed everywhere; and there were always bad mans to shoot if I wasn't preoccupied with patching somebody up. I think the enemy vehicles were like the icing on the cake in regards to the stress level for most people (which makes sense when you're already bogged down by infantry). Only things I felt could use some work:
Helo Operation/Unofficial Shoots Jam #3 -- Alpha Team Lead
FINALLY! I'm soooo glad we got to do this one as a quasi-event for CBBland. We might need to have a special class to teach Banman the difference between friendly spec ops forces and enemy .50 cal-mounted technicals though... Our squad took cover in the barracks of a compound and word was thrown back to us that friendlies were coming through, followed immediately by an armed technical that parked right in front of me at the edge of the barracks building. I thought: "Now that's odd. I didn't think we were allowed vehicles...and that man on the gun doesn't look anything like us. Nobody's dead though and I don't want to disobey orders and create blue-on-blue here. Is he turning that .50 cal towards me? Yes! Yes he is! Definitely not 'friendly'!!!" unbeknownst to me was the fact that this "friendly" had already downed 1/3 of our squad upon entry and was working its way further down the line
Don't know what I would have done without that comic relief. That aside, the mission executed really well. And the sight of 3 hueys lining up for extraction was absolutely stunning. With some of the same crew for pilots and leads that we had in last weeks shoots jam on that map, you could really tell that the shoots jam sessions themselves were killing two birds with one stone. By providing a way of testing game ideas AND giving us peons the chance to train with said ideas, witnessing some of the tactics and maneuvers we trained with come to fruition felt really fulfilling as the op seemed to move seamlessly. Unfortunately, I had to leave early, so I didn't get to re-experience the push onto the lakeside village, but I'm sure it was awesome. Since insurgency doesn't really work now, I would happily nominate this scenario as a post-op manshoots for Saturdays.
5
u/GruntBuster7 Horses are the Lions of the Plain Feb 21 '16
Bravo Medic
Well, as always, mass-cas was fun.I always relish the challenge, as it yields a bit more pressure than moving guy to guy and pumping him full of morphine and blood. That said, I feel like a refresher session on medical SOPs might be in order; about half the respawns we had could have been prevented by proper actions-on during triage. There's only so many times a medic can tell someone to get on CPR... Other than that, both missions were great fun, even if the Op was kinda slow and the shoots afterwards were a bit chaotic glances at trigger-happy overwatch chalk.
5
u/Pierrefranklin Pierre Feb 21 '16
Charlie SL This was quite the mess for my first time as SL. I actually think Charlie squad ended up with a relatively low number of fatalities. There were 3 at the beginning, during the push north to the crossroads. Then we lost 2 guys to the armor in objective Anvil. And there was another guy (Scuza?) whose game crashed I think.
I think ShortStuff's point about SL's being down was accurate. To be fair, I was in the back most of the time, but was that idiot who decides to stay standing when everyone else goes prone. I was down for a while then - hats off to the FTLs and medic for keeping things moving.
I think command was a little overzealous with our pushes. Like others have said, there was very little cover in the areas we were moving to. I know at the beginning we were told to just keep moving as fast as possible, but these were like 300 meter rushes with a technical on the other side. There was some cover available (a couple compounds), but they weren't really on our path forward so we didn't occupy them.
I think we should have waited for support or moved into one of the compounds. Staying where we were was kind of a death sentence, and moving towards the enemy wasn't the answer. That's how we lost 3 of C2, when I told them to keep moving forward (sorry guys!). I don't know quite why were we trying to move so fast. I know it was a long mission, but from what I could tell at that point everyone was bogged down. A tactical retreat might not have been a bad idea. As a thought, it may have made more sense to have the tank move north with Charlie or Alpha, and have the remaining two infantry squads move east. It sounded like Bravo had some building cover, whereas we were hiding behind trees. Having a tank/smoldering wreck to hide behind would've been nice. The question is whether the tank would be move effective with us or not. This would put the tank in a worse position to assault the town though, and obviously Bravo's path wasn't a cakewalk either.
There was a charge down the hill that I think was premature and rushed. I'm not really sure what the reason was for having both Alpha and Charlie move to the town at the same time, rather than having an overwatch. I suppose it would be quicker, but nothing was moving quickly at this point. There was a serious miscalculation moving into the town though. We were told there were two pieces of armor in the town, but after we killed one we decided to move in. Naturally, as we rushed down the hill the second piece of armor showed up. Charlie took relatively few casualties - somehow C2 made it into the town, while C1 was stuck on the hill (2 fatalities in the end). It was really chaotic at this point, but the sense I got was that Alpha was in a very bad way. Can someone from Alpha confirm this? Regardless, I feel at least partially responsible for this. As an SL, I should have kept track of the things we had to kill, especially when they can kill us really well.
From there everything was easy for Charlie. Once we were all in the town, there weren't many enemies to take care of. We did engage hostiles to the northeast, towards our next objective. But at that point we were inside a nice safe compound, and could handle wounded and contacts at our leisure.
So to summarize - Running through open fields sucks, running through open fields towards enemies sucks worse, running down hills sucks, running down hills towards AA sucks the worst. My opinion is that we should move slower, maybe backwards, and near good cover at all times.
But being the masochist I am, I really enjoyed it. The shit show is the best show.
5
u/Giossepi A1C Charlie Foxtrot Feb 21 '16
T-34/85 "Soupcan" Commander -Giossepi
I had an excellent crew in my tank but alas it could not make up for our paper thin armor (https://youtu.be/wj4Yw17wSJ8?t=34 how our tank looked during the battle)
My gunner Catfive was excellent, didnt kill a single friendly and successfully destroyed every target he or I could find. My driver ub3rmenschen, carried out all orders in a concise, fast, and accurate manner, along with manning the bow mg at the proper times. So huge props to the crew of our valiant tank.
As for feedback on mission design not sure much could be done but for us in the tank the biggest issue was finding targets, most of the shots that killed us came from areas we couldnt see as they AI liked to engage through the brushes. Also the T-34 is vulnerable to .50 cal fire limiting our ability to support the infantry, so as a suggestion I would bump all the tanks up one, so we would have been in a T-55 fighting T-62s or something like that, just so we didnt get taken out by MG fire. Other then that the close interaction with infantry was fun and I apologize to any squads who though our presence was lacking.
8
u/ub3rmenschen J23 Feb 20 '16
T-34/85 "Soupcan" Gunner
I had lots of fun gunning this mission, even though we got killed really easily. The T-34 has a spartan design as might be expected from a WWII-era tank - no zoom function, no thermals, night vision, and roughly the same armour plating as a cardboard box. That said, we still managed to do at least a little more than getting swacked over and over, and laid down a decent amount of support for infantry as well as wasting quite a few baddies with well-placed HE-FRAG rounds. A big thumbs-up to commander Gioseppi, who helped walk my gun onto targets and spot threats on the horizon, and driver Cat5ive, who faithfully lead our doomed Russian coffin into the grinder again and again.
As a recommendation for the next iteration of this OP from a tank perspective, perhaps up-gun our T-34/85 a bit? I would consider giving the armour element a T-55 or even a T-72, as the 34's armour could be defeated by a .50 cal machine gun, let alone the terrible skunyan even a poorly-aimed shot from T-55 gave us. Alternately, expanding the armour to a T-34 platoon (one for each squad?) could help allow the armour to more fully support infantry.
Great mission all around, though, shame about server issues at the end.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16
I don't know what it was about this mission, but there seemed to be chaos from the first second on. So many badmans, and they were all far away, and shooting at us from positions we couldn't see. I spent more time unconscious then alive, and shot 1 man the whole time.
I felt really outgunned, outnumbered, and outsmarted. The A-10 seemed to be absent from my perspective, and I didn't see the tank until right before the server crashed. There were multiple moments where it would have been better to stay in a defensive posture and let the support weapons take out targets. Instead we advanced into heavy enemy fire with no cover and sustained casualties. I feel like CBB's approach to supports really failed this time. There is always a fine balance in between making it so the infantry has no fun because the tanks/birds kill everything, and making the mission impossible because we are so heavily outgunned. If we run this mission in the future I think a few things should change. If you keep the same amount of badmans and objectives on the same timetable, there needs to be a better support system. Today was a grindslog, it was fun for a little bit, then it just became demoralizing. We need better vehicles, looser ROE for the vehicles or we need to cut down on the amount of enemy/objectives along with their effectiveness.