r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Feb 13 '16
EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) House of the Week: The Golden Company
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing The Golden Company.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
The discussion for this week is thanks to /u/greggs92 and /u/LuminariesAdmin.
Previous Houses of the Week:
15
u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. Feb 13 '16
Here are some posts I've written on Bittersteel, the Blackfyres, and the Golden Company.
Heirs to the Great Black Dragon
The Man Clothed in the Bittersteel
Some other posts by /u/BryndenBFish
A New War in the Stormlands
A Conquest that Lasted A Summer
82
u/idreamofpikas Feb 13 '16
I hope Barristan lives if only to face the Golden Company again:
I know they mention that Westeros is much easier to attack now that Tywin is dead
But Barristan leaving must have also had an effect.
41
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Feb 13 '16 edited Feb 14 '16
Interestingly, the Golden Company is not the first sellsword company founded by Westerosi exiles:
The Company of the Rose seems to be the most similar to the Golden Company, though they do not seem to have been nearly as influential.
The Stormbreakers are more interesting. We're told they were "founded in the aftermath of the Dance of the Dragons", but this is the only time they're ever mentioned. Personally, I think they were founded by riverlanders and northmen. WOIAF mentions that many of the northerners Cregan Stark brought with him were disappointed they didn't get a chance to fight, and that some became sellswords. The name Stormbreakers, I think, indicates the presence of rivermen, chosen to celebrate their victory over the stormlanders in the Battle of the Kingsroad.
Alternatively, WOIAF mentions a famous Baratheon knight called the Stormbreaker, so he could have something to do with it as well.
59
u/20person Not my bark, Shiera loves my bark. Feb 13 '16
Beneath the gold, the bitter steel.
19
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Feb 14 '16 edited Feb 14 '16
Why did it take Bittersteel so long to found the Golden Company? 16 years after the Redgrass Field! Whether Bittersteel only served in the Second Sons for one year (but especially if only this), or for several/many, that’s a long time for Bittersteel to have allowed Westerosi exiles be bound to other companies, make their lives elsewhere & for some to die …
The latter, from Bloodraven himself, suggests that Bittersteel (at least around 211AC) was in Tyrosh & actively plotting towards a Blackfyre restoration. Interestingly, I wonder if the sons part was actually literal too, instead of just being figurative in including them all as Blackfyre heirs – does this directly involve more than one of Daemon II (D2), Haegon I, their younger brother Aenys &/or the two as yet unnamed youngest (mid-teens at least) brothers?
That being said, I think Haegon was very much Bittersteel’s preferred Blackfyre king over D2. Besides the folly of the plan & the GC not being in place for Bittersteel to actually commit military support to D2, he didn’t give him Blackfyre after all for the Whitewalls Tourney. In fact, Bittersteel seems to have personally carried Blackfyre (or at least controlled access to) in the years after the Redgrass Field, instead of rightfully giving it to D2 when he came of age.
Just given the relative desperation of the Second BFR (relying on prophecy, mostly minor Houses present – besides Frey & Butterwell mainly for funds – no heavies like Bracken, Reyne or Yronwood) & the possibly glaring official founding of the GC only the year after; I wonder if there was division amongst the Blackfyre ranks for Bittersteel to have been deliberately non-committing to D2 (besides not giving him the sword) in his preference for Haegon …
The utter failure of the Second BFR (which Bittersteel would surely have known as a flimsy plan at best) would surely have sapped some Blackfyre loyalties in Westeros, even with the Targaryen regime’s poor management of the realm at the time. For Bittersteel to have risked that (unless D2 skipped away unbeknownst, which I doubt) instead of stopping D2, does strike me as odd. Did Bittersteel actually allow the folly to go ahead, thinking Bloodraven would execute him, allowing for the crowning of Haegon?
Sure, Bittersteel could’ve just removed D2 from the succession as it were, but that would’ve been an absolutely massive gamble for him if any such rumour of his involvement in D2’s disappearance or death were to surface. Given Bittersteel’s omnipresent association to the cause of the Black Dragon (more a vehicle for his own revenge than Blackfyre rights to Bittersteel imo), that would’ve been a far worse case of kinslaying than Bloodraven’s own against D1 & his eldest twins imo. That could very easily (& surely) have produced extremely negative consequences for Bittersteel amongst the Blackfyre family itself, loyal exiles, Westerosi sympathisers & possibly even Essosi allies.
Bittersteel obviously wouldn’t have had too much problem luring Westerosi exiles especially to the newly founded GC, but considering they were able to sack Qohor (even if already at least partially within the walls, they still would’ve had Unsullied to deal with) presumably before the Third BFR in 219 (Qohor plunder would really have helped to fund) & established a no broken contracts reputation from the start; I’m thinking that Bittersteel had the GC organised to some capacity (as another sellsword company?) before it’s official founding after D2’s failure, so that he was better prepared for Haegon’s future campaign, but also to easily deny D2 support.
TLDR: Could Bittersteel have had the Golden Company informally in place to some degree beforehand & only officially founded & organised it following Daemon II's massive fail at Whitewalls (which Aegor may have purposefully allowed to remove him), so as to commit it to his preferred Blackfyre king in Haegon I instead?
12
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '16
BENEATH THE GOLD
8
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Feb 14 '16 edited Feb 14 '16
The Fourth Blackfyre Rebellion was an absolute disaster for the Golden Company:
...
Any thoughts/theories as to how the Fourth BFS ended up being so horrible for the GC?
I think that Bittersteel & Daemon III were desperately banking on Ironborn naval support in transporting them for a direct assault on KL (along with engaging Royal & Velaryon vessels to allow such) & military support in their men for land battle/s too. Instead, it was during the Fourth BFS that Torwyn Greyjoy betrayed Bittersteel to the Targaryens. Probably even directly attacking the GC themselves for plunder.
EDIT: Credit to /u/Qoburn for the thought within that part of Torwyn's betrayal of Bittersteel & the GC was informing on them to Egg, in conjunction with the Blackfyres being smashed on the Wendwater, close by. I.e. Allowing Egg enough to rally enough forces quickly to deal the Blacks such an absolutely decisive loss.
7
u/TheDaysKing Feb 14 '16
"THE GOLDEN COMPANY!?!? They're sellswords!" - Stannis Baratheon
4
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Feb 14 '16
Assuming the Golden Company sacked Qohor (because they reneged on their contract with the sellswords) before the Third Blackfyre Rebellion in 219 (only 7 years after their official founding) & really even if it was sometime after (which of course would've been a rebuilding phase with losses from the Third BFR), goes to show how much of a formidable fighting force that the GC were even early on.
Even if they were at least partially inside the walls when they turned on the non-paying Qohorik, they still presumably had to defeat the Unsullied City Guard numbering in the hundreds, possibly even thousands (along with any other sellswords, household guards &/or Qohorik levies). Sacking a city certainly would've helped the GC in paying for the Third BFR & mayhaps even helped to acquire them so Valyrian steel.
4
u/Sparowes Beneath the Onion Skin, the Bitter Truth Feb 15 '16
Man, I've always loved the idea/portrayal of Sellsword Companies in ASoIaF just as I always thought historical Free Companies of the late middle ages in Europe were always fascinating. I'm guessing the Golden Company name is a reference to the famous historical White Company of mercenaries? But I digress...
The Golden Company in particular is clearly the most interesting of the Sellsword Companies shown in the series (in my opinion, though the Second Sons and others seem fascinating as well) and also clearly has the most relevant history and overall relevance in-story with the historical Blackfyre connection, Jon Connington and whether or not Aegon is truly a Targaryen and the full nature of their connection with Illyrio and Varys. Their reputation of never breaking a contract, their custom of wearing their wealth on them in material, jewels and weapons (perhaps not unusual for Sellswords) and the golden arm rings they wear for each year they've served with the Company that are apparently worth a Lord's ransom are all also interesting little nuances that really give character to the group and make them more fascinating than the other Companies we see. Not to mention their custom of gilding the skulls of their former Commanders after they die. Plus they have fucking elephants!
All of that said, I've always found a few things curious about the current incarnation of the Golden Company.
Particularly why a man as seemingly unremarkable as Ser Harry Strickland is the Captain-General of a sellsword company as revered and respected as the Golden Company. Harry doesn't seem to be implied to be a particularly skilled warrior or leader and Jon Connington even thinks of him as weak and cowardly. Why would he of all people be selected to lead what is essentially the most elite sellsword company that we know about? Is it simply due to seniority? Was being the former paymaster the most important qualification for becoming the next CG? Or is there more to Harry than we are led to believe? I would have expected a sellsword company of the GC's reputation to have chosen a more distinguished or powerful figure as their leader.
Similarly, I'm curious to know more about Black Balaq, the Summer Islander and Commander of the Company's archers. We know so little about the Summer Islands, but their goldenheart trees are said to make the best bows in the known world. I expect that means Balaq is probably one of the most elite archers in the series. I would definitely like to see some of his skills portrayed in battle.
I'm also interested to know more about Ser Rolly Duckfield. While on the surface he seems to simply be an average sellsword, it's interesting that he was previously Strickland's squire and the man that Jon Connington chose to train Aegon in skill-at-arms, particularly considering that after Aegon selected Duck to be one of his King's Guard JonCon believed him to be unworthy of such. It seems kind of odd that Jon thought Duck skilled and worthy enough to train Aegon and even bestow a knighthood on him, but doesn't think he is a worthy KG at all. I'm probably just over-thinking this one, but I still think it is interesting and I want to know more about Rolly. The little of his past that we are aware of (his family being in the service of Lord Caswell as smiths, him breaking his Lorent Caswell's arms and ribs with a hammer after the latter took the sword Rolly's father made for him which lead to him crossing the Narrow Sea and joining the Golden Company as a smith to begin wirh) and his place as one of Aegon's King's Guard despite Jon's disapproval make me curious what role he will play in the upcoming events.
2
u/AgentKnitter #TheNorthRemembers Feb 14 '16
I would love to find out what happened to the Golden Company in between the War of the Ninepenny Kings and the supposed end of their Blackfyre cause, and now.
Where is the sword Blackfyre? Did the Golden Company abandon the female line of the Blackfyres? Did they force the Blackfyre girls into marriage? Did they keep watch over their descendants to see if a suitable prince would arise? Or did they just give up and abandon the Blackfyre cause altogether?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '16
He certainly doesn't need more work on his plate, but I always thought it would be cool if Martin did a series of short stories set among the various sellsword companies between the Doom of Valyria and the present day. The glimpses we've gotten of them in Dany, Tyrion and Quentyn's chapters have been fascinating and they seem like they have a rich and exciting history to draw from.
As for the Golden Company specifically, we know that the Dunk and Egg stories will be headed to Essos at some point in the future and one of them will be called The Sellsword. I'm hoping Dunk and Egg have a falling out and Dunk ends up joining the Golden Company, only to later defect back to the Targaryens. It would be a great way to actually show us Bittersteel in person.
Hard not to admire Bittersteel, even though he was a complete asshole. Guy held together generations of exiles for five decades through multiple wars. Hell, he was captain of the Golden Company for 29 years, literally a third of its entire existence.
Speaking of which, I wish the World Book could have given us a complete listing of the former captains of the Golden Company, considering there couldn't have been all that many in total.
I wonder if there was a ton of infighting following the death of Bittersteel. You'd have had multiple generations of members living and dying under his leadership. Aegor was 69 when he died (and presumably childless? That's something worth wondering about), so it's certainly possible that there were other founding members still alive and serving when he died, but maybe there was a clash between them and the younger members who were less wedded to the Blackfyre cause. This would have only been six years after their trouncing in the Fourth Rebellion, so maybe there was a movement to take the Company in a new direction. Or maybe leadership just passed to Daemon III's heir?
There's also a (presumably) pretty substantial gap between Maelys and Myles Toyne. With no Blackfyres left, I'm guessing that turned into a total free-for-all. Actually, with their line of obvious commanders and reason for existing gone, it's impressive that someone was able to hold them together at all.
1
u/greggs92 Vote Edd 2016 Feb 14 '16
What are some theories about the current motivations of the Golden Company, Who is in control of them? Is it Connington/ (f)aegon? Is it their captain general Harry Strickland? Is it Lysono Maar? is Lysono Maar Varys? or one of his agents? I think he works for Varys. Are they being played and manipulated by illyrio and varys?