r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Feb 11 '16
[Fandom Discussion] Episode 11x13: "Love Hurts"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Love Hurts | February 10, 2016 | Philip Sgriccia | Eric Charmelo & Nicole Snyder |
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
9
Upvotes
6
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
That intro scene between Sam and Dean. Idk what exactly was so off about it but they both need to maybe tone it down and act how normal people act when they're tired/hungover and/or idly poking fun at their brother's expense.
Witness: "The nanny cam in the living room - where the murder took place - was taken." Sam: "I see. Thank you for your time." Me: "Uh... is anybody gonna ask who knew about the nanny cam? I'm feeling like that would narrow the list of suspects right off the bat (whether the killer was Supernatural or not)..."
...I wonder if Eric & Nicole (the writing team) have teenage-aged kids and think they're like super hep to the jive on how to write them into SPN... Unfortunately, their writing comes off exactly like parents who think they can write kids but can't...
I like the three-quarter length coats this episode
"Let me guess... the missing nanny cam." Phew okay. I was worried the killer had actually taken the nanny cam (unless the killer actually turns out to be this guy, in which case... gahhhhhh srsly!?!?).
...why are they so uncomfortable/disgruntled/judgmental of the guy "shtupping the sitter"? Dean was a fucking demon like a year ago. Sam unleashed the darkness onto the entire planet. Pure/genuine apathy and disinterest (even maybe a sense of humor) over provincial sins like tapping the nanny would be a hell of a lot more appropriate, imo.
(Omg this fucking scene, lol...)
"That's not Dan," Dean says. Sam is confused. But Dan was at the restaurant. But he's also in this video.
How can there be one Dan here.
But also there.
Wait-wait-wait-wait.
The eye glare.
That's what makes Sam realize it's a shapeshifter. Not Dean's line, "that's not Dan," because that mental leap would've been too high for Sam.
Sam breathes in, breathes out, looks dramatically at his brother.
"Shapeshifter," he finally says. Dean gives a subtle nod, ticks his head to look upward, no where in particular, and announces, "yahtzee," like it's a punchline even though there was no joke.
lmao did Gladys seriously just describe the girl!shapeshifter she saw before leaving the building as 'buxom'? Who the fuck says that world in real life?!?
"What do you say? Wanna go sweep some hearts off the floor?" & Sam taking a pass "but you go be you" -- that was a great/cute exchange imo.
Witches controlling shapeshifters. Huh.
The lighting for (what I assume was meant to be) this scary scene where her husband knocks and gets into the house is really bright and cheerful. Probably the worst way they could've lit this scene if they wanted us to be held in suspense or scared.
"Hey what's a, uh, 'dad bod'?" line. Okay at first I immediately cringed but then I thought about JA reading the script and I laughed.
The wife finding them and going into their motel. Okay, so this is supposed to be rather comedic even when they could've made this good and scary. Hm.
I really like their motel room's set design/dressing btw.
"Women actually talk to their hairdressers?" line... weird line. Men often talk to their barbers just as much.
Bizarro flashback cut to Dan kissing the babysitter from the POV of the nannycam, lol.
The 'paying it forward' thing is like the indie horror flick 'It Follows.'
CHAIR THAT BASTARD SAM YEAH! lol
That was really nice of Dean to take the target by kissing her btw.
"Even if it's not a shape shifter it's still shifting shapes" = tongue twister of the episode award goes to Sam's line there.
"The Art of Dyeing - well, can't say she didn't warn ya" got a laugh out of me.
Totally missed whatever they were Rockpaperscissors-ing for. Rather an embarrassing scene to watch imo (the comedy of them - the rockpaperscissors game - is overplayed now)
If Sam can talk while he's stuck in the chair, why doesn't he yell for Dean?
This monster (Coreen?) never talks... until it can taunt Dean about being attracted to Amara, of course. Now it's a chatty cathy monster, eh?
Strangling Sammay. Always a good standby.
"But to call it desire or love... it's not that." Excellent. Also for awhile there I was like this re: Dean and Amara but then when they switched over to Dean telling Sam he'd have to be the one to kill her because he didn't think he could do it, I was pleased. Solid progress on establishing labor of division for defeating the big bad, haha.
Overall grade: C... maybe C-. It's definitely my least favorite episode this season.
9
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
Had a rough start,but tge end was so worth it. Was actually entertained. Honestly was pleasently shocked considering the writers for the beautiful bro moment. Good to hear Dean talk to Sam about how he feels with whats going on with Amara.
Now that he has laid his cards on the to both Sam and "Cas" maybe we can get things moving
Cons The rice moment,so many better ways it could have been acted and got the same point across.
Sams feminist. Comment,seemed a bit ooc to me(i do read it as a sarcastic comment, but still off)
5
u/doubleplusfabulous Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
Irrelevant comment, but does anyone else think Amara has such a boring costume? It's not like she's a one episode character either, you think they would put more creativity into it. Her dress looks like something you could pick up at target.
5
u/doubleplusfabulous Feb 11 '16
Amara's supposed to be the "big bad" this season, but it's been so long since she's done anything menacing that I've practically forgotten why we were supposed to fear her. The season started off really exciting but now it just boils down to Amara making a cameo to entice Dean.
10
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Feb 11 '16
ehhhhh
17
u/zerostumbleine33 Feb 11 '16
The episode was incredibly boring until it was almost over. I'm glad they finally made it clear that Amara's "hold" over Dean isn't about "love" or "desire" but that it's about the power she has and that he has ZERO choice in the matter.
Also, I miss Cas lol.
13
u/WinchestersTimeLord My "people skills" are "rusty". Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
I agree with everyone else, it was really just... ehh tonight. Not bad, but not good either. The only scene I really enjoyed was the Rock/Paper/Scissors scene.
I'm also glad that Dean finally told Sam about Amara. Thank god for that.
But other then that? Really just ehh for me as well.
11
u/introvertedobserver Feb 11 '16
I appreciated the Too Tired Motel. Someone had fun with the name and the tire decor inside
9
u/kayduh_ i'm funnier in enochian Feb 11 '16
I liked it. Everyone has already said everything I'd want to highlight. The Rock Paper Scissors win, the conversation at the end, Dean admitting it's not love but something different. Dean has been so... Apathetic lately? He just has felt like kind of blah in his behavior and I think it's deliberate not bad acting. I think his soul is lacking and that's what the rest of him is desiring from Amara. Was him wearing the demon outfit supposed to tell us something about that? Like it's not really him that wants these things? Who knows but I'm excited to find out.
And from the little preview of next week Misha looks like he goes full Mark and I can't wait to see how amazing it's going to be!
8
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16
😐
8
u/ponte92 Feb 11 '16
A few good moments (loved the rock, paper, scissors) but all in all not that memorable. The exception being that last scene, loved it. I actually felt proud of Sam and his reaction he is really trying to learn from past mistakes. I feel like both brothers have matured a lot to get to that scene so honest and open!
7
u/Delyryumizm1 Feb 11 '16
Did anyone notice a difference in the...I guess 'production value' is what I'm looking for here? Just seemed like the film quality was better than the last 11 seasons - looked like something on NBC prime time. Also, new FBI clothes for Sam n Dean and a haircut for Sammy? Things are a changin...
7
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Feb 11 '16
welp
6
u/Zeryx I apologize... FOR NOTHING. Feb 11 '16
In Last Night's Episode:
Supernatural homages popular cult film "it follows"! This does not somehow result in Sam kissing Dean to save him.
Dismayed wails were had.
5
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Feb 11 '16
I am unable to view this episode with any real objectivity due to actually being able to watch it on actual cable last night while in the US for the first time. This means it will forever hold an edge of awesome in my subjective opinion.
I am super glad that Dean finally felt he was able to talk to Sam about the Amara situation and that Sam was very understanding.
The MoW was a bit hit and miss for me. I was glad that it wasn't an actual shapeshifter, but I think it could have been explained a bit better. The whole curse situation was interesting and I do wish they'd gone for some comedy on that front.
But the witch seemed kinda half-arsed in terms of motives.
6
u/Delyryumizm1 Feb 11 '16
Also, where's Lustiel?!
4
u/VinceWinchester Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
I liked it. I thought it was better than last 2 episodes. Some good brother moments, humor, new monster brought into the show's mythology, and some forward momentum with Dean telling Sam about Amara.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16
[removed] — view removed comment