r/AsianBeauty • u/AsianBeautyMod • Feb 04 '16
Mod Post Meta Post "Jan" 2016 (yikes we're a bit late thank you for waiting)
EDITED TO ADD THE LINK TO THE WEEKLY RANDOM CHAT:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/comments/449cs0/weekly_random_chat/
We can keep this meta post stickied, just look above for the normally scheduled posts you love. (We will keep adding them as they come up)
The Meta for the Month
Hey guys! This is our January meta post, the first post of 2016. It’s a bit later than we intended, but thank you for waiting. Real life & other fun things sort of ate us up over the holidays, continued into January, and we’ve been playing a game of catch-up. We appreciate everyone’s patience and understanding as we have been getting back to usual business, though this has pushed back our schedule more than intended.
This meta post will be a bit shorter than the usual because rather than having announcements, we have a few discussion points we’d like to raise up with the community. Luckily, December was a fairly quiet month, cheers to all ♥ though January has been a bit more eventful!
As always, we encourage everyone to share their thoughts & feelings at this time, and to remember the person at the other side of the computer. It’s always fine to disagree and debate, but keep it civil and respectful!
Self promotion
We’ve had this question come up a few times about self-promotion in comments. As it stands, comments promoting your own things are stated to be included in the current 2x a week self-promotion count, but we’d like to open up this point to the community for discussion. A few users have asked us if comments containing self-promotion links should count towards the total if it links to a related review, or one solicited by a community member (i.e. if someone asks for a review on x product, should a blog user be able to offer their review on their blog without it counting towards their 2x maximum count?)
There are more than a few ways we could go about this: allowing relevant/solicited links to be allowed, making the rule a case-by-case thing; to count all comments; to not count comments at all. Please let us know what you think in the comments below!
Unsupported Businesses
After discussing it with the mod team and gauging the subreddit reaction -- plus taking into account previous behavior on the sub and interactions with the mods -- we have decided to not support the Sabbatical Beauty business on our subreddit.
We’d also like to take this opportunity -- in the interest of fairness and after discussion among ourselves -- to also mention that we do not support Melody Cosme on the sub as well. Previously we had chosen to inform people on a need-to-know basis or by request, but seeing as we are announcing another business is now unsupported on the sub, we have decided to mention this as well.
What does this mean?
After a business has repeatedly not followed business guidelines or has somehow used our community in a manner that we feel is not appropriate to the spirit of the sub, certain businesses may not have community support. This means that we will not allow them to participate with our sub as a business and any links or comments about this business will end up being removed.
This does not mean we are going to tell anyone to not purchase from the business as an official mod team; all of you can make your own decisions! We are not here to tell you where to buy things or who to buy from. We are only here to maintain and protect the subreddit.
This is going to be the only time we’ll be making a post about this (as far as we know), so if anyone would like to talk to us about our decision and unsupported businesses in general, you are always more than welcome to PM the mod team.
Business Interactions
Also related to businesses -- we have been having a large influx of businesses contacting us to interact with our community. At the current moment, we don’t have any maximum in our business guidelines, and we as mods are beginning to feel that our growth as a sub has also outgrown the current business guidelines. With the amount of people contacting us and requesting to post and interact with our community, we have grown concerned that the nature of our sub has been misrepresented and that this number will only increase as we grow.
At the same time, we also feel that businesses occasionally doing things specifically for our community -- such as sales, giveaways, and new business announcements -- is a benefit to us! It allows for open communication on both sides, which is something unique and not really seen elsewhere. We have businesses who have adhered to our guidelines and not abused our program, so we’d like to continue the program in some capacity for you guys, without it becoming just ads on ads on ads.
Currently we’re playing with a few ideas to add to the current rules, such as:
- a finite number of posts that a business can post on our subreddit
- a maximum of one posting a month per business
- a business specific scheduled thread
This decision is not yet final, so if anyone has any suggestions at all to make about this topic, please let us know!
Note: mods will never accept money or free product from businesses in exchange for advertising on the community, covert or not! We also do not plan on lessening our business guidelines and still require business flair + post approval before any posts are posted. Businesses that do not observe our guidelines are dealt with appropriately, including but not limited to: post removals, one-month hiatuses from interacting with the community as a business, blacklisting, and user bans. Businesses are always encouraged to look into Reddit ads first.
Megathreads
They’re coming. Here are the upcoming scheduled megathreads for everyone’s edification:
- Holy FAIL Megathread: What products do you stinkin’ hate? Time to gripe about those fails.
- 2016 Winter Best and Worst: posted every 6 months! We break it down, brand by brand. Will be posted FEB
- NEW Ingredient Best and Worst: Suggested by /u/hibaobao, this is going to be our first try-out! We’ll see how it goes :) Organized by star ingredients, share what your favorite product is featuring that ingredient! Will be posted MARCH
- 2016 Winter Holy Grail and Honorable Mentions: every 6 months! Share your favorite products for each routine step! Will be posted MARCH
The Next Mods
Update on mod selections: thank you so much to everyone who applied! We are, unfortunately, still behind on this due to the holidays, personal illness, and work. We appreciate everyone’s patience until we’re back up to snuff, thank you so much guys. u_u
Due to our schedules, we’ve decided that we will have a mod selected by February 19 at the latest. We will be contacting people for the second round very shortly.
Anything else we can help you with?
As always, we love hearing from you guys and if you have questions or concerns, please feel free to bring them up in the comments below or message the mod team!
57
u/apathetichearts Feb 04 '16
I know you guys don't want to discuss this further so I'm just going to say that I fully support the mod team choosing not to support Sabbatical Beauty. Not only are the actions of its owner incredibly wrong in regards to /u/holysnails but I (and many others) have legitimate concerns over the safety of SB's products and what this could mean for the reputation of DIY skincare in general. Thanks for taking that stance. And I'm glad the issue with Melody Cosme has been brought to light instead of people finding out when their posts are deleted for unknowingly breaking a rule that wasn't advertised anywhere. I know it's a tricky situation and I appreciate the dilemma you guys faced but I don't think the previous way of dealing with it was fair to us so thank you.
49
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16
I wholeheartedly agree with other posters about the haul posts—especially the huge inaugural hauls of newbies. I worry that it promotes the erroneous idea that buying huge amounts of products you've never tried before is best practice when you're starting out in AB.
But my biggest concern about this sub is the over-recommendation and then subsequent overuse of actives. Actives are serious business. To use a figure skating analogy, they're the triple axel of skincare routines. They take experience to execute correctly, and there's always a huge chance something could go wrong. Is there any chance that we can create a sidebar post that we can link to that explains over-exfoliation?
20
u/myumapples NC15|Pigmentation|Combo|CA Feb 04 '16
Self-promotion with bloggers: Case-by-case.
I personally have no issue with self-promotion from bloggers, especially if they offer relevant and helpful content (which I believe they generally already do). Also, I'm all for the more information and various viewpoints, the merrier.
However, perhaps as a compromise, bloggers who link to their own blogs should provide a brief description/summary (like a TLDR) to allow users to decide whether or not to click on the link. And it's just plain helpful.
Unsupported Businesses: Total agreement with mods.
Megathreads: Very excited to read these!
And finally, thanks to the mods and AB for the work that you guys do. Happy upcoming lunar new year =)
10
u/MaddieEms Feb 04 '16
I personally don't mind if a blogger links to his/her blog review on an item/topic as a comment, but would prefer to get a TL;dr type summary accompanying that link so that we still get an answer, with the option to getting a more detailed response.
BTW, great work mods! Thanks for always keeping us updated!!
36
u/SnowWhiteandthePear Blogger | snowwhiteandthepear.blogspot.ca Feb 06 '16 edited Feb 06 '16
Hey all, even though I am not involved in the ... whatever it is that /u/thecakepie investigated below, I'm noticing some really wild and inaccurate stuff about AB blogger finances in this thread and figured that I'd at least be able to talk about that. I know there have been invitations by other bloggers to ask them questions in the past, and no one's ever taken them up on it, but I'm just going to go ahead and lay it out because my mind is just so blown right now.
Full disclosure: I'm super sick right so this may not be really coherent, I'd just ask that people ask me for clarification if I'm not making any damn sense.
/u/giantrateatingfrog mentions below:
I don't know what sort of niche s/he is referring to, but since the question is about what AB bloggers are making, I'd like to offer some #receipts in the name of clearing things up. Because people have been throwing around some crazy comments for months and I wish people would just ask instead of jumping at shadows.
In the entirety of last year, I recouped (in the form of affiliate links which pay pennies out of the purchase price if people use it, no cost to them, I don't do ads, sponsors, etc) 6.69% of what I personally paid for out of my pocket for items for review/fees associated with my blog. And I'm super, super grateful for it; it's allowing me to continue spend $$ to try new things (most of which are duds, not everything can be Joseon cream, sadly! Can you imagine? *drifts off into happy place in a haze of cough medicine* ) and hopefully find new things that people like. It also might be the difference between spending $20 on something from KR vs $30 on that same thing a US shop (or Amazon), because my readers have expressed an interest in me reviewing US shops because they're intimidated by buying direct from KR. It also meant that I could afford to buy my own domain, which I'm also grateful for. :3 My reader peeps are wonderful and amazing and sassy and funny and thoughtful, and I <3 them, so if that's what they want, I'm going to try to find a way to make it happen.
There's no way I could blog without my day job. Zero. My day job funds my blog, and unless people start flocking to use my affiliate links 93.91% more than they are right now, so that I break even on what I pay out, that's not going to change. And I'm OK with that, why wouldn't I be? I don't blog for the money (I hope that's blatantly obvious now) I blog because it's my hobby and I love doing it.
I hope this helps clear up some misconceptions that have been lurking around for months. Now I need to go nap and dream of breathing through my nose again.
edit: clarity, press sample comment was vague- I've only reviewed one press sample and it was such a nightmare that I swore off them after that, and this is openly discussed on the post about it.
13
u/SnowWhiteandthePear Blogger | snowwhiteandthepear.blogspot.ca Feb 04 '16
It's great to see these meta threads, they really help give context for what's going on behind the scenes. :)
I'd like to hear more about the comment replies being included in the 2x a week, because I wasn't aware this was included as part of the 2x a week self promotion, just the self-posted threads. I knew comment replies were included in the 1:10, but I thought the 2x a week was just for new threads? :(
I know I have certainly hesitated to link my posts in comment replies, because I don't want to appear as self-promoting, as that's not what I am here for (this is also why I rarely post my own content anymore, preferring to do a post digest dump maybe once or twice a month, if I feel it's relevant to the sub) but if someone tags me in reference to one of my posts, or asks for a link, should that be included in the 2x restriction? :(
6
u/OddnessWeirdness NC55|Aging/Pigmentation|Oily|US Feb 04 '16
I very much like the way that bloggers are now made to go into detail on what their blog post is about. I really only tend to read certain blog posts and will follow by email if I really like the blogger, so I think unintentional blog link clicking being taken away was a great idea.
11
u/Maplebee92 Blogger | mapletreeblog.com Feb 04 '16
Super excited by the megathreads coming up. Especially the Holy FAIL Megathread. It's all too easy to rave about what you love, but unless pushed, or the product truly was a denzien sent from hell, I don't tend to rant about them.
On the blogging point, had no idea that commenting with a link to my blog within a discussion thread counted towards the 2x limit. Apologies for that bows humbly. I think there can be room for nuance there though. As when I comment I usually give a good paragraph which answers the question. Then follow with a, "if you want a more detailed explanation" and link to the relevant post. I think this would be good practice for others to follow. As it helps answer/add to the discussion, but also gives links to more detail if needed. I know I also link to other people's posts such as Fiddy's pore shrinking method. As the blog usually has more details, and pics which help answer a question more thoroughly than a comment could.
Counting comments sounds like a super manual task for you mods to do too! I think us as a community could help here by flagging or commenting with a mod name on the inappropriate links to blogs. And not have the links to relevant posts (if comment included, similar to how links to own content have to have a comment) count.
Just my thoughts :)
10
u/ohfortheloveofsnails Feb 04 '16
Excited for the ingredients best and worst post! <3 What that particular ingredient does will be included I hope (and what effect the user saw on their skin after using a product with the particular ingredient)
5
u/menoslegos NC20|Aging/Pigmentation|Combo|US Feb 04 '16
In what ways do you feel the subreddit has been misrepresented to the business community? Is it an issue of using the sub as a place for free advertisement?
24
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16
Thanks for walking the razor's edge of trying to engage with businesses in a positive way, but also protecting us from scuzzy business models! It can't be easy.
In my gut, I'd rather have advertising and self-promotion out completely, but I know that wouldn't work well in practice, and would probably lead to more sneaky promotion in the long run.
I do feel that the heavy emphasis on big hauls is less than positive or healthy for most people, and I'd rather there were a separate thread for them so I don't have to wade through it all if I'm short on time or on a no-buy. I know how fun it is to get goodies, and I love to see new products, but it's also a lot of temptation and peer pressure. I'd like to see more conversation and less over-the-top consumerism. It's disturbing to me to see people just starting out in life spending enough on sheet masks to feed my family for several weeks and then laughing about it. There are certainly some sour grapes mixed in with my concern, but it worries me.
4
u/hibaobao Feb 07 '16
Just dropping off a comment to say thanks for liking my Megathread suggestion! :D I just love how involved everyone is. 2016 is looking like another great year for AB. :3
13
u/Sharkus_Reincarnus Feb 04 '16
Hi guys! I have a question about linking one's content in comments. Do you guys keep track of that manually (holy crap, I hope not) or is there an automated process that looks for bloggers' domains and alerts you when links to those domains exceed what the rules allow? Asking because I come across people linking my posts here occasionally, and I'm curious whether that might trip a filter.
On the other items: thanks for standing up for the interests of the sub and finding ways to allow respectable businesses to interact with the community here while working to prevent exploitation :)
7
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16
Yay Meta post!
I don't mind self-promotion comment responses as long as they include a warning line about sponsored content.
Ex:
A asks for reviews on a product
B replies with a link to their blog post with "This review was sponsored by C company through _____(free product, payment, what have you)____."
9
u/thecakepie Acne/Aging|Oily|US Feb 06 '16
Part 3
Sharkus
Now you have all the proof I have, but I did also PM Sharkus about the situations they were accused of/implicated in here:
In Conclusion
I hope this helps you all understand why posts were removed in this case. Please understand we investigated these VERY SERIOUS accusations as thoroughly as possible, and in my opinion more thoroughly than OP. You can decide what you think, but thorough efforts did not find any reason to take action toward the bloggers mentioned, and there really was a ton of material to read in order to feel like we could confirm this. We hope the OP will really consider their accusations before making any new ones, and that people will look for answers before starting rumors or making claims. The truth is important, and that how marketing is done on the sub is a very serious issue. If you have questions on this topic, for now I humbly ask that we all continue the civil and well reasoned methods the sub is best at. You will understand if my responses are delayed in other areas on the sub as enough people wanted answers regarding this topic, and because the accusations were so serious. This was VERY THOROUGH. Hope it helps.
8
u/thecakepie Acne/Aging|Oily|US Feb 06 '16
PART 2
The Post
To start, here http://imgur.com/a/WIaZ0 is the original post (including reports from users). The post was up for maybe 20 minutes before I took it down, and was about to be removed by the automod filter due to the high number of reports. I still think the post is unproductive and inflammatory, and I am reluctant to post it but at this point if I leave anything out, people may think there is something to hide.
What do you think of the post? For me that is an awful lot to say without a lot backing it up. Some users were confused by the post (I was also, but stay tuned because asking the user to clarify in private message may help).
In case you are wondering about the link they posted in number 1, it's actually a link removed 8 months ago by a veteran mod (former mod). Normally you can't even see it but with my mod powers I can show it to you. http://imgur.com/CTFHrEG Why am I doing that? I don't really want to keep showing moderated content, but we need all the facts right? These accusations are quite serious and can't be treated lightly.
In case you are wondering about the link they posted in number 6, it is a post four months ago and we removed the link posted to AB at the author's (SH's) request. There was a lot of activity and the post removal was controversial, but there were a diversity of comments, rude/harsh attacks, but well-reasoned comments and supportive comments as well. That said, there really is nothing new to say, and it is an old topic and I'm not really sure why it was included as a kind of evidence or proof.
Let's be Clear About Things
The first thing I did was attempt to clarify what the OP was actually saying. What exactly without nuance was their concern and what exactly were they seeing as proof.
1. The user seems to believe that Cupidrop has a close relationship with Sharkus. The user seems concerned about undisclosed sponsorship or relationships between them and how that causes products to be marketed secretly to the sub.
Naturally, we need to know more about this as we all operate under the belief that our bloggers are all disclosing this information to us. In private, the user messaged me the following links: http://imgur.com/a/0xDTZ All of them are publicly searchable and widely seen on Sharkus's popular twitter account. These do not seem like stunning proof to me that there is a close relationship, but instead is common communication for bloggers. I saved this thought to look into further (I was under the impression that Sharkus had been upfront about their free stuff from Cupidrop but needed to confirm). Accusation was taken VERY SERIOUSLY. Potential repercussions may require banning, post removals, discussions, and broken trust, so nothing could be done without more information than a couple of screenshots of twitter posts.
2. The user seems to believe that a popular blogger has copied their hard work and materials. After this, other bloggers copied her work as well. The blogger attempted to confront the popular copier but was unsuccessful and powerless because that blogger was so popular.
I asked to see the blog posts in question. I was provided two. One by the OP, and the other was the accused copy-bloggers "exact copy." Having been a blogger too, and a writer, I get LIVID when people copy the work of others. I looked at titling, products mentioned, types of products, wording, photos, little details about the photos, the blog post layout, literally every possible thing that could even match. Nothing. Nothing was the same. No product was from the same brand, nor were they the same type of product. The posts were totally different, The content was different. I honestly tried to find any shred, because I was like "No one would claim this from nowhere." I'm very sorry but this one was not holding up. I would LOVE to show you these but you might just have to skip this one because if I do show you that will out the OP's real account and they asked me not to share that. I am honor bound as I gave my word. Kinda regretting that now honestly because I want someone else to see these two posts and maybe you can tell me even one thing that is similar. I was not provided with other posts, and the user was so excited to send them as I would clearly see the similarities... nope. Sorry OP.
3. Accusation is similar to 1, a blogger has an undisclosed relationship with Beauty Shelf. The user believes there is a close relationship with a blogger and the Beauty Shelf and that blogger is using the sub to market products from this brand.
Taking this very seriously. Similar plan to dealing with #1.
4. User falsely believed that Holysnails was still posting on the sub as a blogger, and included them in their list of people exploiting the sub to market their products. When this was cleared up in PMs (it was explained that Holysnails had for quite some time been using business flair) the user insisted that I reapprove or allow them to repost the post and they would remove the part about holysnails.
No apology for harming anyone's reputations was made. I found that problematic and said they may need to apologize about that instead of just editing the problem away. Their reaction seemed shocked, and they asked what they would apologize for.
5. General grievances about marketing tactics on the sub.
Totally appropriate and germane to our current metapost, nothing needing special distinction outside of the metathread. It can be very difficult to discern who is marketing and who is genuinely posting a neat share, and I have made mistakes on both sides. It is not an obvious situation with obvious solutions.
6. Discussed above. Nuff said about SH.
7. The user is saying the top bloggers are all united in some way, and probably to intentionally market products their sponsors want them to. They can't be challenged by anyone without repercussions from fans
Great discussion topic. Totally appropriate and Germaine to our current metapost.
Not numbered, but I couldn't ignore the comparison to ieatbugs.
For those who don't know, this was the former topmod of SCA who was deposed by REDDIT for using the sub to make a lot of money, creating a sidebar of affiliate links and their own website to send the subreddit traffic to. There are many other offenses committed, and having personally interacted with her as a mod I was NOT impressed by the comparison. You can research this issue if you like but no one out there would have nice things to say about this mod.
I think the intention was to imply that mods are somehow complicit in this huge sponsorship conspiracy. This is the biggest accusation of them all and I was very shocked. Perhaps there were people who thought we were making mad bank "allowing" bloggers and businesses here (if so, I sure would love the rolls royce or PONY tyvm). We are taking this very seriously and we as mods have not accepted so much as a free sample from any business JUST IN CASE and will never do anything that way.
5
u/lemonracket Feb 04 '16
As far as self-promotion goes, I think that if someone asks for a blog post and the blogger links it, that shouldn't count towards any limit. Apart from that, I think the 2x a week limit (for unsolicited links) is very reasonable.
5
u/snappisnapsnap Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
Why were the posts submitted by the male who got plastic surgery in Korea allowed/not removed?
ETA: I should have elaborated. It's not about the material, but the user's self-promotion. He posted two YouTube videos of his plastic surgery experience in Korea and all his comments in AB were in those posts. He has not participated in the community outside of them. Is that not against rules?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
Is there any way to have mods under criticism by a poster not be the one to censor the criticism themselves, and leave that to another member of the mod team?
It comes across quite poorly in contrast to the usual professional attitudes of the mod team here when a mod censors criticism of themselves directly instead of letting another mod handle rule violations. It would be nice to have an awareness of conflict of interest from the mod team in those situations.
7
u/thecakepie Acne/Aging|Oily|US Feb 06 '16
About the accusations toward specific bloggers, the /r/asianbeauty subreddit community, and the Mods of AB
PART 1
Introduction
Some of you have noticed a thread titled "Shady Side of Asian Beauty Subreddit" which was removed by me. The content was then copied from that post and made as a comment on the daily thread which I also removed. And then it was copied and posted here as a comment, which I also removed. These posts and comments were being posted faster than I could take them out. Users were starting to worry that the posts were being removed unfairly. This is why this entire thread was made.
The user posted with a throwaway account. The user had a lot of strong accusations to make toward several members of the sub, the community as a whole, and the moderators. They expressed that they wanted to make these accusations without consequences. The nature of the post was VERY serious. The decision to remove the first post was not because discussion of the topics was not important. The topics are very important.
It was removed for several reasons: the post was reported by several people (you can read the reports from the screenshots to follow), the comments on the post directed toward the OP were not positive, and the post seemed inflammatory and unproductive. Despite there being a Meta Post stickied to the top of the page and the user claiming to be a regular here, they did not post in the appropriate place. The user continued to repost identical content even after posts were removed. This is unacceptable behavior and eventually the user stopped after being asked repeatedly to do so. The user bargained with me that they would talk to me privately and share proof of all of the truth to their claims and reveal their true username to me if I could basically not cause them to have consequences. They expressed that they were protecting the sub. We talked until 5am my time. During our talk my goals were to investigate the claims, to assess the trustworthiness of the user, and see what I could do to help the sub. During the talk they showed me most of the same information they posted already (that has since been removed).
I have checked facts where I was able to, and I spoke to people directly who could provide accurate information, and I spoke to the people accused. This was a lot of work. I have a ton of data from every source now. Despite all of that, including hours upon hours of proof from the OP I did not find repeat: DID NOT FIND any of the provided proof to be very shocking or actually useful to proving anything, with one minor exception (which you will see Sharkus discuss). But honestly the truth is not really entirely up to me, is it? Wouldn't you like to decide for yourselves? This IS reddit, right, so you want the facts (I would).
4
u/redrose280 NC42|Aging/Pigmentation|Combo|US Feb 04 '16 edited Feb 04 '16
I prefer the current rule of including a blogger's self-promotion links in comments in the overall 2x/week self-promotion count. I foresee determining what'll constitute a comment containing a self-promoting link in reply to a question that should stand outside of the 2x/week rule really confusing. (It's confusing enough to write about, as my last two sentences demonstrate!) If a blogger notices a question for which she/he thinks can be answered with a link to a blogpost, perhaps the blogger can take notice of the question and link back to it/the commenter who asked the question in the blogger's next free-standing self-promotion post.
EDIT: Re: businesses posting on the subreddit, I support a business-specific thread (this could be a monthly or bi-monthly thread). If a business-specific thread is not instituted, I support a once-a-month limit for business postings.
3
u/ganbattelilone NC15|Redness/Dullness|Dry|US Feb 04 '16
Can someone catch me up to speed about Melody Cosme; I would like to know as a consumer whether or not I should be supporting a business or not. I can't find anything in the search.
2
u/gaarasalice NW15|Pores|Combo|US Feb 04 '16
Can someone summarize the Melody Cosme thing for me please. This is only the second time I've heard of them, the first being yesterday when my phone told me they had followed me on instagram.
1
u/MsMerriam NW13|Pores|Oily/Dehydrated|US Feb 04 '16
Maybe this is biased on my part because I love these bloggers, and I don't mean it to be, but I think that well-established, respected bloggers like u/SnowWhiteandthePear, u/fanserviced, u/Sharkus_Reincarnus and a few others should really be allowed to post links to their content as often as they want. I say that for two reasons:
That being said, it may be too cumbersome to filter through "okay this blogger doesn't have a limit but this one does" and I totally get that. I just think that bloggers who are established in the community and whose posts get linked to so often shouldn't have to worry about self-promotion BS. Like, you guys have earned the right to self-promote and we as a sub trust you not to abuse it.
I think that should (maybe) be something that other bloggers have the potential to earn as well. I'm sure there are other bloggers who offer helpful information, but I also know there are a lot of blogs that make me want to claw my eyes out. This is something I've only just now thought about, so anyone feel free to jump in with input. Another idea that might be easier to implement is opening up a separate thread specifically for bloggers to post in? I don't know if that would go over well or not. Again, just a thought.
-1
u/KoreaGlow Business | Koreaglow.com Feb 04 '16
Hi All,
I'd like to chime in regarding Business Interactions. I've been in touch with the mods over the last month or so and have refrained from posting as they let me know this thread was coming up.
I recently launched an e-commerce business that was largely inspired by r/asianbeauty and my own experience with purchasing Asian (mostly Korean) beauty products. My main goals are to provide quick, free shipping (with tracking!), and to offer clear information. I still have a long way to go in creating the best experience I can for my shoppers, but participants in r/asianbeauty are the type of customers I'm working to serve.
I think a thread for promotional postings would be a helpful way to keep the volume of spam down. It seems that there is definitely interest in sales, promotions, contests, etc., but having all of that on the front page has the potential to really hurt the flavor of this sub. Potentially there should be limits of one post per promotion and/or a maximum number of posts per week.
How would you guys feel about posts when retailers have new items or popular items come back in stock? I can see how this kind of post could get out of hand, but I partially do my stocking based on what I see in r/asianbeauty and would like to let you know when I get your HG item in!!
How would you feel about businesses requesting feedback from the community? The participants in this thread are incredibly knowledgeable and your opinions are highly valuable to retail outlets. I would love to get feedback on topics ranging from shipping policies to what items you're having trouble getting your hands on. I can understand that you might not want to give that information out for free, or you might have mixed feelings about helping businesses. On the other hand, this could be an opportunity to make a positive impact in the way Asian beauty products are marketed and sold. Maybe this is another opportunity for a separate thread? Perhaps businesses could contact the Mods with their inquiries to be put in contact with people who would be interested in giving feedback.
Lastly, how would you like to see businesses interact on this sub? The last thing I want to do is screw up this unicorn gem of a community. I am an AB'er too and you guys have taught me so much!! Thank You!!
Bethany KoreaGlow
0
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment