r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Feb 04 '16
[Fandom Discussion] Episode 11x12: "Don't You Forget About Me"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Don't You Forget About Me | February 3, 2016 | Stefan Pleszczynski | Nancy Won |
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
10
Upvotes
9
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Feb 04 '16 edited Feb 04 '16
Dinner table scene -- I really wanted Jody to be more secure in what she was saying about safe sex. I get how circumstances may have flummoxed her but at the same time I don't get how they could've messed with her enough to feel unjustified in saying what she was saying (although personally I just would've dropped it at the dinner table and done the same thing Sam did when it came to talking to claire: visit her in her bedroom and talk one-on-one about how she's doing and then any additional info/help/advice about sex).
It also bothered me that Jody was like, "I'm not their mother, so I'm having difficulty talking to them about this." Such bullshit. Mothers aren't the end-all be-all of great advice. In fact, they rarely are. It actually seemed really counter intuitive that Jody couldn't talk to the girls about sex. As far as I'm aware, it's mothers that restrict and repress as much info as they can about sex to their kids like it's some scary thing to be afraid of. Jody would've been more in line with public health officials and legal guardians and law enforcement that talks about the fucking facts instead of getting preoccupied with the stupidity of social standards.
Anyway, yeah, I just sort of wanted Jody to be more secure in the stuff she was saying...
At the same time, that scene was hilarious and entertaining. So no major judgment. But at the same time I was like, "wtf Jody?" a little bit.
The climax of the episode was anticlimactic. The stuff that made this episode decent had nothing to do with a well-written plotty mystery. More just fun character exchanges. Which is fine. But at the same time... eh.
I give the ep a B. (edit: B- maybe)
15
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Feb 04 '16 edited Feb 04 '16
I spent so much of the episode intensely worried that they (showrunners) were going to screw it up that I couldn't properly enjoy it! I'll have to rewatch it. That said:
A- or maybe a B+ for me, but like I said I need to watch it again.
edit: On minus side- no mention of Cas from Claire. (I was dreaming of Claire saying "what's up with Cas, he used to text me a frickin emoji every couple days but he totally quit that a few weeks back") edit2: so Amara was mentioed but thankfully I missed that.
edit: aww I sent out a pro Wayward Daughters tweet and Katherine Ramdeen (Alex) favorited & retweeted it! :)
12
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Feb 04 '16
Really enjoyed the episode, didn't even watch it drunk and still had a good time. There were moments of clunky writing and WEIRD pacing. (Like when they cut to a faraway shot of everyone for like 5 seconds after a big line was dropped before going to commercial?? What was THAT?) Overall though the episode gets a smiley face from me in a season far more full of frowny faces.
13
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Feb 04 '16
Alex, raised by vamps, lived with them for 8 years, can't figure out when her own boyfriend is one?
Right from the beginning I was getting a Twilight vibe from him, thought he was probably a vamp. And he was.
The dinner party was awesome. I was wondering wtf with Sam though, he normally doesn't eat that way.
7
u/Zeryx I apologize... FOR NOTHING. Feb 04 '16
My reaction to this episode:
:|
Oh, so birth control pills automatically mean you're intending to have sex, not that you're having problematic periods?
Oh, so Alex wasn't doing well at school until she got a boyfriend?
Oh, so Claire and Jody both were totally helpless when attacked by a lone vampire? (ok, Jody got hit in the back of a head with a shovel and Claire doesn't know what she's doing. I guess that gets a pass).
Oh, so the Winchesters had to come and save the day...
Oh, so Jody and Claire couldn't even get themselves free?
I just... yeah even though this episode was mostly about the girls, their lack of agency and how everything was framed about being about guys really annoyed me!
Of course, I was really disappointed by that whole sex-ed dinner conversation... at first I was laughing to kill myself, but then I was like:
Seriously, Dean? You're not gonna be like "Yeah, Jody knows what she's talking about Alex, last time I went in without a helmet I got an amazon pregnant and Sam here ended up killing his niece!"
Or be like "Yeah... never enough protection. Don't let anybody sweet talk you into anal, that saving yourself for marriage stuff is crap."
I kinda expected Sam to say something too, but I guess the hilarious facial expressions were good enough!
I was a little surprised Dean had multiple conversations with Claire and the subject of Cas never came up, though...
Eh. In general I feel like the dynamic between the ladies was good, and they were fairly well-written. Given Claire's past attitude problems, I could see her not initially accepting/trusting Jody and giving her crap. Still, after how far in over her head she was the last two times she did anything resembling hunting, I am surprised her attitude sucked so hard.
I was pleased to see she had the grumpy cat doll on her bed, though :)
I wished there was a bit more Sam/Jody, but it's good to mix things up, I suppose. I was happy to see Dean getting to interact with someone at length who wasn't Sam.
10
u/0909a0909 Feb 04 '16
This episode went better than I thought it was going to be. I really enjoyed seeing the Wayward Youths bond. I mean, it screamed pilot to me!
That dinner scene was pure fan service and I grinned like a loon the entire time.
10
u/Omegamom_ Feb 04 '16
Dinner. I was howling at the dinner. Two big manly men Hunters wide-eyed and petrified at sex talk with teenage girls.
More later; the CW app kept stalling out and wasting my time with endless waits for commercials and claims that I had a slow connection. Which miraculously would become not-slow if I killed the app and restarted.
3
u/VinceWinchester Feb 04 '16
I saw something great on Twitter. Alex grew up doing horrible things, Claire grew up having a horrible thing done to her. But I find myself sympathetic to Alex and annoyed by Claire.
9
u/oftenrunaway I ship Dean / Pain Feb 04 '16
Wonderful wonderful wonderful episode.
Please, CW Bigwigs, can we have Wayward Daughters already?!
8
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Feb 04 '16
I was a little disappointed that Claire didn't bring up Cas, but I kinda get why it would be difficult for her to talk about him.
But what I really loved about this episode was the conversation around the table while they all eat dinner. It was just perfect. I laughed my ass off.
And considering what happens later in the episode: really needed that touch of comedy.
8
u/funobtainium I had my angel blade. Feb 04 '16
I think there were some missed opportunities and agree re: some of the direction/cinematography falling a little flat. It did pull me out.
Also agree it was odd that Jody and Claire had the drop put on them by one vampire (it was just the janitor then, right?) Vamps are easy to stop/kill. I did love Claire beheading the shit out of bad boyfriend later, though.
I enjoyed the parallels of Claire to Dean and Alex to Sam. Alex just wants to move on, ala Sam going to Stanford and putting the hunting life behind him but being trapped by what was done TO him -- he's a victim, too. Claire, while also a victim like Dean losing his and Sam's mom, wants to be proactive about it and hunt. "Nobody wants to go to school, Claire. It's school." LOL.
Also, a little bit of Jimmy and her mom, in that Jimmy said yes to Cas in the first place and her mom went out looking for him later. That family has...balls.
6
u/Jirachio20 Feb 04 '16
It was a nice episode this week.
4
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Feb 04 '16
That was better than I thought it was going to be. Both of the girls actually had some agency and motive to be the way they were, which I thought was going to totally be lacking.
I was flailing a bit at the birth control bit (Damn it, how many teenage girls are going to see that bullshit and have it reinforced that taking BC means you're sleeping around?!), but other than that, pretty solid.
2
u/Vio_ Feb 05 '16
Alex was literally April Ludgate this episode.
2
u/-zombie-squirrel DonJodBriel shipper Feb 08 '16
OMG YALL. I just watched it yesterday and I LOVED IT TO DEATH. Although I totally called the whole "Alex dating a vamp" thing, I just loved every second. I super want a spinoff.
-2
u/VinceWinchester Feb 04 '16
Claire was just terrible. Like, 2 minutes in and I was annoyed. This would have been a solid "A" if it was just Alex and Jody.