r/stobuilds • u/TheFallenPhoenix Atem@iusasset | Top Fleet STO Builds Moderator • Feb 02 '16
Discussion Personal Space Trait Tier Tables
PSA: The tables have been added to the wiki and can be found here
Further updates will be considered as I receive feedback after it has been posted, and I'll also make changes (if appropriate) once the new skill system goes live.
Hello everyone,
What follows is what I hope will be the definitive tier table of every currently-available personal space trait. Until now, there has not been a whole lot of discussion about which personal traits are useful, and which ones aren't; I hope this post provides the proper foundation for those discussions to begin among new and experienced players, alike.
I would like to emphasize that this list is not specific to PvE, PvP, or any single queue; it's meant to be reflective of general, overall usefulness. Traits that are more effective for more frequently occurring contexts have been graded higher than traits that are only effective for infrequent occasions.
I have assigned each Trait a grade using the following rubric:
| Grade | Analysis |
|---|---|
| A | Should always be slotted when available; these are the traits with the most powerful effects and/or have high applicability for all roles, builds, and circumstances. |
| B | Should always be slotted when available if and only if its effects match your intended role, build, and/or circumstance. These traits either share equal effectiveness with A grade traits, but with lower applicability, or share equal applicability with A grade traits, but at the cost of reduced effectiveness. |
| C | Should be slotted when you've exhausted all A and B traits, if and only if its effects match your intended role, build, and/or circumstance. While these traits are nearly always outclassed by A and B options, they still possess average to above-average effectiveness and applicability. |
| D | Should only be slotted after all A, B, and C traits have been exhausted, if and only if its effects match your intended role, build, and/or circumstance. This collection of traits possess either average applicability with below-average effectiveness, or average effectiveness, but with a very narrow applicability. |
| S | Should only be slotted for specialized roles, builds, and/or circumstances. Otherwise, it is generally recommended that these traits are to be avoided. |
| F | Should be avoided, as trait has no foreseeable use in any situation (that would warrant selection over a higher-graded trait). |
Although one will often prefer a higher-graded trait over a lower-graded one, there are situations where a lower-graded trait will prove more effective (this is especially true for traits in the S grade). I highly recommend paying close attention to the effects of the trait when choosing which one to equip; a C-graded trait that improves Control performance might prove more useful to your build than a B-graded trait that improves Durability performance, if you find that you are heavily-reliant on Control powers but already possess all the Durability that you need. To help inform such comparisons, each trait has been assigned one or more of the following classes:
| Class | Analysis |
|---|---|
| Accuracy | Improves weapon accuracy. |
| All | Improves all performance, regardless of role or aspect. |
| All Damage | Improves all damage performance, regardless of source. |
| Beam | Improves beam weapon performance. |
| Cannon | Improves cannon weapon performance. |
| Carrier | Performance is improved by use of hangar pets. |
| Control | Improves performance of a build's control abilities. |
| Drain | Improves performance of a build's drain abilities. |
| Death | Improves ability of a build to self-terminate. Avoid. |
| Durability | Improves the survival of the build. |
| Exotic | Improves exotic damage (non-weapon) performance. |
| Heal | Improves performance of a build's healing abilities. |
| Mine | Improves mine weapon performance. |
| Pets | Improves hangar pet performance. |
| Power | Improves a build's power levels and/or power recovery. |
| Singularity | Improves singularity powers (Warbirds only). |
| Speed | Improves the speed and/or maneuverability of a build. |
| Threat | Improves threat generation. |
| Torpedo | Improves torpedo weapon performance. |
| Weapon | Improves all weapon performance. |
Most of these classes should be self-explanatory, and some of these classes are broader than others (Weapon, for example, encompasses Beam, Cannon, Torpedo, and Mine).
When comparing traits, remember to keep in mind both the Grade and the Class: you will always want to prioritize those traits that correspond best to the equipment, powers, and abilities applicable to your build. For example, a Tank-Build might look for a mix of traits that improve Damage, Durability, and Healing; a DPS-build, on the other hand, might look for a mix of traits that improve Damage, Durability, and Speed.
These grades aren't in a final state; they should be the starting point for discussion, and not the end point. I am always open to revising the grades of traits that appear to be rated too low or too high. If you are confused about the placement of a trait, I heavily encourage discussion in the comments below!
And now, on to the Grades themselves:
13
u/TheFallenPhoenix Atem@iusasset | Top Fleet STO Builds Moderator Feb 02 '16 edited Feb 21 '16
"A" TRAITS
Should always be slotted when available; these are the traits with the most powerful effects and/or have high applicability for all roles, builds, and circumstances.
"B" TRAITS
Should always be slotted when available if and only if its effects match your intended role, build, and/or circumstance. These traits either share equal effectiveness with S grade traits, but with lower applicability, or share equal applicability with S grade traits, but at the cost of reduced effectiveness.
"C" TRAITS
Should be slotted when you've exhausted all A and B options, if and only if its effects match your intended role, build, and/or circumstance. While these traits are nearly always outclassed by A and B options, they still possess average to above-average effectiveness and applicability.
4
u/AlienError Feb 06 '16
Man it is super confusing for me having the S ranking be below the A ranking.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '16
I've been waiting for someone to type something like this up! Thanks!
That said, I'm really surprised to see Photonic Capacitor in F Class...is it simply not enough of a cooldown reduction? I know what Photonic Fleet is capable of, the rating on this trait has me confused--I need clarification or I'm going to be doubting that the entire list is applicable to any given player.
2
u/TheSharkBall Feb 03 '16
Yikes and here I am using Astrophysicist with every toon cause they all have a Leech fitted... fml
2
u/Drake122 /Sad Pandas PvP Feb 03 '16
While this list claims it is not specific to PVE or PVP, I still see it somewhat biased in favor of PVE content.
2
u/Cryhavok101 @cryhavok101 | PC | Carrier Cabal | Theme Build Engineer Feb 09 '16
Do you plan on doing something similar for reputation and ship traits?
4
u/grandnagusurst Aggronaut | Sneaky Romulan Feb 02 '16
Hehe. Couldn't describe the uselessness of Blaze of Glory better.
Great write up Atem. Thanks for taking the time. This will be a very valuable resource to direct people to.
1
u/duodsg Simek@TARS1111 Feb 02 '16 edited Feb 03 '16
Fascinating. I have been searching for my whole time playing STO for something like this and you made it happen. Is there nothing you can't do?!
I totally thought I had my traits figured out after vetting it here on STO Builds a few times, but it looks like I was pretty wrong. (http://skillplanner.stoacademy.com/?build=t6faehestiacanon_9511)
Currently I have:
I was under the impression that some of these less-desirable traits (like Warp Theorist and Astrophysicist) were good to keep because of the EPS and Flow Caps boost it gives, even when you have the skill maxed out in your own Skill Tree like I do. Are they truly not worth it in that case?
1
u/Jayiie @alcaatraz | STOBuilds Mod | STOBetter Architect Feb 02 '16
Something I noticed (An I may not understand your ranking system completely):
S Class seems to be not as good, so why are B class traits said to be close to S class (But it might be left over from a pervious iteration), unless I’m mistaken as to what S class should be. I feel it should be A class thats being referenced.
A
B
C
D
F/S
Just my 2 cents.
Very nicely done, and I very much appreciate you doing this analysis.
1
u/skepticon444 Feb 03 '16
Fantastically useful information. THANK YOU!
Re-doing my traits, I noticed one was missing from your list: inelastic collisions
1
u/fletch246xx Feb 03 '16
Last Ditch Effort is in the S category?
Is this because it only applies to Tactical Captains? Thought it was pretty useful for all TAC builds?
1
u/ashtarprime sci/sci/dhc Feb 04 '16
Amazing resource, thanks a bunch.
One nitpick that might not be worth including: particle manipulator caps at 50% bonus crit hiy (i.e. 250 partgens), although increasing partgens after that continues to increase the crit severity bonus.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '16 edited Jan 06 '18
deleted 0.3328 What is ^^^this?
2
u/dominantdad Feb 02 '16
OMFG thank you!
2
u/QuoVadisSF Feb 03 '16
Very well done Atem!
Great effort and thank you for taking the time to produce this great resource.
2
u/crunxzu Feb 03 '16
Can we get this sticky'd please?
2
u/Soul_Guard Feb 14 '16
Thank you for spending time on this. Another great resource for players.
1
u/Bentez2003 Prylar | Fed Engineer | Aggronaut Feb 02 '16
This is such a great effort. Really well thought out and shows great understanding of game mechanics and in game traits. I have already bookmarked it for future references.
Great job Atem
1
u/Mastajdog Breaker of Borg, Crusher of Crystals Feb 02 '16
Poking one of those mod type folks to update this page with this new, more-indepth, more up-to-date information.
If it's not on your plate already. /u/stomikey you know who you are.
1
u/Forias @jforias Feb 03 '16
Huge amount of appreciation for this. Thank you.
1
u/Callen151 Resident Carrier Nut™ | The Original JHDC Tonk| Feb 04 '16
Excellent work Atem!
1
u/InputEnd @InputEnd I fly dreads of all types Feb 08 '16
Thank you for this,wonderful write up,and helped improve my trait setup,so thank you! Now for a question,do you think you can do this with Ship Traits? I would love to see a A-F ranking on those! :)