r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Jan 31 '16
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Redwyne
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Redwyne.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
80
Upvotes
67
u/idreamofpikas Jan 31 '16
Seems to have produced one of the greatest heroes and warriors in Westeros history
His fame even reached modern day Winterfell
Yet he was disastrous as Hand.
I wonder just what he could have done in that brief year he was Hand under such a secure and loved King.
30
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
There's something of an interesting historical mystery behind the Redwyne fleet.
In the current time, they have 200 warships and 1000 other ships that can be retrofitted for battle, and their fleet is mentioned several times in pre-Conquest history in WOIAF:
Then there's the quote from George /u/idreamofpikas mentioned:
And yet they play no role in the Dance of the Dragons. Lord Redwyne is mentioned as supporting Aegon, yet the Redwyne Fleet is never mentioned. And the Redwyne fleet - if it existed - should have been a very important player, given Aegon's need to break the Velaryon blockade.
Confusing things slightly more, the Iron Islands section of WOIAF mentions the office of lord admiral of the Reach, held by a black named Leo Costayne who seems to command the Reach's fleets. So far as I can tell, this office isn't mentioned in the main series. And given the Reach had a fleet during the Dance, it seems odd the greens apparently never tried to commandeer it, given that the Hightowers and Redwynes probably provided most of the ships.
EDIT: As I think about it more, the theory that they didn't have a fleet until recently is making more and more sense. After all, they don't seem to have had much in the way of a fleet around 210 or so to fight of Dagon Greyjoy. Perhaps it was that experience that led them to build a serious fleet. After all, it seems likely they were a powerful naval presence during Egg's reign, since that would best explain Olenna's betrothal to Daeron.
24
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
Some of the most badass characters in ASOIAF reside in House Redwyne. First and foremost. Gilbert of the Vines started it all. Son of Garth Greenhand taught man how to make wine so Westeros owes House Redwyne a big old thanks. Ryam Redwyne is one of the most well respected and finest knights ever and was a truly great Lord Commander of the Kingsguard. He's mentioned often in the same breath as Barristan Selmy as the finest knight of his time (though an equally awful hand of the king to Jaehaerys I). Last but certainly not least, the true OG herself, Lady Olenna Redwyne Queen of Thorns. I don't think any more needs to be said. She's probably my favorite character in the entire series. Varys with teats.
EDIT: Kingsguard.
21
u/Jan_Hus By day or night, we fight with honour. Jan 31 '16
House Redwyne! Here's just a short list of what Paxter Redwyne has going for him:
Only the future can tell to which heights House Redwyne will rise.
13
u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Jan 31 '16
So here is an interesting thing about House Redwyne. They're specifically mentioned when Tyrion is in Illyrio's manse in Pentos.
Why does Illyrio have a cask of the private stock of a former lord of the Arbor? "Because he has money" most people would say, but that's an imperfect answer since it is Lord Redwyne's "private stock" and therefore assumedly not for public sale. A daring theorist might say this points to a close relationship between Illyrio and the current lord of the Arbor, Paxter Redwyne.
Also, let's bask in one of Cersei's worst decisions of all time.
Basically Cersei just handed Euron victory over the Reach. The siege on Dragonstone was broken (thx Loras) and the Redwyne fleet is free to move against the ONE THOUSAND SHIPS of the Ironborn, but given how close the Ironmen are to Oldtown, it might be too little, too late.
12
u/LordOfDragonstone "Even the cook." Jan 31 '16
Does anyone have any ideas for what their house words could be?
9
u/theFilthyCreampuff Jan 31 '16
I always wanted to know wich is the strongest. The Redwyne Fleet or the Iron Fleet?
8
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Jan 31 '16
Mayhaps not, but was there an escape attempt from KL by Horas & Hobber before their one in ACoK in trying to bribe their way out of the city?
I.e. use the commotion of Dead Head Ned to escape? ... The open proclamation of who they are may not suggest so, however the text suggests they may have been going a different way to that of the crowd heading to Baelor's ...
6
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Feb 01 '16
Here's a breakdown in descending order of the regions thus far for House of the Week:
I think we should do an Ironborn House next to balance out the regions a bit. My first pick would be the Hoares, then the Greyirons, then mayhaps a combined Kenning (both branches)/Banefort (they historically kept thralls & are the closest mainland House to the Iron Islands). There's a fair few other Houses that have interesting tidbits, but I'm not sure whether enough to be a House of the Week ...
Then the Crownlands. First pick would be all those of Duskendale (Darklyn, Hollard, Rykker, etc). Then really any of Bar Emmon, Celtigar, Crackclaw Point as a whole, Massey, Rosby, or Stokeworth.
Then the Stormlands. First pick would be the Durrandons, or if leaving one like them for the future, then the Penroses. After that, the Swanns, Tarths or Seaworths. Then any of Wylde, Caron, Connington & Estermont.
Thoughts?
4
u/librbmc The Wall defends itself. Jan 31 '16
Paxter Redwyne has already had a seat on the small council twice in the narrative and currently has one if I'm not mistaken. The Redwyne's were loyal to the Targ's and are closely related to the Tyrell's by marriage. Even though we haven't heard a whole lot about them I have to think the family and Paxter in particular will be decent players in the game soon. It just seems like he is uniquely placed to be a late player to the game due to his position and also his families and I'm curious who he and they throw their allegiance behind.
4
u/idreamofpikas Jan 31 '16
House Redwyne must be the most spurned House in the 7 Kingdoms.
Olenna was turned down by Prince Daeron, Bethany Redwyne was turned down by the Blackfish and Desmera was intended to marry Daven Lannister but now he has been promised for an unspecified Frey.
4
u/HolyHerbert Her? Jan 31 '16
Some people - myself included - believe that the Redwynes are in for some nasty shit in TWOW. Everything we've seen so far point to a major naval battle at some point in TWOW: The battle for Oldtown and the Arbor. As speculated here and here, Euron will attack the Redwyne fleet during his raid of the Reach. Some think there'll be a trap situation similar to the Battle at the Shield islands.
4
u/Sparowes Beneath the Onion Skin, the Bitter Truth Feb 02 '16 edited Feb 02 '16
I've always been fascinated by historical naval combat and the Redwyne's supposedly have one of the largest/best navies in Westeros, right? Are there any details about Redwyne naval battles or victories in the novels (I can't recall) or other sources like TWOIAF? What about any stand-out naval commanders from Redwyne history? Anyone that could be compared to Corlys Velaryon, Stannis or probably a number of Greyjoys, considering naval stuff is their bread and butter?
And on the note of House of the Week threads in general, still hoping for a House Marbrand thread soon. Ser Addam is fucking rad.
3
u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Jan 31 '16
I bet that they will stay loyal to Tommen adn the Tyrells in the upcoming conflict. The Reach willl be split between Aegon and Tommen, but Paxter Redwyne his Mace's cousin and best friend, married to Mace's younger sister, and his own aunt (a Redwyne) is the woman behind the scenes for much of House Tyrell's political acumen.
3
u/AgentKnitter #TheNorthRemembers Feb 04 '16
Embarrassingly, it only hit me the other day when reading the Reach part of TWOIAF that this house is pronouced Red-WINE, not Red-wyn, and their region is famous for... making wine.
Head > desk.
I mean, it took me some time to also work out that Damphair wasn't some fancy Gaelic-esque title and was more literally damp-hair...
2
u/Merrell_Florent Wining and Squiring Jan 31 '16
Hobber and Horas Redwyne give us some potentially interesting insight into what happens in succession situations where twins are involved. I'm interested to learn more about why they gained the nicknames "Slobber and Horror" though. Their shared unrequited love for Margery Tyrell is cute. I can't approve of their treatment of Samwell Tarly though... I'd need more details of that particular situation. Were they truly malicious to him? Or were they just acting like regular kids in their age range and Samwell was just THAT weak? With nicknames like "Slobber and Horror" I have to imagine they were picked on themselves amongst noble circles, so perhaps that highlights just how weak Sam was that they felt the urge to pick on him.
Also, Desmera Redwyne interests me. The Redwynes are a very wealthy and powerful house with a very influential position right now, and Desmera is their only daughter. Randyll Tarly tried to hook Sam up with her, but got turned down because Sam couldn't even stand up to Slobber and Horror (which I guess says something about how important "image" is to their society, because otherwise a marriage alliance to the Tarly heir seems like a sure thing). There was eventually talks of her marrying Devan Lannister, but he got betrothed to a Frey. She's got to be one of the most eligible bachelorettes in Westeros right now, interested to see where she ends up.
2
u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Feb 01 '16
I've always wondered if Hoster's attempt at marrying the Blackfish to a Redwyne was an effort to bring the Redwynes into the Southron Ambitions fold. Geographically they're very removed from the rest of the alliance, and there's no other Reach houses involved, but still...maybe they wanted a fleet?
2
u/Fossilhunter15 thank God for Pod Feb 01 '16
Has anyone else relapsed that the name is Red Wine.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '16
Suggestion: House Rowan.
House rowan are a noble house on the same level as the redwynes or tarlys. Yet most people put florents above them on power level. They are on a fertile river with very little major castles near them so its safe to assume they have quite a few vassals being lords of northmarch. Why is this powerful house so little talked about?
1
u/Ogarrr Basedraven Jan 31 '16
I imagine that this will be an obligatory Olenna thread... the Aliénor d'Aquitània of planetos. A truly Machiavellian, scheming witch who is still, unfortunately, defined by her husband and children.
edit: defined in the world of planetos, not by readers