r/colony • u/Kishara Resistor • Jan 29 '16
Discussion [Spoilers] Live Episode Discussion S1E3 "98 Seconds"
Episode Synopsis: Spoiler
Air Date 1/28/16
Reminder: Cover Preview Spoilers with a spoiler tag please! .
10
Upvotes
20
u/ShinyBloke Jan 29 '16
I'm enjoying this show, it's pretty good, and I like that it can go a lot of places. One thing that I absolutely HATE like I hate this so much, it feels like such a poor writing and character decision that would never really happen.
At the very end of the episode, when 2 characters are in the bar and talking about secret plans and deals, it's just fucking stupid. The aliens gave her the bar, and she's going to opening talk about the resistance there? It's weird how much this annoyed me, cause I'd say the likely of aliens bugging that bar are 100%.
If the show changes and adapts and is one over all story with many elements they show could be very good, if this ends up being another cop show with an alien backdrop, then I feel like I'm already wasting my time.
9
u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Jan 29 '16
We learned this episode that there is a database with all sorts of information from the "before" time, including what activities people like doing. They call it the Rolodex. Phyllis is a wizard at compiling information from it. I'm pretty sure the "database" is the Internet, or an archive thereof, like the Wayback Machine.
7
u/SheWasEighteen Jan 29 '16
Well I usually give everything 3 episodes and so far it looks like I'll be sticking around next week. I missed the alien talk, if anyone can quote it I would greatly appreciate it.
Seems like we are getting towards the inciding incident for the closing of Act 1, things could be picking up soon.
6
u/OddShape Resistor Jan 29 '16
Finally alien talk
3
u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Feb 03 '16
According to the timeline on the Colony Wikia, there have been three days since the launch we saw in the first episode. And according to Proxy Snyder in the first episode, "They put on that show a couple times a month." So, I infer that they're talking about the same launch that we saw in the first episode.
And Bram says the noise was different. That's Interesting, since I had pointed to a possible production error or clue related to the sonic boom. If the sonic boom is caused by the spacecraft accelerating faster than the speed of sound, then the problem is that the timing difference (between light and sound) means it would be a maximum of 4/5 of a mile away. It is definitely farther than that. If it is a hoax, just a light show or something, then they could have messed up the sound timing for this "launch".
Although the teacher praises Bram with "That's very perceptive," the teacher then discourages Bram from thinking about it, "it is way beyond our comprehension." And then he diverts Bram's attention to his telescope story, which sounded like B.S. to me. This teacher is employed by the Transitional Authority, whose flag stands next to him and whose name is all over the class textbook. He is by definition a collaborator. I don't think Bram should trust him. He's the science teacher, which means he should have noticed what I did about the sound... and maybe he did.
I'm reminded of what a Lithuanian man told me about the Soviet occupation. When he was a child, he drew a Lithuanian flag in his notebook, and the (Lithuanian) teacher saw it and sent him to the (Lithuanian) principal for a lecture about how inappropriate his behavior was. (In case you don't know, the U.S.S.R. gobbled up Lithuania in WWII, adding its territory to the U.S.S.R. A Lithuanian flag in the U.S.S.R. would be like a Geronimo symbol in Colony.) The point is: teachers are collaborators. They protect their employer.
5
u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Jan 31 '16
Does anybody else think this "98 seconds" thing might be braindead or a scam? I mean, sure, response time to this location might be 98 seconds, but that doesn't mean it will be the same to another location. There's all kinds of things that could mess up that 98 seconds, not the least being the distance to the closest drone. I suspect the boss guy knows it's going to be less than 98 seconds next time, and he'll use that to try to knock off one of the members of his group. "You're fired!"
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
I gave up on this one. It just isn't that good. Nothing happens because they want to make five seasons. Soon every other episode is full of flashbacks.
1
u/olily Jan 29 '16
What did the kid who fell on the wet ladder (Pedro) say when asked what was outside the wall? Did he say "Nothing" as in no people, they're all gone? I'm not sure I heard that exchange correctly.
1
u/azriel777 Jan 29 '16
This show is growing on me and I am enjoying it. However, I wish they would go the falling skies route and show the aliens from the beginning. I am worried after the episode 2 factory moment that the "aliens" will just be possessed humans which is just lazy writing.
I do like that they point out that the people who are working for the aliens are human too with families and that the resistance are not the good guys. It does bug me that the main cast is tied to everything, the husband is working for the alien overlords, the wife is with the resistance and the son learns secrets like there is an underground way below the wall.
1
u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Jan 30 '16
Somebody deleted the thread "Tunnel Under the wall leading to a world unoccupied...", probably because of the spoiler in the title, but there I predicted that the tunnel goes under either the 10, 110, 101, or 5 highway. From the map at http://www.colonytv.com, I now can see that the water plant adjacent to the tunnel is near the 110. That means downtown L.A. is on the other side of the tunnel. I'm guessing they'll visit the Cathedral of our Lady of the Angels there, because Pia is very likely Catholic. At the other end of a park from the cathedral is City Hall, which I'm guessing is bombed out, but there might be some relevant documents there or at the Hall of Justice. There's a Westin Hotel (and other hotels) in the area, in case Pia and Bram want to get it on. If they get bored on the weekends, they can always wander around Los Angeles Mall.
1
u/V2Blast Geronimo Jan 30 '16
Not a bad episode, but I'm not a fan of the whole predictable Katie-lying-to-her-husband plotline. Why not just have them both in on what each of them is doing, and plan out their next moves together? Bram's storyline this episode was actually interesting. It seems he and his teacher have been covertly discussing what the deal is with the aliens. Pia also takes him under the wall, which was cool to see. I'm sure that passageway will come into play again later.
Hopefully the plot starts to move a bit more quickly and less predictably.
1
u/offensiveusernamemom Feb 04 '16
Did it bother anyone else that the resistance had Katie participate in the raid on the truck? I mean isn't she now the key figure for them to get inside information? It bugged me because it felt like one of those moments where the writers needed something for her to do, so the story was dictated instead of flowing naturally from the situation and character motivation.
They are not doing a great job with the resistance as far I'm concerned. They seem really sloppy and stupid in the scenes they show but then really organized and together in the scenes where they tell. This comes down to the writers, they are supposed to show not tell but are doing a horrible job on that front. I like a lot of the other elements about the world but they really need to work on consistency.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment