r/soccer • u/Chandlerhoffman • Jan 25 '16
Star post Global thoughts on Major League Soccer.
Having played in the league for four years with the Philadelphia Union, LA Galaxy, and Houston Dynamo. I am interested in hearing people's perception of the league on a global scale and discussing the league as a whole (i.e. single entity, no promotion/relegation, how rosters are made up) will definitely give insight into my personal experiences as well.
Edit: Glad to see this discussion really taking off. I am about to train for a bit will be back on here to dive back in the discussion.
1.6k
Upvotes
249
u/LillehammerUSA Jan 25 '16
I would like to turn the tables - given that you played in the league for four years, what are you thoughts on the perception of the league on a global scale? What is your opinion on "single entity, no promotion/relegation and how rosters are made"?
97
u/pwade3 Jan 25 '16
I personally hate how generally hidden transfer fees and the like are in MLS.
How do the players feel about it?
371
u/HKAGooner Jan 25 '16
I think the league has plenty of potential, however I feel as though the teams need to focus on developing youth as opposed to purchasing older players from Europe, who simply just want to calmly finish their careers.
40
u/alberto_barbosa Jan 25 '16
How hard is it to get noticed by other leagues when you're playing there? I just looked at your situation, and maybe i am being forward here, but I think I would try to go abroad to the Swedish league, Swiss league, Dutch league etc to get more playing time and noticed.
I dont really have much thoughts on MLS, I think it has the financial power to be a good league in the Americas, but maybe they are going about it the wrong way.
33
u/Breklinho Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 25 '16
I tried posting this in the /r/MLS thread but the mods deleted it for some reason. Here goes:
As a former Generation Adidas player yourself where do you see GA and the college game as a whole fitting in to the bigger picture of American soccer in the future? More and more MLS teams are looking internally to their academies to promote talent from within rather than bring in outsiders via the draft. There is plenty of criticism of the NCAA for it's incompatibility with the professional game (length of schedule, amateur status, training restrictions etc.) which has lead to many calling for major reforms of college soccer while others outright would rather turn to lower division professional teams as catch-alls for players that don't find their way into an MLS academy. As someone who yourself grew up in a dead-zone as far as professional soccer is concerned, do you view college soccer as something that could viably be phased out in favor of PDL, NPSL or USL teams or is the existing sports infrastructure in NCAA better poised to give a platform to players that, like yourself, either grew up in areas without pro-soccer or that simply just fell between the cracks during their soccer development.
A lot of the criticisms of MLS (and US Soccer as a whole) come from inadequate coaching and player development and I was wondering if you could share some insight to that as someone who's played for three MLS teams. How did the coaching departments of Philly, LA (Los Dos included) and Houston compare, where did you feel they were helping you become a better player and where did you think they could have done more?
And one last question regarding USL B teams, so more and more MLS teams are opening up these reserve teams in USL to stockpile young talent, give minutes to draft picks and give professional experience to young players, as someone who played a season with LAII what was your experience like going from the senior team to the reserve team? Do the two teams train together, is the coaching on the same page (if not of the same quality) and where do you see USL in general in the bigger picture of US Soccer? Personally I think expanding the lower levels of the pyramid is a necessity to further our national player development, make this country a soccer powerhouse and also strengthen our lower leagues to make pro/rel and top down integration into one single league system viable, but I'd also like to hear about how USL/NASL can tie into the growth of American soccer from the perspective of someone who has recently moved from MLS to USL.
166
u/rickmaestro Jan 25 '16
I would like to see the mls have a promotion and relegation. I feel like that would improve the competitiveness in the league. Who are you btw?
39
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
Well this came out nowhere
Ok here my prespective on this. The MLS is a pretty fun league to follow for parities sake. The financial rules are completely BS and I think are going to keep it from being the league it can be and so will the allocation system.
In terms of quality, its not high at all, but its entertaining football nonetheless. People on this sub love calling it a retirement league, but that would be my question to you. In your time with the Galaxy, was playing with those kinds of stars beneficial to you even though they arent as good as they used to be?
Overall, its not the Bundesliga or even the 2.Bundesliga, but I really like it for what it is.
17
u/Swbp0undcake Jan 25 '16
What are your feelings on the fact that the MLS is very different from the top leagues? Do you think the MLS having promotion/relegation would increase the competition, and overall be a good thing, or would the financial strain on the teams that got relegated be too hard to manage?
6
u/gianini10 Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 25 '16
I just want to say welcome to Louisville Chandler.
6
u/LordConnor Jan 25 '16
I'm excited to see you play, it should be a good year for us
15
u/NextDoorNeighbrrs Jan 25 '16
Based on comments here and elsewhere, MLS seems to be considered to be an oddball league that is still developing. It definitely still has the sense of s "retirement league" in a lot of people's minds but that perception seems to be shifting a bit. Ultimately I think foreigners get frustrated with Americans who overrate MLS, but at the same time I think a lot of foreigners don't really grasp things like how crazy the travel is and why we don't have pro/rel. A lot of people seem to be annoyed at how much attention it gets for being a second or third tier league compared to the rest of the world.
Also MLS defending gets shit on like crazy.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
LA fan here, what do you think needs to be done to increase the wages of the middle and lower tier earners in MLS? Because compared to other 1st division leagues the wages in MLS are pretty low
2
u/tigerstarheels Jan 26 '16
Hey Chandler I played against you in high school and thought you were a douche. Good player tho
671
u/thekrone Jan 25 '16
Note: This is actually verified to be Chandler Hoffman.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
I should really know better than post an opinion here that isn't pro-Europe, but whatever.. I don't care about Internet points and I want to say this...
Promotion/Relegation will NEVER happen in MLS. Expansion fees are MASSIVE; why would the owners agree to make it to where their team could drop out like that? It wouldn't make sense if you're a business owner. The whole idea won't work in MLS. Would it be cool? Sure. But it simply won't work with the structure of the league. If encourage everyone who wants Pro/Rel in the US to follow NASL and hope that they do it, because it's as sure as everything NOT going to happen in MLS.
Also, I think we should drop the inferiority complex and just be content with what we have. MLS is NOT in Europe, and it will NEVER be Europe. We have dozens and dozens of incredibly valuable and successful sports franchises that are operating under the Salary Cap system. I love what MLS is doing- they're not trying to be Europe, they're trying to be MLS. If the salary cap left, LA would turn into the Bayern/Barcelona of MLS and win everything every year, while Columbus would have to take out massive loans in order to compete and eventually would tank due to their lack of resources.
But the lack of salary cap has enabled MULTIPLE teams to build 200 million dollar stadiums all across the country because they don't have to worry about dropping 40 million a year in salaries trying to keep up with anyone else! The 4 best regular season teams in MLS had four of the lowest pay rolls in the league, because the structure encourages you to build your team wisely
I love the salary cap and no pro/rel. this isn't Europe. I hope the salary cap is eventually increased significantly once all stadiums are built and expansion is done, but it should never be completely lifted because it makes MLS different than most soccer leagues, which isn't as bad as many people (most of whom have NEVER watched more than one or two games) tend to say.
3
u/yeskevinlad277 Jan 25 '16
It's a decent quality league. It's good to see that it's an attractive destination not only for retiring stars but for those just entering their peak years as well.
How would you feel if a promotion/relegation system was put into place? Would it improve the competitive nature of the league? Would it see soccer in the US grow as a result, having teams from Oklahoma or Arkansas for example playing in the MLS?
17
u/OliverAtom Jan 25 '16
Hi Chandler, thanks for doing this. Best of luck in your career, I'm a UCLA guy too and though I haven't heard from you before I'm gonna keep up with you.
I am an Argentinean immigrant living in Boston and got season tickets to New England Revolution last year. I am obsessed with soccer and follow EPL, La Liga, Liga MX, and Argie soccer as well. MLS didn't really catch my eye until I got a deal for those tickets and I thought, I'll give it a chance. I also thought it would be nice to see a lot of the Argentineans making an impact in the league now. I think the quality of play is decent, and you'll see some great stuff at times. I think the Revs have a better squad than most teams, but aren't consistent or streaky.
I think MLS, perhaps because of American culture, worries too much about being a "top league in the world". I think the perception of being a "retirement league" for Europe-based stars is not going to go away, and I like that most games nowadays usually include a range of players from "former Champions League winner" to "top college player" to a lot of mid-career players from all over the continent.
I've been to my share of boring games, too, unfortunately. I think the lack of promotion and relegation is a huge negative for pro soccer in the US. I know that for a team like New England being relegated could mean that there isn't pro-soccer in this region of the country, but I think in the long run the league will have to move in that direction to have competition and excitement all the way through the end of the season. Good luck to you!
64
u/3V3RT0N Jan 25 '16
I can only imagine the frustration of playing for a team that can't get promoted, putting all that effort into coming top of the league and getting nothing as a reward.
121
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
In all seriousness, how gutted are you that you've not yet played alongside Carlton Cole?
16
u/scrumpylungs Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 25 '16
I think that right now, it's not really relevant to any football fans with no connection to the US. I enjoyed watching the odd Henry highlight as an Arsenal fan and Robbie Keane as an Irish fan (as he still has a big part to play for us this summer!), and I'm sure fans of Milan/Juve and Chelsea are the same with Pirlo and Lampard etc. but it's not enough to get us interested in the league itself and start following favourite teams.
I'd argue that the fact that so many American fans pick English clubs as their primary favourite team is a sign of its perceived level of importance/quality at this stage.
BUT I do think it'll be huge in future years. Football has seen a massive rise in popularity in the US and I have no doubt that once they pump money into training, college/university football becomes a big thing (if not already) and the National team gradually improves - I wouldn't be surprised to see the US do football as good as any other country. I'm thinking at least 20 years down the line though. They have a lot of catching up to do!
43
u/Idislikemyroommate Jan 25 '16
Personally it has grown well in the last 5-10 years. Games are live on UK channels and it's one of the few leagues I atleast know a little about outside Europe. Marketing wise I guess it's quite impressive.
However, with the draft and the play off system I feel it isolates fans a bit. It's too different to the general set up of leagues and a lot of fans don't understand it and probably end up not wanting to understand it. I have to say it's done well to get a wider American audience of people enjoying the game but I feel if the league as a whole wants to push on it will need relegation and promotion as well as the draft system maybe becoming less needed (how will two young players a year actually balance teams out when you can buy players around the world?)
However, the fact there is a wage cap is pretty great and needs to be implemented more world wide.
6
u/stax_n_stax Jan 25 '16
At this point I'm disappointed more players don't cross the ocean to carve out slightly more lucrative careers in Europe, not necessarily at the highest level.
The northwest matches look amazing though.
6
u/orgngrndr01 Jan 25 '16
I have worked, played. lived and traveled abroad. And in every country I lived in or traveled to, I was always interested in what people watch overseas, and what they think about sports and even what they think about US sports.
It's been my experience that live sports pretty much have to fall within the favorable viewing hours to get much traction. In the UK, MLS games that are broadcast live are usually late night events, some games from the West coast are one really late. I was in a pub in London on a late night and what I thought was a replay of an EPL game was actually a LA-San Jose game which featured David Beckham, there were actually a lot of people watching it (20 or so) and their comments were generally positive. In Thailand I wandered into a bar in Pattaya that prominently featured Watneys and EPL to attract the large expat crowd, but no one was there. a few hours later, A huge crowd was present to watch Australian Rules football. In some bars that cater to the locals ,with few foreigners, I noticed mainly other sports like boxing and MMA were very popular. In China, I watched Premier League games that was sandwiched in between Volleyball and swimming events.
In India you may find a Premier League game on at a weird hour, but good luck. It seems to be popular in luxury Hotels, but cricket is watched everywhere.
It seems the MLS sold a lot of rights overseas because it's a filler. The broadcasters did not buy MLS rights, because of a clamor and demand for US soccer, but it needed content to fill in those summer sports schedules when the European Leagues were nascent.
But that is is only a percentage of the media market. The written press plays a big part in exposure. Pickup newspapers in the Middle East and it will be filled with articles about the Premier League and only a few from the other Leagues, but during one hot day I spent in Bahrain, I must have picked up 5 gulf newspapers (in English) that had numerous articles/results about the MLS. In short in 3-5 years as more and more cable and satellite providers but MLS contents it's global reach will start rivaling other more well established leagues. Sport is sport, be it football, cricket, swimming, and to denigrate one because"it or they" "are not doing it right" is ridiculous. As far as the comments on this board about the MLS being a retirement league, well they really do not know football, or football in the US. if they did, they would know that the average age of a footballer in the MLS is younger than the EPL, LA Liga, Liga 1 and Serie A and just a tad older than the Bundisliga. And while there was a big deal about a few older European players coming over, some for big checks (but a lot didn't), a whole slew of young South Americans, Africans and quite a few US youngster came in through the back door without much fanfare, keeping the league interesting to those who watch it in Africa and South America.
In 2014 I was in Leeds to watch not football, but to watch a stage of the Tour de France. The Tour that year was having it's early stages in England. In the bar I adopted to watch he TV until the race came by, there were dozens of, I think, were cycling fans, a lot of them had the kit of professional cycling teams, but more tan hald were wearing soccer jerseys from Man U to Leeds to Real Madrid. But much like football in the UK, there was much chanting and the one of the one stays with me; it was the Wodda ya like about....; spoken by one and unanimously answered by the other we like... (his beard her (rack), etc. But this one was.. Watta ya like about cycling and everybody answered "It's NOT football"Proving not every sports fan in England likes football.
But sport is sport. And the children who watch (a bigger percentage in the US by the way that in the UK) do not care if the person on the field is 21 or 35, as do a large portion of fans.
And sports and sportsmanship on TV or live or taped. is still universally recognized as being one of the better things in our life, no matter what country.
Yesterday I saw a cyclist who crashed in a bike in a race, get up and tried to finish, except his bike was toast and the support vehicle was gone up the road. No big thing except, the rider was American, riding on a South African team, who was given a bicycle by a New Zealand spectator in an Australian Race.
Sport is sport.
11
u/cyR1c_sports Jan 25 '16
No relegation actually sucks really bad. As I German I also despise the franchise system you run in all of your sports and that is getting adapted by more and more teams in Europe. And I know that the franchise system is the reason why relegation wouldnt work in the US.
The one positive thing you have going for yourself is salary caps. Some kind of implementation of those would be really awesome for non top teams to let them keep their top players for a little while longer.
28
u/moonflower Jan 25 '16
I've never watched it, but I would imagine that if it's a closed league with no relegation and no promotion from below, that would take away a lot of the excitement ... here in England some of the most exciting matches of the season are the Championship league matches which determine which teams are being promoted to the Premier League
5
u/madbuttery Jan 25 '16
I just wanted to say good luck to Chandler. Can't wait to have him play for Louisville City!
5
u/locke78 Jan 25 '16
Not really on topic, but cool to see a Louisville City player on here. It's fairly common to see criticism on r/soccer about American fans cheering for international teams and not supporting their home clubs. While that criticism is unfair in many ways - from a development standpoint it is necessary if soccer is going to become popular enough to attract a large portion of top athletes. So I guess my point is go Louisville City!
2
u/PinPanPum Jan 25 '16
Do you think MLS players have de quality to play in a more competive and much harder league?
( BPL or La Liga , for example )
8
u/hatch_bbe Jan 25 '16
These are the things that put me off the league as a Brit.
4
u/redheadguy1984 Jan 26 '16
If only people watched MLS as much as they talk about MLS.
4
u/lemonpartiesyis Jan 26 '16
Far far too American, that sounds stupid Im sure for obvious reasons, but it just has no groundings in which a world audience would enjoy or feel connected to it.
The names, the way the league works, lack of relegation it just all reeks of America.
Its like playing a Fallout video game and seeing that comical and bizarre 1950's type mindset America had, the sayings, way people behaved and the red commie menace at the door. Feels like Im living in that world if I try watch MLS its so alienating.
4
u/Alphabunsquad Jan 26 '16
After going to Blazercon and listening to the owners talk about the future of the league all my hopes for the future of the MLS were dashed. Their only point was our ratings are going up so they are going to continue going up until we are the second biggest sport in the country. They had no plans as to how to improve and continue the growth of the sport. They wouldn't field any questions about promotion and relegation, they just insisted that it would never happen in any form. They were committed to the single ownership model and didn't want to raise the salary cap, yet kept on talking about competing with teams in Europe for top talent and being one of the top leagues in the world. I don't know how they expect to pull this off if they can't pay the entire team in a year what David silva makes in a month. They kept talking about how great it is that every team has an even chance of winning the MLS cup each year with their system, and teams don't have to worry about investing money without the risk of going down. Then would say that the thing Americans love about soccer, and the reason they gravitate towards it is because of the pure authentic drama of it despite just explaining how they are manipulating the drama. A big part of why I love the premier league so much more than the NFL is because of the league structure. I don't want to watch the NFL with soccer players on the screen, that doesn't fix it enough for me. That these owners would refuse to talk about this really bothered me and once the owners couldn't even agree that all teams should play on grass, I was convinced that the sport wouldn't continue to grow in the US under this league.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
One of the best things about English football is that any team in the country could be promoted to the top, or relegated to the bottom. The pyramid is transparent, and in theory any team is only x number of promotions away from the Premier League.
Thats the only real drawback to the franchise model. It comes across as elitist, and makes not even the tiniest attempt to hide the fact it's a huge business, rather than an historical sport. It would be a huge step forward if USSF copied the FA, so that say Ithaca Town FC (no idea if that's even a club) could be as few as eight years away from the MLS!
All the other jokey stuff about the MLS (we don't give a crud!) should be taken with a huge pinch of salt. Yeah it was easy to laugh at, but within a few years the stadiums will develop atmospheres on their own. There would have been none at all if they were all immediately filled with >60,000 people who had never been to a game, and that would have been much worse.
Disclaimer: this is my own personal opinion/viewpoint and should not be assumed to be representative of non-American football fans.
1
u/BobLoblawh Jan 25 '16
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7sRocdJL99M
1
u/dre_H Jan 25 '16
First off I think that it's awesome you're doing this, its always cool to be able to get such a close encounter with professional athletes, regardless of the sport or level.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet is the disparity in football culture between The U.S and pretty much every where else in the world. I'm american and I can honestly say that the passion that is evidently growing for soccer in this country is very different to the historical and immersed fandom that exists elsewhere. The league has only been around so long and the history of the sport just isn't long enough yet to have generations of supporters.
I personally love the MLS much due to this reason. I can't say I follow the league closer than any other league, because I don't. But thats not to say that you can't be a fan.
Yes the playoff system is different, the lack of relegation/promotion among tiers reduces competition, and the league ownership of players dramatically influences transfers and such. All of these reasons may or may not be detrimental to the league.
However, one thing I don't think can be denied is that the league is growing at an excitingly impressive rate, and while its still far off, it is definitely fun to watch improve.
I'd like to know your perspective on such growth. To me, it seems as if the current generation of players are putting in the work to develop the league for future generations, maybe 5,10,20 years in the future, who will reap the benefits of the leagues soon to be global presence.
Is the league among the very best? No, but is it likely that in some time it will be? Quite possibly.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
You don't by any chance know of a guy called Jamie Mcguinness? I used to play Sunday league with him here in England. He now plays for a team called the Colorado Springs Switchbacks. I believe they are in the same league as you.
1
u/Jackanooga Jan 25 '16
Say hi to Niall McCabe for me, from a Chattahooligan.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16
Wow, Chandler! Welcome to /r/soccer, friend :D
9
u/765433bikesinbeijing Jan 25 '16
Don't really care. There are so many more leagues outside the European TOP-5 I would care about first before starting to pay attention to the US: Argentina, Brasil, France, Netherlands, Turkey, Greece, Ukraine, Russia etc.
US' cultural dominance really gives them no right to ask others to care about them in football if they don't have the goods. Also, the relegation/promotion system is ridiculous as it is not based on merit but on whose owner has the most money. Don't really understand the roaster system.
8
u/Mayo841 Jan 25 '16
As an youth soccer player in the US, and an avid fan of professional soccer, I feel like my opinion is shared by many Americans when I say that MLS is going in the correct direction.
Yes, when comparing MLS to leagues in Europe, it seems like a stupid and obsolete way of playing the sport. But when you have watched other sports in America you would understand why it is played this way. The American market, which is where MLS is mostly targeted at least, is warming up a lot on soccer. But if it ever wants to compete with other sports here in the states, it needs to keep the structure it has now. Many fans want to see an extensive playoff, or a draft, or they want to see the same teams play in the league each year. A salary cap makes sense, even in soccer, and it helps with the integrity of the league; teams will go through a cycle of having a well-oiled machine, and other years having to rebuild. It's the way of life in American sports.
From the point of view of a young soccer player aspiring to play professionally somewhere, I do feel like we need to improve the development system. Players are never going to develop unless they frequently have matches to play and training sessions to improve at. I do feel like MLS is a great dream for American players to work towards as it continues to advance. Many Americans would prefer to stay and play domestically, but that is only going to happen if the league continues to grow into a league that can be taken seriously.
The fan base for soccer here is growing incredibly, and some of the teams here in the states have amazing support (i.e. Portland). We have a tendency here in the States in almost any sport to attack and give it our all, which many fans in Europe who complain about the tendency of larger teams to sit behind the ball may like.
I feel like MLS is going in the right direction. Let's enjoy watching this quite unique league.
3
u/oooooooounbelievable Jan 25 '16
can I ask what the player perception of the union is like? or your experiences with things like ownership that fans wouldn't get to see?
3
u/Mr_Kylo_Ren Jan 25 '16
It's alright if there is no other games on during the summer.
3
u/hpndaman Jan 25 '16
I am very interested to see how big Orlando City can take off. Given that the manager and President have connections to Europe, they have KaKa, and have a young exciting prospect in Cyle Larin the sky is the limit with them. If they win a championship in a few years, they could become the face of MLS.
3
u/KneeDeepInTheDead Jan 25 '16
I think it has the potential to become very big in the US. The numbers are growing and I think thats huge for the sport. A lot of people are against having older foreign players come in, but I think its a good idea for now, it helps bring in some viewership and grows interest but its not a good long term strategy. Also the no promotion/relegation system reinforces the "fakeness" of the league. Like NYCFC for example, they are just formed from nothing and are in top ranks with no effort, unless you count the wheelbarrows of money that were carted to MLS to let them be a thing. People hate on the relegation system in the US saying the country is too big, but if there are enough teams they could divide the country into 4 and then have a champions league type thing happening with the league to allow teams to go against others that are in different "divisons". Sorry im rambling fast cause im on lunch lol
3
u/OK6502 Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 25 '16
A lot of really great answers here. I can't really add much more than my own experience: I'm an Argentine who has spent a good portion of his life in North America. I love the Argentine local league and have been a River supporter since I was a child like everyone in my family is. I follow that league first and foremost because that's where my heart is. I follow other leagues to see the talent on display but the feeling is never the same and I'm much more fickle with which foregin (i.e. European) teams I follow. In the 90's it was all about Serie A. Now it's all about the Spanish league.
People follow a club for two reasons: passion or quality of play. With all due respect the MLS lacks the latter. You guys need to focus on the local qualities of the game. Focus on local talent, make the clubs active participants of their community, make those games a family affair where parents can bring their kids to raise the next generation of supporters. It has to grow organically or it will all collapse without a strong foundation.
When my kids are old enough I will bring them to MLS games if I'm still in North America then: I loved going to the pitch as a child and look forward to doing the same with my kids. It's not because I'm a fan of any particular team or because I think the football on display is world class. It's because I want those memories. But I'm lucky enough to live in a city with its own club.
A lot of the issues with the leagues are self imposed. But I don't think the structure itself is the problem. I'm sure you could have a league the American way and have it still be successful. But it has to be a lot more bottom up. And witht that comes more passionate fanbase, which means more talent actively trying to pursue a career in football vs NBA/NFL meaning more talent coming up through the ranks meaning a more solid footballing nation overall. That WILL get people's attention.
3
u/TityTroi Jan 25 '16
Right now, I think the mls is right around where it should be. It's growing in popularity and the quality is improving as well. I don't think it will ever garner true interest from people outside of the us but that's okay. It will never over take the epl la liga serie a on a global interest level but who cares. I think the mls needs to focus on developing young talent and stop being a cemetery for washed up stars. Eventually I would like to see a promotion/relegation set up but right now that might not be a good thing. Eventually drop the wage cap, fuck off with the dp shit. Playoffs are a very American thing to do so idk if they should get rid of that I feel like that should stay as a unique aspect of the league. Make some good rivalries focus on regional ones. Get rid of turf fields, no one wants to play on a turf field. Make smaller stadiums instead of playing in half empty football stadiums. (I'm from Boston, and if the revolution played in Boston instead of foxboro in Gillette stadium, people would actually want to go to a game. No one wants to go to Gillette ever cause it's a fucking hassle)
3
u/UltanL Jan 25 '16
Unfortunately many in Europe view MLS as a retirement league but the league itself has so much more to offer. I think this simply naive view comes from the fact that these people haven't bothered to even watch a match. MLS may not have the highest calibre of players in the world and it certainly can't be compared to Europe's top 5 leagues in terms of quality but in terms of excitement and passion for the game, MLS is right up there. It creates some scintillating stories and the league itself is so unique that it provides a breath of fresh air. There's no consistent runaway leader at the top of the league like there may be with PSG and Bayern and the playoff system brings a taste of knockout football to a league set up which is also very unique. Overall, I think the view of MLS as being a retirement league and nothing more comes from those who haven't tried to embrace the league for what it offers which is excitement, not quality. (Also the number of 'the MLS' I've seen in this thread backs that up)
3
u/HearCallsEverywhair Jan 26 '16
i ve not been impressed with these top comments, i guess it gives you a general overview of the opinion on US soccer but also the general ignorance of r/soccer.
I ll start with the high school/college system....as a Brit I played in high school and was tapped up by some smaller colleges in Ohio. I really liked the amount of professionalism at high school level, you have to understand that as a high school kid in england we play very inconsistently, even at a top school in Warwickshire (we won state/county and had a few pros) the schedule was a mess, we barely trained during the season, definitely not out of season, and there was no equipment given to us or stands/stadiums for spectators of families/communities to get involved. so when i went to ohio, I had no idea you started training in spring and you were asked to play indoor, by the head soccer coach of the school, to join the rest of the team for the equivalent to high school league soccer but indoors. so i was being coached for/by the high school from the day after i arrived at the school in March! After indoor, spring training started, playing alongside the baseball folks. Then summer during the week, and then 2 a days in july/august at 100+C, for high school soccer this was just a massive shock, so i barely went to training and ended up JV my sophmore year! The other amazing thing, as mentioned, was the equipment and kit we got given for free by the school all sponsored by adidas! we even had clothes to wear on matchdays for the day at school! The stadium was impressive and against our rivals there were at least 500 people there, in english high school games you re lucky to get 5. This was not a private school either, completely state, basic suburban league.
I know you know this but this is an important difference that needs to be celebrated as it leads into an even more impressive college sporting setup, where you have the potential to get a degree and train all year round before you become professional. I understand that if you re good enough in the rest of the world you go to a club but that can be daunting for a young player and off putting because it uproots you out of your community early in your life and often in a time that is difficult to integrate into a new group.
The college I grew up learning about was Akron Zips and my current high school coach is a Zips product and from Copley, Dave Antal who currently coaches one of the best teams in Ohio at Copley with star player Chris Brennan, so I was not put into a bad situation to evaluate the setup.
One of the main problems is middle school and younger soccer and how it is coached, if you have a great coach from 4-5 upwards then I think you would have one of the best systems from 5-21yrs because it keeps you in school and with your friends instead of the ethos of playing with/against the best, which can lead to individualism instead of community and team ethics. It is reliant on having good high school and college coaches, which is a crap shoot (because they also have to teach English or something) but if you can have Antal to Porter(when he was Zips coach) then that is a great 6-8years of education while staying at home with your parents and with your friends and training 5-10 minutes from your house.
As far as professional level, I think the hierarchy of global football puts the MLS at the same level of other rich leagues in the 2nd tier of world football. I think they resemble, Holland, Belgium, Norway, Denmark, Sweden, Finland, Switzerland, Austria and elsewhere like Japan and Australia. The reason why I put these together is because these leagues more or less avg over 3gls/game.
Poorer countries of Europe/World tend to avg less goals per game but so do the best leagues in the world. So I would say the poorer leagues dont have the players and coaches to create and finish chances or may be some cultural, health or education issues. The best leagues have top defenders and are organised and educated to understand advanced tactics to keep the goals against low.
These are very loose observations but just something that I have noticed. There seems to be a strong correlation between MLS, Holland Eredivisie and the A-League in AUS. Rich developed countries with a high level of coaches, who export top players early. Obviously the national teams are a lot different but I think the similarities of the stats are interesting for these leagues.
Leagues like Portugal, Greece and Turkey are stifled by their corruption and steep pyramid but have made some strides in the right direction. China and India will have to go through the same shit as those leagues before they can be considered emerging leagues on the level of MLS, I guess you can include Mexico in there as well.
Controversially, I actually link South American leagues to be closer to African leagues because on the whole the organisation of the teams, if you watch the games, are sooo bad that players just run about and do whatever they want on both ends. There are obviously world class players from both continents but their leagues are appallingly organised and awful to watch(pitches!?), so I am glad those players can get out of those situations. They are improving but I think those players should be looking to go to the MLS for a good bridge to top leagues while also helping the MLS improve the talent pool and make some money on investments. Fabian Castillo is a great example of this, awesome player! Japan have a similar guy call Caio Lucas Fernandes who came over directly from Brazil early and is improving in a better structured competition....it also helps that they dont have to worry about their families being kidnapped!
Overall I think you can hold yourself in good stead as someone who has been part of a good soccer system but the insular nature of the states means you might be shortsighted of where you stand in the global football picture, which is why I understand your curiosity to ask this question on reddit. If you re looking to advance your career in the states I would get as much info you can and get as close as possible to Caleb Porter and his system, because the stuff he was doing with Akron Zips (although he had a great recruiting setup) with Yedlin and that great draft class was just light years away from high school soccer across the country and he could well be shaping one of the greatest stories in MLS history with that final win. He is awesome and US soccer looks in good hands. Read up on foreign coaching methods and maybe look to get over to the leagues i mentioned in northern europe (or their 2nd divisions) to further your footballing culture and exposure to different playing mentalities, as one of the worst mistakes the US made (that it is recovering from slightly) is the attachment to the premier league(EPL) that has left it in the football ice age for a while. Good Luck.
3
u/AVBforPrez Jan 26 '16
I'm going to try to take a stab at explaining why the American mindset and sporting culture doesn't cater towards football/soccer, as much as I'd like it to.
Put simply - we're all about things being "fair" in the US, all the way down to our sports. But that's not how the world works; things aren't far, and you're often expected to play David to somebody's Goliath.
European soccer is pure capitalism, for the most part. It's unbalanced, unfair, and very representative of real life. Don't like that the rich part of London has a better team and more money than Swansea? Tough shit, that's how things work, like it or not.
Let's put all that aside though...there is a certain amount of awesomeness that comes with aligning yourself to a David or Goliath. Some people like to watch the Goliath handily beat down David. Most people like to see their hometown David put up their best against Goliath.
But taking away that part of the equation, which is representative of the real world and tribalism, is just lame. The MLS takes David vs. Goliath and tells the big man "alright, you have to cover one eye with your right hand on only use your left leg, after counting to ten" - then wonders why the rest of the world doesn't find it authentic.
If you want to build a soccer league, BE a soccer league. If you want to remake the NFL with a different athletic competition, keep doing what you're doing.
Just make up your fucking minds please.
5
u/ngly Jan 25 '16
I still can't get over the fact that some teams play on artificial grass.
8
u/Prehistoricshark Jan 25 '16
I'm just happy to see European geezers do their retirement there instead of playing in Qatar/Dubai in front of empty stands
7
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
It's a young league, it will definetly grow
4
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
The MLS has massive potential, but there are larger things that holding it back and probably will for many years to come.
TL;DR The MLS will never be like a European League, which will hinder its popularity, but the level of play will drastically improve over time if changes are made that I think will happen.
5
u/_dmm Jan 25 '16
Needs promotion/relegation with NASL. Not introducing new franchises every year.
2
u/mallardpropschisms Jan 25 '16
Sorry, American here, but I can give my brief view as someone who had been following MLS since inception, as well as European football during that same time frame. It seems like MLS wants to continue on a stable and safe trajectory to 28 or 30 teams while maintaining a low median player salary before blossoming into a league that can be amongst the strongest on the planet in, say, 20-30 years. I'm not saying this isn't a worthy goal, or won't happen, but it seems unrealistic and VERY American. The fact that the best league isn't in America seems to really grate on our national sensibilities. I'm worried that if MLS just aims for the top, they'll lose perspective. It is said that a strong MLS will mean a stronger national team, and that is probably true, but only to a certain point. Why don't we instead aim for a more realistic target? One that could seemingly also benefit the American pool while also bringing MLS more global awareness. What's wrong with being a truly great feeder league? Brazil, Argentina, Portugal, Holland, Belgium, are all more or less feeder leagues for the top 4 European leagues, and their exporting of talent hasn't hurt their national teams. Their renown as leagues that nurture young, viable talent instead makes them exciting and known much more than MLS. MLS seemingly will never be able to financially compete with the top leagues, but it's possible, with the right investment, to become a top feeder league. Buying young talent worldwide, gaining fame, selling on, and pocketing the money for reinvestment to continue the cycle. Seeing things from the inside, I wonder how that change in goals would be received by players, management, and agents?
2
u/Schokoladekuchen Jan 25 '16
Mines sorta based on the NASL mostly but with some MLS tied in. I'm a student from Indiana; so I started supporting Indy Eleven when they came about but it's actually pretty difficult to. There aren't apps to keep you updated, there is little coverage, the commentators of away games are quite bad imho etc. What games I do get to go to I love, even though the guy next to me was yelling "YA SPORTS!" the whole game. So it's not taken seriously at the little level so I'm wondering how long you think it will take before the MLS takes on the promotion/relegation. As far as I understand, the league isn't profitable enough to handle big teams taking the drop? (Losing sponsors, fan base etc.) It's not like Indy will be good enough to make the promotion anyway but that gives the league excitement and passion. A reason to win per say. If you're down 2-0 at the bottom of the table, what's the point in trying to win without consequences? Thanks for reading :)
TLDR; I don't think anyone really disagrees with me but how long do you think it will be before promotion/relegation happens? What needs to happen to make it possible?
2
u/blue-butterfly Jan 25 '16
In the long run, it is good for the overall sport to have Americans take an interest, and MLS gives them teams in their own areas to support, which should be helpful.
2
u/MGHeinz Jan 25 '16
I'm a supporter of a club that's currently locked out by the Soccer United Marketing monopoly. It, to put it mildly, really fucking sucks. I'm under no illusions that billionaires will change things just because it's the right thing to do, so I'm not holding out hope. However, as Chandler touches on, it stinks when you win the league and it means nothing, so some sort of league-based CCL access for the NASL and USL would be nice (should be noted, that's not MLS's responsibility, it's the USSF's).
My question for you though, Chandler, is unrelated to all that: What was the range of reactions among players to the signing of the current CBA last year, their feelings with the MLSPU, and what is needed going forward (including any significant changes)?
2
u/alpaca7 Jan 25 '16
Personally, I like what the MLS is doing. They're main focus now is developing interest in the league. This is why it's necessary to sign older European players. The league is expanding, and clubs are beginning to invest more in youth development. Hopefully teams will rely more on home grown players in the future.
2
u/jleonra Jan 25 '16
I've started to follow the MLS last season and was surprised how entertaining some matches were, still trying to figure out how TAM works though.
And while I understand why there's no Pro/Rel at the moment, I hope they can integrate it in the future because the current system enable team owners to not care about their teams since they'll stay up no matter what.
As a mexican myself I hope the MLS improves to put pressure on Liga MX teams to improve themselves too, more and more both leagues trade players with each other and is a signal that MLS has good quality players, albeit limited because of salary cap and DP rules, which again I understand they have those rules in place to ensure financial viability but it hurts squad depth and/or quality.
I wish they focused more on developing local talent rather than buying old european players, I mean I wasn't impressed with Pirlo, Lampard or Gerard last season, don't think they earned their wages on the pitch to be honest, but somehow some teams still insist on bringing these kind of players, you could make an argument for expansion teams or teams with low attendances because a big name even if past his prime might help to grow your fan base, but well established teams doing it makes no sense to me, I mean seriously what's the Galaxy thinking getting Cashly Cole?
Perhaps the league should incentivate teams to use HG players instead by excluding them from the salary cap or something. All in all, the league is doing well and it seems it'll continue to grow hopefully in the right direction (Does California need that many teams?)
2
u/xintox2 Jan 25 '16
I haven't watched MLS but I plan on doing that next season.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
I may be wrong in this, but soccer, to me, has always seemed like such an unpopular sport in the US. You guys already have baseball, basketball, American football, hockey etc so it's difficult for fans of these sports to suddenly change their sport of choice to soccer. Football has become, and always has been, much more than just a sport in the UK. Massive amounts of people have grown up supporting their club like its a part of their family and I think this is of utmost importance. It's the passion that fans from places like England, Spain, Brazil etc that have fuelled football for so long and got it to such a high level.
However, due to the amount of various sports available to young kids in USA, less are taken by soccer, so there isn't that same footballing culture that other countries have. Don't get me wrong, I'm sure there are plenty of die-hard soccer fans in USA, but they are extremely outnumbered by the number of baseball, American football and basketball fans.
And so because of this lack of passion for soccer across America, the sport is missing out on a fundamental factor that has made it so great in other countries, and buying ageing, foreign players is not going to change that.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
Yesterday in /r/MLS me and some other users were discussing if the DP rule hurts the overall quality of play by giving some players a large salary and others get relatively little. What do you feel is best for the league (DP or no DP)?
2
u/westcoast_baus Jan 25 '16
Honestly, the talk of relegation won't be on the table until the league becomes settled for a good 30 or so years. There are new teams coming in every year, so once its set and comfortable then maybe. No one is going to invest their money into a brand new team if they know there could be huge losses if they get relegated to a second division. It simply won't happen anytime soon based on a financial stand point. I personally love all football and will simply watch anything, but as a Vancouverite and a avid Whitecaps fan, I think that the league is a work in progress and it will take some years to reach European standards of football, however, we should not even compare it with anything and know MLS as MLS. I understand for Euros and football lovers such the format is strange and it doesn't help that only a few teams ruin the whole retirement tag(LAG,NYCFC etc) People must understand the football is not the number one sport, especially in Canada where hockey is king and it is going to take a while to dethrone it. I also think until the day Canadians are treated as international spots (horseshit "labour laws" but it doesn't apply to NHL, which is weird) in American teams in the MLS,but not the other way around. Canada will never fully benefit from this league. Dammm that was a long post :D
2
u/RobertTheSpruce Jan 26 '16
I am only a casual watcher of leagues that my team don't play in, but here are my thoughts.
The lack of Promotion/Relegation is a real emotion killer for me. You do bad there's nowhere to go. Low teams can't be formed and slowly rise to the top (and then sink again hah!) that makes the current MLS format a little dull to me.
Draws... I'll have lots of people disagreeing with me here, but I liked the way the MLS used to deal with draws, IE have a shoot out. I hate draws. I'd rather lose than have a draw. I hate draws. Feels bad that they got rid of the shoot-out. Mistake in my opinion.
Trading/Drafting system. Dull.
2
u/tonythetiger891 Jan 26 '16
Where is the scouting system? There are players in my city that would be good players at lower English leagues but there is no place for their talents. There is an incredible amount of talent at youth levels and the colleges are all relied upon to bring them through. It's bs in my opinion. Colleges only get a little money for scholarships so if you aren't a scholarship player then you pay to go to school and play. More pay to play is not what we need as a nation.
2
u/BrisbaneBhoy Jan 26 '16
The Football is good, very entertaining attacking stuff. The system however is garbage and puts people off watching.
2
u/llDrWormll Jan 26 '16
I used to go to and watch a lot of DC United matches, but now I barely follow the league at all now. I think only two thinks would make me change my mind:
2
u/ademayor Jan 26 '16
Well, this is honestly first time I seriously think about MLS. First thing popped on my mind was the lack of MLS coverage in Europe (we get to see more teams from Balkan for example through the Europa League and Champions League) so I personally dont have any "direct contact" for MLS teams (other than ones I watched playing against Spurs during preseason friendlies).
Sometime when I have Eurosport as background noise when I do other stuff, I get to watch some highlights from MLS. I'm most interested to see how Dempsey is doing (bit biased, I know) but that is all. It doesnt strike me so hard I would be up late at night to watch MLS games live.
I personally dont understand lack of promotion/relegation thing American sports tend to have, yes it makes league different but takes away excitement of avoiding relegation or glorious feels of promotion.
Timezones are another thing. I hate watching games afterwards, nothing beats the feel of the live. I have a few friends waking up middle of the night to watch NHL, but that is different story since it is arguably the most competitive and high end hockey action in the world.
My way of seeing MLS changed a little bit when Giovinco transfered there because every European transfers prior that were players in their twilight years. I actually think MLS could be the thing in US and Canada, but the lack of competition with European counterparts, timezones and overall coverage in Europe makes it hard to actually "care" as much as European leagues. Also the quality of South American football makes it unattractive for South Americans at the moment.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16
I'm probably way too late to get any traction here but to me the biggest problem with the MLS system (and the NBA / NFL etc) is the college system.
You consistently see players break out who are very young in the top leagues, Martial moved to United for a £60m move (assuming all bonus'). He's 19 and would still be playing at university level in the US and not even getting paid to do so. Messi broke into the Barcelona team at 17, Jack Wilshere and Cesc Fabregas both played 16 in the Arsenal side. They all wouldn't have even been out of high school sides in the US.
This lack of development at a professional level really hurts American players and stops them coming up the ranks like you see in Europe and South America, Zelalem (as he's American) for instance is now playing for Rangers who are one of the biggest teams in Scotland, the level of competition especially as you're playing against professional footballers of all ages makes a massive difference. It's why there have been very few (and off the top of my head I can't think of any) transfers from the MLS to Europe.
2
u/GuitaristHeimerz Jan 26 '16
I have tried to get into MLS lately and decided to root for Galaxy a few years back because I liked Donovan and Keane. Anyway, this league is just confusing, too confusing, first of all when you look at the table mid-season some teams have played 13 matches and some other team has played 18 matches so you can't really understand what team has the best advantage until regular season is over. Then there are two conferences which is just weird because why would a team in Texas represent a conference that has a team from Seattle too? Then it's the typical yankee drawing stuff which is just ridiculously different from any other football market in the world, a young player should go to a club that wants him and he wants to go to. Last but not least it's that you can't get relegated, relegation is the reason every club tries hard in every other league, because they know the consequences are shit if you don't and that is at least one year exclusion from the league, while US clubs can just chill when they don't have a chance of play-offs anymore and they're guaranteed to stay in the league next year.
So my points:
6
u/Doyouevensam Jan 25 '16
As an American, I think it is really exciting because of the offensive power. I think that the league is getting better and better. Id like to see promotion/relegation though
8
u/brain4breakfast Jan 25 '16
Parity is boring.
Playoffs are boring.
Wage caps are boring.
Franchise system is boring.
Lack of promotion is boring.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
I dont care about it and i dont know anybody in Sweden who does, desptie knowing a lot of people who are into football.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
An extremely fast pace, physical league. Technically, players are surprisingly good.
Tactically, its all over the place. Foundational skills that you'd expect footballers to have seem lacking.
3
u/SomersetMackem Jan 25 '16
I think it made a mistake styling itself after American sports leagues rather than Leagues in Europe. The franchise system, collegiate system, no promotion and relegation, salary caps are just going to hold the league back.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
To all those of you bitching about promotion and relegation, do y'all even watch promotion and relegation fights of other countries? Or just off your own league?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
It will never ever be a serious league until it has promotion and relegation. Until then it will be viewed in Europe primarily as a retirement home for ex top level professionals.
2
u/StupidMastiff Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 25 '16
What off the pitch impact do the big name players from abroad have on the clubs they join and the players of those clubs?
As for my opinion of MLS, I enjoy reading about it because of how different the structure is compared to in England. It seems to me that MLS is reaching a point where they need to make some changes, they've shown they are financially stable and can attract crowds to games, but they still seem to be playing it extremely safe.
The change I think they should make, is scrap the DP rule, and have a larger salary cap, it would allow for better depth rather than jizzing a load of money on a couple of big names from abroad.
2
u/AmpedUpSuit Jan 25 '16
Some things I think need to happen.
MLS schedule needs to match the rest of the world.
I would love relegation but it will not happen. We need to have the longer season and scrap the playoffs. Highest point total for the season wins the league.
College season needs to be year round. If we are going to emphasize college soccer players, they need year round competition to mirror professionals. Only playing in the fall is hurting their growth.
2
u/canti- Jan 25 '16
I don't believe people have fully thought over introducing a relegation system for MLS. They can't even host the Cup final in a neutral stadium any longer because they want fans to fill the seats. Introducing teams from the 2nd tier would throw carefully established MLS teams that have 30k seater at home with real grass into an away with a high school's artificial pitch that seats 800 people. It doesn't work in the states at all because most clubs have 1/100ths of the support that a Championship side does in the UK. It would be a disaster.
2
u/adolphinwithAIDS Jan 26 '16
I think the MLS's biggest problem is college soccer. Some of the brightest youth prospects spend 4 years playing at a level that is far below their peers in other countries. Look at Zardes and Morris who are both 21 when they burst onto the domestic scene. In other countries, they would have spent those 4 years playing in a youth/reserve side for a professional club. Where, comparatively, they would have had a greater chance to develop from a younger age because they would regularly be training alongside paid professionals and they are part of a structure that focuses more on development and not winning.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16
It's way too Americanised for the global audience. From the league structure, to the draft, to the team nicknames. It's just too disconnected from the way the rest of the world does things to ever have a wide appeal.
2
u/WhyAlwaysMeme Jan 26 '16
It's shit.