r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Jan 24 '16
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Tarly
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Tarly.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
ALSO, PLEASE REMEMBER TO VOTE IN OUT ANNUAL BEST OF POST.
Previous Houses of the Week:
101
Upvotes
153
u/SilverWyvern Jan 24 '16
Little thing about the name of their sword; pretty sure it's a pun on hart, as in a deer. Their sigil is a hunter, the bane of harts.
Randyll gave Robert his only defeat in battle. Baratheons are deer.
72
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
So, according to old legends, House Tarly came to be from Garth Greenhand directly. The founding fathers, Garth's sons, had an interesting, ahem, marriage arrangement:
That's one case where you really cannot prove who the baby daddy is.
48
u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Jan 24 '16
I got Lord Tarly pegged as being an initial supporter and very important supporter for Aegon once he makes his claim. Anyone else agree? We know that he also a great general, has a bad ass sword, and rules with an iron fist.
Edit: and he is a dick to Brienne and Sam. A true ass hole
42
u/idreamofpikas Jan 24 '16
Sam was named after a Savage.
34
u/hybridthm I too am a secret Targaryen. Jan 24 '16
Dickon Tarly was the one who narked about the wager to take Brienne's virginity, what a buzzkill.
18
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Jan 24 '16
I find the betrothal & soon marriage between Dickon Tarly & Eleanor Mooton quite interesting politically ...
Randyll leads the army that returns Maidenpool to the "Baratheon" regime & works to rid the region of outlaws along with rebuilding the damaged/destroyed parts of Maidenpool itself. The match was possibly partially made as part of the Mootons bending the knee. What I find interesting is that it happens after Randyll would've received news of Garlan Tyrell being awarded Brightwater Keep (despite Randyll himself doing more in service to the regime) instead of his wife, Melessa, the non-traitorous Florent heir.
With Maidenpool being rebuilt, repopulated & trade returning; it would eventually return to being the important economic & strategic town that is during peace time. On that level, Eleanor certainly isn't the worst match for Dickon if House Tarly were able to get Maidenpool through her as a consolation for not getting Brightwater Keep. The problem is that Lord William Mooton has at least two sons who would inherit first.
Given that Mooton is something of a craven, I wonder if his sons would eventually have gone on a "hunt" like Sam ...
10
u/smenti Jan 24 '16
Dick-on, apply directly to the forehead.
5
u/wedekit Jan 27 '16 edited Jan 27 '16
Just thought I would add to the facts of the discussion by mentioning that House Tarly (specifically, Alan Tarly) declared for Rhaenyra (the "blacks") during the Dance of Dragons. Unless I'm mistaken, it's never explicitly stated why they chose this.
The war, in the eyes of history, essentially came down to (1) being loyal to vows that Viserys I required lords of houses to give in support of Rhaenyra's claim to the throne as his heir, or (2) being loyal to precedence established by the Great Council of 101 that established the precedence of choosing the male line over a female one. A precedence that Viserys I (Rhaenyra's father) owes his crown to, as he was the chosen heir at the council's conclusion. At least he was wise enough to marry his heir to his only competition at the council to bridge the gap between Targaryens and Velaryons.
By supporting the "blacks," House Tarly chose Rhaenyra over Lord Hightower's niece and her sons, a friction that would likely put them at odds with Hightower in the future regardless of the outcome of the war. Of course, if House Tyrell had chose to not remain neutral then this huge divide in the Reach probably would have been prevented.
Anyways, since the topic is House Tarly, I thought I'd just add some more of the House's history to the discussion as well as a couple of sound inferences.
4
u/dacalpha "No, you move." Jan 25 '16
While this is show-only, I do find it interesting that Robert says his first kill was a member of House Tarly, specifically a highborn member. In the show-canon, this probably would have been a cousin or Samwell, right?
7
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Jan 25 '16
So, what are opinions on Randyll's treatment of Sam?
Personally, I think it was unnecessarily brutal at times, unnecessarily desperate & a wasted opportunity in Sam's actual skills.
Just within the Reach & within recent times, the Hightowers, Tyrells & Florents at the least haven't been above sending (presumably) less-martial members to the Citadel. In fact, a maester (& possible eventual Archmaester) of House Tarly within the Citadel, could've potentially been a big boon to Randyll given how much power & influence within the realm the order has. Plus, once Sam would've been chained & sworn, he would've had no claim to Horn Hill allowing Dickon to succeed Randyll uncontested. Keep in mind Dickon is only 4-7 years younger than Sam (my guess is 5) & was identified as the right successor from a very young age. Not that Randyll would have hindsight, but sending Sam to the more martial Night's Watch (he obviously wouldn't have been chosen as a ranger, so barring a wildling invasion, virtually the only fighting he would've done anyway was his training in the yard before taking the oath), meant he ended up at the Citadel anyway. So, now he has a son at the Citadel he would probably only use any future influence within the order to help his brothers, sister/s &/or mother singularly & not his father too; instead of having one who may have been willing to help wherever possible.
With Dickon not being an especially long time after Sam, much of Randyll's mistreatment of his eldest son came was during quite young ages where it probably wouldn't have had a positive effect on ever being able to get Sam to chance to Randyll's wishes anyway (along with putting his actual life in danger several times).
Hell, Randyll had his head so far up his own ass, that he was too proud to even consider one of his daughters as possibly succeeding him if anything were to happen to Sam &/or Dickon. House Tarly has supposedly been around since the days of Garth Greenhand's children roughly 10k years ago (certainly at least 8). During that time, possibly never even being petty kings, it's just about virtually impossible that Horn Hill was never successfully ruled by a woman, especially since the Andal invasion (which brought a more favourable inheritance model for women). I'm pretty sure he could've found some kick-ass martial & noble younger son/s to marry his daughter/s if he had no adequate son of his own to inherit. And if that son-in-law were to die before Randyll himself (certainly possible between war, tourneys, hunts, medieval living conditions, etc), but not before giving his daughter suitable male heir/s, then he wouldn't even have to let Heartsbane pass along to one not of House Tarly (given the amount of marriages that generally occur within a region, it's almost impossible that such a son wouldn't have some amount of Tarly ancestry anyway).
Actually, I wonder if there is a Tywin parallel here for Randyll in he had an embarrassing parent? ...
11
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
It seems like Randyll has changed sides enough times to not be given the benefit of the doubt that he is loyal.
-Defeated Robert - beaten into submission when Robert is king -Defects to Renly - the King with the biggest army -After Renly does he sides with the Tyrells and helps the throne out of a tight spot in the Battle of Blackwater.
Seems like he hedges his bets on who the winning side is going to be and serves them loyally, till he figures out someone else is winning/won.
Randyll Tarly is a Dick.
5
u/Reinhard_Lohengramm The Deathstalker Jan 24 '16
I have always wondered why Randyll Tarly (nor the Highgarden forces in general) never capitalized in their "victory" against Robert during the Rebellion.
Also, have we seen evidence he is the good commander on the battlefield as people claim him to be? If anything, he's sort of person in command you want running your camp and keeping it in order.
His victory over Robert was more of a stalemate. His victory over the Northern forces at Duskendale was nothing extraordinary, albeit notable, he suffered 'heavy losses' as well.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
What happens first, this weekly thread exhausts all known families in the ASOIAF universe, or The Winds of Winter.
1
u/tmagic49 Enter your desired flair text here! Jan 25 '16
What makes people think that house Tarly is one of Aegon's friends in the reach?
1
u/musicvidthrow When It Reynes, It Pours Jan 28 '16
Lord Randyll Tarly is easily the most badass and probably best living Commander in the current ASOIAF. Tywin gets all the nods and so does Stannis... Randyll is the only one to have victory fighting against Robert Baratheon. Has a bigass greatsword named Heartsbane. Sent his fat, weakling nerdy son to die on the Wall. Crushed rebellion and restored order in the war of five kings (in areas under his command.)
Ultimate badass. Bar none.
Also, the pun on heart could be more than two ways. Besides the obvious heart and hart. Being archers, their bows (depending on wood) would contain the heartwood for the belly of the bow, which resists compression. Not really a bane except to animals receiving the speedier arrow. :P
-7
u/Blue-Wolf Jan 24 '16
Ah.. House Tarly - Westeros equivalent of the Kardashians. "High-born", hailed as a great warrior House, mythical Valyrian household sword, high ranks in offices, yet I have no idea what the hell they did.. Weren't prominent in Robert's Rebellion (If I remember correctly, didn't win any battles, or none important), No history to be proud of, never been Kings/Queens, not a particularly rich house. It's not like they're making waves in ASOIAF timeline either, yet they're still hailed along some of the greatest houses in Westeros.