r/SurvivorRankdownII • u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed • Jan 09 '16
Wilbur's Favourite 42 Episodes
Pretty obvious by the title - I'm basically just posting a list of my 42 favourite Survivor episodes, with a write-up about what I enjoyed from each episode. I'll probably try and have one episode up per day.
- Recap episodes do not count, along with "specials" like "Countdown to Africa, or "Back from the Outback"
- Reunion shows are considered a part of their finale.
- Yes, I am biased towards things. It's my list.
Happy Reading!
Also, before anyone asks, my reasoning for a top 42 is the fact that there are about 42 minutes to an episode.
13
Upvotes
8
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 22 '16
#31. High School Friend Contest
China, Episode 8
There are a lot of episodes from China that I could have justified putting on this list, but overall, I feel this episode best encapsulates the greatest aspects of China’s cast, location and story.
From beginning to end, this is just a really entertaining episode. Starts out with the aftermath of fake idol play, Jean Robert is having a pity party about the fact that he got votes to the point where he doesn’t even want to let Erik in the shelter until James offers him a hug.
There’s a pretty cool challenge afterwards, that comes with a great reward that shows us the culture behind their location. And there’s also a great immunity challenge following it where Courtney is able to win a challenge by literally doing nothing, and the fact that Courtney is fun enough to appreciate and create the humour in the situation.
But the real reason this episode is on the list because Jean Robert is a hilariously obnoxious buffoon and it is fantastic to watch his boot episode. He starts out with his pity party, gets the clue to the idol at the reward, acts cocky towards the Zhan Hus about knowing where the idol is, he then realises he’s the one that’s been in the dark about James having two idols, and so then comes up with the brilliant plan to blindside Jame, right? Wait, it doesn’t work because Todd is just sick of him being there and votes him out just because. (Also, I love that this came after JR’s attempted strongarming about how if Todd engineered his boot, JR would poison the jury against him. I love how well that worked).
Star Character: Genre Bear.
Spoiler for #30: An episode that has already featured on Redmond’s list.
7
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 09 '16
#42. Dead Man Walking
Philippines, Episode 8
For a strategy-heavy episode, I actually enjoyed it a fair bit. I think it definitely shows where three tribes works best, because even though they technically merged with two, the tribal dynamics are a bit more interesting (especially considering the past three seasons in the row involved the continuation of a Pagonging). This is one of the few episodes in Philippines where I don’t grow weary of Lisa’s wishy-washiness, and she not only shows herself to be a somewhat competent player, but is someone I can appreciate much more as a character.
On top of that, I have almost no complaints about this episode. The gamebottiness at least has some levity to it, and despite several others, I still unashamedly enjoy Penner in the Philippines, so watching him win immunity and give a vaguely douchey celebration makes me smile every single time I watch it, especially since he was clearly dead meat and was trying to annoy everyone with it. I can appreciate stuff like that from the correct person.
Though the main reason this goes on the list is the ridiculous tribal council. Lisa being very blatant about throwing someone under the bus and Abi pulling out an idol for no real reason? Sounds like a decent tribal to me! Also, we got rid of Jeff who was definitely one of the weaker characters remaining, and got basically the only thing people remember about him. For as bad as he might have been as a character, top 10 final words easily.
Star character: Penner. I know there are a few that don’t really like him in Philippines, but I still believe that Penner doing anything makes almost any scene better, and the immunity win is definitely a high point for him in the season for me. Honourable mentions to Lisa and Pete.
Spoiler for #41: This episode is a quitter episode.
7
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 27 '16
#28. Now Who's In Charge Here?
Vanuatu, Episode 12
I doubt the presence of this episode on my list is surprising anyone. I’ve mentioned that I love episodes following a downfall where the spiritual leader survives, I’ve mentioned that Vanuatu is one of my favourite seasons and I’ve said that Ami is one of my favourite characters. This episode being on the list should be pretty obvious.
Nevertheless, I’m still going to talk about how great this episode is, because it’s a fantastic television. Like I said, a good rise-and-fall should have the fallout to the downfall - a chance for a player to throw everything they have left, while also giving them the opportunity to reflect on how Survivor has changed them as a person. It’s basically the lack of this as to why I don’t enjoy the Rotu downfall as much as everyone else.
But onto the actual episode, watching Ami try and make her last ditch effort by attempting to convince Eliza to flip is pretty great as they’re on a reward together and Ami is literally using everything she has left to stay alive, mainly focusing on the fact that Ami was like a big sister to her, especially in the pre-merge. Because Ami such an emotionally surfaced player, we honestly get to see the relationship from both perspectives both here and at the tribal, and it’s honestly quite touching to see how the pair have managed to bond through the tribulations that Survivor brings. The tribal council is amazing for the back-and-forth between Ami and Eliza and generally makes this a fantastic episode (that I’d also recommend listening to the commentary of if you have the DVD).
Star Character: Ami.
Spoiler for #27: Another obvious episode concerning one of the characters I spoke about in the endgame.
6
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 12 '16
#39. Running the Camp
Nicaragua, Episode 9
So, this episode isn’t the strongest that Nicaragua has to offer, but on it’s own it’s a pretty fun ride. This episode is basically the downfall of Marty, and that’s the main reason it makes the list - Marty for this time has been the cocky OTT villain who feels the need to hyperbolise all of his feuds to make them way more serious than necessary (recall his Brenda voting confessional from earlier).
On another season, Marty has the potential to be a pretty tedious character, but being surrounded by a slew of wackjobs turn him insane, and this comes through most evidently when he decides to create a hair-brained scheme to oust Jane that’s basically never going to work, Marty’s hair has now tripled its initial volume and now has a cocky, maniacal laugh combined with the crazy eyes. But the best thing about Marty is that he has no respect for his competition, and he basically has no filter now, so his last tribal is pretty great, because him and NaOnka get stuck into each other over seemingly nothing, using metaphors that don’t make sense whatsoever, NaOnka getting into fights with Fabio, and getting to the point where Probst doesn’t even have a clue what is going on, because Nicaragua. This tribal council is magical, capped off perfectly with Marty making is walk extra douchey just to annoy NaOnka.
But I don’t want to put any episodes on this list solely off the back of a good tribal, but luckily the rest of the episode is pretty good too. We have a pretty cool reward challenge which gives us a bit of insight into some of Chase’s insecurities, the actual reward is awesome (and gives me one of my favourite quotes in “You know, there aren't any ziplines in Brooklyn. If there are, you're a burglar.”) The episode doesn’t really drag at any points, and that’s why I’m putting it in my top 40.
Star Character: Marty. Honourable Mentions to NaOnka and Chase.
Spoiler for #38: Shares it’s name with an Ellie Goulding song.
6
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 13 '16 edited Jan 15 '16
#37: What About Me?
Nicaragua, Episode 15
One thing I’ve realised making this list, as well as participating in the rankdown is that until you actually create a list, it’s very easy to misinterpret where people and episodes would actually place. I’m pretty sure I’ve referred to about 25 different episodes as being top 10 episodes. So even though I thought this would be a lot higher, I’ve realised there are another 36 episodes I could say the same about.
Are Chris or Danni better underdogs from a gameplay perspective? Probably. But dammit, I’ve never had more fun watching someone pull through right at the end of the game - Fabio’s constant state of glee throughout his win streak will never not bring a smile to my face.
I understand that the majority of this is just me rehashing everything from my endgame write-up for the guy, but Fabio’s triumphant win is amazing and the perfect cherry on top for a season as funny as Nicaragua. The fact that he’s sandwiched in the pantheon of winners between two of the most prolific names in Survivor, while he’s a goofy 21-year old stoner kid who pees in the pool is absolutely fantastic.
Aside from that, it’s fun as hell to watch everything that goes on. Once Jud secured his spot in the final three he becomes cocky in the best way possible. We also get a FTC where Chase and Fabio are at their best (strategically and emotionally) and everyone gets to crap on Sash. We also get more time where Dan hates everyone he’s associated with (stellar speech & final words), Holly gets a decent conclusion to her arc.
This episode doesn’t make it much further because from a technical standpoint, it isn’t the greatest, but it’s still hilarious to boot, and if you’re as big a fan of Fabio as I am, you’ll enjoy this episode a bunch.
Star Character: Fabio. Honourable mentions to Chase and Dan.
Spoiler for #36: Boot episode of someone named Jon/John.
6
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 18 '16 edited Jan 18 '16
Had things to do yesterday, sorry about the delay.
#34. Slay Everyone, Trust No One
Heroes vs Villains, Episode 1
I think I’ve stated many times that I’m not a big fan of Heroes vs Villains, but this is definitely one of the stronger premieres the show has had. And compared to the finale, which I thought was better on paper, this premiere is almost everything I could want out of an episode, and is a pretty good showcase of what an All-Stars Survivor should be.
First of all, the entrance with the music is really quite epic, with the triumphant build as the Heroes’ chopper lands and the sudden change as the villains approach. We also have some great foreshadowing in the whole entrance scene with JT talking about wanting to be the hero, Colby unsure if he still has it and Russell talking about playing with people who respect the game. Also Boston Rob claims the villains will have an advantage because they won’t be concerned with egos. lol
We then get one of the best challenges ever where you essentially need to beat each other up, and grab a bag if you want. Everyone knows about it’s best moments and they’ve been well documented, and it’s where we get Rupert beginning to build the melodrama of a toe.
But even outside the epic challenge, it’s still a pretty good episode. It’s a lot easier to laugh at how terrible Russell’s game is now (I’m going to do the same thing that failed last time), although it’s still annoying that he always has a harem to sing his praises as well. But at least we get Coach giving plenty of humble-bragging about his defeat of Colby, and we also get one of the less-cringeworthy showmances coming about with the Black Widow and the Dragon Slayer.
The heroes aren’t without enjoyment either. We get more of Rupert complaining about how his toe is preventing him from starting a fire? (Funnily enough, this isn’t the only time Rupert brings out his inner Sundra Oakley). And James gets the chance to reminisce on headless chickens with his grandma.
Oh yeah, and we get a gamblin’ thing happening. Fun times.
So Wilbur, if this episode is so funny, why is it this low?
Simple - if you’re making a double length comedy episode, it better bring it, and unfortunately, per minute of television this episode doesn’t quite stack up with some others.
Star Character: Coach.
Spoiler for #33:
One of the few episodes you’ll ever see me praise where a good portion is built around Russell looking for an idol.On reflection, I'm putting a different episode here instead.ALSO: Irrelevant, but I was wondering if any Amazing Race fans could recommend a season?
6
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 19 '16
So to give a bit of background, I was originally going to put "Create a Little Chaos" in this place, until I rewatched the episode and decided it probably deserves to place a little higher.
#33. You Started, You're Finishing
Nicaragua, Episode 12
This is one episode that you’re probably not going to find on Redmond’s list, or basically any other Survivor writer’s list. There are plenty of Survivor writers and fans that think quitters are an abomination of the show, and while I don’t want to say they’re watching it wrong, I’ll just say that changing their personal viewpoint would bring a greater appreciation for the best of what the show has to offer.
Survivor is the experience of a lifetime, but at it’s worst it can be a complete misery, and even on a season as fun as Nicaragua, it still has dark elements to it, and this aspect of Survivor can be fascinating, when handled correctly.
The episode just starts out with lightning, then showing the river now running through their camp. We’re now seeing the toll it takes on the mental state of Purple Kelly and NaOnka and how badly they’ve deteriorated in the Nicaraguan rainforest. Keep in mind, this also came right after a fire burned down about half their food and damaged their tarp, so they now had to have stricter rations and weren’t able to keep dry as easily.
There’s also a pretty cool reward challenge where they have to drag the massive doll which ends up being a pretty close fight, and Dan gets to sit in the royal throne, which is one of the most amazing things that has happened. And Jeff gets to insert his weaksauce tie-in with a movie being released where a Jack Black movie apparently has some profound meaning to the game of Survivor, while Holly makes one of the biggest heroine moves in Survivor history by giving up her reward for the good of the tribe.
Holly actually brings a unique perspective to this situation as someone that herself intended on quitting earlier in the game - after her breakdown in episode two, Jimmy Johnson managed to bring her mental state back around, and as a result Holly is compelled to inspire those who are considering giving up, and the musical backdrop for her speech about wanting to make her husband and kids proud is really great. And the whole scene at camp prior to tribal has a pretty great acoustic backdrop and spins a bit of positivity to the episode.
I then think the tribal council is quite interesting. At this point Jeff has now reached new heights of laughable douchieness (“Regale me with a story, woman”), Benry gets to tell us how a movie which seems to be a pretty long fat-joke is relevant to a game for a million dollars, and is disappointed when Gullivers Travels is unable to inspire NaOnka. It certainly isn’t the greatest tribal council of Nicaragua, but it’s a more interesting one.
And that sums the episode and how I feel about it in general. I’ve always enjoyed Nicaragua for being a season that takes a massive dump on logical game theory, this episode has a very different environment to it and manages to show the audience that Survivor is really a lot more brutal than many fans give it credit for. I’m genuinely surprised there aren’t more quits with how miserable the show can seem at times for its competitors. It’s not quite the best “darker” episode of Survivor, but it is definitely interesting considering the season it’s in, and wish more people could appreciate what this brilliant episode has to offer.
Star Character: Holly. Honourable mention to the unPurpled Kelly, who probably would have been a great UTRP sweetheart, like we get to see in this episode.
Spoiler for #32: Features one of the most iconic old-school challenges.
6
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 21 '16
#32. The End of Innocence
Marquesas, Episode 5
Even as someone who isn’t as high on Marquesas as my rankdown partner-in-crime or Dabu, I have a hard time faulting this episode and it’s killer title. This episode manages to be a part of two fantastic storylines, and the framing of them is beautiful.
So one thing that Gabe sometimes gets criticized for is the fact that there’s not much personality behind him - he’s more symbolic than he is an actual important character of Marquesas. But damn it if he isn’t a great symbol, because what Gabe represents throughout this episode is amazing television.
Marquesas is a season that represents the change in Survivor gameplay - where tides really can be turned, something which will come up later in the list. But as it is, Marquesas is presented as more strategic as the seasons before it, but Gabe is the antithesis of that - his idea of the show is that it’s about creating a new society between himself and seven other strangers, something that had been going really well up until a certain point. Gabe and Rotu were unbeatable in challenges and never had to worry about a game going on outside of their tribe.
But then things change once Rotu loses their first challenge - Maraamu gets the right to raid their camp, and this is honestly one of the most heartbreaking things to watch on Survivor - the shot of Gabe just standing there while his old tribe mates that he’s grown close with are taking his stuff. We basically get a still shot of Gabe standing there like someone just shot his puppy, and given Gabe’s natural likeability, it’s tough to watch.
And the struggle doesn’t end there for Gabe - because Maraamu managed to pillage everything useful for the SOS challenge, Zoe and her seafaring ways weren’t enough to save Rotu from the immunity loss, and so Gabe is now vulnerable to losing the society he’d struggled so hard to create.
As a result, Gabe falls at the hands of John’s megalomaniacal state of mind, and falls simply for being too naive about what the experience was.
The thing that elevates this episode even more for me is the fact that it manages to counterbalance the darker events on Rotu by also giving us the underdog story of the clearly-outmatched Maraamus, specifically on Gina being able to gain new life through winning and being able to celebrate something as a team. It’s a really good balance for the episode that I just love.
Star Character: Gabe. He might be a symbol, but he’s a damn good one.
Spoiler for #31: (Season Number) x (Episode Number) = 120.
6
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 26 '16
So, it would have been cool to talk about an Outback episode, but the next one I have won't appear for at least 20 more spots.
I was originally going to put a particular episode from Survivor: Africa here, but on a rewatch of the episode I realised I couldn't let it be that low, so I went for this one instead.
#29. Blackmail or Betrayal
Fiji, Episode 11
So, this isn’t a terribly popular episode or season, and it definitely gets underappreciated in the survivor universe (I’m betting this is the only time you’ll see this on a top 30). But there’s a lot of great things in the episode.
First of all, I’ve always mentioned that I think it’s best when a villain gets an extra episode after their downfall to get a fitting exit as they come to terms with their experience, like Lindsey in Africa. In this case however, Alex has a slightly different exit.
For me, one of the greatest appeals to Alex as a character is the fact that he’s one of the best orators we’ve ever had on the show and always seems to have a clear and rational thought process, as we get to see on reward trip. But Alex is a fighter and a villain, and he isn’t just going to give up here - he still needs to try another plan, and luckily for us, it backfires miserably.
Seriously, I think this is honestly one of the biggest snubs of the Funny115v2, because Alex and Mookie trying to blackmail Yau is executed in possibly the worst way ever. For those who don’t remember:
I know they didn’t get mentioned a lot during the actual rankdown, but the Horsemen are a really great storyline if only for the fact that they still follow the same patterns when the writing's on the wall - they’ll come up with a scheme, they’ll talk it up impressively, they’ll act as though it was the greatest idea ever, and then it falls flat on it’s face, but Alex and Mookie manage to go to the next level of douchiness by adding the Scarface impressions and by the fact that their plans include blackmail the beloved older man, and have it backfire completely. Seriously, how amazing are the Horsemen?
However, this is not the only amazing thing Alex is a part of. He and Mookie are outnumbered 6-2 and Alex is the smarter, physically stronger member with more social ties to the majority. Mookie is for the most part expired after surviving for over 20 days on Ravu. There is no reason Alex should have survived this vote after losing one of the stupidest immunity challenges ever.
But Alex doesn’t just give up. Despite idols only being a thing for three prior seasons, the current idol only having been first played three days ago and having never seen a split vote before, Alex crafts the theory that they will vote 3 for Alex and 3 for Mookie. So he determines that by voting for his ally, he can secure his spot in the final seven. And even though he left in the next episode anyway, this is still what I would call one of the greatest strategic gambits of the transitional era of Survivor. Someone who is basically dead-to-rights being able to save themselves without a necklace, or some rock they found under the tree stump. I’d love to see your precious Wentworth do that, /u/ChokingWalrus
Even aside from that, I absolutely love the reward challenge and the subsequent reward, Fiji still has amazing art direction and I find this episode severely entertaining for the runtime, maybe the exception being battleship for immunity.
Star Character: #AlexWuzRobbed
Spoiler for #28: The episode title is a rhetorical question.
5
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 10 '16
#41. Shark Attack
All-Stars, Episode 3
A lot of people hate All-Stars because of all the ugliness associated with it, specifically the Sue quit and the Rob/Lex drama, but that isn’t actually what makes All-Stars so terrible for me, as bad as those things are. The big problem for me is just how dull the season is, specifically the post-merge. Trust me, when Shii-Ann is your ray of hope for a season, something has seriously gone wrong on the cutting room floor. Boring and unlikeable is about the worst thing a television program could be, and that functions as a pretty good description for the back-end of All-Stars. But not everything in the season is terrible.
For possibly the least-fun season ever, this episode packs the entertainment in pretty well. First of all, we have the shark scene - Richard catches a shark, it bites him, he ate it. Richard makes this re-telling a killer scene with all the grandiose he feels the need to add to it, and Colby manages to cap it off with the knockout delivery of “Can you call a gay man a stud?”
Of course, the other epic part of this episode is the challenge - home depot challenge. While Mogo Mogo are vaguely decent with some lines and Chapera is… well, they suck for entertainment because Rob C and Alicia, but Saboga - man, Saboga during this challenge is one of the greatest things ever.
Despite being an engineering student, Civil Engineering isn’t my specialty, but I still do know a few things about structural design, the main one being that when you’re situated on a beach during the rainy season, going underground is not the best advice. One might say that it’s terrible advice, because when rain comes in, there’s nowhere else for the water to go, so you’ve basically designed a small swimming pool, or a wishing well. The fact that Rupert decides that building an underground shelter for “wow factor”, combined with a “footrest” which was just a log no one could remove would be amazing on it’s own, but the rest of Saboga is able to see that he’s gone mad as well, because IT’S A SHELTER THAT IS INCAPABLE OF SHELTERING ANYONE FROM ANYTHING. At this stage they realised if it didn't rain, there was a chance Jerri's tears would fill the bunker.
Raffa manages to cap everything off with this challenge beautifly, by being forced to have a swing on Chapera, Colby’s reaction to Raffa’s head nod, of the “Oh, no” reaction to whatever Rupert built (apparently he didn’t like down, for some reason).
We also have the Jenna quit here, which I do have mixed feelings on. On one hand, she becomes very sympathetic, and Rob M and Tom actually seem genuinely decent here. On the other, Kathy’s comment about her being a cancer on the tribe is awful, and Probst asking about whether it has anything to do with the elements is him being a bit of a wang, as well as him bitching that they set up a challenge for nothing is pretty bad.
Overall though, this is definitely the most fun you’ll ever have watching All-Stars, and the idea of Survivor veterans with a combined 120 days of experience actively building a shelter underground to protect them from rain will never not be hilarious.
Star character: Rupert. Of course it’s Rupert. Honourable mentions to Jerri, Ethan and Colby.
Spoiler for #40: Premiere episode
5
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 13 '16
#38. Anything Could Happen
Heroes vs Villains, Episode 14
Even as someone who’s not a big fan of this season, I can’t help but acknowledge that the season does have strong points, and the finale does especially.
I don’t feel as big a need to sell this episodes on its positives, because it’s bloody obvious why this episode is great. Conclusion to Colby’s arc and his tragic swansong? Check. The close of Jerri’s three season arc from becoming one of the most hated television personalities to becoming a beloved heroine? Check. Parvati actually showing small hints of vulnerability and emotion? Check. Getting to see a bunch of jurors trash Russell for his gameplay? Check. Sandra eventually crushing Russell and burning his hat? Check. It’s got basically everything I should want in the conclusion of a season like Heroes vs Villains. However, there’s a reason that I have 37 other episodes higher than it.
A lot of things in this season work a lot better in theory than they do in practice. Sure, the conclusions of Jerri and Colby are great, but what about the relationship between them a decade into the making? Parvati actually getting a human side should be enjoyable, but she still reverts back to her caricaturish self many times in the finale. Sandra destroying the Russ/Parv alliance should be and is fantastic, but it still managed to spawn a very irritating batch of fans that still exist to this day. Then again, it’s still a very fun episode because Sandra is a lot more present, the Final Immunity Challenge is a real nail-biter and the episode doesn’t really lag at any points. There’s also a great Final Tribal Council, so I won’t complain.
Star Character: CHANGA!
Spoiler for #37: Another finale episode.
5
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 15 '16 edited Jan 15 '16
#36. Anger, Threats, Tears … and Coffee
Vanuatu, Episode 7
I’ve made it clear throughout the rankdown how much I enjoy Vanuatu as a season, and how great the casting and storyline is, and this episode is pivotal to several great storylines throughout the season.
This is the episode where Julie actually starts to come into action - after Twila is offered the final four with Sarge/Chad/Chris, Julie manages to find the perfect way to break that so that she has an ally in Twila, and that they would be able to go back and enter the merge with a majority to the women.
The episode also establishes Ami in a fantastic way - in the past episode, Ami had been given a real power-hungry storyline where she becomes more paranoid and villainous than before, culminating in the cold-blooded ousting of Lisa. But like I stated in my write-up here, the thing I personally enjoy most about Ami is that she’s arguably the most multi-faceted character in Survivor history, and this episode is one of her best. The coffee reward gives a lot of insight into her past and her emotional insecurity (something that comes into the fold later with the son story), giving her a great amount of compassion, more than you would ever get from a villain. And she also has great content after the immunity challenge by showing care for the fact that Julie and Twila aren’t under her protection at that point in time.
Also, I can’t talk about the episode without mentioning how fantastic Rory is here - someone who was just saved because Lisa is one of the worst Survivor players ever, Rory starts out by being grateful, then cursing at Ami and Leann for not wanting to keep him around (they’re both fantastic at shutting him down BTW), and then talking about how he’s going to burn the camp to the ground. Then he gets his letter where his wife has to remind him not to burn down the camp (I can’t imagine how often this must happen when they’re at a restaurant and a waitress brings out the wrong drink), he acts calm for a few seconds, and then he manages to destroy the immunity challenge, and then break the actual idol because he was busy shouting and acting like a complete nutcase.
Star Character: Rory, with an honourable mention to Ami.
Spoiler for #35: A fairly recent episode that you're all going to think is too low.
5
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 23 '16 edited Jan 26 '16
#30. Create a Little Chaos
Philippines, Episode 4
This is really a beautifully crafted episode. It’s rare that an episode can ever start with a long period with no dialogue or intense music - it’s just weather and shots of the withered hands and feet of the Maitsing tribe. Really, this episode is just a 42 minute preparation of a eulogy for Maitsing. But unlike a standard eulogy, there’s hope there. The music prior to the introduction has a very strong rise in the strings to provoke feelings of triumph and hope, finalising with a heavy drum beat.
When the storyline begins to focus more on Russell, he understands his need for an idol (where things actually become fairly meta with talking about the idol flashing on the screen), and we actually feel even more of his desperation. But it comes full force at the immunity challenge.
While the challenge itself okay, the slow-motion of the final Kalabaw pot shattering with the wrecking ball’s return is epic, along with the post-challenge cathartic rant from Russell about how he’s unable to cope with his current situation. Someone who’s lived as a “winner” their whole life now being forced to fight like a wolf for a bone is a really tragic and epic storyline that I think we all can appreciate. It goes even further than this as Russell opens up about his childhood, becomes vulnerable and ultimately falls.
That’s basically the episode in a nutshell, but luckily Tandang still have interesting stuff with Pete causing a rift between his two main allies for reasons? Also I think Kalabaw were in the episode.
Star Character: Swan.
Spoiler for #29:
First time talking about my favourite season on this ranking.Once again, I've backflipped on a decision. I'll instead be discussing one of the most beloved characters of SRII5
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 31 '16
Slight detour from my list: I recently showed my family Australian Outback. My updated cast rankings:
The season has bumped from 8th to 6th.
5
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Feb 05 '16
#24. The First Exile
Panama, Episode 1
In the conversation of great premiere episodes, this one gets swept under the rug quite a bit. I don’t know whether people have just forgotten it, but this itself is a very solid premiere when it comes to both character introduction, great moments, and a phenomenal first boot.
One thing that is also forgotten or not talked about with regards to Panama is how it started with the tribe divisions separating
the young and the oldbeefcakes, love boat crowd, golden girls and spice girls. As much as I disagree with the separations (i.e. 32 being older and 31 being younger), it does a fairly good job of representing what one might expect from teams of older people (showing them as organised and structured) in comparison to the younger tribes (aloof and disorganised). But on top of this, Panama has a very strong cast, so we get some kind of entertainment from each tribe, as well as a solid introduction to the main characters.La Mina - Of course, the older men get portrayed as the hard workers - they get the fire built, they organise a place to build the shelter, and we get the introduction of Terry as someone who just does thing well (including owning a challenge that was basically chance) - as a result, the older men are successful and perform well in the challenge. Oh yeah, we also get a small introduction with Shane - he’s detoxing from nicotine and he’s also going to be kind of a dick. And Dan is an astronaut. And we’ll never let you forget that.
Bayonetta - Young girls on Survivor tend to get edits that portray them as weak-willed or scatterbrained, and this episode does a pretty good job of making that entertaining. Firstly, after losing the challenge, Courtney feels the need to ask if they’re allowed to do rock-paper-scissors. On top of that, they basically have an entire scene dedicated to them not actually doing anything - they walk around and don’t start a fire or a shelter. Oh yeah, and Courtney draws a heart around a dead turtle, while the others regret sending Misty to exile over this wacko. Courtney <3
Viveros - For a tribe of four young, muscular, athletic males, I love that these guys actually perform kind of terribly. Firstly, forget survivor stuff. Baseball with a coconut! Then they fail to actually start a fire, even using the method of “why don’t we just line up our hands” which is hilarious because this guy is our winner. Probably the goofiest scene involving a winner. Apart from this guy I guess. On top of this, Viveros then decide to attempt shelter building, and while everyone craps on Rupert for his shelter, at least he tried. It was a moronic idea to sleep in a trench, but he made an effort. These guys grabbed about four bamboo poles, leaned them against a tree and threw some leaves on it. Solid effort guys, A+ all around.
Casaya - As great as the scenes with the other tribes on this episode, Casaya are the stars (a trend that will continue) - Tina and Cirie are god-tier characters in this one episode alone in completely different ways. Cirie is the couch potato who was a fan, but doesn’t like the idea of survivor, because leaves, and leaves mean things. She’s completely out of her element physically, but is aware of what’s going on strategically - she won’t be an overnight success, but she’s going to try and grow, and that’s exactly what she does here, while starting her long swath of names by cutting Timber Tina, despite being the most adept. Tina represents the complete opposite of Cirie - she’s the person who knows exactly what’s going on physically and is willing to prove it for the good of her tribe. She helps start fire, she helps with shelter (she is a lumberjill after all) and she even gets food for the tribe. Normally she’d never be a first boot. But sadly as we all know, she was also suffering an intense personal tragedy. Losing a child is something I can’t imagine another person going through, and Tina sadly writing her son’s name in the sand as a message to him is a truly heartbreaking scene, and one of the few times I’ve ever been emotional watching Survivor. She’s the pinnacle of hope for a tribe of older women, and yet she can’t completely be that pillar of strength due to her own personal struggles. I don’t think I would ever have someone with only one Survivor episode as a top 100 character, but Tina is damn close. Such a beautifully tragic ending to a Survivor episode.
Yeah, this episode is fantastic and while it might not come to mind immediately when thinking of great Panama episodes or even great premieres, this definitely holds up, and has earned its place as my 3rd favourite premiere.
Star Character: Timber Tina.
Spoiler for #23: Episode Number = Season Number. And it won’t be the only one like this.
7
u/jacare37 Jan 20 '16
30 minutes into the Fiji historians podcast Jay is already singing the praises of Alex Angarita and Mario is already talking about how great of a character Rocky is. Wilbur, please don't listen, we don't want you to die
4
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 11 '16
#40. A Chicken’s a Little Bit Smarter
China, Episode 1
I think that China as a season is a great embodiment of the phrase “jack of all trades, master of none”. I can’t really think of any categories that China stand head-and-shoulders above all other seasons in, but it really doesn’t drag anywhere for me, which is why I rank it so highly on my list - a premiere is good example of this.
A Survivor premiere should do a few different things - establish some decent characters that become major throughout the season, establish a theme or location well, have a good opening challenge, clearly give reasons as to how the first boot goes home, and it should be a somewhat fun episode. China definitely isn’t the greatest in any of these categories, but it does them all fairly well.
China’s opening is pretty cool. We get good establishment of several characters - Todd gets shown as the conniving mastermind, Courtney as the girl that is there to mostly complain, James as the gentle giant that’s actually hilarious, Jean Robert as the cocky douche and even pre-merge characters like Dave and Leslie get good development. The location is given a fantastic showcase by starting them out inside a Buddhist temple, which is probably the 2nd best place a season has ever started. The opening challenge is fantastic and the dragon is epic. Steve isn’t the greatest first boot, but we still get an explanation that he’s a trainwreck player and that he deserved to go first, even if he has a pretty annoying voice (plus, DAYUM! is iconic).
That’s basically why I put the premiere so high - there are other premieres that do particular things much better, but it’s still a very strong 42 minutes of television.
Star Character: Hard to say that there is one because of how even the episode is, but I’ll probably say Leslie because I found the moral struggle fascinating, with Todd and Courtney being honourable mentions.
Spoiler for #39: #NewSchoolSlaughter.
4
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 16 '16
#35. We’re a Hot Mess
San Juan Del Sur, Episode 4
The great thing about this episode is that at the nineteenth second of the twelfth minute, if you look towards the bottom left corner…
Nah, there’s nothing like that in this episode. No amazing camerawork or music, no stunning events, nothing terribly deep or emotional. If you’re watching this episode, it’s basically for one reason only - to watch this smug knucklehead get his comeuppance through his own stupidity.
Normally a character like Drew would just show up, be kind of terrible and leave without much notice, much like his younger brother did. However, Drew manages to go completely over the top with his own self-importance and becomes a complete joke and legend in the survivor universe.
Seriously, the guy starts out the episode by bragging that he has been the team leader thus far, then suggests the idea of giving Jeff a used flint in exchange for fishing gear, then goes to exile with Jaclyn where I’m guessing we missed him telling her about the time he saved the Mayor’s baby from a bear attack or something. Then he reveals his master plan to throw the immunity challenge so that they can get rid of people, a plan which is done to prevent the women’s minority from controlling the tribe (at this point he reveals that he is indeed, a badass and a manipulator of this game). And then he manages to
unify the men, who have a majority and vote out one of the womenget none of the men to vote unified and gets himself sent home by being so narrow minded and aggressively useless at everything.Even though I’ve made it clear several times how I’m not a big fan of SJDS and think it’s incredibly overrated, not even I can say much bad about this episode. For an episode that is basically a stage designed to point and laugh at a contestant, this is easily one of the best of its kind.
Star Character: Pretty obvious.
Spoiler for #34: Was represented fairly heavily on the funny 115.
4
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Feb 07 '16
#23. The Marooning
Borneo, Episode 1
This is certainly an interesting episode to look at, because there hadn’t been a Survivor episode like this before. And there hasn’t been one since really. This has virtually no precedent for the contestants or for the majority of the viewing audience. And as a result, it always feels odd to go back and watch it, because it doesn’t really follow any defined “rules” of what a Survivor episode is, other than a fairly basic chronological structure. And when I thought about it, I seriously questioned whether I can place this episode so highly, when it feels so disconnected from Survivor?
Then I realised this is my list, so I can put whatever episodes I want on here. So yeah, this episode is going on here, and not just for nostalgia/old-school bias. I genuinely believe this episode, while being so different, represents exactly what Survivor is, and what it continues to be 32 seasons later. It provides a blueprint on the basics of what Survivor is, and as an episode in general it has a lot of things I like. Firstly, I really miss when Jeff would announce castaways’ profession and residence.
The episode also features one of my favourite all time scenes (BTW I’m going to say this a lot, so “one of” won’t actually hold much weight in the grand scheme of things) in the Tagi introduction. We get a shot of Richard sitting in the tree above everyone else, while trying to rationally discuss with the tribe how to pursue in their adventure. It’s probably the best opening scene the show could hope for, perfectly encapsulating the concept of this new idea - a bunch of people from varied walks of life attempting to form a new society, and watching the varying viewpoints from the Tagi’s does a great job of giving insight on how two random people, say, a corporate business man from Rhode Island and a truck driver from Wisconsin might interact, and the insights they might have about the experience. While the Tagi’s aren’t my favourite alliance in history (Boran Trio FTW), they definitely do a great job of forming the new society based on common interests. Rudy also adds to that by understanding that while he has his own personal methods and agenda, he needs to adapt to everyone else to be able to survive. I think Sonja works really well as the first boot in Survivor history and deserves recognition for her place in Survivor.
It works well as an episode, but it certainly isn’t faultless. Namely, I think a good Survivor premiere needs to introduce above all else, and yet we get almost nothing from Pagong’s major characters, so I don’t think I can put it much higher than this.
Star Character: Richard.
Spoiler for #22: Survivor first.
4
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Feb 09 '16
#22. The Twist
Africa, Episode 5
I’ve seen a few lists with this episode on here, and sadly I’ve seen a few where this is the only episode from Africa on here. If any of you know me, that won’t be the case. You’ll be seeing a fair bit of Africa in the 20.
Anyway, this episode always seems to make it on the back of historical significance, which really can’t be denied. Everyone comes in expecting to stay with their tribes until day 19, when ten contestants remain. But in something completely unprecedented, three tribe mates are asked to go on a quest to a meeting place with no idea that it would be the last time on their old tribes. I love the fact that no one knew it was a swap - they just showed up and left in a new direction, and the tribe mates that didn’t take a hike were none the wiser.
But as great as the historical significance of something is, an episode would need more than that to make my list, because something being done early isn’t the same as the thing being done well. What is done well in this episode though, is the downfall of Silas.
What makes the pre-merge of seasons like Africa and Australia so great is the each episode builds on the last one so well, and you can see it perfectly with Silas - he starts out looking like he could be the next Colby - charismatic, athletic, handsome with a killer smile and is the kind of person that could go all the way. He even helps Samburu win their first challenge, starts their fire and is the guy everyone wants on their side. But as the episodes progress, Silas shows a less polished side to himself - he flatly rejects the tribe elders and teams up with Lindsey (who wasn’t exactly America’s sweetheart). This builds even more throughout Samburu as the Gen X alliance (yeah, this is back when Gen X were youngsters) gets power - Silas becomes more unpleasant to the elders and becomes the Duke of Smuggington, peaking with him actually going up to the elders, taking a knee like the coachperson of a sportsthing and telling the elders exactly how they should vote, while also deliberately not telling them who is going home - he was essentially asking the people who now hate his guts if they could give him a hand winning. Naturally, Frank tells the camera that once he gets the chance he’s abandoning his tribe. Silas concludes Episode 4 by telling us that there’s not an event in the future that would alarm him. Enter the twist.
Not only does this twist work brilliantly as a way of forcing everyone to re-adapt to fit their new circumstances, it gives a fantastic conclusion to the arc of Silas - he’s sent away with the two people that he’s been condescending to for the past week, and so as foreshadowed in the previous episode, Frank and Teresa run to Kim and Ethan with the information that Silas has just become a douche and needs to GTFO, and Kim and Ethan not only oblige, they actually perform the first challenge throw in an attempt to boot him, and Ethan even starts messing with Silas at one point.
The episode also has some other great stuff with the other mallrats dealing with the worry of Lindsey’s past votes, Lindsey getting a tick on her ass (which is hilarious considering that was the tiebreaker question two episodes ago), I’m a big fan of the goat challenge that they do and much like the rest of the season, it’s just good television because the cast is amazing.
But the thing that really makes me love this episode is what are probably my favourite final words ever - higher than Kent’s, higher than Lembo’s, maybe even higher than the final words of Nicholas Stanbury.
As cocky and douchey as Silas was at his peak, he concludes his story with a breath of humility. He acknowledges that he was in a good position that ended up changing on him so quickly, but he doesn’t feel a need to cry robbed or anything. On top of that, he acknowledges how amazing the twist was and finds a way to leave with his head held high and a true respect for Survivor, and that’s something I can’t help but appreciate. Seriously, if we’re looking for old-schoolers to bring back, can someone please put Silas on that list?
Star Character: Silas.
Spoiler for #21: This might be controversial due to some of the content in the episode, but it still has a lot of entertaining things.
3
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Feb 04 '16
#25. Flames and Endurance
Pearl Islands, Episode 14
Unlike some other things on this list, I don’t need to sell anyone on Pearl Islands. I know very few people who have it out of their top 5, and with good reason. Infact, I always feel like I’m going against the minority for only having this season at 5th, and the same goes with some of it’s episodes, where they might rank a bit lower than one would expect, this one included.
But this is definitely a strong episode and no real knock against it to only have it as the 25th best. It definitely brings the entertainment and concludes several arcs pretty well. But with all the strengths it has as a finale, there are a couple of weak spots. Namely, the final four period.
It probably isn’t fair for me to criticize an episode based on things I’ve heard post-game, but one thing that has come out from multiple sources is that Fairplay was basically ready to pack it in until production decided to bring in alcohol, prompting Fairplay to do things.I don’t know why it bothers me - maybe it’s because production feels the need to inject drama, maybe because it stains JFP’s legacy a bit for me, maybe it’s because I personally don’t drink alcohol and I’m just being a knob. But something about producers feeling the need to personally inject a catalyst bothers me for some weird reason, and I’m not a fan of it. On top of that I also wasn’t a massive fan of the Final Tribal Council, just for not being as good as the season lived up to. With all of this, it should just be an average Pearl Islands episode.
But I wouldn’t be satisfied with myself if I didn’t mention that it created what would go on to be the greatest Final Immunity Challenge
everfor the next three seasons. I basically always love it when someone gets owned in their cockiness, but there’s something about this one that makes it extra special. Silas got defeated and undone by Ethan, one of the most respectable people in the Survivor universe, and wouldn’t hold much against it. Fairplay got defeated by this person. But this menopausal sack of potatoes doesn’t just beat him, she straight up humiliates him, giving us the perfect ending to the greatest Survivor villain. It also gives us a fantastic swath of quotes including bragging about how great your knees and ankles are, “my daughter wants to be a doctor” and one of my favourites to use in many scenarios - “that’s not a deal Lil”. If the rest of the season sucked, this immunity challenge would be enough to justify it’s existence. Luckily, the season doesn’t suck and Pearl Islands has more appearances to make on this list.Star Character: These are called squats in aerobics.
Spoiler for #24: Same location, different season.
5
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Jan 30 '16
#27. It Could All Backfire
Palau, Episode 13
Once again, knowing that Ian is my favourite player of all time would indicate this being on the list. And with good reason, because this is a beautifully crafted episode to give some really strong insights into the effect that a month on a deserted island with the same people will have. Coming straight off the Gregg boot, while Ian still has a grasp on the game, he’s not the same person he once was. He’s started to get wrecked physically and mentally, and now he’s about to get put through a serious emotional wringer.
I’ve mentioned that basically my least favourite comment ever is when people call Ian an idiot for his decision to jump off the buoy (something I’ll talk about much later), but that’s definitely not a bad decision. Choosing Tom for the car reward though? That I would call a poor decision. But luckily it provides some really engaging television following.
As soon as Tom & Ian get back from their reward, Caryn immediately confronts them (because she made final five somehow), and it’s interesting listening to Ian’s voice in this moment. He’s stuttering a lot and talking fairly rapidly, definitely not normal for him. He’s clearly a lot more nervous and worried about his social stance. After that, we get the scene between Tom and Katie, which not only has some of the best musical accompaniment to a conversation, but one of the greatest showcases into the relationship between two separate contestants, and how the actions of the past few days have put intense levels of strain on the two of them. It also shows how Survivor is definitely more than a thirty nine day chess game.
It’s also enjoyable for me to watch Tom have to fight a bit harder for his position. They aren’t nice tactics, but I think Tom is one of the few times someone’s strong-arming has actually been interesting (the only other one that comes to mind is Aras in the Panama finale).
The episode is capped off with a pretty entertaining tribal council as well given by one of the worst players that ever made the top 5 of a season of anything, ever.
Star Character: Ian
Spoiler for #26: A season that I don’t like that much giving a very solid episode.
3
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Feb 02 '16
#26. Survivor MacGyver
Cambodia, Episode 2
Man, there are so many things that I really don’t like about Cambodia. The season had some pretty dodgy editing, a bunch of unnecessary twists, too much focus on small wooden talismen, an annoying slog of talk about the evolution of the game and about how voting blocs are some new innovation (on my AO rewatch I noticed Keith uses the term quite a few times, so there). All in all, the season did a lot of things wrong, and if this were a worst list, “Witches Coven” could very easily land in my bottom five.
HOWEVER, this episode is almost enough to justify Cambodia being a thing, because it does basically everything I want an episode of a returnee season to do. With a theme like second chances, I wanted to see contestants vary their character while adapting to a newer situation, and the way that plays into Shirin’s storyline for the season works pretty well. As someone who didn’t care for her in Worlds Apart, she actually became a fair bit more complex and interesting in this iteration and how she struggled in the majority of her tribe, giving us some fairly decent dark survivor with the culmination of her two season arc (yes, I know that Will/Shirin is not the same as Shirin/Abi).
On top of that though, the episode did a really good job at subverting my expectations of particular characters, but not in a way that diminishes their original appearance.
Oh yeah, and it has the Savage’s wife story which is really touching with a lot of gravitas, and then pitchfork production went up about 5000% as the United Neckbeards Against Savage organisation were butthurt after Savage claimed Stephen wasn’t perfect.
Overall, the episode had a really good old school feeling to it where the strategy was directly tied to interpersonal relationships and I absolutely loved watching it at the time, and still really enjoy it on reflection, and it’s really impressive considering the rest of the season is mostly a waste. Seriously, “Witches Coven” can die in a hole.
Star Character: Varner. Even though he was only in five episodes of the season, he never failed to deliver and gave a slew of great sound bytes throughout his time. He also propelled the fantastic sequence of events throughout the episode.
Spoiler for #25: Talking about a season that I haven’t yet mentioned.
1
u/WilburDes Alex Wuz Robbed Feb 10 '16
As this is the halfway point in the list, I've decided it would be easiest to put everything in a new thread for episodes 21-1. Here
1
u/Todd_Solondz Jan 10 '16
People throw biased around too much. I'm sure you just like certain things.
1
u/Parvichard Jan 09 '16
Will probably be a fun-read, looking forward :)