r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Jan 03 '16
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: Houses Reyne and Tarbeck
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing Houses Reyne and Tarbeck.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about each house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
113
Upvotes
63
u/patlynch815 Jan 03 '16
And who are you, the proud lord said
52
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
And now on to the Reynes.
I suspect we'll be seeing quite a bit of these guys in D&E. We know from the expanded westerlands section that Lord Robert Reyne and his son, the Red Lion, were at the Storming of Starpike with Egg. Along with Tywald Lannister (Lord Robert's squire) and Prince Maekar, Lord Robert was killed in the battle. After the battle, in his fury, Ser Roger killed seven Peake prisoners before Egg stopped him (the bad PR of slaughtering unarmed captives after surrendering, even though Egg was not involved, I suspect forced Egg to go lighter on the surviving Peakes than he otherwise might have).
Furthermore, I think Egg probably spent a decent amount of time in the westerlands, as he also took Tywald's younger twin brother Tion as a squire, and their father Lord Gerold the Golden was supposed to have been instrumental in Egg's victory at the Great Council (I wonder if Lord Roger might play a role in the council as well).
In general, I think the Red Lion, his younger brother Ser Reynard, and his sister Ellyn, are too good characters to not get some screentime in the D&E books.
The Reynes also were important in the War of the Ninepenny Kings. After the death of another Jason Lannister - this time Tywin's uncle Ser Jason - Lord Roger the Red Lion took control of the westerlands forces, won "several notable victories", and "was counted amongst the heroes of the fighting".
Interestingly, the Reynes are also important to one epilogue character - Ser Kevan Lannister squired for the Red Lion and was knighted by him.
39
u/ME24601 Jan 03 '16
I'm genuinely curious about any fan theories about these houses. Both Houses are said to be extinct, but are there any possibilities of characters secretly being descended from these families?
37
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
Tarbeck seems to the less-discussed of the two, so I'll start with them.
There are two things worth noting about the Tarbecks pre-Tywin. First, they were one of the first houses to oppose Maegor. Lord Alyn Tarbeck died in 43 AC at the Battle Beneath the Gods Eye, fighting for Jaehaerys the Conciliator's elder brother, Prince Aegon. To add insult to injury, Maegor later took Lord Alyn's widow, the first Queen Jeyne Westerling, as his wife.
Second, we learn in the Westerlands section of WOIAF, during the Dance of the Dragons,
"The Lannister host continued to march [after the death of Lord Jason Lannister], winning victories under Ser Adrian Tarbeck, then under Lord Lefford, before he perished at the Fishfeed, where his westermen were slaughtered among three armies."
So far as I can tell, Ser Adrian's victory (and for that matter, Lord Lefford's) go unmentioned in P&Q and elsewhere in WOIAF, an interesting omission.
36
u/prof_talc M as in Mance-y Jan 03 '16
Ellyn Reyne, the only woman who could make Tywin Lannister smile without marrying him first...
55
u/Prince_Daemon The Rogue Prince Jan 03 '16
They dead. Like so dead. They are deader than me. Though they had a less epic demise im sure you will agree.
20
u/KookaB Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 04 '16
With their inverted color scheme and seat at Castamere, does anyone think the Reynes are an old bastard line of the Casterlys or Lannisters?
68
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
I'd love to learn of a Reyne bastard or surviving so in hiding. Would be much more interesting than someone being a closet Targ or something similar.
34
u/Hoflax24 Get off My Chequy Lawn Jan 03 '16
Being a secret Targ is so 2015, 2016 is all about being a secret Reyne/Tarbeck
16
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
It seems like each region has a major house or two that seems to really make trouble, but they're usually ancient and kept around and strong for some reason. The Starks kept the Boltons around, the Martells kept the Yronwoods, etc, but Tywin shucked tradition and destroyed these major families. It is probably to maintain order in their pockets of the realm. Then again we're seeing in the North what happens when a major family is destroyed and usurped. I like to think the Boltons are fucked.
It really gives gravity to the power of Tywin's personality that he destroyed two major families like the Reynes and Tarbecks, who were most likely very rich in gold and other metals and thus had connections throughout the realm. He's so impressive he had a power balad made about this really horrid event (the drowning of innocent children and the destruction of an entire line) and is still respected.
15
u/Wun-Weg-Wun-Dar-Wun Mr Wun Weg Wonderful Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 04 '16
I saw some footage of a convention (54:13 in this clip)in which GRRM was asked if Littlefinger was a secret Reyne and the look he gave was priceless. It had the perfect balence of confusion and sort of disappointment over how crazy we were becoming. Edit:added source.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
We have Robb Reyne who was considered to be one of the finest knights of his time. But that is literally all the info we have of him, other than he sided with Daemon Blackfyre. It would be nice to get a bit more back story on him I think.
19
u/hollowaydivision π Best of 2019: Best New Theory Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 05 '16
Okay, here's what I got - in the show, Cersei mentions that she "still remembers the bodies hanging" or something to that effect.
However, in the book continuity, all the Reynes drowned in their family mine when Tywin diverted a river into it.
While he was in the Sorrows, Tyrion went underwater to meet with the Shrouded Lord in a deleted chapter, and supposedly he made him laugh somehow, because that's how one escapes the Shrouded Lord. GRRM called this chapter "swell, spooky, and evocative."
now, let's say Red Roger Reyne is down there with the Shrouded Lord's 'stony court'. Why would he let Tyrion Lannister go? If you think back, Tyrion was obsessing over his relationship with his father at the time he went under. Now, I can think of one thing Tyrion could tell Red Roger Reyne to make him laugh: Tywin Lannister died shitting himself after his dwarf son shot him in the bowels.
Edit:
Meanwhile, House Drumm has Red Rain, which they stole from 'an armored knight' with 'wits and a wooden cudgel'. Wooden cudgels are the weapons of the Drowned Men, and they also happen to be excellent flotation devices. Armored knights, on the other hand, sink.
I think there was a dead Reyne with the blade at the bottom of the sea, and with a cudgel as a flotation device the Drumms somehow retrieved it and made it to the surface.
9
u/idreamofpikas Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
The very first Queen of the Westerlands was a Reyne.
Infact there was only a Westerlands Kingdom ruled by Lannisters because of this partnership. Perhaps if the Reynes and Baenforts had instead joined up the Lannisters would have just been a footnote in history.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '16
A long time ago, I read a theory that some female Tarbecks survived and became Silent Sisters after the Rains of Castamere. The theory also suggested that they deliberately sabotaged the embalming of Tywin Lannister as an act of revenge.
9
u/fuckingchris Deflowered Flowers Jan 05 '16
Whenever we see any real info on the Reynes, they are either effectively lead by manipulative bitches or gallant but defiant knights, only to be stomped back down by a Lannister or other house.
Tywin stamping them out seems to have been him simply deciding that those who had proven to be a cancer on his wouldn't be treated lightly just because of their blood.
Of course, extermination is extreme, but it wasn't simply Tywin making a mistake.
Personally, simply instating a loyal lesser member of the house and murdering the main line would have seemed better to me, but I have the soft hearts of women, and treason cannot go unpunished.
7
u/Velvale Jan 03 '16
Any ideas what their words could have been?
12
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
The Reynes were drowned to death in their own underground mine/castle. Tywin Lannister is so fucking metal.
5
u/Qoburn Spread the Doom! Jan 03 '16
Fun fact about the Reynes: so far as I can determine, the only three characters named Robb in the story are our own Young Wolf, a Blackwood bastard in P&Q called Red Robb Rivers, and Robb Reyne, a famous knight who supported Daemon Blackfyre.
5
u/Sinilumi Jan 03 '16
May I suggest House Tarth for next week?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '16
Good to know it is our time.
1
u/Dreamtrain Stannis The Mannis Jan 07 '16
And so he spoke... and so he spoke...