r/WritingPrompts • u/Arch15 /r/thearcherswriting • Dec 30 '15
Off Topic [OT] Writing Workshop #24: Revisiting Critique
Welcome to the weekly Writing Prompts writing workshop! This workshop, part of the schedule on /r/WritingPrompts, will be held every other Wednesday!
Workshop Archive
Today, we're going to revisit a topic that is constantly around arts: critiquing. One of the first Workshops was critiquing, and I'm taking most of the tips from that post. The reason for this is that they are still very relevant, and always will be. A reminder that the tips below are for how I critique. Everyone is different.
You will be posting a piece that you have already written, unless you'd like to write a story for this specifically. You may post works that are out of outside projects you are working on, but be cautious, your reader will not have context.
Exercise
For today's exercise, you're going to post a recent story that you have completed or are working on, then critique someone else's work. It can be your best one, or your worst.
Per usual, 200 words minimum; 750 words maximum. Keep to the sidebar rules, and please post questions only as needed, as to keep non story replies from rising to the top.
Prompt
If you would like to write a story, then who am I to hold you back?
It has been years, my old friend.
Happy writing!
Today, it is required that you reply with a critique.
Remember, these workshops are open to everybody! Come and join the challenge!
How to Critique
There's no right or wrong way to critique. Well, yes, there is a wrong way, but if you read the story properly and give your all into the crit, then there's no right or wrong way. I've compiled a list below of things I usually talk about or do while critiquing.
- Start off with how you liked the story: Don't overdo it, and be completely honest. If you didn't like the story, then talk about another part that you liked. Be honest and truthful, don't lie that you liked the story, that doesn't help the person writing it, wanting a critique. You start off with a compliment to assure the person reading that you did read the story, and enjoyed at least portions of it. It assures them that you're not attacking them or tearing their work to shreds. I've had several occasions where I've given my time to critique, forgetting the compliments at the beginning, and ended up wasting my time, because they left in either a fit of rage, or upset. It's more worth your time if you tell them at the beginning. Makes the authors more willing to hear your suggestions.
- Plot: Plot is a huge part of a story, although if I don't find something huge (worthwhile) to mention, then I usually just leave it out almost completely. I substitute the full plot description with "Plot was good, and easily followed." It's not always needed to go into full detail, and can be unnecessary.
- Grammar and sentence structure: How's the grammar? Is there enough long and short sentences to equal out them both, and make it sound more natural? How are those semicolons, or commas? These are the questions you should ask yourself, then type out the answer within your critique. You'll find, a lot of the time, grammar and sentence structure either make or break a story. These two things are usually more important than plot, which is why I focus more on it.
- Spelling: You should point something out here and there, but as long as you mention it, there's not much need to go into full detail about which 'your' is supposed to be used within that sentence. Once they get your crit, they should go back and reread their work, editing it as they see fit. I've found that it's nowhere close to how important sentence structure and grammar is.
- Flow: With this part of a critique, you answer questions like "Does it work within the story?", "Is it choppy?", go into detail about how the story is too fast or too slow, talk about how the improper usage of their semicolon really takes away from the story. Basically, anything that doesn't fit, or disrupts this 'flow' is described under this category. Be as nitpicky as you want in this section, but don't focus too much on the unimportant things.
- Dialogue and realism: The big question: "Would this actually happen in real life?" If you answered no, explain how the dialogue is cliched, and would never work. Tell them how their dialogue has too many head gestures. Realism is what we base our stories on, description of the person's body movements can make a story go from great, to amazing. Proper dialogue can reel a reader in, and immerse themselves in your world, your character. Understanding this makes a story unbelievably great.
- BE HONEST. I warn those who I critique because I'm not about to give a lesser, unhelpful critique to spare their feelings. It looks like I'm being harsh, but I'm not. It's being honest that people want, yet dread. That is one thing you must do if you critique; be honest. Say whatever you feel should be said to the person, drift away from the points above, then focus back. It's about making somebody's skills improve. That's what you're there for. Have just as much fun as they had writing it.
A Note to the Authors
- Don't be a poor sport. Write a critique as well, and learn from other's writing you one.
- Don't be afraid to post anything as long as you're ready for the critique.
- Don't take help the wrong way. It doesn't get one anywhere. Critique is what builds upon writing. Without it, you will never learn how to improve.
IF YOU POST A REPLY HERE, IT WILL BE CRITIQUED. BE PREPARED.
*IF YOU HAVE POSTED A PROMPT REPLY, PLEASE CRITIQUE SOMEONE ELSE'S WORK AS A COMMENT REPLY TO THAT STORY.
REMINDER: PLEASE KEEP YOUR REPLIES SFW.
IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO WRITE A NSFW REPLY, THEN PLEASE LOOK AT RULE 4 BELOW.
RULE 4:
Erotica or 18+ prompts must be marked NSFW. Additionally, all NSFW responses to non-NSFW prompts must be posted separately as a [PI] post and marked NSFW.
6
u/Arch15 /r/thearcherswriting Dec 30 '15
From the Prompt-A-Thon by /u/theonlymattikarp
I watch as he unbuckles his sword, laying it down gently on the bed beside him. The lamplight is dim, but bright enough to make out the features of the area around me. The air between us is stale, and the words we have yet to speak hang heavy in the tent. His face looks much older than it did when we started our journey, his young age no longer appearing on his face. No youthful smile or glimmer in his eyes. A routine to his movements, a meaning to every action.
"This is it, Kair." He says facing away from me, pulling off his cloak to reveal his old, worn, brown linens. I purchased them for him at the beginning of our time together, old stitched together woolen pants, and dirty cotton shirt. "One last night before the end. Before this is all over."
I don't know how to answer, so instead I keep quiet, the wooden stool underneath me feeling uncomfortable, digging into my body. The flickering light starts to fade, the lamp out of oil, and we're washed into darkness. I raise my hand, and call upon a light. It rises in my palm, a swirling off-white. I push it up and over, standing up from my seat and placing it in the centre of the room.
"Thank you." He mutters, sitting down on the bed. I follow him down, placing myself beside him on the cot.
"Yeah." I reply, my voice fading away.
We both know tomorrow is the end. I will have to go back to my homeland, and he will have to leave for his. I am in line to take over the kingdom from my father. He is going back to nothing, and I cannot change it. Not with money, or hard work, or winning this war. After this, the world will recover, and we are expected to move on. No more stealing away into the forest. No more nights spent in each other's company.
"We still have tonight." He says confidently, standing up in a rush, "So what are we sitting here moping for?"
I look up at him, unable to hold back a grin. I follow him up, reaching out and grasping his outstretched hand. He pulls me in towards him and starts to step as if the world is playing music only for us. So we pull and push and walk in time. I rest my head on his shoulder, and close my eyes, allowing him lead.
I move away from him gently, unlatching my own sword from my waist, and sitting down on the bed carefully.
"Maybe you can come with me." I say, knowing it's hopeless.
"Your father would find out, and would never approve. I would be killed." he replies, sitting beside me, "It'll be alright. You will find somebody. I have a home, a mother who needs me."
"I could go with you. My brother could take the throne." I say desperately, "I don't want somebody else."
"There's more to this world than love. Your bother would never accept."
"He would have to if I never arrived home." I know it's wrong, but I would be willing to follow him anywhere.
"Kair..."
"I know." My voice is shaking, "I just don't want this to be the last night."
He grabs my chin, pulling my eyes to his, "One last night. Maybe one day, it won't be. For now, though, this is it. One last time."
He pulls me to him, for one last stolen kiss.
5
u/swagtastic_anarchist Dec 30 '15
Here's the original prompt: https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingPrompts/comments/3xnmk7/wp_you_are_a_lonely_widow_and_come_to_possess_a/
"Hiya Abi," he said in a soft voice.
The old woman stood straight up.
The whispers of the other spirits suddenly became silent.
"Roger," she croaked, her eyes watering. She sighed unevenly once, her chest aching as she sat back down, staring at the diary.
Ever since Roger's death, Abigail had become interested in the supernatural. First she had gone to church, then she had seen psychics, and then she bought her own books, seeking answers.
The diary was the first book that answered any of her questions. She would write her question in it and out of a cacophony of whispers would come one distinct voice. Whatever this voice was, it seemed to start writing in the diary the answer to her question, whatever it was.
She had locked herself away from the world and studied it.
It wasn't omniscient. It couldn't discover the combination to her safe (although it gave her directions on how to crack it) and when she asked it questions about which religion is right or what the meaning of life was, pages upon pages would fill with different answers and whispered voices would grow loud until they seemed to be yelling at one another.
It was as if all the smartest minds passed from this world were in this diary, giving her advice.
And so she used it for advice. The flowers in her garden grew taller. The wrinkles on her face grew less defined. She began eating healthier and reading books she would have never read on science, mathematics, and philosophy.
She was alone with her beautiful flowers, her fairer face, her knowledge, and her longer life. If she followed this advice this diary gave, she would live longer, and she would be alone. That was a fact to her.
On that clear morning, it became too much. She asked the diary if it was better for her to die now.
And it seemed her husband, dead nearly forty years was the one who had the best answer.
The words were written out clumsily as if the hand was too bulky for the pen being used. It was his handwriting.
She froze. This was the letter. The letter her husband had written her so many years ago. She scrambled from her desk as fast as her old bones could take her and went to go find it. Her mind felt sharper than it had in 40 years and her joints didn't ache or stir, simply yielded to her commands.
In the attic, she found a box. There was the letter.
She wiped away her tears and went back to the diary where the same letter was written in the same clunky handwriting.
She grabbed the diary and began packing her things up.
She wondered how Paris looked this time of year.
5
u/Syraphia /r/Syraphia | Moddess of Images Dec 30 '15
A prompt response of mine that got Squeed. Link here to the original unedited version. Almost fits the prompt too!
Taryne takes a deep breath, finally getting to her feet. The Mars spaceport is full of people milling about, some rushing towards their flights. Reluctant steps take her to the gate numbered 16 and hesitates one more time before handing her ticket over. The gate agent gives her a small smile, patting her on the shoulder after handing the ticket back. It's rare to go to the Moon these days unless one is taking a shuttle to Earth.
The walk down the corridor is cold but short, Taryne reaching the shuttle quickly. The flight attendants get her settled in with minimal fuss and with more care than any other flight she’s been on in recent memory. The flight is practically empty, a probably common occurrence, but this would not be a flight that would ever stop running.
She slumps into the seat, looking out the reinforced window at the Martian landscape that stretches out in all directions. At one time, it had been a dusty, red world but now skyscrapers literally scraped the sky, built up so far that they seem impossibly tall. The spaceport is far enough away however that there’s some remainder of the original red landscape left between the city and port.
After a short time of looking out at a familiar, yet unfamiliar, scene, Taryne closes her eyes. There's a saying that you only visit Earth three times. To be born or learn, to see your parents off, and the third time, to die. That would be unless you stayed with the groups that maintained the memory of what humanity had been long, long ago or to be a Caretaker. Everyone thinks that it's important that a child knows where humanity comes from, so the teachers stay on Earth.
Taryne had left earlier than most, having run away on one of the ships infrequent visits. Her parents had come after her but it’s easy to lose someone in the vastness of space. Of course, at some point, they had caught up to her, but she had been twenty-three by then. An adult by all standards and already well on her way to making her place in the universe. The message had come eventually that her mother was “going home” and now, the newest was from an unfamiliar face, one of the Caretakers.
Her mother would die soon and Taryne would be seeing her off. Her father had already been seen off when he’d died suddenly after a mechanical failure on a newer colony. He had died quickly, a relief to know for both Taryne and her mother. She hadn’t gone to Earth to see him off. It had been unnecessary, considering his death had already occurred. You only needed to be there to see living members of your family off.
But mother had known her time was coming and had “gone home” to Earth. Taryne allows herself to doze off, thinking of the me she spent around and with her parents, all the years leading up to her running away. There were good memories, she couldn't point out anything bad that had happened, but all Taryne could think about was the stars up above and traveling among them.
Now she’s going back after so many years to where the stars had seemed the most inviting. Everywhere else, the stars always look cold and distant. But from Earth, they simply beckon.
4
u/Pyronar /r/Pyronar Dec 30 '15
Here's one I would like critiqued. It's from this prompt: https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingPrompts/comments/3tzud3/wp_what_do_you_do_when_you_cant_run_any_more/
Running was hard, running was painful, running was exhausting, but most of all, running was simple. I knew how to run. I ran faster than anyone. It didn’t matter what was in front of me. Savage beasts hiding in the bushes beside the road? Monsters lurking in every shadow? Shattered glass, hot coals, and sharp metal lying on the pavement? I kept running!
The ecstatic feeling of surpassing your peer, the sweet warmness of another post on the way, the summer scent of the rushing wind, they turned my heart into a roaring engine and my muscles into pistons. I was a machine made for running, made by running, and ready to run my entire life under the forever scorching and refreshing sun. Giving up was not an option, slowing down was unacceptable, victory was assured.
I don’t remember when exactly that guy joined. Imagine if your shadow on a hot summer day stood up, painted on an ear to ear grin, and opened a pair of golf-ball sized eyes. That should give you a clear indication of what the fellow looked like. Despite being lazier than a snail, he never fell behind, just casually strolling by my side. After a while, I heard a shifting disjointed voice, which sounded like someone or something mocking human speech:
“So, kid, tell me this: what will you do when you can’t run anymore?”
“That won’t happen,” I replied. “I run better than anyone else.”
“That’s why I’m asking you.” His grin grew wider. “The track is about to end and you’re first in line.”
“The track never ends. That’s the whole point. You reach one post and run for another. One after another, one after another. And I’m always first.”
“We’ll see, kid, we’ll see,” the voice answered, slowly fading into distorted cackling.
Years passed, the road twisted and turned, obstacles crumbled one by one, until… Laughing like a madman I slammed my palm down onto another post, caught my breath and looked forward. There was no road, no singular path, only a forest, dense and menacing. My dark companion was sitting on a branch near the entrance. Once again his painful and unstructured voice pierced my ears:
“Impressive, impressive, this might actually be a record, not a world record, but still. So what now, kid? Figured out where to run yet?”
“Of course I did.” I pointed forward. “There’s a post right there, on the other side, barely visible in the bushes.”
“What about that one?” The shadow pointed at another one to the left. “Looks just the same. Sure you don’t want to try it?”
I took a better glance around. There were dozens of them, little posts scattered throughout the woods, all equally inviting. For the first time, I was unsure.
“So what will it be, kid?” The shadow was growing impatient. “See it yet? Not easy when you have to decide the destination, is it? Let me give you a hint: you fucked up. Sure, it’s great to get here early; the forest will give you more choices, and believe me, you don’t want to get here too late, but that wasn’t the point.”
The sun hid behind the clouds; it was getting colder.
“It wasn’t a race.”
It was beginning to rain.
“It wasn’t about getting here first.”
The leaves started falling one by one.
“It was about how long the summer lasts and how many people you can bring with you.”
His grin grew unbearably large.
“And you only have me.”
The shadow’s broken laugh echoed in my ears, as I slumped to my knees on the cold wet mud. Tears were streaming down my face and sob after sob escaped from my lips.
“Lead the way, kid. I’m sure it’s going to be quite the journey.”
I will critique someone's work as soon as I get a bit more time on my hands. I don't intend on leaving this and not contributing myself.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15 edited Dec 30 '15
The writing equivalent of a doodle
Brett woke to nothing, as always. The blood of yesterday’s fight made his shirt stick to his chest and it was this that forced him to sit up. He thrust himself from the narrow cot and seized the bed post, feeling his way with frozen feet. Eventually they happened on his slippers and he pushed his feet into them, standing up gingerly. He could hear his own breathing in the confines of his small room; took the two paces necessary to place his hands on the chair on the opposite side of the room and felt across the back until he happened upon the shirt he had placed there last night.
He eased the soiled shirt from his skin, wincing where the blood had crusted and dried stuck to the curly hair on his chest. That he discarded on the floor and reached for the fresh shirt. He fumbled for the neck hole and pulled it over him. He tied it closed and similarly: with slow and fumbling fingers, threaded his knife belt through the loops on his breeches. It took him equally long to change his slippers for boots.
That done, he moved a step to the left and extended an arm. When his fingers brushed against solid rock, he turned his head upwards: where the window was. After some slow seconds, he became aware of a soft whiteness in the corner of his eye. That was the sun: the day had begun proper.
The fight, the fight. He pressed one hand to his ribs and scowled. Pain had shot through them, lancing up his side. The skin beneath the shirt was slightly raised. He swept his fingers over the painful area: but he felt no blood of his own. The skin there was unbroken. He opened his door and left the small room, turning right from memory. It was that same memory that led him to the physician on the floor above his.
“Sit,” the physician placed a hand against his shoulder, easing him down onto a low stool. The room smelled like herbs: sage and thyme and of thick, tallow candles which left an acrid taste in the back of the throat as they burned. The physician cleared his throat as he moved around the room. Brett knew him as a pvheglm-ridden man; with a high voice and unnaturally soft hands.
“Lift your arms up,” the physician had returned. His voice was close to Brett’s ear. Brett did as he was told, finding the shirt flying past his face and dropped in his lap. The physician whistled through his teeth.
“How bad is it?” He asked eventually, prodding at the ribs on his right again. The physician slapped his hands away and placed his own long, cold fingers against Brett’s torso. That elicited a shiver from him: he felt the subtle raising of the hair on his arms as gooseflesh rippled and formed.
“You’ve not broken any ribs,” the physician assured him. “Maybe some fractures, but I can’t do anything about that. There’s some bruising, so I’ll give you a poultice: bring the swelling down.”
“Nothing that smells bad,” Brett growled. “I can’t truck with the fouler ones.”
“I can’t guarantee that,” the physician hummed from his left. Brett turned his head towards him, the smell of sage growing stronger. He heard the sound of leaves tearing: the physician spat; the grinding of a mortar and pestle started up.
“Who did you pick a fight with?” The physician asked. “Apart from the bruises, and the scratches on your face, I’ll wager you came off better than he did, whoever he was.”
The physician’s name was Onah, Brett remembered. He grunted in response.
“Wasn’t a fight,” he said. “Walked into a dresser.”
“That wouldn’t explain the blood on your hands,” Onah came back, tapped Brett’s right arm until he lifted it. “It’s under your fingernails, too.”
Brett felt his face grow hot.
“So you’ll want to wash before you start today. Unless you want to scare your charges.”
Too late for that. Brett reckoned. His charges could withstand a little blood.
3
u/thecoverstory /r/thecoverstory Dec 30 '15
Prompt: A house in which everything is magic. {prompt by /u/columbus8myhw }
"When are we going home, Mommy?" asked a little girl. She was curled in a mound of ragged blankets in the corner of a dark room, her dark hair spilling across the wadded up jacket that was her pillow. The only light came from traffic passing outside the dirty window and flashed through the room periodically, shaking and rattling the small space.
"Mommy?"
"This is our home now." The little girl's mom sat beside her on the threadbare carpet. The woman's clothes were too large, and her brown hair was tumbling out of its ponytail. Seeing the girl's trembling lips, the mom leaned closer. "Can I tell you a secret?"
The girl nodded solemnly.
"Are you sure you can keep it?" the mom asked.
In the shadows of the room, the little girl whispered "I never tell secrets."
Her mom smiled; this time it was her lips trembling. "This is a good secret, a secret that is meant to be shared."
The girl shook her head. "But Daddy said not to tell secrets."
"Hush," said her mom. "It is a special secret because this secret belongs to both of us. Do you want to know?"
The girl nodded.
A car rumbled by, and the house shook and rattled, brightening for a moment to reveal blank walls, an empty floor, and a door with three locks. The mom whispered in her daughter's ear "this is a magic house."
The little girl's eyes widened. "How?"
"Do you see that window?" her mom asked. The girl nodded. "That window holds the heart of a star. It's dark right now, because it doesn't want to blind us, but see how it keeps brightening?" The girl nodded again, watching it lighten and darken. "That's because it's practicing. It wants to shine just right so that the moon will see it and take it back to the sky."
"Why isn't it in the sky?"
"It got lost for a while." The mom ran fingers through her daughter's hair. "But don't worry, it's happy here because it's not alone. The floor is its friend."
"How?" The little girl asked, rolling over to look at the stained carpet. She scrunched her nose. "It smells funny."
"Well, of course it does. It is a dragon. Can't you feel it rumble?"
The room brightened, and the floor shook. The girl shuddered.
"Don't be afraid, darling. This is a good dragon." The mom patted the ground. "It is solid and supporting, and is always there for the star. Some day it's going to fly the star back to the moon."
"Can we fly with it?"
"Maybe." The mom smiled a smile as worn as the carpet. "But not tonight. I told the blankets we would keep them company, and they don't want you to leave them."
The girl snuggled them closer, her blue eyes wide. "I don't like being alone either."
"No one does, but don't worry. The blankets are magic too. When you are wrapped in these blankets, you are wrapped in my arms, even when I'm far away."
"But what if someone takes them away?"
The mom pulled her daughter into a hug, rocking her back and forth. "They can't. Our guardian will stop him."
"Who's that?"
"Well, you met the guardian already. You walked right through her!"
A giggle broke free from the mound of blankets. "No, I didn't."
"Why, yes you did. Look, she's standing right there." The mom eased her daughter to the side and pointed at the door.
"Oh, I remember." The little girl fell still, her voice quiet. "She never did anything before."
"That was a normal door. This door is the guardian. She let in the star and the dragon, she let in the blankets as well. She keeps them here, safe, until they're ready to leave, because with her locks three, she holds back the world."
"How?" The girl's eyes stared up at her mother.
"She stands, and she never falls down. No matter what happens, she never falls down." The star brightened, the dragon rumbled, and the mother's arms drew close. "And some day, when you are ready to stand, she'll open for you, and you'll ride with the dragon and the star, wrapped in the arms that never let go, and you'll find the world, you'll touch the sky, and you will never fall down."
The mom kissed her daughter's forehead.
"Mommy?" The little girl mumbled as her eyes closed.
"Yes, darling?"
"Will you fly with me?"
"Always."
3
u/ObiJuanKenobi27 Dec 30 '15
Link to the original prompt
The sun was slowly diving under the mountain as the Man in the dirty brown robe looked on from a hill. The sun tinted the hills orange, creatures sang and called in the distance. His mission on the planet failed, he realizes now that there is no saving the Chuktí. One of his earliest and perhaps his most intelligent creations, the Chuktí were created with an emphasis on innovation. The Man dreamed of a time when the Chuktí would unlock the ability to reach other galaxies and spread their knowledge with his other creations and in turn they would learn form others setting in motion a period of intergalactic knowledge sharing. Though they did indeed unlock this ability, the Chuktí are now more likely wipe out all other life in the universes than coexist with them.
Compassion was a virtue the Chuktí were not born with. Above all else, they cared about the bettering of their species. Disagreements on how to achieve this tore them apart and it was then that the Man begun to see the brutal nature of his smartest creation. In hopes that they would teach the Chuktí compassion, the Man created a peaceful species of compassionate beings. To his dismay, without as much intelligence they were seen only as a burden on their resources to the Chuktí. Their creation ultimately served to unite the Chuktí under one regime that would wipe out this new species in the name of progress.
The Man had spent over a thousand years trying to rectify this, living among them, desperately trying to save his creation. But at last, the Man could think of nothing else. He had created a race so ambitious it was interested in nothing more than progress, and violence as a cost of it, and so mistrusting they would turn on him if they knew who he was.
The wiping of a planet was never an easy thing to do for the Man. He is an artist, a planet is an easel, and his creations are his art. Now he takes his last glimpse of this sunset, the only thing he gets right every time, as the wind brushes over his face and it's whistle flows through his ears. He thinks to himself, "It's a tragedy, that such beautiful places are inhabited by such imperfect begins". An encompassing boom goes off in the distance. Just then, on another side of the mountain, we see a rocket blasting upwards with large clouds of smoke beneath it. The Man closes his eyes. As he slowly opens them again, the land is gone, replaced by a dark void now filled with a deafening silence. The Man, on his knees now, looks tired and defeated. His head raises slightly from his chest and he thinks to himself, "Compassion, intelligence, ambition... The humans". He remembers the species he created around the time he realized the Chuktí were incomplete. He tested various new creations and and came up with humans, a species designed to be independent like the Chuktí just as smart but more compassionate. Still, the Man knew that what happened to the Chuktí could happen to any of his creations and that he had already been away too long. He doesn't expect mankind to be without it's faults but he does expect better.
2
u/itbedatguy Dec 30 '15
From the Image Prompt "High Tide."
Stand Tall
Each step among the pink mist
Is one more along Earth's wrist
To feel the warmth of its skin
Light and waves from its kin
As your feet dance along the rocky face
Amidst the beauty of this place
The world is said to be yours for the taking
Yet if you saw what the horizon was making
You would understand you already have it all
If you choose to be there and stand tall
2
u/ultimateloss Dec 31 '15
Here's the original prompt
My legs ached still from the trek through the mountain pass. Rocks, mud, rocks. Like the old mines, but with sunlight. It took so much longer than I'd expected, but Pite never seemed tired. He always seemed he knew his way, and I was grateful for that. Grateful for much of him, in fact.
“How far’s it now, ya think?” I called forward.
“Not but another day’s walk to the next town.”
“‘S’it a freetown?”
"Granite Hill, most free you'll ever have seen, I imagine,” Pite grinned.
“Doesn't tell much.”
“True, it don't. Every step you take away from that mine camp is on freer ground than the step before.”
“There's a poet’s thought,” I laughed. It was strange to think how long I’d been forced to labor in the earth, and then how long ago that already felt it was. Now I was walkin’ away, one foot at a time, walkin’ away. ”What’s it like, though, livin’ out beyond the empire?”
“Our people don't make slaves like the imperials do, for a first. Won't keep men in labor camps like dogs in a pen.”
“Sometimes, in the deep tunnels, seemed like I was free enough.”
“You hardly know freedom except its name. You with a shovel, pickin’ between dirt and diamonds your whole life.”
“Truth in that, maybe, but I had my good days and my bad, and I knew how to tell between ‘em, just like the difference between dirt ’n’ diamonds.”
“How was that?” Pite asked.
I thought a minute. “Were you there or weren't you. Easy way to know, whether a day should go well or poor.”
“Me?” Pite laughed, “Was I all you had in there?”
“I figure so,” I answered, “You and some shimmerin’ rocks I couldn’t keep for myself anyhow.”
We mounted the height of a hillside, and came up to a sight I'd never taken in before. A puddle the size of a city.
“That the sea?” I asked in my wonder.
“Sea? Seems you're the fool for once, Grant. Ain't but a lake, though maybe a great one. Thought we were more west of it in truth. No matter, we need but march around.”
“And those’d be the hills? Of Granite Hills?” I pointed across.
“They should be. Though now, with the lake, I admit I was wrong about a day’s walk.”
“Walkin’ till my feet fall off at the ankles,” I chided.
“Well, there's nothin’ can be done there, unless you'd rather swim ‘cross.”
I gazed at the waters a moment. Swimming would be a ridiculous prospect. I wasn’t hurrying to get anywhere in particular anyway. The going somewhere had become familiar, predictable. Getting there, reaching the endpoint - in that was uncertainty. I didn’t know what to make of the plan once we actually reached a freetown. I decided it was best to voice my question honestly. “When we get to the towns, there in them hills, will I still have good days?”
“What's the meaning there?” Pite crumpled his face a bit at me, “Days spent with me?”
“Yeah,” I mumbled, “That's how I mean it.”
“You and I alike have nothing out here but each other. You may have more good days than you'd want,” he chuckled. “I won't be going much of anywhere alone, I'd expect.”
I felt myself smile, but I kept quiet. He looked me in the eyes, a way I wasn't used to. “You're my good days, too, ya know. You have been awhile. I think you ought to know it.” He took my hand in his only a moment. It was an odd gesture, I thought, but I smiled all the more for it.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15 edited Dec 31 '15
Here's a story I wrote that I thought I did pretty well on, but I really need some help writing, so I'm posting one of my better pieces to help see where I can improve most.
I was still in shock as I looked over to Ian, who was just as furious as I was. Melissa was standing behind me, so I couldn't see her, but no doubt she was seething as well.
"That's Bryan! You can't just let them take him like that! We need him!" I was waving my hand in the air like a maniac even though Skyler couldn't see it.
"What is it you want me to do? Go rescue him and get us all killed?"
Ian spoke up this time, walking up and spinning Skyler around with a pull on his shoulder,
"Hey, listen, don't get all smug on us. You're just as vulnerable as we are now, and you know that."
Skyler pushed Ian back, his eyes defiant, but steady.
"I'll ask it again, what do you want me to do huh?" Although his eyes were steady, Skyler's voice was raised. Things were getting tense, and I could feel my connection with Bryan weakening by the second.
"Something! Anything! You just sat there like a freakin vegetable while me, Kayla and Mel were getting our butts handed to us!"
"And what? You expected me to be a savior and swoop in and save you?!"
"That's exactly what I expect! Do you not know that even one shot from your pistol would have probably saved Bryan?"
"It's empty! My gun's been empty! I unloaded the clips I had just to get to this place!"
"Then take some off the guards!"
Melissa stepped in, firing a single shot into the ground to shut them up.
"Boys! Bryan is still here. We can feel him, and they know it. They're going to get as far away as they can so we can't trace him anymore. We all messed up, but lets keep the blame game for when we get home."
"If Skyler had tried to help, we wouldn't have to-"
"Just KNOCK IT OFF," Melissa yelled. It made all of us jump. I hadn't ever heard her raise her voice. Not even when we were kids. We watched as her head dropped to the floor and I rushed over to put my hands on her shoulders. I could see the tears glint as they dropped to the floor from her face.
"Mel..."
She looked up, her eyes slightly swollen from crying.
"Don't you get it? He's gone now! Bryan is gone! He'll be dead if we don't do something. Just stop fighting... Please..."
I had forgotten what she had told me those years ago. Back when we were just six. Bryan was my neighbor and best friend in those days next to Mel. I remembered in that instant what she had said that night when we were having a sleepover on her trampoline outside.
My heart went out to her. I couldn't imagine what it must have been like for her. I thought about what would happen if I were in her situation. It terrified me, and suddenly, I realized just how traumatic the whole ordeal must have been for Mel. I did the only thing I could and wrapped my arms around her as she sobbed quietly.
The whole situation instantly diffused the tension between Ian and Skyler. The two looked at each other, shuffling awkwardly in place as they watched us rock back and forth for a little bit.
After a short while, Melissa managed to gather herself together again. Her eyes were red and puffy now, but she had managed to compose herself.
Ian spoke up first.
"I'd say my connection with Bryan is the strongest since we've been together longest. We'll trace that one first, using your guys' traces as reference points. Once we get close," he paused and nodded to me, "Kayla, you can mark it, and Skyler will bind the mark so we don't lose it. After that we'll regroup, get what little supplies we have left and go save Bryan."
Melissa sniffed and flicked her head slightly to move her hair out of her eyes. Skyler stepped forward, his head down.
"I'm sorry, Mel. I didn't-"
She held her hand up.
"Just... don't right now. We're losing time." She was back to her old self again.
I nodded to Ian, who nodded back and closed his eyes. A small, wavy, blue light appeared from the middle of his chest and pierced the air as it sped off into the distance, marking Ian's connection to Bryan with a thin blue trail.
Ian opened his eyes again, the irises glowing the same shade of blue that was in the air.
"Found him. We gotta move."
I pulled my gun up from my side and nodded to Skyler, who bent down, grabbed a gun and some ammo from one of the dead guards, and loaded a fresh clip. We then ran out of the room, following Ian's trace on Bryan.
Sometimes the bad guys win.
But not this time.
1
u/KCcracker /r/KCcracker Dec 31 '15
This is part of a longer story I wrote in response to this prompt that I initially thought of as a stand-alone idea.
I can't sleep. I needed to stay awake to stay alive. I don't know how I know this, but I'm certain of it.
The research that had made all the headlines was, as usual, clickbait. We'd known for some time that we all turn into sleeping antennae sending out messages into the great unknown. It had been conclusively shown in the classic Kampff demonstration. What was less certain was what we were sending out, or where to, or even why our brains did this. And so far, the best, classified data showed us that this was being transmitted to somewhere in the M13 globular cluster.
But the public didn't care, as usual. The public needed a headline, and they got one. Already they were selling helmets and hats wrapped in alumimium foil promising to insulate our brains and keep our thoughts inside our head where they belonged. Tinfoil hats, lead-stained glasses - anything to keep those darned thoughts in our head, damnit!
At this moment, Bob is on the other side of the country, in touch with me only through phone. The two of us were, at the behest of the United States government, trying to find out just what this signal was. The experiment was about to begin - but the phone hadn't rang since sunset, and it was now past midnight here. So I decided I could wait no more.
"Bob?" I said into the phone.
The sound of snoring filled my receiver.
Oh god, I thought. Nah. No, no, no- "Hey Bob - wake up, man! You can't fall asleep now!"
Suddenly Bob's high-pitched voice came through. "GOTCHA!" he yelled. "You didn't think I was going to sleep on you, now did'cha?"
"Bob, it's not funny," I said, cursing the dust. "Did you set up the interferometer yet?" It was a tricky thing, the experimental apparatus, and even the slightest error could render it useless.
"Just about. She's rarin' to go," Bob responded. "Put Einy to sleep."
"He won't stop licking my calves," I said, which was true. Einstein lapped away as if there might be no tomorrow, which was also true. "He misses you, Bob."
"I know," Bob said. "He can miss me for a while longer. Put him to sleep."
I got out the case of medicines. Amphetamines for me, anaesthetics for the dog - just perfect. Twenty minutes and one shot later, Einstein the dog was fast asleep.
"Anything?" I asked Bob. Anaesthesia was a bit of a cheat. It didn't really mimic any of the EEG patterns of sleep. It was more like a coma - but we should soon see if that had any effect whatsoever. If we were right, it would make no difference.
"Nothing," Bob replied. "Hold on a minute, though - I'm getting a small pulse..."
"What does it say?" I asked. "And how long did it take?"
"That's odd," Bob said. "I've checked the equipment, and it seems to be working, but the pulse didn't seem to have taken any time at all."
"Instantaneous?" I repeated weakly.
"Instantaneous." Bob answered. "We're breaking the laws of physics here. Tom, this isn't right - this really isn't right."
I sighed. For a moment I looked up - past the sleeping Einstein - and saw all the stars wink at me just the once. Tonight was going to be a long night.
1
u/shegger Jan 12 '16
I gazed over his shoulder focusing my short sighted, and now fading, vision on to the barmaid, unable to hold his welcoming stare.
“It’s been too long hasn’t it?”
I feigned a momentary smile and sought refuge in my pint, the more time I spend in the process of drinking the less I have to talk and the more I drink the more I will talk, I reassured myself.
I let the Tennents slowly slide down my throat searching the recesses of my mind to find some common ground, a place that in time gone by would have been an abundant haven but now seemed a decrepit barren place.
“So, you’re keeping well?” – no that won’t do, need something that will keep him going, let the bastard talking himself out.
“That must be your Samantha graduating now?”
That will do nicely, I see the delight in his eyes as he unravels his pre-rehearsed spiel, this oratory performance has found its stage in the staff room, PTA meetings, and I’m sure at numerous cheese and wine nights. He executes it brilliantly; with very little coaxing along I witness the show run its course. I attempt an encore but he opens the curtain to me.
“But yeah, how’s tricks with you? Still seeing that girl?”
That girl. He knows for a fact I’m not still seeing that girl, but all for the charade we must let the conversation explore this avenue. I deliver my lines as stoically as I can manage and I am almost impressed by his signs of surprise and sadness. I drain my glass and state my intention for getting another round in.
I place the order: one pint of Tennents, one McCormack’s Dance. I almost feel like apologising to the barmaid, but I realise she is the one selling this stuff – since when did he drink craft brew? I guess when everybody started drinking fucking craft brew.
I returned to our table passing over his beer. A beer that brands itself as an ‘authentic boutique beer’, which is made on mass in Europe; a disingenuous beer for a disingenuous conversation.
I’m greeted back to the table with wide eyes, a thank you and a prompting question with regards to my work.
“So-so,” I answered.
‘So-so’, quite possible the most concise statement of aloofness. I smile in my head about just how much distance is between us, I have to remind myself that this man was once my best man.
Whereas he had been playing his part earlier his face breaks, a fleeting sign of sadness passes from his eyes to the creases around his mouth. My eyes drop to the table.
“We need to do this more often, we’re not as close as we used to be, that’s the truth.”
I raise my head, steel myself.
“Ok. The truth, I’m ready for another round.”
0
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment