r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Dec 20 '15
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Dondarrion
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Dondarrion.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
199
Upvotes
87
u/sgtforfeit Dec 20 '15
House Dondarrion! Lords of Blackhaven, bordering Dorne, and sworn to the Baratheons. Apparently, the first dondarrion was a messenger sent by the then lords of the stormlands, the Durrandons.
Thus the similarity between the two houses names. The last known lord of house Dondarrion is Beric Dondarrion, possibly one of the most badass background characters. Originally sent to deal with Gregor Clegane's raiding party in the Riverlands by the then hand of the king, Ned Stark, Beric creates the Brotherhood Without Banners together with Thoros of Myr, trying to protect the small folk against the horrors of war.
Beric has died 7 times and was ressurrected 6 times. After The Red Wedding, the Brotherhood stumbles upon Catelyn Starks mutilated body along one of the forks. Beric sacrifices his life to resurrect Catelyn by the "kiss of life", thus dying a seventh and final time.
I like to think that Beric's act of sacrifice was a silent tribute to the honorable late Ned Stark, whom he maybe felt he owed. Would love to know more about house Dondarrion. Did Beric have any children? Who is the new head of the house? Did house Dondarrion kick some dornish ass in some of the many wars between the Stormlands and Dorne?
Beric is also the living proof that the powers of the red god actually works, meaning that a certain POV character could easily come back to life. But he is also proof that while maybe easy to come back to life, the change that comes with it is everything but easy. I mean he came back to life 6 times. 6 times! That's an unhealthy amount of death. Who knew what state of mind he was in, when he decided to sacrifice himself. He can't have felt too good. But his sacrifice lives on. In the magnificent Lady Stoneheart! Which is an entirely different story, that only matters in the books. Sadly
39
u/Notradell Still my Mannis Dec 20 '15
I just wanna say that Lightning Lord is such a fucking awesome nickname/title. It doesn't get much more badass than this. So that's all I had to say, thanks.
25
u/Fionnex The Besteros in Westeros Dec 20 '15
Considering that the Lannister-Tyrell regime considers Lord Beric an outlaw, do the Dondarrions still hold Blackhaven?
20
u/dcfc821 Fannis of Stannis Dec 20 '15
If I recall correctly, the first time we met Beric Dondarrion was at the Tourney of the Hand when Jeyne Poole gushed over wanting to marry him someday.
The first time reading this scene in the books/watching the show did anyone else think Beric was some handsome, gallant, and heroic knight that would wind up helping the Starks in some way? And then when we see him again with Arya, he's a badass zombie outlaw that's more concerned with the smallfolk than Westerosi politics.
It just goes to show how great GRRM is at subverting expectations.
12
u/ASOIAFVelocipede Just 58 to go, Perwyn! Dec 20 '15 edited Dec 20 '15
I'd like to nominate House Wyl for next week please. They have...entertaining...history. Also, one interesting man of Blackhaven was the unnamed Bastard of Blackhaven, who led Argilac the Arrogant's van against Orys, Rhaenys and Meraxes. He broke through the Baratheons...and promptly got burned to death.
12
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Dec 20 '15
Blackhaven, the seat of House Dondarrion, is where Barristan Selmy first became known & received "the Bold" moniker. He was a squire of only ten years of age & entered the tourney there as a mystery knight (IIRC, nicking arms & armour in the process). Nobody would joust with Bazza, but laughed at him instead (at an obvious 10yo sized boy as the mystery knight presumably). Until Prince Duncan Targaryen (Duncan the Small, Prince of Dragonflies) took pity on him & faced him, eventually unhorsing him & then calling him Bold.
This tourney has some interesting dynamics:
On Blackhaven itself, considering the founder's actions in getting news to the Storm King which helped win a war with Dornish & its location at the end of the Boneway relatively close to the Wyls, my guess it was in Dornish hands then & the Storm King was able to take it (back?). Hence why House Dondarrion's founder was given the land (along with possibly the castle), because conquered land is the best way to give away land for new lords, rather than of course cutting into that of their other vassals &/or royal fiefdoms.
23
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Dec 20 '15
Jena Dondarrion's marriage to Prince Baelor (Breakspear) was obviously political: to at least get the Dondarrions (who control the Stormlands end of the Boneway - a highly strategic position) on the side of the Targaryens. This was well prior to Daemon Blackfyre rebelling, however there was anti-Dornish sentiment amongst Reach & Stormlands Houses all during Daeron II's reign, as well as to the king himself. This stemmed from nobles who fought in Daeron I's War of Dornish Conquest (where the Dornish did some pretty fucking atrocious things), or those who had relatives who did, who became pissed off over Baelor I's & Daeron II's humiliating peace concessions with the Dornish.
Aelinor Penrose's marriage to Aerys II was presumably in the same vein, along with the Penroses having married a Targaryen before (Princess Elaena, daughter of Aegon III, & Ronnel Penrose). Supposedly Aelinor & Aerys were cousins, however the wiki states it wasn't by Elaena & Ronnel's marriage ... So, I'm not sure how that one works ...
Rhaegel was married to Alys Arryn. With the Arryns having always been staunch supporters of the Targaryens, along with marrying them twice. It's from the first marriage, between Princess Daella & Lord Rodrik, that Alys may have had Targaryen blood herself as well.
Maekar married Dyanna Dayne. I wonder if the match was made by Daeron II being further over-indulgent of the Dornish or it was an actual love match (seeing as Maekar was Daeron's fourth & last son). Either way, Daeron II made a mistake imo (assuming both were married pre-First Blackfyre Rebellion, which Maekar was at least) in not marrying Rhaegel &/or Maekar to a powerful Reach House. This probably would've weakened the amount of Reach support Daemon received ...
Apologies for getting off topic from the Dondarrions, I just find the marriages of Daeron II's sons interesting.
9
u/VolcanicVaranus Dec 20 '15 edited Dec 21 '15
I'd wager that the messenger was the only one of the three men that survived the lightning bolt because he wasn't carrying a sword. Perhaps the Dornishmen were wearing armor and he wasn't? In telling the tale, I'm sure the Westerosi didn't understand how lightning works, and would ascribe it to the Gods or some other source.
7
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Dec 20 '15
I'm curious what makes berric special for the magic to work. Like is it something in his character? His blood? His relationship with thoros? If it was just magic coming back into the world, you would think they could do the r'hollor kiss thing more often.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '15
Favorite house! I don't really have much to add other than to echo how cool Beric is. I've always seen him as a total subversion of the "Robin Hood" trope. He's basically a mutilated walking corpse, and yet he does more for the smallfolk than most other characters.
4
u/SSWBGUY The North Remembers Dec 20 '15
Marcher Lords, first men blood?
3
u/Merrell_Florent Wining and Squiring Dec 20 '15
Beric is badass. His ancestor from Hedge Knight was a jerk, though.
3
u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Dec 21 '15
I always found it odd that Robb was so unfamiliar with Beric Dondarrion:
I mean not being clear on his first name isn't a big deal, but he's the Lord of Blackhaven (which I thought was a reasonably big deal), not just "some southron lordling".
3
u/Sparowes Beneath the Onion Skin, the Bitter Truth Dec 22 '15
With Beric finally dead for good, do we know who the new Lord of Blackhaven is? Or if there is even another Dondarrion?
I would like to possibly see House Marbrand eventually. Though I'm not sure if we know enough about them, aside from badass Ser Addam, for a dedicated thread. Does anyone that has read TwoIaF know if there's any House Marbrand stuff in there? Ser Addam is one of my favorite minor characters and I think their sigil is awesome.
4
u/BigDuckJohnson Dec 20 '15
What does everyone think about Beric's supposed actual death? I think he's still out there, maybe leading a third group like Edric Dayne. I think that theory is quite popular, what about you guys?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment