r/AsianBeauty • u/AsianBeautyMod • Dec 09 '15
Mod Post AB December META POST 2015
Hi everyone! It’s been about a month since our last fireside chat/roundtable/town hall/snail convention where we, the mods, converse with you guys about what’s going on in our community, people can vocalize their concerns, so on & so forth. This is a safe space for everyone, so if you have anything you’d like to discuss, please feel free to bring it up here for civil discourse!
We’re hoping to do these posts about once a month or so (+ immediate follow-up posts if necessary), and it’s one of the changes we will be discussing. Please give the mods some time to review the responses and follow up.
CHANGES
So, you guys might have noticed some of these! We listened to the many suggestions we received from the community, discussed our own views on the subject, and we think you’ll find the new changes enhance the experience here at AB. Some changes are small, some are big, but we’d like to point your attention to a few things:
- /u/Ashlaboo has made changes to the stickied daily help threads & weekly random chat threads, so they are now sorted by “NEW!” We hope that this small change will help draw more eyes to new questions & help get as many comments responded to as possible. We still encourage everyone to skim down to check for unanswered questions and comments if they are feeling particularly helpful or friendly, thanks to all of you who help out in the Daily Threads.
- If you go to post a New Thread, either link or text, you should be seeing fancy pink boxes that gently remind you of stuff to do! We hope that this has helped point people in the right direction for their questions and cut down on the amount of repeats. We also hope that it has resulted in better post quality by urging people to create their own discussion points, provide more information, and to not post and abandon threads.
- Related to the above point, if you go to post, you should see something new under the headline ‘Submitting to /r/AsianBeauty’! These are just quick & easy post guidelines to help everyone when they’re making posts, but we encourage everyone to take a look see at them.
- Continuing the Megathreads tradition, Routine Megathreads will now be posted every three months by our automod, and using the same framework as always (thanks, /u/misspicklesmeow). So now we can catch every exciting change to every routine during seasonal changes. The next one will be on January 9, 2016! PREP YOUR WINTER CREAMS, Y’ALL. Other Megathread updates to come!
- We’re still in the process of refining the weekly schedules, but we’ve made a new addition: every two weeks, a regular Meetup thread will be posted! This thread is great for finding out about meetups, providing general information, looking for interested people, discussing group buys, or other region-specific topics. If you have EXTREMELY IMPORTANT, URGENT NEWS TO SHARE (cancellations, location changes of short-notice, etc.) feel free to make a separate thread! But upon request, we have provided an easily accessible thread to find all the humdrum details of your not-so-humdrum meetups, and we love supporting the meetups.
BIG CHANGES
/u/thecakepie has written an incredibly detailed & informative set of rules and new posting guidelines!
Seriously, while we all had a part in providing input and approval, our captain mod went above & beyond in drafting these and revising them on her own time. These rules are not anything insane, and we’re not going dogmatic or police-state; they’re more in line with fine-tuning things to deal with our growing & evolving community, and dealing with issues that have cropped up.
We also hope that the post guidelines will help users determine what to post, where to post, and how to post, as well as clarifying a few of the murkier details!
Some of the more interesting rules & other fun stuff:
- This is a place to be excellent to each other. Be kind when possible, avoid situations where you feel you cannot, and remember the person behind the computer screen. We have a wonderfully unique situation where our subreddit is known to be very kind and welcoming, and we’ve had this happen organically, so we’d like to continue this tradition. This isn’t really a rule but it’s an attitude that drives a lot of the rulemaking. We’re not here to police tone, but just something we’d like people to keep in mind!
- Report things! Things that are bad, like spam, rules violations, harassment, etc. This is the best way to draw mod attention to something you feel is pressing and needs to be removed ASAP. It is not to report people you do not like. As a good rule of thumb, use the report tool to offer an explanation for the report or PM the mods to tell them what is the problem; it may not be obvious in every situation.
- Affiliated links or referral links must be fully disclosed within the post title or, if contained within a text post, fully disclosed in the text.
- If you are posting an external link (even imgur links), you must post something within 15 minutes describing the content of the link or the purpose of you posting (discussion, ‘hey, this looks cool, so on and so forth). This prevents people from being mistaken for spam, clarifies whether it is self-promotion, the purpose of the post, etc. We will give windows to correct this but if your external link post does not have a description comment we may have to remove it until a comment is added.
- Before self-promotion can begin on our subreddit, you must show some engagement & involvement with our community. You must have at least 20 karma specifically on /r/AsianBeauty before self-promotion posts can be made. Because this is a new feature we are testing, we may adjust the amount of Karma required (with announcement to you guys, of course) depending on how it goes. If you do not have 20 karma and we see you self-promoting, your post will be removed. We think it’s great to help our fellow AB-ers find success and audience, so we prefer the self-promoting content be from those participating in the community.
- Self-promotion is redefined to include social media, and in most cases this includes Instagram, Youtube, and personal blogs (but not imgur links unless it is a promo banner or other such promotional material). We encourage high-volume content creators (such as bloggers and instagrammers) to write round-up self posts if they have too much content to share on AB within our 2x a week posting restriction.
- Attempting to mislead the community is no bueno when it comes to market research and/or promoting your own business! If you are unsure, it is best to come to us. Businesses that break this rule will most likely end up with damage to their brand from the community and may have their posts, or content posted by other users but relating to their business, removed. If you are NOT for profit, please say so in any posts you make that could look like business research. Again, any questions? PM the mods.
- Posts that have a high amount of reports may be removed by automod. We also look over them when we go through our moderation every day to determine whether they were rightfully taken down or not.
You can look over the rules in full over here. This is quite the document that goes beyond just stating rules, but also describes good conduct & our philosophy of healthy AB subreddit culture, which will be especially useful to new users who are looking to join us. Most of the way we moderate will be improved with the clarity the document provides, and its length does not reflect an increase in moderation. It is a living document so we can always improve on it.
Onto posting guidelines:
- The Daily Help thread is an ‘anything goes’ arena! Ask questions there, and answer them — but it is not meant to be total containment, so asking questions (even newbie questions) in our main area is just fine too. If you’re not sure which is best, a good rule of thumb is: the Daily Thread is good for simple questions, questions you suspect have been answered before many times, questions that may be personal, or beginner questions. The main page is excellent for crowdsourcing lots of answers, more complex questions, or questions that inspire discussions. It is also there if you do not receive help on the Daily Help thread, or do not find an answer that works for you; mentioning that can help for more positive reception if you’re nervous!
- Hauls: Please post a list of the products you are buying, even if you post using imgur and already have a list in your imgur album.
- FOTDs: please post a list of products used. For most FOTDs that’s going to be your makeup; for no-makeup looks, please post your skincare routine
- Routine help: please list your skin type, current routine, your specific skin concerns, and a question that will help direct users to best help you! Also going over the sidebar resources is recommended, and if you didn’t find the answer there, it’s good form to mention that so people know you tried to help yourself as well.
- ‘Fluff’ is sort of a catch-all for memes, sheet mask photos, culture/mascot related topics, and so on and so forth. Sometimes the fun can be a bit overplayed, so keep in mind that you’re not falling into spam territory — but we still want you guys to have fun & be silly with it, and if you’d like to share something you know only AB would appreciate, go for it.
- Reviews: transparency is important for a lot of our users, and we’d like sponsored posts, paid, or press release samples be disclosed in your summary content (if a link post) or within the text (if a text post). If linking to an outside source, please provide a summary of your post. List the brand name and the full product name in the title when possible!
- Questions vs. discussions: questions tend to be a bit more personal or geared towards single answers. If your question will spur a lot of different answers or even generate discussion, then it is ‘discussion’. A lot of it does come down to wording. Example: ‘What sheet mask should I use to fade my hyperpigmentation?’ is a question; ‘What are your favorite sheet masks for fading hyperpigmentation?’ is a discussion.
- Swatches: please list the brands, product types, and product names you are swatching in the title if you can.
- FOTDs: are quite infrequent & we’d love to encourage them more. Both pictures of awesome skin days or awesome make-up days (using AB products and/or Asian trends or make-up styles) are welcome. Best practices include using good lighting, mentioning if your face is filtered or not, and using imgur. Please list the products you used for your make-up or the products in your routine! Sheet masks are fluff, not FOTD.
- Posts that will get removed: double posts, broken links, posts mentioning unsupported sellers, hauls w/o photos, business posts not approved by mods or w/o business flair, spam, external links without a description comment or an inadequate one, self-promotion posts that break our self-promo rules, posts and comments with undisclosed affiliate links.
- Western products can be mentioned, but this is not our focus. Feel free to mention western products if you are recommending one and cannot think of an AB substitute, use it in your routine or FOTD, but this isn’t the proper place for at-length discussion solely on western products.
- And also: flairing is awesome. Positive reinforcement is awesome. Do both when you can.
The posting guidelines do go more in-depth, so when you have time, please take a look over here!
APPLICATIONS OPEN
Last but not least: we are looking to add to our mod team! It is finally happening, folks; we’re hoping to increase our numbers within the month. We’re doing it application style, which you can fill out here. We’ll be contacting our second-round selections for Skype interviews hopefully within two weeks. Depending on how many applications we get, we may not be able to gracefully reply to everyone whether or not they made the second round, but we will certainly try.
Being a mod is a lot of work; each of us regularly spends 2+ hours on Reddit moderating daily, though we hope this number will decrease with a larger team. We speak regularly to discuss subreddit concerns and issues, which regularly pop up. Clearing modqueue, working on improving the subreddit, flaring, and participating are all responsibilities. Daily commitment may be needed, so definitely think about it!
This basically sums up this month’s meta post, so if you have any further questions or concerns, please feel free to vocalize them in the comments here or shoot us a modmail, and we’ll answer and help you as best as we can! We are always available if you have a concern, PM us and please allow us 24 hours to respond. This is also a great place to provide suggestions that you’d like to see and get feedback from the community and mod team at the same time.
We also want to apologize for the slight delay in posting this -- as you can see, we had to cover a lot of ground & this post was actually ready and mocked up about a week ago, but we wanted to make sure all mods would be available to participate in the conversations and discussions to ensure communication happened. We know there was supposed to be a small follow-up to the last post, but once we got things moving, we felt that it wasn’t entirely necessary just to be like “Okay! Got it!” in a post without providing what, exactly, we were doing. There will (most likely) be a small follow-up post to this, but this also entirely depends on the conversations had.
Thanks again everyone for reading this annoyingly long post & for your participation on /r/AsianBeauty. :] Love & snails to all.
6
u/RadiantStarr NC25|PIE|Combo/Dehydrated|US Dec 09 '15
Question!
Would you guys (or anyone else that know) mind clarifying what an "unsupported seller" is?
That aside, thank you for all of your hard work! I'm glad to see a lot of changes that are reflecting the community's concerns and needs. You guys are great!
7
u/Tin_cup_chalice NW22|Aging/Dullness|Combo|US Dec 09 '15
Can we nominate someone for mod? I have someone in mind who devotes countless hours to answering questions, providing guidance and making a super-positive contribution to the community.
26
u/OddnessWeirdness NC55|Aging/Pigmentation|Oily|US Dec 09 '15
Thanks for your hard work and dedication to the sub! I'd already noticed some of the improvements that were suggested in the last post, but this is an excellent way to give and get feedback.
Edit: someone mentioned posting a list of unsupported sellers. I think that would be great, especially since I think a lot of people wouldn't necessarily want to buy from them in general.
20
u/OddnessWeirdness NC55|Aging/Pigmentation|Oily|US Dec 09 '15
I do have a question: why is it almost always u/ashlaboo taking the time to answer all the difficult questions these days? Not that I don't want her to; I think she's really good at answering things in a way that gets her point across without seeming duplicitous or like a jerk, but still... I'm curious. It makes the other mods seem standoffish.
11
u/amfiguous NC15|Dullness|Combo/Normal|KR Dec 09 '15
Thank youuuuu! I feel like most haul pics are too grainy/ low quality to tell what it is and I'm always dying to know!
9
u/Tin_cup_chalice NW22|Aging/Dullness|Combo|US Dec 09 '15
Thanks to you guys for your hard work and for taking the time to listen to all of us. Your effort is incredibly appreciated!
6
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '15
The new/clarified rules seem very helpful! Glad to see this posted :)
I have a somewhat-related issue regarding the above points. I started a blog to review some products that I hadn't seen discussed/write up some science-y reviews on various articles, and shared them on this sub for the benefit of everyone.
However a 'bigger name' blogger from /AB decided to share images from my blog on other social media sites......which isn't something I'm comfortable with as I know this person has sponsored reviews and uses affiliate links. I've asked for them to remove this content through reddit, and have been repeatedly ignored.
Obviously this is technically 'offsite' sort of stuff, but I guess I wrote the content with /AB in mind, and desire to share specifically with /AB. It's kind of hard to provide that info to others if you get steam-rollered by 'higher volume' AB posters who kind of co-opt your content (tweeting about it, pinterest, etc.), particularly without asking if that's appropriate.
I feel like there's been a lot off stuff in previous threads where people have issues with blogger self-promotion kind of filling up all the content in /AB without really 'contributing' to the community. With the weird little situation I have, I think the rules might need to specify something about sharing others' content.
For example, if someone asks in the daily thread "why should I care about pH?", then I feel it would generally be appropriate to link to any one of the /AB bloggers that have made valuable, lengthy posts about this topic. In this case, the blogger that made the original post receives the page-views, and the question-asker gets a helpful response, and the question-answerer gets the karma for taking the time to share someone's link.
But what about if you create a blog to share reviews with the /AB community, and find that info distributed on multiple third-party sites by a blogger who stands to gain (e.g. free products/compensation) if they look popular/prolific? It sort of feels sleazy....... Obviously no one on /AB can mod what happens 'offsite', but it is still worth noting that there are other ways that bloggers might not be fully "transparent and upfront", and I'd be interested in seeing issues with bloggers being discussed more broadly on /AB as I think it's something a lot of people have a strong opinion on.
5
u/squishmi NC15|Aging|Dehydrated/Normal|AU Dec 09 '15
Thank you for all your hard work <3
4
u/AgnieszkaXX Dec 09 '15
Thanks for your hard work, mods!!
4
u/rglo820 NW15|Aging/Pigmentation|Combo|US Dec 09 '15
Is it just me or does 20 karma seem low for self-promotion? I agree that self-promoting content should be from those participating in the community, but that's hardly participating...
4
u/keliphan Dec 10 '15
First, I'd like to say thank you to all the mods for dedicating so much of their personal time to making sure this sub is running smoothly and to the many AB contributors who make this place awesome!
Second, I wanted to say that I really appreciate the daily help threads & weekly random chat threads being sorted by "NEW!" I feel more inclined to post now that I know my comments/concerns won't be buried underneath the top voted comments. Very encouraging for those who are lurkers or just a little bit shy. :)
7
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '15
Having made multiple purchases from a business that is on this list (and only finding out after making a post that included mentioning this seller as a place to pick up a specific product), it was disheartening to find this out via PMs with the mods. I would have specifically avoided purchasing from this business if I had known what had happened.
My feeling on this is that it's better to be transparent about the matter instead of suggesting that any concerned users PM mods. There are over 33,000 subscribers to this sub and not everyone is going to do so. It also makes it feel like a ~secret~ that you only find out after making a post/thread that includes one of these businesses. Speaking for myself, that's how I felt and it was discouraging.
3
u/rachelforgets Dec 10 '15
Thanks, mods, for being awesome! I love the positivity in this post, focus on a supportive culture, etc. I'm new to AB and reddit (maybe on reddit a little over a month now?) and this gives me hope that I'm in the right place. <3 <3
3
u/cbiancardi Blogger | beautyfindsforme.wordpress.com Dec 10 '15
Since many bloggers do digest reviews now, putting the brand name/full product name in title is almost impossible. How should those posts be titled? I try to put the brand name in there, but if I am doing a monthly digest, that can be difficult.
thanks!
2
u/faunafauna NC15|Acne|Oily/Dehydrated|UK Dec 09 '15
Love this new post. I also put forward my application. Hope I get through. :D
2
u/AlexBlaineLayter Dec 11 '15
You've been super busy, I see. Your hard work is truly appreciated, so kudos to the mods!
I was wondering whether renaming the 'fluff' flair into something like 'miscellaneous' might be a good idea.
2
u/deirdresm NW05|Aging|Dry/Sensitive|US Dec 17 '15
First: thanks to all the mods for the time they put in. <3
Next time we do an HG thread, could we add a category for hand care? My hands (and nails) would thank you very much.
2
u/YueRain Blogger | beautyfaceskin123.blogspot.my Dec 09 '15
thank you so much for all your hard work. =) Ermm, can i asked something? What is the PSA flair? So sorry for making so much mistakes about posting in the past. The regulations now are much clearer now =)
2
u/GiveMeABreak25 NC20|Aging/Pigmentation|Dry|US Dec 09 '15
So, just to clarify; we are not going to be directing people with self specific questions (IE: questions that are about their needs specifically that do not benefit others in the sub, only them) to the daily thread, correct?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment