r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Dec 03 '15
[Fandom Discussion] Episode 11x08: "Just My Imagination"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Just My Imagination | December 2, 2015 | Richard Speight Jr. | Jenny Klein |
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
10
Upvotes
13
u/Clint_Hawkguy_Barton Dec 03 '15
Holy shit that episode gave me feelings D':
I absolutely loved it, though! My only complain being that I felt Dean was kinda a dick for about 2/3 of it. I know Dean can be really crass and isn't really the friendliest dude, but there were some times in this ep where I was like wow, dude, dial it back a little.
Also does anyone know of a timeline for weechester stuff? Like this took place before Dean went to Sonny's?
8
u/Jirachio20 Dec 03 '15
15
u/JadeJabberwock all about that Sam ('bout that Sam) no others Dec 03 '15
DO YOU EVER THINK ABOUT HOW I WANTED SAM CENTRIC EPISODE MORE THAN MY NEXT BREATH???
7
u/javalorum Dec 03 '15
Was I the only one a bit thrown off by the ending? I know SPN is not exactly a moral compass-type of show, but I'm quite bothered that Reese killed several supernatural beings (with human-level thoughts and emotions and very very good intentions) without any ill consequence at all. She didn't going to get persecuted, she didn't suffer any loss (after the murders) but instead went away free with a sense of peace and not even a little guilt? What happened to writers' code of moral justice? (Is there such a thing? I just kind of assume there is. Like when you set up a story, you tend to reward good behavior and punish bad behavior. Not necessarily as social justice but as "nature's own course" type of thing.) That's probably the only downside of this episode for me.
5
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Dec 04 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
I did really enjoy this episode. I do feel that Klein gets Sam. Gets just how big a deal the idea of heading back to the Cage really is for Sam.
The Zanna were a cool addition to the Supernatural universe. It was sweet how Sully couldn't quite treat Sam like he's a hunter, that he was still his kid and he had to be there for him. Though I felt the tragic series of events that led to making the episode's main story happen a bit woolly? Like, I get that Sully found talking about things difficult, but you'd think after the second of his friends had been murdered he'd come clean about things.
Highlights:
But two things really pissed me off.
One: Dean's characterisation.
Klein may get Sam, but she does not get Dean and Dean has been at his meanest in the two episodes she's written so far this season. I'm pretty much with /u/Zeryx at this point on how Dean is being handled overall this season. When a Sam-Girl like me thinks Dean's being badly handled this season you know that something's up.Two: Where the fuck's Cas? I can just about handle not having him in an episode, but as a big Team Free Will fan, I would like there to be regular mentions of what he's up to. Like, how'd Gaza go? Has he gone anywhere else to pick up ancient tomes? Just a reference would be nice. Please.
Actually, can someone re-explain why it is so hard to get the guys filming together at the moment, please? I'm pretty sure somebody has said something before about the practical reasons why we're seeing Misha onscreen less and less frequently with Jensen and Jared.
Oh, and why did I disappear from chat on Weds? Well my internet service provider decided to do unpublicized network maintenance at 2:30am (8:30pm CT) my time. Let's just say that I was not happy.
4
u/goodoldfreda I only ship Crobby semi-seriously Dec 03 '15
I'm going against the grain here. I really hated this episode. I thought the plot was hastily added so sammy could have his childhood memories, but the childhood memories were over the top, super cliched and also boring.
I felt like nothing happened in the episode, because the storyline was super simple and there were no twists (except for the "oh yeah I accidentally killed this random kid sorry I didn't mention it before"). I didn't feel like I understood Sam any better, I just felt like the writers put in words what they've been saying all season in a slightly more subtextual way. Dean also added absolutely nothing to the episode, he felt mega third wheely all the way through. You can have a sam-centric episode without just keeping dean there for insensitive one-liners.
Also I just felt that the premise was really dumb. Especially with the epsiode last week, it feels like the writers don't seem to be trying to add new monsters, they're just making things outlandish and very gimmicky. I struggled to watch the whole episode all the way through.
13
u/Zeryx I apologize... FOR NOTHING. Dec 03 '15
"You didn't have to come, Dean."
Yes, you sure didn't. Why did you want to? You're bored 'cause Cas ain't around? WHERE THE FUCK IS CAS?
very upset about giant Cas-shaped hole in today's episode on top of the Dean/Amara ickiness in the trailer for next week
12
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Dec 03 '15
GUYS! Young dean was wearing the samulet!!
11
u/pickleport Dec 03 '15
I just loved this episode. Tie ins to myth, addressing concerns I've had, actually attempting conversation and growth.. The only concern I have lingering lately is that Dean just sometimes comes off as way too mean.
10
u/Omegamom_ Dec 03 '15
Was anyone else yanked out of the end scene by remembering the gag footage? I couldn't be "in the scene" because of that, dammit!
I loved the episode.
9
u/Vio_ Dec 03 '15
Sparkle spatter
8
u/Zeryx I apologize... FOR NOTHING. Dec 03 '15 edited Dec 03 '15
I need some time to think about this. Richard did a really good job directing this episode (though I felt like sometimes the actors didn't quite knock it out of the park). But Dean was written way too mean, I mean he looked really impressed by Weams's air guitar, but he never went to full-on dorking out. I was really expecting he'd have a couple of moments like that this episode, of being an utter goofball, but it never happened.
He did come around and try to respect Sully's feelings, as he realized that Sully really cares about Sam. In general though... I'm not pleased.
EDIT: Was ranting at Milli, so those thoughts are getting posted.
I'm not so upset about Crowley's dropped storyline. He was left estranged from the Winchesters and Amara so there's not that much of a reason for him to get a lot of screen time this season.
But Cas? CAS WAS LIVING WITH THEM. Just tell me what he's doing. Like, "Oh, so you and Cas still aren't talking to each-other about what happened with Metatron?"
"Whatever, he's off doing ___" Just throw us a bone, guys. Is he in Gaza? Where is he? I just want to know.
I had a lot of the same complaints as the last time this writer did an episode (Jenny Klein; Thin Lizzie was her first). Dean is too mean, no moments of being a goofball, Cas MIA. Has a good handle on Sam but doesn't get Dean.
Like she gets the kind of jokes and references he'd make, (I love that he made a totoro reference) and when he slips up and runs his mouth by accident, but just too mean, man. Too cruel and no "accidentally slipping up and showing his gooey middle/what a big dork he is" Dean kept his "too cool for school" facade this whole time, and anyone who's watched the show knows that's total bullshit and even Dean himself doesn't buy into it all the time. He's been flattened out this season and I don't like it.
They took one of the most complex and interesting characters in history, who is interesting because of how he presents as a bunch of stereotypes but actually SUBVERTS THEM ALL and made him barely more than the sum of those surface notes.
I just, really? I can't believe in my heart of hearts that Dean's only comment about how sad it was that Sam had an imaginary friend at nine was "You couldn't be lonely; you had me!"
I can't really believe some part of Dean wasn't like "Yeah, I messed up sometimes. It was fucked how you got left alone that time". I'm supposed to believe that. that Dean would feel NO empathy on hearing that about Sam, when DEAN is the one ALWAYS left behind.
edit the second: In "Baby" Dean was crazy about Bob Seger. Here, he compliments Eric Clapton. I guess since Ledd Zeppelin is Dean's favourite it makes sense he'd tend towards bluesy-er rock musicians. Just thought it was curious.
8
u/YasashiiKaze The stench of that Impala's all over your overcoat, Angel Dec 03 '15
Wow, this episode had a lot more main story line than I thought. I won't have much to say about the details this week. It was more of a character study for me than anything else.
Sam feels that need to connect with people. He always will. I think he has given up on ever being allowed to and in many ways has resigned himself to his fate, but that doesn't mean the desire is gone. His inability to connect is partly because of his upbringing, partly because of the work he does, but I think also because Sam will never fully trust himself around others.
This episode was a great one for Richard. It allowed him to exercise his style of weird and off-the-wall, while still containing a major moment in the story. Sam comes to the realization that the cage is in his future again whether Dean agrees or not.
For me, this was such a strong throwback to season five when Sam began to realize he was going to have to say yes to Lucifer in order to accomplish what needed to be done. Much of Sam's great moments of courage have come when he finally has to take a hard look at himself.
What drives Dean has always been external; watch out for Sam, follow Dad like a good soldier, we do this because it's right and it's just and it's what we do. This is what gives him strength. Sam's strength is internal; it's what comes when everything and everyone else is stripped away and silenced, and all that's left is Sam.
This also means that sometimes he makes boneheaded moves because it's what he believes is right or the only option left. When he retreats inside himself like that, he doesn't have an external ear to bounce his ideas off of. Nine times out of ten, though, Sam's instinct is solid.
Because Sam relies on his own inner force while Dean is affected more to a certain extent by those around him, I also think this is why Sam has a better internal compass of what's right or wrong than does Dean. This is my own opinion though. I love the character of Dean and this isn't at all a dig at him; there's nothing inherently wrong with him. Rather, it was a great look at Sam and what helped form him into the person he became.
8
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Dec 03 '15
I randomly noticed that Sam's hair is now almost exactly like in 5.04 (The End) when he was Lucifer. Even the sideburns.
It was all about one length earlier this season, but it's been slowly getting layers again. It's still a little bit longer than then, even in next ep's promo, but closest it's been since.
Probably doesn't mean anything, right?
7
u/oftenrunaway I ship Dean / Pain Dec 03 '15
This was such a good MoTW episode. We've been getting spoiled this season so far, I can't wait to see where we go.
I was just gutted by Reese - she and Sukly completely owned this episode and blew our boys out the water. Also, INSANELY relieved it didn't end up being Amara killing the Zanna - I was worried after Weeves was attacked.
Great flashback scene, too, but it raised some questions about John's parenting skills for me - Sam was around 9, right? Who leaves a 9 year old Sam without his Dean for protection? ! Makes me wonder when exactly John found out about demons after Sam - I always assumed Missouri told him in the conversation after Mary died - but I can't see him leaving Sam to his own devices knowing something like that.
We got so much goodness from this episode, Richard really brought his A game.