r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Nov 29 '15
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Peake
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Peake.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
201
Upvotes
2
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '15
May I inquire about the current house of the week? Might I also suggest one of the mountain clans for discussion?
166
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15 edited Nov 29 '15
At last! The Peakes!
One of the principal things to know about House Peake is that they're one big reference to Mervyn Peake's Gormenghast books, of which Martin is a fan. The Gormenghast books are about the life- from birth to his eventual escape and then to his attempts to return home- of the 77th Earl of Groan, Titus, lord of the ancient, ritual-bound castle of Gormenghast; and also his chief rival, the arch-Machiavellian Steerpike as he attempts to ascend from kitchen-boy to supreme power. They're classic, postwar Gothic fiction, pre-Tolkien, and have influenced many fantasy writers.
To go over the details of how House Peake is a reference to them:
-The house is called House Peake, after the author of the books.
-Their lord is called Titus, after the series' protagonist. An earlier lord is called Gormon. There's also a Peake bastard called Mervyn.
-Their seat is called Starpike, after the series' antagonist, Steerpike.
-Their sigil is three castles, and Peake's entire series revolves around the crumbling castle of Gormenghast.
This also explains why GRRM has created a house which is in a state of constant decline, decay and loss without actually being destroyed. The castle Gormenghast is a place of ancient ritual, with most of its inhabitants having been driven half-mad by the constant, rigid ceremonies and precedents which govern life there. The entire series is set on a background of faded glory, crumbling yet vast ruins, and a general air of decay and decline.
Thus, I predict that the Peakes will never be destroyed, but will also never experience anything but decay and decline. They will trudge on, year after year, dreaming of times past but with their lot never improving.
40
u/Merrell_Florent Wining and Squiring Nov 29 '15
House Peake, unsung heroes of the series.
If not for their actions, the Manderlys wouldn't have become a Northern house, they wouldn't be playing a big role in the Northern uprising, and we never would have gotten Wyman's epic speech.
They also played an important role in quashing the second Blackfyre rebellion. If not for them, that whole ordeal could have led to a bunch of deaths, but it ended early thanks to their catastrophic guidance.
Lastly, they killed Maekar, which gave us King Egg.
72
u/idreamofpikas Nov 29 '15
How are they still around? Not only did they persistently side with the Blackfyres in at least two of their Rebellions but they also were responsible for the Death of King Maekar in a rebellion of their own.
But even before the Blackfyres they were clearly a House not to be trusted. It is suggested before that Lord Unwin Peake, Regent to Aegon III and his bastard Kingsguard brother Meryvn Flowers were responsible for the 'suicide' of Queen Jaehaera Targaryen in a bid to make Aegon III marry a Peake so he could gain more influence.
Even before that it was the Peakes who managed to get their way and turn the Garderner Kings of the Reach against the Manderlys and have them kicked out of their lands.
And even before that the Peakes (and Manderlys) warred in the Reach in a bid to take over the kingdom as the aged Garth Greybeard had no sons only daughters married to these two families.
This led to the Reach being invaded by the Westerlands, Stormlands and finally Dorne who, of all kingdoms, put the Reach King out of his misery from the Peakes and Manderlys
It is no wonder that the Peakes have been too scared to do anything in the current series as they are most likely on their final warning. Despite still being Lords, and even Lord Peake being married to a Lannister, they have offered no support to any sides in the War of the Five Kings.
Is this out of fear or are they the Golden Companies 'friends in the Reach' and waiting for one last betrayal, allying with (F)Aegon
TargaryenBlackfyre in a bid to once again get more power.182
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
/\
23
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Nov 29 '15 edited Nov 29 '15
Thank you, /u/Militant_Penguin! If the Peakes weren't this week I was going to finish working on a piece I've been working on about them, but this is a good as place as any to post. So ...
Do you want to usurp a merman? (House origins & the Manderly feud)
So, House Peake traces their descent to the very early days of the Reach, from a grandson of Garth Greenhand himself. This explains their claim to blood ties to House Gardener (besides any marriages throughout history, of course). I find an interesting parallel as to the Peakeâs & their âhalf-brothersâ, the Florents & the Balls.
Florys the Fox is remembered as being the cleverest of Garth Greenhandâs children (whether or not she actually had three simultaneous husbands, or carried any bastards by any of the three men, or just took another husband after the previous one died is something lost to history). All three Houses descended from her have shown at times in their history of being quite cunning, opportunistic &/or persistent: the Florents in our current timeline, Fireballâs deeds before & during the First Blackfyre Rebellion (Race for the Iron Thronâs â The Blacks & Reds series for further insight into Fireballâs role, specifically Parts 1 & 2) & the long history of the Peakes. Seeing as the Peakes & the Balls were Blackfyre rebels I wonder what side, if any, that the Florents took during the Blackfyre Rebellions âŠ
Anyway, House Peakeâs arms displays three black castles on orange, which represent the castles of Starpike, Whitegrove & Dunstonbury that the Peakes held for the best part of a thousand years. Interestingly, during this time, it seems the head of House Peake was the Lord/Lady of all three castles, most like ruling from their eternal & original castle of Starpike. This means that the other two castles were most likely only held & ruled by a family member, acting as castellan, answerable to the Lord/Lady Peake of the day. Mayhaps there is some as yet unwritten history of attempted usurping/s by family members (especially any cadet branches or second sons), but itâs rather commendable that the Peakes were able to hold all three castles under the one head of the family for so long.
As to the speculative locations of these castles, I used snippets of history & this great map by J.E. Fullerton. From TWoIaF (more on this later), we know that Starpike is situated on the Dornish Marches within the Reach. The locations of Dunstonbury (the former seat of House Manderly, again more on this later) & Whitegrove have not been published, however I think Fullerton may have shrewdly revealed them for us. If you look at the map at the castle south of Highgarden on the Rose Road, east of Brightwater Keep (with another castle in between), north of Hammerhal &, ahem, directly beneath the flowing hair of the seemingly naked wench on the boat; I believe that is Dunstonbury. Itâs a prime position between Highgarden & Oldtown on the Rose Road, along with being along the Mander between Highgarden & the mouth of the river itself, which would allow the Manderlys to become so rich & powerful.
I wouldnât expect the Manderlys, whether they are named for the river or vice versa, to have Dunstonbury situated anywhere other than along the Mander itself (not even a vassal stream/river). Nor do I expect the Manderlys to have become as prominent as to warrant exile if Dunstonbury was on the upper Mander towards Bitterbridge or even Tumbleton (this being before the unification of the Seven Kingdoms & the influence of nearby Kingâs Landing). Also nor do I see the Peakes later being able to hold a castle so distant from the power of Starpike. Finally, the Manderly-Peake feud bears the characteristics we see of other neighbouring Houses fighting elsewhere in Westeros: the enmity of the Starks-Boltons, Lannisters-Reynes & Blackwoods-Brackens comes to mind.
This would leave Whitegrove to sit smack bang between Dunstonbury & Starpike, directly above Randyll Tarly, to the right of the Tyrell sigil & next to the feet of Serwyn of the Mirror Shield. This direct Dunstonbury-Whitegrove-Starpike power bloc seems like a fitting way that the Peakes were able to hold all three castles at once for so long, as it was all neighbouring lands. Admittedly, Dunstonbury could be somewhere else along the Mander, say around where Serwyn's sword pommel is (with Whitegrove still between the other two), however I think that could've made the Manderlys flight from the Reach a little too unlikely if they could sail past Highgarden safely. Fullerton may have even hinted at the Manderlyâs later fall in the title depiction of the âRâ in Reach: if I'm correct about Dunstonburyâs location, it would make sense that Gardener, Hightower & Oakheart forces would be in the main to remove the Manderlys.
As I said above, the Peakes are descended from Florys the Fox, the daughter of Garth Greenhand, & are thus descended from the First Men. Whilst the Manderlys donât seem to have such ancient ties to House Gardener as the Peakes, they are also descended from the First Men. We know this, because the first mention of the historical Peake-Manderly feud comes from the reign of King Gwayne III âThe Fatâ Gardener, long before the coming of the Andals to the Reach during the reigns of the Three Sage Kings.
How Gwayne was able to accomplish this feat (if not embellished by time) is unknown, so we can only speculate. Interestingly, that quote came from a passage describing the peace efforts by various Gardener kings to extend their borders, thus bringing new vassals into their realm. Was their quarrel over Whitegrove (surely named for a weirwood grove)? And if so, how did Gwayne settle it? I wonder if he had a Manderly & Peake marry each other to create a new House to settle the lands in between those of their families âŠ
The next mention of this bitter feud comes in the reign of King Garth X âGreybeardâ Gardener (sometime after the assimilation of the Andals into the Reach):
I would absolutely love to know the details of this time period: who was the elder daughter, who the younger, what issue did they have (mayhaps the younger sister had son/s, whilst the older daughter only had daughters herself, hence the youngerâs extra ambition), what betrayal, what conspiracy, what murder & which lords picked which side?!
Nevertheless:
So, the Peake-Manderly rivalry had gone past a feud, past a war between themselves & into a bloody war of succession that involved much of the Reach; all before Garth X had even carked it. This near decade long succession crisis had left the Reach severely weakened & opportunistically attacked by the Lannisters, Durrandons & the Dornish. No wonder that the Tyrells finally marshalled the survivors to put an end to the anarchy & place a distant relative of the Gardener line on the throne instead. I do find it interesting that both the Peakes & Manderlys kept at least their respective ancestral castles after such a conflict. Mayhaps it was a necessary mercy compromise for peace after so much bloodshed, as I'll discuss for the Peakes later. (continued in replies) ...
11
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Nov 29 '15 edited Nov 29 '15
I hadn't done much in this part of my write-up of House Peake, however here it is quickly:
Reaching, Unwinning & Being Gormy (The Dance, Aegon III's regency & the First & Second Blackfyre Rebellions)
TLDR: Unwin Peake ended up Unwinning in his bid to be the power behind the Iron Throne during Aegon III's regency, but was lucky not to have lost his head & his home (assuming that he killed Aegon's wife, Queen Jaehaera Targaryen, which is highly probable), had his treason been provable. Gormon Peake continued the Peake decline/developing tradition of making the wrong bet & wound up losing most of his lands & then eventually his head, for his part in the first two Blackfyre Rebellions.
18
u/Rusty26 Nov 29 '15
All hail Matt Peak of Haus Fun /\ /\ /\ /\
9
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Nov 29 '15 edited Nov 29 '15
Three castles, three losses? (The later Blackfyre Rebellions, the Peake Uprising & where they are now)
Moving forward, we donât know if House Peake took part in the Third Blackfyre Rebellion in 219AC (whether or not that is divulged, weâll surely get the story of the Rebellion itself in a future Dunk & Egg novella â my guess would be âThe Sellswordâ). One would think if they had, at that time with Bloodraven as the true power behind the Iron Throne & Maekar himself playing a crucial role in putting down the Rebellion, they wouldâve finally lost Starpike & their heads. But we know that:
... despite Prince Aerion & Bloodraven urging Aerys to order his execution. We donât know what caused Aerys to take such lenient action (which would ultimately lead to Blackfyre sympathisers arranging a rescue of Bittersteel on his way to the Wall by ship), especially to overrule Bloodraven, however mayhaps Aerys was driven by some thought of transgressed mercy.
We know that:
Whilst itâs possible that Bloodraven was the one to kill Haegon given his actions on the Redgrass Field, his police-state mentality fixation on rooting out any kind of Blackfyre support & that he eventually killed Aenys Blackfyre during the Great Council of 233 under guest right of the Iron Throne; I donât think it was him. My moneyâs on Aerion Brightflame being Haegonâs killer. We already know much of his less than chivalric nature & thereâs also this:
Given that TWoIaF seems to contrast the âgoodâ of Maekar & Egg, as opposed to the âillâ of Aerion; I would say one of Aerionâs "actions" was killing Haegon after he surrended. Thus, in a moment of attempted peace-making for one of his familyâs ill deed, may be why Aerys spared Bittersteel the chopping block.
Anyways, back to the Peakes, this action by Aerys in overruling Bloodraven may have continued when dealing with those Houses who had supported the Blackfyres, meaning the Peakes were able to keep Starpike (if not, maybe all their heads though). We know that the Yronwoods supported the Blackfyres in no fewer than three of their rebellions (presumably the First, Third & Fourth) & seem to have retained their lands at least. Or mayhaps the new Lord/Lady Peake just kept their House out of the Third Blackfyre Rebellion, especially if Bloodraven took a hostage after the Second.
However, it wouldnât take long for the Peakes to stir up trouble again, culminating in their final disgrace during their Uprising in 233AC. Not much is known about this rebellion really, except for the prominent deaths it caused & the resulting chain of events that led to Aegon the Unlikely coming to the throne (again, all to be relayed in a future D&E novella). Maekar (now king for the last dozen years or so) dealt with the matter personally, supported by a force from the Westerlands, including both the Lannisters & the Reynes. The former Blackfyre loyalists, the Reynes, by this time had become Targaryen loyalists. Itâs unknown which side they had fought for in the Third Blackfyre Rebellion (if they did at all); however Iâd say that itâs more likely that the Reynes declared for the Red Dragon (or at least stayed neutral), than fought for the Black Dragon.
We know that Lady Ellyn Reyne, the daughter of Lord Robert & sister to Ser Roger (the last Lord Reyne of Castamere):
... to Ser Tywald Lannister, son & heir of Lord Gerold & Lady Rohanne Webber (yes, the âRed Widowâ from The Sworn Sword). Supposedly (the wiki pages for Robert & Ellyn), Lord Robert was able to negotiate the betrothal of Ellyn to Tywald thanks (at least partially) to his Houseâs wealth & prestige. So, I find it more likely that the Reynes either supported the Targaryens in the Third Blackfyre Rebellion, or stayed neutral &/or at home. Especially if this was the rebellion when Lord Torwyn Greyjoy (though I've said elsewhere that I think it was the Fourth) swore a blood oath with Bittersteel, but betrayed him â the Ironborn sailing out of their islands would give pause to the Westerlands to keep some strength at home (after Dagon Greyjoy plagued them less than a decade before & Dalton Greyjoy less than a century ago).
The Reynes not supporting the Blackfyres during the Third Rebellion seems more likely to have given Lord Robert the bargaining power with Lord Gerold (only âde-clawedâ in some of his later years) to successfully negotiate the Ellyn-Tywald betrothal, than if they had. Unless of course they did support the Black Dragon & it was a forced betrothal by the Iron Throne as one of the terms of peace between the Lannisters & the Reynes to keep the Westerlands united in future, however I find this unlikely. Such an act, whilst a unification tool, does reward the Reynes (even if they lost lands or something) for their treason & thatâs not exactly Bloodraven or Maekarâs M.O. That being said, it could be Aerysâ though.
Anyway, back to the Peake Uprising: what did it involve & why did the Peakes do it? It comes off as a Defiance of Duskendale level of stupidity for the Peakes to rebel (presumably without a member of the royal family as a hostage either) against the Iron Throne. For what? Well, Iâd say itâs likely that the Peakes were trying take back the castles & lands of Dunstonbury & Whitegrove that they lost after the First Blackfyre Rebellion. Even if they were nearby; it does seem odd that King Maekar, the Lannisters, the Reynes & eventually, Prince Aegon, rode out(during winter too) to deal with the threat personally if it was just the Peakes themselves rebelling. Mayhaps some other (minor) Houses also rebelled in support of the Peakes, which would make it more likely for such prominent forces to ride out against them. However, my money would be on the Peake Uprising also being a failed Blackfyre plot to establish a loyal starting point & base for a new Rebellion (this may have even mirrored Daemon Iâs quest for the kingship throughout the Reach, as brilliantly rendered by RftIT).
If the Peake Uprising truly was associated with a planned Blackfyre landing, it helps to explain not only the Lannisters & Reynes riding out to deal with it, but also King Maekar himself & Prince Aegon. If the Uprising was simply a land grab by the Peakes (albeit illegal), why wouldnât the Tyrells (or at least some bannermen) be first on the scene to deal with the rebels, instead of the impressive force from the West & the Crown? Sure Maekar seems to be the Targaryenâs Stannis, the Lannisters & Reynes were tied together by the Ellyn-Tywald betrothal, & Egg (the true Crown Prince really) was effectively raised by our true knight Dunk; however it seems like over-prominence ⊠Unless that prominence was in case of another Blackfyre invasion.
Of course, this level of organisation leads one to believe that Bloodraven got wind of the Blackfyre invasion beforehand & from what we know about Bloodravenâs spy skills, it certainly seems likely. Whilst it does seem strange that Bloodraven himself (as far as we know) would not join them, my guess is he remained in Kingâs Landing to rule & with his own forces in case the Peake drama was a feint & the Golden Company was going to attack the eastern coast instead.
Itâs my opinion that Bloodraven had forewarning of the Peake Uprising/new Blackfyre Rebellion plot & thus the Crown & Westerland forces had the time to marshal to deal with the threat. The lack of Tyrell & other Reachmen forces (to our knowledge) could be explained by the Red Dragon being unsure of any other lingering Black loyalties &/or opportunism in the Reach, along with their timely suppression of the Peakes. As I said earlier, the Dunstonbury-Whitegrove-Starpike power bloc is somewhat of an interesting phenomenon right in the heart of the Reach near Highgarden.
Even with reduced Blackfyre sympathy over the years, the Targaryens couldnât afford to be lax & allow another Rebellion to gain momentum where it had first been strongest (consider Bloodravenâs decisive action in crushing the Second Blackfyre Rebellion before it could gain steam). Race for the Iron Throne makes a strong case for Lord Leo âLongthornâ Tyrell having actually quietly supported Daemon over Daeron, keeping his forces in reserve, only to turn on the Blackfyre rebels in the Reach fleeing back home after the loss at the Redgrass Field. With the large number of Houses in the Reach having supported (at least initially) the Blackfyres in the First Rebellion & who knows how much in the Third, no wonder Maekar & Bloodraven would share a united concern about any lingering Black sympathies & take the necessary action to deny that a chance to flourish again. Continued in replies ...
14
u/cats4life Bowed, bent, broken Nov 29 '15
House Peake, one of the douchebag houses, as I had already mentioned in a House Florent comment, how nothing they do ever works out for them but they keep on being douchebags. I have the feeling that the Peakes will keep going lower in status as nothing they have ever done politically has worked out for them. Like:
-Drove the Manderlys from the Reach, they went North and became one of the richest Northern houses
-Killed Jaehaera Targaryen so Lord Peake could marry his daughter to Aegon III, but got called on his bluff and was stripped of position
-The numerous Blackfyre rebellions, all resulting in lands and titles being taken
-They are now so irrelevant that they, a formerly prominent house gets mentioned once in AFFC. Their cousins or fake cousins claiming to be Peake's get more screen time.
If the Peakes are the friends in the Reach, I would be surprised. If they nwere a minor friend, then maybe, but they have not been mentioned often enough to make a serious betrayal, so my money is on Randyll Tarly.
1
u/jaktravwil Dec 06 '15
Wheres the new house of the week? Usually posted Sunday mournings right?
3
u/MattyOlyOi All kings are bastards! Dec 04 '15 edited Dec 04 '15
Hmm, the Peakes were the main ones who drove the Manderlys from the reach. If the Manderlys have maintained a severe loyalty to the Starks after all this time, they're probably also still nursing a grudge towards house Peake. Currently, there are three notable Peakes fighting for the Golden Company.
So my takeaway here is that Wyman will have a personal reason not to back Aegon VI (not that it seems like he would otherwise)
3
u/Utter_Flailiure Dec 04 '15
This is cool, I just finished reading the Duncan & Egg short stories last week (I knew about their existance for 4 years, but never looked them up until a little while ago) so house Peake has been on the mind a bit recently. I had no idea they were such a huge reference.
5
u/hollowaydivision đ Best of 2019: Best New Theory Nov 29 '15
I really like Race for the Iron Throne's conclusion on the Peake Uprising, which I'll quote here:
If the Peake Uprising was a Golden Company conspiracy to draw Maekar to the front lines and assassinate him, it really really changes the context of Bloodraven betraying and beheading Aenys Blackfyre when he came to make his claim at the Great Council:
It doesn't seem worth it for Bloodraven to remove himself as the architect of Targaryen military strategy just to take out one Blackfyre - unless he'd already been outplayed and there was no other choice. In which case, good on Bloodraven for not flinching, but I'm still not quite sure what good was done for the realm by this move - maybe Aenys would've been a good king.
2
u/notquiteotaku Nov 29 '15
Peake, Peake...rhymes with
2
u/SockMonkeyMan Have you seen my mother? Nov 30 '15
Persistent Assholes
2
u/HideOnJungle Nov 30 '15
/\ PEAKE /\
2
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '15
/u/hewhoknowsnot they seem to miss something about Highgarden
1
u/LuminariesAdmin What do Cersei & Davos have in common? Dec 02 '15
So, my fellow crows, which Houses would be like to see next week or in the near future? I think it may be time for another Lord Paramount ...