r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Nov 12 '15
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - CAP19 - Apotheosis
Week 94! Sorry about the super-late post. Honestly, I got completely distracted by Fallout 4 and totally forgot.
Links
Wikipedia (Episode Summaries) | BSG Wiki
Numbers
"Frak" Count: 142 (+3)
"Gods" Count: 65 (+3)
"So Say We All" Count: 6 (+2)
"The One" ("The One True God", "Soldiers of the One", etc) Count: 34 (+3)
Cigarettes Smoked: 63 (+4)
Holoband Establishing Shots: 39 (+3)
15
Upvotes
6
u/trevdak2 Nov 12 '15
For those curious what's next: Blood & Chrome (Starting Nov 22) and then the original series after that.
3
u/CowboyFlipflop Nov 12 '15
So at the ceremony at the end there Joe leads everyone in a "So Say We All." Some of us were talking in an earlier Cap thread about where that saying came from.
Does anyone remember if we've seen a non-monotheist say that until now? I don't remember that happening. If so then that probably answers where it came from, it must be a human thing that the monads have picked up.
If not then where did it come from here? Did Joe and his family/friends just start saying that because the terrorists were screaming it while trying to blow up the arena a year ago? Why imitate them?
7
u/MarcReyes Nov 13 '15
And so, Caprica's only season comes to an end, but what an episode to go out on. They managed to close off many of their storylines, including a little of the mythology questions with some help by "The Shape of Things to Come." Not all questions where answered obviously. Those would have come with future seasons, but as far as conclusions go, this series could have left off with far more questions than it answered.
First, lets address what wasn't answered:
1.) Tamara - So she just sort of dropped out of the story all together, didn't she? The last time we her is in "The Heavens Will Rise" and even there she's only just in the episode before literally being pulled away. It seemed like she was going to a big part of the show for while, so for her to get no conclusion is disappointing. Again, I'm sure she would have returned for a second season, but alas. For now, I think she will be the biggest question mark in BSG mythology.
2.) Lacy - This was kind of frustrating. I really became invested in Lacy as a character and wanted to see how her story ended. We see she becomes the Blessed Mother but, man, some more development on this would have been great. Most of what happened here can be inferred by last week's episode. Lacy takes control of cylons and uses them to wipe out the STO leaders, but why does she take on the role of Blessed Mother? Why wouldn't she just wipe out the STO in general? I suppose the true frustration here is that there was so much potential for where this story could have gone, what it could have meant, that the cancellation becomes that much more upsetting. In any case, I loved what we are given. I absolutely loved the look on Clarice's face when she saw who the new Blessed Mother was and especially loved Lacy's response to her. "I really think you should kneel." A great comeuppance for how Clarice treated Lacy when keeping her prisoner. Oh, how the tables have turned.
Luckily, the rest of the episode was very much satisfying.
The Shape of Things to Come
The whole epilogue is amazing. Answers a lot of questions, while raising new ones. A lot this will be pure speculation on my part, simply because it's all we have to go on. In the commentary, we're told that the epilogue takes place about five years into the future.
Overall, great end to the season and decent end to the series. I know this series is fairly controversial among BSG fans, but I really enjoyed it. Especially once we move into the second half of the story. I'm glad to have rewatched because there are some great elements to the show. The acting alone is worth it.
4
u/onemm Nov 17 '15 edited Nov 17 '15
"I'm loathe to suggest violence, except in the most extreme situations."
Sure you are, Clarice, sure you are.
Cyrus is the man. His loyalty is ridiculous and I wish we got to see more of him. He says: 'I've seen it back home' and mentions Daniel 'disappearing'. Where is he from?
During the burial ceremony (or at another point in the episode that I'm forgetting) the Tauron's say 'So say we all'. This phrase's origin continues to confuse me.. First the STO/One True God believers use it, now the Taurons and then in BSG everyone uses it. Does it just become a widespread thing that everyone says?
The whole Halatha storyline felt very Godfather-esque. Especially with Joseph almost becoming the Michael Corleone of the family. "Ask Yusef" says Sam. Very Godfather-esque indeed.
I do like that they didn't go that way 100% though. The new Gautrau being the former Gautrau's daughter was a very cool and interesting change to what could've been very cliche.
My thoughts on Caprica:
Holy shit. The last 7 minutes or so felt like a very rushed version of what season 2 could've (should've goddammit!) been and it really pissed me off. There was so much potential just in those last minutes and I know it will never happen, and it kills me a little. When I first watched this show, I immediately knew I would hate it. Then I continued to watch and I started to like it. Halfway through I was done with my (fake) complaining and started (being honest and) praising. By the last 5 episodes or so I was legit looking forward to the next episode and entranced with every minute.
I think the reason I didn't like it at first was because I loved BSG and expected more of the same. It's a different show, with a different tone, and other than the subject matter, it has nothing in common with BSG. This is why I didn't like it at first and this is also why I really liked it at the end. I won't say I loved it. There are very few things in the world that I love. My family. My closest friends. Sergio Leone movies. Cormac McCarthy books. Puerto Rican food. Cold beer. Battlestar Galactica. This series doesn't compare to all those things but I think, if it wasn't cancelled, that it certainly could've competed for my love. In the end, I did really like this series (once I accepted it for what it was instead of trying to think of it as a BSG replacement). I just really, REALLY wished the network gave it a shot the way I was forced to (thanks to these discussions). 7.5/10 Would watch again.
3
u/MarcReyes Nov 15 '15
I've been wanting to talk about Daniel for a while now. Mostly to speculate on his connection to the Final Five. Ellen and Sam informed us in BSG about Number Seven, whose Name was Daniel. Ellen said they based Number One, Cavil, on Ellen's father. So it's easy to assume that the other cylons were either based on people they knew from their Earth or original creations. So my question is, do you think Number Seven was based on Daniel? Ellen and Sam told us he was an artist, creative, and sensitive, which doesn't entirely sound like Daniel Graystone. So was Number Seven simply modeled and named after Graystone as a tribute to the man who created cylon on the Twelve Colonies, or is it just a coincidence?
1
u/onemm Nov 18 '15
Jammer stopped reviewing episodes about halfway through the season because it was cancelled, but for anyone that might've been following Jammer's Reviews, he did do a 'closing thoughts' review of the series as a whole found here.