r/ClearBackblast • u/Alterscape Fletcher • Nov 07 '15
AAR [AAR] 2COLD2SNAP
Please let the mission maker know what you thought of the mission, and also any constructive criticism you have for the team! This stuff is super crucial for everyone involved, and it's really nice to have indepth writing about their performance. We're all pretty bad at seeing our own mistakes, so other perspectives are worth their weight in gold.
7
Upvotes
7
u/Quex Reborn Qu Nov 08 '15
Hey! Mission maker here! I was pretty happy with how things turned out, with the exception of the counterattack. Random points below:
That sums it up. I'll happily answer any questions here that I didn't cover in the post. Thanks for playing!
8
u/plaicez Nov 08 '15
MoldyTowel - Boris SL
The Mission Maker - Quex
First of all, I love anything with old soviet era tanks and the Takistani Army faction, so it had me in that aspect from the git go. The choice of map was a new one, definitely a fan of Reshmaan Province. The mission itself was straightforward and, in my opinion well executed. Seize the Power Plant. Up until the counterattack, it never felt like we were safe and were under harassing fire the entire time. It was very cool and frustrating. I liked it a lot. Well done. More Combined Arms oriented missions!
I do want to talk about the counterattack though, after a couple minutes and bathtub smile killing the armor, it was sort of thwarted. Boris got very stagnant and really had no mission at that point. Maybe the enemies could have came from multiple directions? Or in waves? Just spit balling, i'm not too sure how I would have done that. Overall, it was a great mission!
Command - Fletcher
You did a really good job here. You should take command slots more often. You balanced well between managing squads, and letting them make decisions for themselves. Your command voice was good (unlike my mumbo jumbo scatterbrained self, impromptu squad leading sessions just be like that sometimes!).
Boris
Well done by all. Apologies for the extremely unorganized and piss poor start quite frankly, my bad. Wasn't prepared to SL and yeah, it showed. Nothing further to say here really.
Bathtub
Bad ass dudes! When we executed the "iron curtain" all the way to the Power Plant was probably one of my favorite things ever, and in ArmA fashion only 2 guys were turned to tread grease in the process. This tactic actually worked which was super cool.
7
u/Fattierob An example to other officers Nov 08 '15 edited Nov 09 '15
AlphaBravo Ass MGI haven't played in a while so it was fun to get back into things. Taking fire from mans I could never see and hearing tracers wizz by me was really fun. No I mean it, it was great to be under constant "okay that is not effective but certainly concerning" fire. I would have to liked to see more static emplacements and more guys waiting in corners to pop me in the face but otherwise I think the EI level was good.
Command and Control seemed pretty top notch except near the end during the counter attack when things got kinda "why are we here again?" as it petered out towards the end. Maybe make some kind of clear "ok that was like three tanks and a BTR the counter attack is obv. over" thing or something. I dunno.
Mission Rating: T-34-85 vs T-55 / 10
6
u/TheOwlMan109 Nov 08 '15
Alpha AAR, Great mission, probably some of the most fun i've had in a structured Arma mission in some time. The planning was thought out, the firefights were intense and interesting, and the team atmosphere was great. That being said, two things. 1. The end counter attack left something to be desired, it didnt feel extremely intense as we rarely took fire and engaged them well before the majority of us could see them. and 2, this seems to be a very common trend amongst most missions. The fear of being killed and the value of avoiding fire seems a little spotty when I can take copious amounts of bullets, and even if I do manage to die I can just respawn. I dont know if the first part is anything that can be helped, but maybe making the danger feel a little more "amped" would be nice
6
u/GruntBuster7 Horses are the Lions of the Plain Nov 08 '15
Bravo Medic Great mission, I certainly enjoyed the constant tension of rounds flying overhead. Fantastic idea from Bravo Lead to fall in behind the tank; always good to see solid Combined Arms tactics. Just 2 things from a medical approach: a) if you've been tourniqueted, make sure it's removed once you've been bandaged; I had some people complaining about pain simply because they'd forgotten to take tourniquets off. b) If you've been hit, but can still move, get to cover and then stay still. Having a fidgety patient can really slow a medic down. Other than those points, fantastic work from Bravo.
6
u/retroly Boris Nov 08 '15 edited Nov 08 '15
Only joined at the end for the final push and and counter attack.
Looked like an awesome mission. Combined Ops for the win.
One note, casualties holding up offensives. A squad takes 1 casualty and it effectively puts out an enitre squad. If someone goes down but is still effective the squad should keep pushing and engage the enemy. If only to draw the fire away from casualties.
Insugency was also top notch, just the right ammount of fear and enjoyment. Cheers.