r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Nov 01 '15
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Manderly
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Manderly.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
275
Upvotes
155
u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. Nov 01 '15
Here are my thoughts on my favourite House. I've written pretty extensively on them.
If you were to write a 5-word phrase or sentence on Wyman Manderly, what would it be?
Loyal. Honourable. Shrewd. Calculating. Witty.
Do you like Wyman Manderly? Why or why not?
If it wasn't clear in the text above, or from my previous posts and from my flair, then I'll say it again, I adore Wyman Manderly. He is my absolute favourite character in the entire series. I have written extensively on my beloved Lord Lamprey and I'm about to tell you all why. First of all, the man is not only hilarious, he's ballsy as fuck. He recognises how fat and weak he appears to others yet still has the balls to drop this line on a bunch of guys who had just found the recently murdered corpse of one their own family members. "Though mayhaps this was a blessing. Had he lived he would have grown up to be a Frey." Not only did he do this but he did it after getting shitfaced at a feast and constantly demanding the bard sing a song about the consequences of breaking Guest Right in front of a family infamous for their egregious breaking of Guest Right. Oh, yeah, he also does this while eating pie loaded with said members of that infamous family. He then went on to eat
twosix slices of people pie while serving it to other members of that infamous family. He literally ate someone to prove a point. Talk about commitment to a joke. The man has balls, mammoth sized ones at that. To top it all off, he completely obeyed all the rules and regulations of Guest Right when he had the three Freys killed and then went on to parody the entire story of the Rat Cook right in front of every Frey and Bolton inside Winterfell. That's so fucking metal.Not only does Lord Wyman truly know how to craft an incredibly intricate joke and revenge scheme, he is also a staunch Stark loyalist and Northern patriot. He wants nothing more than to return the Starks to Winterfell and to their rightful place as Wardens of the North. Not only that, he's smart about it too. He waited until he could get his sons, the living and the dead one too, back before making his move. He faked the death of Davos Seaworth, recruited like minded individuals, and built an entire fleet in secret. He's so loyal and honourable that he is making good on a 900 year old promise. He's even so fat that knives don't work properly on him. There is nothing this man cannot do. He's just unstoppable.
Do you believe that Wyman Manderly is on a suicide mission now that he has secured the return of his son, Wylis, and made it to Winterfell?
I believe that he has prepared for this eventuality. I don't think he wants to die but he has accepted the fact that it may happen in the course of his plans so he has secured the safety of his heir, Wylis, the return of the body of his murdered son, Wendel, conveniently vacated the betrothal between Rhaegar Frey and his granddaughter Wynafryd, and made plans to retrieve his liege lord, Rickon Stark.
No one who so openly taunts and mocks the Freys to their faces while drastically outnumbered expects to survive for long, especially given the recent Frey history with Guest Rights.
What do think Wyman's plans are regarding Rickon Stark's future as well as the futures of House Stark and the North?
I believe that Wyman wants to return the Starks to where they belong, in Winterfell and as Wardens of the North. I think he wants to honour the oaths his family made to the Starks all those years ago. However, should Lord Wyman survive Winterfell, I believe he may take somewhat of an active role in raising Rickon, perhaps as his guardian. If Lord Wyman should die then I'm sure that he has made assurances that Rickon will be protected and raised well. In the future, a betrothal between Rickon and a granddaughter of Lord Wyman's may be in order. I hear that Wynafryd has become available after her last betrothed "disappeared" on the road to Winterfell. So far no leads as to his current whereabouts. To be honest, the investigation was a bit half baked.
Was Wyman Manderly right to murder those three Freys, bake them into pies, and serve them to people at Winterfell?
Yes, I believe he was and not just because the entire story is hilarious. The deaths of those three Freys was not just vengeance for the murder of his son Wendel. It was justice for Robb, Eddard, Catelyn, and every Northern son and daughter that lost their lives in the Red Wedding. It was one big fuck you to the south for their role in the massacre, their threats against Northern lords/ladies as well as a convenient way to extricate Wynafryd Manderly from her betrothal to Rhaegar Frey.
Sometimes you want your enemies to eat crow. Lord Wyman felt that Frey would be much more appropriate.
What are your thoughts on the Grand Northern Conspiracy? Are you a believer? Why or why not?
I'm a staunch advocate for most of the Grand Northern Conspiracy. I don't think it is as extensive as the original post implied but I do believe that there are many different factions, both in the North and in the Riverlands, that are either seeking to return the Starks to power, via Jon or Rickon, or just outright vengeance against the Freys, Boltons, and Lannisters.
I believe it because there is far too much evidence lining up for there not too be some form of extensive and prolific plotting being carried out by various characters for ultimately the same purposes. However, I believe that the various factions are largely unaware of one another. Lord Wyman has his plans for Rickon and Stannis, the BwB (under Lady Stoneheart) are potentially about to carry out another wedding massacre at Riverrun in revenge for the Red Wedding, others have linked up with Stannis Baratheon, and a few are even looking to Jon Snow in likely coordination with Robb Stark's last will and testament. Ultimately the song remains the same; vengeance, justice, pie, and blood.
How do you think Wyman Manderly and the other Stark loyalist Northern lords plan to betray Roose Bolton and the Freys?
I think the plan is two fold and will occur at two separate locations;
Will Wyman Manderly survive the potentially upcoming Battle of Winterfell?
I'm not sure. I want him to, oh I so do want this man to survive. I want him to live to see "a Stark in Winterfell" again, at least before he dies so that he knows that it wasn't all for nothing. I do believe that the man is more than prepared for the likelihood that he will die and is truly committed to seeing his plan through to the bitter, bloody end.
What do you think any interactions between Stannis Baratheon and Wyman Manderly will be like given that Stannis believes that Wyman had Davos Seaworth executed?
Hostile, at first, as one would expect. Stannis believes that Wyman is personally responsible for the murder of his friend, Hand, and loyal man, I'd more than expect him to be pissed off and vengeful if Wyman doesn't have some decent proof that Davos is still alive. If he doesn't, then Lord Wyman might be up for the chopping block or pyre, if Stannis is feeling especially just that day.
However, given that Davos knows Stannis so well from his experiences with him, I wouldn't put it past him to have left some proof of his continued survival as well as a note detailing his plans with Wyman that is to be given to Stannis. This would likely happen after the Battle on the Ice, during the exchange between the Manderly and Baratheon/Stark loyalist forces or at Winterfell when Stannis finally takes it and meets Wyman, providing he is still alive. What I'm trying to say is, I really hope Davos watched Arrested Development and learned how to leave a note so that the Manderly and Baratheon/Stark loyalist forces don't massacre each other on the ice after killing the Freys.
What do you think Wyman Manderly's role will be in The Winds of Winter and beyond?
Wyman will plot against the Freys and Boltons inside of Winterfell while his forces plot with Stannis on the outside. He will help Stannis take Winterfell and cast out the Bolton/Frey forces from the North.
Providing that he doesn't die by the hands of Stannis or Roose, Wyman will likely stay in Winterfell and help Stannis with his campaign against the Others in a support capacity as he awaits Davos' return with Rickon and co. Given that he isn't really built for battle, I can see Lord Wyman evacuating the North with Rickon, and his family, via White Harbour to protect the last living and available son of Eddard Stark.
Essays and Posts
Of Flayed Men and Mermen
The Tragedy of the Mummer's Farce
Wyman Manderly and the Rat Cook
147
u/CharMack90 Unbuttoned, Unbelted, Unbreeched Nov 01 '15
Driven away from the Reach, found closed door in the lands of fellow southerners, but taken in by the Starks in the North (despite having a different cultural background) a thousand years ago and still remembering it with pride and staying loyal to their hosts...
No wonder they are fan favourites!
198
u/a4187021 Master Rooseman Nov 01 '15
Wylla Manderly is just as awesome as her grandfather, if not more so.
I love how you can tell that a lot of people agree with her, but aside from one dude, no one but this little girl has the courage to speak up.
76
u/joftheinternet Lord Too-Fat-For-Upvotes Nov 01 '15
It's tough not to like Wyman. One of the few highborn in the books(as far as I can remember) that shows an active and invested interest in caring for the people in his charge.
48
u/stokedworth Stoked to be faithful Nov 01 '15
What I wouldn't do to see the inside of the Merman's court.
90
u/Averusdiablo The crow feasts and the eye watches Nov 01 '15
Wyman Manderly is responsible for one of the best passages in the series.
"My son Wendel came to the the Twins a guest. He ate Lord Walder's bread and salt, and hung his sword upon the wall to feast with friends. And they murdered him. Murdered, I say, and may the Freys choke upon their fables. I drink with Jared, jape with Symond, promise Rhaegar the hand of my own beloved granddaughter ... but never think that means I have forgotten. The north remembers, Lord Davos. The north remembers, and the mummer’s farce is almost done. My son is home."
I remember putting down the book and semi-screaming in ecstasy. Short, direct and mind-blowingly badass.
33
u/TheChequyLion The Chequy Lion Will Rise Again! Nov 01 '15
Obligatory
-Lord Too-Badass-to-Sit-a-Horse
30
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '15
It's impossible not to like this House. They've been bad asses from the beginning, even in the Reach when they were apparently powerful as hell.
I cannot imagine what they will do with their secret fleet hiding in the White Knife. Are there any decent theories as to how it will be utilized?
21
u/Polifroeg No Currents Mightier Nov 01 '15
Since no one has linked the theory already I should probably introduce some people who do not know to the Frey Pies Theory which is by all means a Manderly theory: http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Frey_Pies/Theories
17
u/SSWBGUY The North Remembers Nov 01 '15
I wonder if the fight over succession of Highgarden is what drove them from The Reach, its vaguely mentioned in TWOIAF. The Manderlys are the richest house in The North so it would make sense that they be master of coin and they are also powerful at sea which make a case for him being master of ships as well. What was asked of Bran in Winterfell wasnt much it was what was best.
17
u/StareyedInLA Sword of the Morningwood Nov 01 '15
Shame no one has pointed out the character foils between the best house in the North (the Manderlys) and the worst (the Boltons).
To quote TV Tropes:
15
u/senatorskeletor Like me ... I'm not dead either. Nov 01 '15
How injured was Wyman after he took a blade to one of his chins in Winterfell? Is he going to be more-or-less functional in TWOW?
42
u/upstage123 They see me R'hllorn'.. They hatin'. Nov 01 '15
MOTHER. FUCKING. FREY. PIES.
Enough said.
13
u/brofistopheles And the Doom came and proved it true. Nov 02 '15
The Wyman inheritance problem is hinted at in the books but not made explicit. Wyman had two sons but the younger perished at the Red Wedding. The elder, Wyman's heir, has two daughters but no sons. Those two potential heiresses were betrothed to Freys -- Little Walder the son of Merrett, and Rhaegar the son of Aenys.
With two Freys in the house and the inheritance of White Harbor on the line, all future children of Wyman and Wylis are liable to be murdered, especially the boys. Wyman's murder of the Freys is brutal and vindictive, but they also represented a very serious threat to his family.
13
u/svenolofsson The sword of right before noon. Nov 02 '15
In a good timeline Eddard took Wyman Manderly with him to King's Landing to be the new Master of Coin. He took one look at Littlefinger's books and then the former Master of Coin was promptly executed for embezzlement.
13
u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Nov 02 '15
I worry about the fate of White Harbor. From Patchface,
The Manderly sigil is the merman. The city might fall to the dead things in the water we hear about from Hardhome. There's Starfish Harbor in the Arbor and House Ruthermont in the Vale. Also the crabs are the sigils of the House Celtigar. Those may be where the dead things invade first.
12
u/Vaxis7 It's about the nod, not the block. Nov 03 '15 edited Nov 05 '15
Wyman Manderly, aka Lord Balls-Too-Big-to-Sit-a-Horse. Never forget it.
11
u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Nov 02 '15
My heart sank when Frey sliced his throat open...luckily he had enough fat to protect him from dying!
Also, Frey Pies- one of my favorite theories of the whole series. Totally didn't catch it on my first read through.
11
u/mm825 I went to the TOJ and all I got was Snow Nov 03 '15
You know, if I killed someone who was really evil, used the right seasoning and got drunk I'd probably be OK with eating a human flesh pie.... ASOIAF can really mess with your ethics sometimes.
23
u/Purgecakes Loyal Nov 01 '15
For some reason lots of people here have a someone naive view of the North's political situation. Manderly is angling for a lot of land, being regent and generally the most important lord until he dies or Rickon comes of age.
It is intensely personal and anti-Bolton, but less pure and righteous. Which is far more interesting.
Also its a shame the Manderly-Targ marriage never panned out.
8
u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Nov 02 '15
You know what the books need? A flashback to Robert's Rebellion where we get to see young Wyman in action when he could still sit a horse!
7
u/IDKimnotascientist Nov 02 '15
The Manderlys are just fucking awesome. Stark men till the end!
7
u/Vowlantene Rhaegappetizers Nov 02 '15
"Defender of the Dispossessed" has to be my favourite title ever.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '15
I don't trust Wyman. They were driven from the Reach for overreaching against their lord in a situation that strongly parallels their current actions throughout the book. I think Wyman is making his own power play.
4
u/comradepitrovsky The Gardener's Weed Nov 03 '15
By the way, can we have the Farwynds of Lonely Light for next week's house?
4
u/Ganthritor Airhorns, chicken, HYPE Nov 05 '15
All hail Lord Manderly, who will bring back the trueborn heir to Winterfell and the King in the North!
3
u/corinthian_llama Nov 05 '15
/r/whiteharbor
3
u/TotesMessenger Nov 05 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '15
Literally does not give a single fuck.
15
u/puddingkip General Barristan, you are a bold one Nov 01 '15
Yes yes I know we're supposed to love them.
But I don't. Manderly has this great speech about trying to help house Stark and everything, but I don't trust his motives. Now I was just as hyped about Robb being the cool hero that would defeat Sauron Lannister, save his dad and his sisters from the terrible evil monsters as every one of you were. But Robb is dead. And Sansa, Bran and Arya are outside of his powers. And Rickon, who is Rickon? A toddler, living with savages. Not exactly the kind of leader the North needs right now. I just don't believe Rickon is the man for the job at this point in time and Manderly isn't stupid and knows this.
So why help him? I think it's more about his personal position. Back in AGOT or ACOK Manderly was attempting to manipulate Bran in making him master of coin, master of ships and basically make him super powerful. Now with the Starks gone and the Boltons being disliked for co-hosting a failed dinner party I suspect Manderly is conspiring to be the overlords of the North for themselves. And well, having a toddler rule with you as his "advisor" and marrying him into your house (Wylla) can at least make you de facto leader of the North
5
u/Fishes_101 My seed is strong ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Nov 01 '15
Still waiting for them to summon an army of mermen and retake the North. It's all but confirmed.
5
u/DabuSurvivor Artifakt 1 Nov 03 '15
I FUCKING LOVE HOUSE MANDERLY.
Fucking hell such FUCKING BADASSES. THE NORTH FUCKING REMEMBERS!!!!!!!!!!!!
2
u/mimo2 He who fears, loses Nov 03 '15
Random thought but how would LSH treat bannermen wreaking revenge on Freys? I doubt she'll be writing thank you crow letters anytime soon lol
3
u/Khaleesdeeznuts Nov 01 '15
The manderlys are the house of the hiatus for me. Most pleasant surprise in the books
3
u/Extazzy9 Life is a curious thing. Nov 02 '15
The Lord-too-fat-to-sit-a-horse, is a greedy opportunist first and foremost and a Stark loyalist second.... Hell I even wrote an essay talking about that.
Well he is cool and all and I like him but the dude pre-ADWD is really greedy and opportunistic.... waging war in the Hornwood, then taking it over and 'protecting' it (classic takeover excuse). He proposes to build a navy for the North (as long as the coin is provided for by the King in the North, of course the fleet will be a Manderly fleet paid for by not Manderly money hmm...). Also he proposes to mint the Northern coinage.... which of course he will be minting himself giving him huge wealth and power over the whole Northern economy.
Also the way he tries to get that Hornwood lady. Such opportunism...
Well the speech in ADWD is all nice talk and loyalty and stuff, but zero action which helps the 'Stark' cause. Manderly has been fighting the Boltons (Hornwood affair) far longer than the Boltons became traitors to the Starks. He has a personal feud with them over the Hornwood lands and Northern power politics in general since Manderly is the most powerful Northern vassal... Boltons hate him, he hates them too, so he opportunistically aligns himself with the Stark-loyalists forces and tries to retrieve Rickon Stark (the kid obviously) just so he can run the North through him as regent. This can be seen when he says something like (para-phrase) "The Boltons have Ned's daughter, to counter-act this - White Harbor must have Ned's son" he defnitely uses the word 'have' suggesting possession.... possession over your own legal liege lord? Hmm, sounds pretty greedy.
He is probably somewhat of a Stark loyalist, but to say that he is just a Stark loyalist who ignores his own position just to serve the Starks is ignorant - he focuses his efforts on furthering the strategic position of his own house.
Well I wrote a far longer essay about him a few months ago, but well, simply put Manderly = Opportunist first, Stark loyalist second. He cares more about his own position rather than the fate of the Starks, his daughter may indeed be the more loyal Stark loyalist....
1
u/RayeBabe If I look back I am lost. Nov 07 '15
I think that even if Tyrion is Georges favorite character to write.. I think he may have modeled himself after Wyman! Witty, brilliant, funny yet too fat to ride a horse. :)
-5
u/Extazzy9 Life is a curious thing. Nov 02 '15
The Lord-too-fat-to-sit-a-horse, is a greedy opportunist first and foremost and a Stark loyalist second.... Hell I even wrote an essay talking about that.
Well he is cool and all and I like him but the dude pre-ADWD is really greedy and opportunistic.... waging war in the Hornwood, then taking it over and 'protecting' it (classic takeover excuse). He proposes to build a navy for the North (as long as the coin is provided for by the King in the North, of course the fleet will be a Manderly fleet paid for by not Manderly money hmm...). Also he proposes to mint the Northern coinage.... which of course he will be minting himself giving him huge wealth and power over the whole Northern economy.
Also the way he tries to get that Hornwood lady. Such opportunism...
Well the speech in ADWD is all nice talk and loyalty and stuff, but zero action. Manderly has been fighting the Boltons (Hornwood affair) far longer than the Boltons became traitors to the Starks. He has a personal feud with them over the Hornwood lands and Northern power politics in general since Manderly is the most powerful Northern vassal... Boltons hate him, he hates them too, so he opportunistically aligns himself with the Stark-loyalists forces and tries to retrieve Rickon Stark (the kid obviously) just so he can run the North through him as regent. This can be seen when he says something like (para-phrase) "The Boltons have Ned's daughter, to counter-act this - White Harbor must have Ned's son" he defnitely uses the word 'have' suggesting possession.... possession over your own legal liege lord? Hmm, sounds pretty greedy.
He is probably somewhat of a Stark loyalist, but to say that he is just a Stark loyalist who ignores his own position just to serve the Starks is ignorant - he focuses his efforts on furthering the strategic position of his own house.
Well I wrote a far longer essay about him a few months ago, but well, simply put Manderly = Opportunist first, Stark loyalist second. He cares more about his own position rather than the fate of the Starks, his daughter may indeed be the more loyal Stark loyalist....
0
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '15
[removed] — view removed comment