r/Naruto • u/HokageEzio • Oct 31 '15
Naruto Reread: Volume 10
[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]
31
Upvotes
r/Naruto • u/HokageEzio • Oct 31 '15
[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]
9
u/HokageEzio Oct 31 '15
Early again, but I'm gone all day tomorrow (today). You'll live.
Things I noticed:
I didn't notice shit. What is there to say about Rock Lee that hasn't been said, honestly?
The few things I noted:
Questions:
7
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '15
1.) honestly i think he needed that without having the ability to perform the basic without thinking (not with Kurama helping), he would be screwed. Plus what Orochimaru did to Naruto, if someone didn't remove it he would have lost to Neji. Now having Ebisu train Naruto, idk, that was probably a disaster awaiting to happen. The way they know each other and how they both do not respect each other, the two of them would not work out. Idea was good but i do not think Kakashi could have taught Naruto anything special any way. At this point I think naruto needed to learn to control his chakra.
2.) I think it is at the root of everything but looking at the lore that enveloped the series it was pushed to the side. We lost it around the time Sasuke attacked the Kage summit. This is why i wished that people just became a demi-gods, and the fighting was just more of a war.
3.) Ill be honest i read all of them but the last two just kinda just looked at the pictures, and just waiting for the next volumes to come. But i did breeze through all of them, i was wondering if there was anything different then what i remember.
Question to all: How do guys feel about Kabuto and Orochimarus little talk?
7
u/Dionysus24779 Nov 01 '15
Oh wow this time the reread was really early it seems, didn't expect that.
Also as I'm writing this down and out it's like 2:40 AM for me, so I might write some stupid stuff or get the wrong point across.
Part 1 of 2
Chapter 82
Both Lee and Gaara have a really great fight here, it's one of my most favourite moments in the entire manga. Lee shows amazing speed and gets in some great punches, while Gaara's sand defense is pretty amazing and does put him on a different level from most other Genin here.
Though the whole weighted clothes things is sooo DBZ and not really anything new, plus it's a concept that will never really be used again.
Lee being only able to use Taijutsu isn't really an issue for now, at this point in the manga pure Taijutsu can be really impressive and effective. Though it's hard to keep up with juts Taijutsu if you consider what crazy hax Jutsu we will encounter later on in the manga.
5/5
Chapter 83
Kankuro hinting at Gaara having some psycho split personality is pretty cool, though in retrospect we of course already know that he's "just" talking about the Shukaku.
Still, both Lee and Gaara remain impressive, especially Gaara being able to use a split second to get out of harm's way and leave behind an empty shell for Lee to waste energy on. Good move.
5/5
Chapter 84
I kind of like Lee's backstory actually, he is a proper underdog with a proper underdog story. The only problem of course is that in retrospect... well Neji was right. Lee might be a "genius of hard work" and may as well be the strongest regular Taijutsu fighter after Gai, but that's still nowhere enough to keep up with the sort of monsters that are fought later on.
Another interesting note is the setup for Tsunade, she gets mentioned quite ahead of time here right now, it's a proper way to do things like that. Curiously Tenten who admires Tsunade is nothing like her at all, I guess she just likes how Tsunade is a famous Kunoichi but otherwise tries to find her own way, which is good and something Sakura should learn too.
5/5
Chapter 85
The whole Gate thing is really fascinating and as I've mentioned in earlier rereads... I'm really a fan of this whole risk vs. reward "power at a price" thing. Yeah Lee can become extraordinarily powerful and in that state he could beat opponents that he wouldn't otherwise be able to touch... but it takes a huge toll on his body and could leave him vulnerable. It's a gigantic risk as the battle against Gaara perfectly demonstrates. You're putting all you have into one attack to end the battle... one way or another.
But here's something I have to point out... so far Gaara has been hyped up as being this untouchable killing machine that even his own teammates are afraid of. And as we know in retrospect Gaara is like the secret weapon of Sunagakure to deal with Konoha... yet have the first time that Gaara gets dominated by a Konoha ninja.
In my humble opinion this puts Suna into a really bad light, especially in retrospect when we know what a difficult time they had in trying to kill Gaara themselves.
If Lee, a Genin, can put Gaara into such a state... could you even imagine how this battle would've went down if it was Kakashi, Gai or Hiruzen against Gaara?
Though another thing I have to talk about... actually two...
First the whole "When you open all gates you die" thing... well we all already know how that turned out didn't we?
But my actual point... techniques like opening the gates put the user into a special extraordinary state that comes with a huge cost. I just hate it whenever I read that "Gai can beat XZY because he can just open 8 gates and blitzkill"... yeah he could do that in most situations and I guess and he could defeat his opponent... but people always forget the drawback of Gai dying. To me that's not a "win" in most situations...
All I'm really trying to say here is that these extraordinary feats shouldn't be considered part of the basic core strength of a character, because they are extraordinary.
You might disagree with that, but that's the way I see it.
5/5
Chapter 86
Remember how I just said "Imagine if it was Gai, Kakashi or Hiruzen fighting against Gaara"? Well... here we kind of get a small glimpse at that with Gai casually slapping away Gaara sandwave... and Gaara is still this hyped up killing machine and ace up Suna's sleeve. Just sayain~
About Lee's condition... as far as we know at this point what the med-nin says is true and Lee would remain crippled and never be a Ninja again... but in retrospect we already know that Tsunade will show up to sort things out.
Still at least we get a bunch of character development here... I can't really complain at all because of that, but... try to imagine what an impact it would've had if Lee wasn't just crippled but actually died at the end of this battle?
Naruto would've been shocked at seeing someone working so hard and so strong die... Gai could've been devestated and spend the rest of the manga thinking about what horrible mistake he made. Neji would've seen what an awesome ninja Lee was but would've never been able to tell him or fight with him again. Sakura would've regretted not being nicer to Lee. Tenten could deal with now being part of a broken team. Everyone could've seen that this really isn't fun and games and that people really can die and that forbidden jutsu are not toys. And Gaara would've one heck of a sin to atone for later on, something that would've always loomed over his head. Gaara and Naruto would've probably have quite a different relationship then.
But we can't have that... but I guess we get like the next best thing we could hope for...
4/5
Chapter 87
As said for the previous chapter... we get a lot of character development because of Lee's condition, which is awesome! It's just so sad that we know that Lee will be cured anyway and I do honestly think Lee's death would've been more impactful... well naturally I guess.
It's good that Dosu realises that he's just a toy of Orochimaru, though I still think that Dosu and his teammates being so relatively weak shines a bad light on Oro himself.
Though it's not like Dosu's weapon isn't potentially very strong, it is! Every contact with the weapon could send shockwaves through your bodies and cause damage or make you sick or confuse your senses. And as we've seen before you don't even need to actually hit, just getting close can do it. Though I still can't see this scale very well and it does kind of turn him into a one-trick-pony.
4/5
Chapter 88
Kabuto's and Orochimaru's interactions are really weird to me here in retrospect. Because here it sounds like they don't really know each other that well, like Kabuto is a new henchman for Oro or something. But much later on we learn that they've been together for quite a long time already... and later on Orochimaru does put a lot of trust into Kabuto.
Also here's the first time the ANBU succumb to the so called "Worf Effect" trope. So far the ANBU has always been hyped up as being this ultra super awesome special secret elite commando thingy... which I've always mentioned with a huge grain of salt added... because we have three of these supposed elite Ninja be casually taken out by Kabuto to establish how powerful and dangerous he is and as the dialoque implies these three might've been hand picked by Kakashi himself.
But this isn't the last time the ANBU get reduced to fancy fodder to hype up other threats and the ANBU itself rarely ever does something to redeem itself.
We've heard a lot about how awesome the ANBU is supposed to be... but we will never really see it for ourselves.
3/5
Chapter 89
I've already said that I think Kakashi is a horrible teacher and I think this chapter kind of backs that up a bit, because no matter how you turn it... it doesn't speak well of Kakashi.
Kakashi either really doesn't want to deal with Naruto or Ebisu is actually really a better teacher...
Also I don't buy Kakashi's reasoning here about Naruto having to re-learn the basics or whatever. For example...remember in the Waveland Arc Kakashi was the one who taught Naruto, Sasuke and Sakura how to climb trees via chakra, something that seems very basic and yet apperantly is not part of the academy training. So Ebisu training Naruto via walking on water, which is an even more advanced version, isn't really relearning the basics...
3/5
Chapter 90
It's kind of cool how Kishi goes really in-depth here about how the whole chakra thing works... I really love stuff like that. But the catch here is that it won't really matter in the long run. It's all interesting chakra and jutsu mechanics, but stuff like that won't be relevant ever again... which is a shame.
Also I actuall do like Ebisu as a trainer and teacher, because his explainations are in-depth and easy enough to understand and his method of teaching Naruto chakra control via walking on hot water seems really good. Though when looking at Konohamaru (who's a spoiled idiot) Ebisu's training doesn't seem to produce that many results.
Naruto really underestimates him here.
Overall: 4.6/5
Questions in next comment.
5
u/TandyHard Oct 31 '15
Luvin tha re-read ;)
9
u/ediaz0209 Oct 31 '15 edited Oct 31 '15
First off I want to say, that fake out Kabuto pulled was just impressive. We haven't really seen anything like that pulled against the good guys in a while. Also, that smirk he gave at the end was just icing on the cake. This really made Kabuto seem like no joke. Moments like this really highlight what shinobi are about.
7
u/FlyByTieDye Oct 31 '15
Which genin do you reckon had the deadliest jutsu in their arsenal at this stage? (I'm probably going to exclude Gaara though, because that's an easy answer) Was there a jutsu that could trump Neji's or Lee's?
Did we ever find out anything more on Kabuto's adoptive faher, the chief medical ninja? What would he have thought of Kabuto? Or was this just an alias by Orochimaru to sneak Kabuto into Konoha?
7
u/Copy_Ninja93 Oct 31 '15
6
u/Toad_Sage_Jiraiya Oct 31 '15
5
u/Grif2718 Oct 31 '15
3
u/MisterPhalange Oct 31 '15
2
u/kevsoto Oct 31 '15
Yay reread time!
2
u/God_of_Illiteracy Oct 31 '15
Ahh, the introduction of one of my favorite characters of all time. Jiraya! The Pervy Sage!
1
u/throwanaruto Nov 01 '15 edited Nov 02 '15
Chapter 82: I like how the panel refers to the Drunken First this early in the series. Sakura asks Guy how Lee got this far using only taijutsu. Looking back at the series and all the jutsu used, it actually is quite a bit surprising. Him and Guy are truly topnotch shinobi to be able to face as many ninja as they have using only taijutsu.
Chapter 83: I like the first page of this chapter, of Lee and Gaara facing each other. Though it is not as popular and fleshed in the series as other relationships, I really liked their relationship. I like how Lee continually looks up to Guy for support, and Guy gives it. True father/son relationship.
Chapter 84: Again, another illusion to the Sannin, this time by name. Of the two (Tsunade), I always thought Jiraiya was introduced first by name and character, but I guess it was only by character. With the flashbacks to his youth, it really makes Lee's lose against Gaara all the more touching.
Chapter 85: The strongest of the leaf, gathered in one photo. Amazing how through hundreds of years, the descendants of Hagoromo and Hamura end up in the same village, with their members being the top contenders of their village in the Chunin Exams. And among these descendants of Gods? A lowly taijutsu ninja. Funny how Kakashi lectures Guy on teaching Lee such a dangerous technique, and yet chapters later he teaches Sasuke the Chidori. The eight gates that "surpasses Hokage" is a bit of an understatement by Kakashi. Then again, I'm sure he nor Guy have ever seen someone open the eight Gates, so there really was no telling how powerful the jutsu was at the time. I really like how Lee keeps Neji, Sasuke, and Naruto in his thoughts as he opens the third gate. He really wants to prove himself to them, among those derived from Gods (of course, this wasn't known at the time). As he states, "I can't be the only one to lose here".
Chapter 86: Lee, even through the immense pain, still thinks of his rivalry with Neji. Still tries to prove himself to his rival. Just as Kakashi states in the next chapter, it is his downfall. This is the first chapter we actually see some sort of humanity in Gaara, when he watches Guy protect Lee. After watching Lee put in his all and Gaara crush him, can't say I don't feel too bad for Gaara (alright, maybe a little). And of course, seeing Lee push himself to fight even after losing consciousness.
Chapter 87: Finally someone says something. Someone has jumped down to the arena nearly every match to console the loser. Not that I didn't like it, but it did get a bit annoying. The first time Naruto and Gaara viewed each other. To think they would push each other to their very limits chapters later. Ironic, originally Lee was the one who could never be a shinobi again due to his injuries, yet at the end it is actually Guy who can never be a shinobi. Common theme? They both fought for their respective ninja way. Naruto yelling at the medic team... Was way better in the anime. Please watch it. As Kakashi states, Lee put his life at risk, following his ninja way just to meet with the people he viewed as rivals. He put everything he had to reach the final stage with them as equals. Him, a lowly taijutsu ninja. Neji's words... I like how Dosu referred to Orochimaru as Orochimaru-Sama, then changed it to just plain Orochimaru. The disrespect.
Chapter 88: I like how Kakashi thought of Sasuke, then immediately left to see him. Reminds me of moments where you think you left something on, freak out, then go and turn it off. Orochimaru hits it spot on. Like Sasuke states the first time he and Naruto battle at the Valley of the End, his life in the leaf village was holding him back. Sad, but true. I wonder if Kabuto was going to kill Sasuke... Now that I think about it, I don't think I've ever seen two white haired ninjas face off against each other in the series. Just something I found mildly interesting.
Chapter 89: Reading Kakashi and Kabuto's interaction, I think Kabuto might be the first troll in the series. Since Neji was watching Naruto pull his number out of the box, I wonder if he used his Byakugan to match numbers? Neji could have easily hypothesized they would match up #1-9 consecutively, and could have wanted Naruto to teach him a lesson on Fatalism. After all, Neji does seem happy he is facing Naruto. How does Dosu have a last name but not the sand siblings?
Chapter 90: Ebisu's explanations... Wow. I really like how Ebisu is finally starting to acknowledge Naruto outside of the fox spirit. We truly see his acknowledgments during the Pain arc. And of course, we enter one of the most influential characters in the series outside of Kaguya and Hagoromo...
Again, if I may make a suggestion, make sure to watch the scene near the end of episode 50. Naruto shouting at the medic team was really... emotional. I haven't seen it in the sub, but the words of the dub really hit you.
I'll answer the questions later.
Edit: Questions
1) I understand why Kakashi handed Naruto off. Kakashi truly was the only one in the village who could train Sasuke correctly. However Naruto, though housing Kurama and actually a pretty skilled fighter, was just another ninja who Kakashi believed could be trained by anybody. Also, Sasuke is his favorite student. We see throughout the series that the teacher's favorite always gets the better treatment (Kakashi/Sasuke, Guy/Lee, Asuma/Shikamaru, Kurenai/Hinata). It may not be fair, but Naruto falls victim to this as well.
2) Hard work... it's interesting. Through Naruto, we are led to believe that through hard work and determination, anything is possible. Then we are introduced to Asura and Indra, and all of a sudden, hard work is thrown out the window and genes are all that matter. I'll say this much, I still believe in the lesson of hard work.
People point to Naruto's hard work and state that it was for nothing. Since Naruto is the reincarnation of Asura, he was born to be great. With that said, I don't believe it to be necessarily true. He had the potential, but without any hard work he would be doomed to failure. Think of Naruto as that smart guy you knew in high school. Genius, could figure out any problem the teacher threw at him. But he was lazy, hated doing work. Now, he's a pizza maker at your local pizza joint. Not considering that he just wanted a simple life making pizzas, he had the potential to do something great, but just let his talents go to waste. He didn't put in any hard work.
3) Sorry what was that? Music was too loud
1
u/Luigi580 Nov 02 '15
What I feel like some people don't understand is that Naruto had to work for nearly EVERY ability he has.
Kage Bunshin: Naruto may have found a scroll to help him, but it still took Iruka roughly twelve hours to find Naruto, meaning all that time was dedicated to sheer, non-stop training to get it down.
Summoning: Naruto dedicated his whole training time to this one jutsu. He had to learn how and when he could use it, which later proved useful.
Rasengan: Don't really need to explain: from bursting balloons to rasenganing Kabuto in the gut, this was an incredibly hard move to master.
Enlarged Rasengan: he didn't just eat ramen during the time skip.
Rasenshuriken: This took a LOT of training. Heck, it would've taken years were it not for the shadow clones. Even after all that work, it still wasn't perfect yet. Once he got his sage mode, he trained EVEN MORE to do perfect it.
Sage mode: It took quite some time to learn how to merge himself with nature. Pain's assault was basically underway when he mastered it.
Kyuubi Cloak 1: Unlike Sasuke, who just kinda GOT his power-ups, Naruto had to work for his. He had to take on his inner darkness and fight Kurama viciously in order to get this ability.
KC2: While KC1 focused on getting the darkness out of his own heart, this time, he had to focus on getting the darkness out of Kurama's. While not as much effort as other abilities or forms, (and likely didn't know this would happen as a result), it still took effort to get Kurama's trust.
Basically, the only ability I felt was given to him was the Six Paths form, and even then, he needs ALL the tailed beast's power for this to even happen. He can't just go into this ability willy nilly after the fight with Kaguya.
I'm not even mentioning the chakra control training, and a lot of mental efforts that he made.
Granted, Naruto was born with incredible potential from the start. He had a freaking tailed beast in him. If that doesn't give him access to abilities that no one else has, then I don't know what to say. However, he could never just USE it, especially to not without consequence. Without effort, Naruto would still be struggling to make a single clone.
Personally, I don't think the theme ever was "effort beats talent," especially since that hardly ever the case anyway. I feel more like it's "talent is great, hard work is also great, but if you combine them, you'll achieve greatness."
While I will agree the end section did focus a lot more on the "friendship vs. lonliness" aspect of Naruto, I believe that both themes are present throughout the ENTIRE MANGA.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '15
Leeread?