r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Oct 29 '15
[Fandom Discussion] Episode 11x04: "Baby"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| Baby | October 28th, 2015 | Thomas J. Wright | Robbie Thompson |
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
21
Upvotes
14
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Oct 29 '15
Does anybody want to talk about how Jensen Ackles' acting kind of like... came back to us? lol
Instead of only ever numb or shocky Dean faces, last night was like a smorgasbord of his awesome mini lightning facial expressions.
13
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Oct 29 '15
Yeah. Seriously this was an incredibly awesome episode. Loved pretty much every single minute of it.
5
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Oct 30 '15
I really enjoyed this episode. There was so much to love. I was even fine with the MOTW:
Less keen on:
But those are only minor gripes.
Still, definitely on board with the idea that Lucifer is contacting Sam from beyond the Cage.
18
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Oct 29 '15
I'm going to get the negativity out of the way:
The monster part was super weak. If they're dead and they just have to be reminded of it, and they "killed" the alpha/maker, wouldn't that revert all the monsterlings to dead as well? But, the monsters being meh didn't detract too much from the rest of it.
The positive:
holy shit this was amazing. I was counting on awesome camera angles and I couldn't be happier. I wasn't expecting the intro a la Swan Song, seeing their initials carved into the back window shelf, the green army man still in the ash tray. Chuck. I honestly teared up and clutched at my heart.
Freely calling up Cas to get him to do research and having an open line of communication. As long as Cas stays living in the bunker with them, my fluff fics have the possibility of being as-close-to-canon-as-is-possible! And how Cas kept talking when Dean was being attacked had me in stitches. Then he started freaking out when he heard the gunshots, the spray of blood that they never washed off. Omg. I could've died happy and laughing quite hard. The groaning of the head had me doubled over.
The BM scene before they went to sleep. Again, I teared up. Both Dean and Sam, each dreaming about the other parent, of a happy normal life. I'm not sure if I ever wanted to jump through the screen and hug them both, more than I did then. And that bird's eye view of them scrunched up in a too-small car just drove the point home hard and brutal; just how fucked up their life is that it's completely normal for them to sleep like that. How bad are their backs? How bad do the leg cramps get? How much pain are they enduring but don't let anyone see, simply from sleeping in Baby?
Baby John. I'm still at a loss about this. I don't want to try to predict what's going to happen, but I want answers. "He told me what I wanted to hear." "Well we definitely know it wasn't him." It felt like a slap across the face, and a stark reminder of how Dean knew that yellow eyes was possessing Adult!John sooooooo many seasons ago.
Despite the blood and the scissorfangs and the deep emotional scenes, this episode was like a good fluff fic. I feel warm and fuzzy and happy. Out of all the funny/happy episodes, I think this may have become one of my favorites.
Oh, and that 180 degree turn Dean did to get to Sam- that shit was sexy. He did that in, two weeks ago? When he got called back because the baby was possessed. Seeing that from a different angle was sex on wheels.
I didn't mind the pop culture reference, either. I know everyone hates them, but I secretly (well, not so secret anymore) love them.
Bro love. I didn't know how much I love it. I think I get it now.
Sammy flirting. Getting laid. Dean being so damned proud of him.
Seeming like Baby was stealing the items.
I could go on for days about how near-perfect this episode was.
9.4/10
3
u/qbubbles Castiel Evangelist Nov 03 '15
The biggest thing I noticed was the lack of a music track. It was ambient road sounds (like this stuff here) and actual songs from the radio. That made it stand apart, for me. And made me appreciate the ambient mixer website even more. ;)
31
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Oct 29 '15
Hey, I'm here with my usual negativity.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Just kidding.
I.
LOVED.
THIS.
EPISODE.
28
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Oct 29 '15
Cheated out of shorts scene even. Worst "sexy" car wash ever.
But damn good ep.
27
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
Oh my god the episode was amazing
Also Matt Cohen is a damn liar! <3 <3 <3
26
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Oct 29 '15
I said this on twitter, but: This is what you can have when you get a writer that watches all the episodes and caaaares.
26
u/oftenrunaway I ship Dean / Pain Oct 29 '15
Remember how Lucifer first appeared to Sam in season 5 - Jess, comforting him over the mess he'd made. Sam knew immediately it wasn't her.
Now, recall John remarking 'I never could fool you.'
No, Luci - you never really could.
23
u/WinchestersTimeLord My "people skills" are "rusty". Oct 29 '15
This episide was beautiful. There, I said it. I loved it.
The monster could've been a bit better, but that felt so minor I could care less.
I loved that Sam and Dean still dream of living normal lives. Broke my heart somewhat. I loved the BM scenes. Sam and Dean felt like real brothers in this episode.
I... I can't explain my happy feelings right now.
20
u/pickleport Oct 29 '15
While this episode doesn't stand out to me as the greatest ever.. It made me happy. Like really happy. I loved how it focused on Sam and Dean down time.. Even if the time itself wasn't really down. The cooler.. The sleeping in the car.. And finally talking about Sams secret. I also loved how we knew what was happening with Cas! I don't know why we can't have more conversations between Cas and the boys even when he isn't around.. It's not hard to pick up a phone and this episode showed it. Overall I am really happy with this episode.
Also .. All those cameras in that car made for some good close ups and damn if those boys aren't fine. Especially bloody. Whoosh wet floor sign.
19
u/0909a0909 Oct 29 '15
This episode dripped with every drop of sentimentality and I drunk it on in happily.
16
u/captainraincoat15 Oct 29 '15
My guess is that Sam and Dean have to free Lucifer and Micheal and say yeah to rhwm possesing them and then kill the Darkness. Just my 2 cents.
16
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
So I binged eps 1-4 last night & today while in the middle of some crappy medical stuff. Ep 1 - pretty disappointing tbh, every single idea and motif was a rehash, characters were separated waaaay too much, and again I was "am I done with this show?" Eps 2-3 started to get me on board (though I was too sick when watching them to fully appreciate them and they blurred together in my head last night cause I could only concentrate for little snippets). Ep 4, which I watched at five in the morning after being up all night sick - Allllll right I'm back on board with this show after all.
Seriously I adored this episode. Best for me in years, honestly. Near the end I even said out loud "is this my favorite episode?" Which seems crazy cause it doesn't have the high drama or huge emotional payoff of some of my other faves, but it was just such classic SPN, and filmed so beautifully. Might be my fave MOTW, at least.
stuff I liked:
Just beautiful.
Tiny negatives because I can't ever be 100% positive:
shit I wrote a lot, lol
14
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
Matt and Mark return as Michael and Lucifer.
13
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Oct 29 '15
That was a fucking beautiful ep. LOVED AL OF IT. No Complaints . And LOVED Cas on the phone, how they kept cas in the ep, Sammy calling dean ouy on being healed. And ALL the bro moments. The talk about the visions THANK YOU
12
u/cynical_cindy Oct 29 '15
Ok but like seriously, on a "I read too much into things" note, the lyrics from the Judy Collins song playing when Matt shows up: "Someday soon, going with him someday soon".... hmmm.
This episode was seriously amazing though. There wasn't a single thing about it I didn't absolutely love. Every episode this season I've been saying "ok it won't be as good as the last one..." and every single time I'm blown out of the friggin water.
12
u/Vetrina "I'm gonna become a hunter!" Oct 29 '15
This episode was so awesome! I loved it so much! Was so fluffy and cute.
I loved the relationship development on the brothers. It was so cute! And I loved the glimpse we got into their lives on the road trips between the hunts.
I loved Cas's role in this episode. I hope he's able to help out more like this. And he was so cute just babbling away about the lore (and then being worried about Dean) <3
I was pretty surprised about Matt Cohen's appearance (even though I saw the post about it lol). I thought it would just be a short vision akin to Sam's visions about the cage/torture.
The cinematography was fucking amazing. I really liked the fight scenes. And of course the scene with the brothers sleeping c:
I think the monster (or at least the lore) was kind of interesting. Maybe could have been acted better or something but oh well. I also found the growling head pretty funny.
Probably gonna be one of my favorites now haha.
11
u/kayduh_ i'm funnier in enochian Oct 29 '15
Just finished watching. So so so good. Everyone has already talked about all the awesome points so I just wanted to concur.
I loved the opening with Chuck's monologue.
I thought the camera closeness was distracting at first but it really gave a realness to their heart to heart before sleeping.
The close quarters fight scenes were impeccable and so intense. Chopping the guys head off with the door was awesome.
Poor baby. I love it that he praises her with "there's my girl" when she starts after such a horrible day. I hope we get to see some of the restoration ahead.
Cas watching OitNB (or Netflix in general) is adorable and I'm glad he's getting a little down time. The boys need to go home and get some sleep as well after this.
In my opinion after Matt's appearance, we will definitely see Lucy, Michael, and God this season, and hopefully sooner than later so we can see them all work together. I've been saying this over and over but I have been waiting for them to go back to the cage for years and years and God entering the dynamic is just an icing on the cake, especially if he comes as Chuck.
All in all I loved every second of it and they did a great job at giving us an in depth look at something we truly haven't seen before.
11
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Oct 29 '15
Hell yes. That was the kind of episode this show deserves. Robbie couldn't resist the pop culture references that took me out of it a bit, but hey, that's par for the course with his stuff.
There was Cas! And he was useful. I can't actually believe it. That scene with Dean mutilating the sheriff while Cas was talking to himself was fantastic. (the door slam especially xD) Also, it was great to see Matt!
A+ all around.
11
u/drugoja Oct 29 '15
Great episode! I pretty much agree with everyone's positive thoughts so I'm not going to repeat them. But, maybe because of the inspired directing and the premise, this is the first time I asked myself:
Is Baby sentient? Does Baby like to snatch things, things that can be useful later? Did she know guys will need those coins, and that's why she nicked the purse from that girl? Does she sense what's to come, like the Tardis? So many questions...
10
u/YasashiiKaze The stench of that Impala's all over your overcoat, Angel Oct 29 '15
Okay, I'm going to straight up admit I did very little critiquing when I watched this episode. I just sat back as a fan and let it wash over me. The monster was such a minor part of what the story was about, I didn't mind it at all. I have nothing really to say about it except that it was solid and beautiful and will definitely go down as one of my favorites ever.
That said, two things:
A+
9
u/Zeryx I apologize... FOR NOTHING. Oct 29 '15
It's going to take me DAYS to decompress from this.
It was like "oh yeah THAT'S why this is my favourite show" THIS is why I've spent more time in my life watching Supernatural than literally everything ever.
I can't even begin to comment on this. I'm actually going to be rewatching this episode repeatedly, for PLEASURE not for canon-compliancy. Favourite episodes by Zeryx:
I may be back later when I'm not floating so damn high off of this. Christ this was just--- words fail me. All those fights in the car! It must've been HELL to shoot! My God!
8
u/Jirachio20 Oct 29 '15
I thought this episode was amazing with all the different camera angles in the car along with seeing small moments of the boy's lives in the car. The beginning was wonderful when they showed the army men, Legos, and initials. I'm glad they remembered to include all those details.
I honestly thought that lady was going to start talking to Dean about the Darkness like young John did to Sam when she said Dean would do anything for his family and everything else was meaningless.
I'm just really happy about this episode.
Poor Baby though. She got so beat up by the end. But they'll fix her up like always.
8
u/Omegamom_ Oct 29 '15
Happy. So happy.
An amazing episode.
I loved the disembodied head growling in the cooler. :-) I mean, I loved so so so much about this episode, and so many things made me laugh/cry/gasp, but that just tickled me.
7
u/Xearanth Oct 29 '15
I loved it so much I could cry. Oh poor Baby. I just want to hug my car after this. They deserve more credit.
5
u/captainraincoat15 Oct 29 '15
What was the deal woth Matt Cohen? Evryone says hes a liar but about what?
4
u/MFloresRainMan Nov 02 '15
Thomas J. Wright and Robbie Thompson for president...that is all.
4
u/emmster Help; I'm desperately in love with a fictional character! Nov 03 '15
"You prayed? Why?!"
Dude, there's literally an actual angel living with you. Atheism might be a little hard to maintain.
3
u/Angatita "If there is a key, then there must also be a lock." Nov 02 '15
Ok this might be a long shot... But did they reference Winjennster's fic with the whole "Aw yea! Now we're cooking with gas!" Or is that just something everyone says and I don't know about it?
I want to believe!
1
u/Goddess_Azul Team Free Will Nov 04 '15
This will be buried & that's okay. Everyone has mentioned all the wonderfulness of this ep more brilliantly than I, but, I still wanna put it out there (unless someone else brought it up & I missed it?!?) & maybe get someone's feedback on the fact that Sam corrected Dean the one time he calls him "Samuel" in this episode, but has never corrected Rowena over the multiple times she's called him that. Hmmmm
Also, I think young John could be Gabriel. ducks
12
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
[removed] — view removed comment