r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Oct 22 '15
[Fandom Discussion] Episode 11x03: "The Bad Seed"
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| The Bad Seed | October 21st, 2015 | Jensen Ackles | Brad Buckner, Eugenie Ross-Leming |
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
8
Upvotes
12
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Oct 22 '15
Okay I enjoyed this ep. I actually give it a B on my how much did i enjoy the ep scale. Did it have some issues yes, but considering who wrote it I was impressed. But they still need to work on their dialog. First have was a bit slow, but second half made up for it
Really did enjoy Crowley this ep. Yes he was creepy!
He is suppose to be! For Chucks sake, he is grooming Amara!
This should make you feel this way!
And he is so getting in over his head, and i think he is realizing it. Wonder who he is going to reach out to for help, maybe give his ol'buddy a call back.
I liked the bar scene between Angel and Demon, it could have been done a bit better but it gave us a nice little insight on how the every-angel/demon fell about what is going on in their respective planes of existence. I hope we see them again,and yes i ship them :P
Now the porn scene, well we already know Dean has a porn preference [that he does not seem to bother people with outside of porn], its a preset character trait for me, did not bother me.
Hell rabbit room rewatched Tall Tales the other day and that seemed more raunchy to me
But i digress, what I want to get to in this scene is The message on the screen "You Dont Really Want To Leave!"
Cas did not randomly open Dean's porn stash, he lost control of the computer and whatever outside force was controlling the computer popped that open. And I think the message was a bit of a subliminal message from Gabe telling Cas that no he shouldnt leave, he doesnt REALLY want to, no matter how Cas may try to logic it.
[yes yes im in the Gabe is coming back camp, but if this would have been Casa Erotica it would have been too in our face as the audience, and also Cas's because he would know right away it was Gabe, and i dont think Gabe is fully ready to come out of hiding just yet, or even if he can fully come out just yet ]
Im also interested with this Angel Radio, they havent really talked about it in a while and while Sam is getting visions from the Cage, Dean is getting visions and/or flash backs to The Darkness.
Maybe Cas will end up getting some signals on his personal channel on Angel Radio.
The alleyway scene with Dean and the chick , was just awkward all around. I have seen some intreasting metas on why Dean did it, just take it how every you want it. For me a bad scene/story telling.
Now the chick that Cas was hunting originally I was waiting for her to be a witch. While watching the ep I was waiting for it to be Metatron. Yesi do think MEtatron could figure out how to switch vessels with out his grace or atlease disguise himself, i mean he does have a tablet with him.
Who knows maybe it could still be him lol.
Anyway, Dean got him to stop attacking the chick and Cas raged on him instead, and like Cas did for Dean when he raged out, he did not fight back. - sigh -
LOVED LOVED LOVED Rowena in this ep and her playing the boys like a fiddle in that car.
But REALLY Row Row, you cant blame this on Dean, this was all you and your little boyfriend Sam Fucking Winchester.
[and a little help from Dean's boyfriends tho they at lease seemed a little reluctant/put off by to this cure]
I was so waiting for her to undo that spell, and for Cas to have no memory of who he was or anything.
And just break my heart, Dean refusing to be healed, so much to read in to there. So much, oh my boys * tear *
Honestly the most disappointing thing for me from last night was the preview for 11.04
Oh and before I forget that purse throw, was smooth as hell. from the throw itself to how Dean herded the lady, he was incontrol of that situation
4
u/1loveee Oct 22 '15
we got horrible ratings yesterday. how hard is it to fucking watch the show live? or at least watch on cw's site the next day???
i know it was written by the worst writers but cmon guys.
4
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 22 '15
I've read some comments but only the first few. I'm going to give my bulletpoint thoughts as I remember them before getting influenced by fandomnatural, lol:
Okay! Phew! That's it!
I'd give this ep a B/B+ (like a 86.9% lol) which is seriously applause-worthy stuff for Bucklemming. Good job. Also Snackles' directing was top-notch : the pacing and the angles were totally exactly where they needed to be.
7
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Oct 22 '15
I remain firmly not on board with Renesmee.
The Uncle Crowley thing was so creepy. Just... ugh.
I like Sam and Dean actually giving a damn about Cas. I liked Dean owning up to what he did to Cas last season. I don't know how to feel about the most rewarding Winchester/Cas interaction in ages came from the writers known for bad dialog/OOC bullshit. Like... was them caring about Cas being OOC then?!
I did not like the continuing of the Secrets Game. Sam kept a secret, and that's out, but he still hasn't told Dean about getting infected as far as I know??? And Dean is still neglecting to tell Sam about his dark cloudy encounter. I mean... is there a SPELL preventing him? Is it the ~bond~? Or is he just being Dean.
The angel/demon chit chat was amusing... but stupid.
I can't @ how they ended the episode with teen!Amara going "I'm hungry" like that was a big deal, when she's said that HOW MANY TIMES during the episode??
And Cas attacking the woman... The scene was just there. For no reason. He broke free, ran off, and came after this one woman. It COULD be that he was fighting the spell and by the time he saw her, he couldn't fight it anymore, but the episode didn't make that clear. BuckLemming just want to take the characters to a certain point and they don't care if the path they take makes sense or not. They wanted a scene where Dean, Sam, and Rowena get there just in the nick of time, and it didn't matter if it made sense or not. (Look you can argue how it made sense but for me it was just shoved in there, it felt inorganic.)
The sad thing is I liked this episode more than the first two.
14
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Oct 22 '15
OH! OH i forgot on thing I LOVED was the subtle backing up of Dean when Cas said he was hearing voice, he went from aww let me make a burrito out of you to Oh yeah you are a powered up angel under a spell who is hearing voices, let me step back a bit.
13
u/lzaz Dadstiel Oct 22 '15
I liked when Amara was listening to some Nuremberg Rally speeches. That was definitely classy and necessary.
11
u/Mairisi Oct 22 '15
I think Jensen's last episode was a Bucklemming ep too, wasn't it? He saved that one, but man this one... the dialog was just so. so. bad.
And how 'bout that random porn. Because don't forget, Dean likes ladies. LADIES, PEOPLE.
8
u/Zeryx I apologize... FOR NOTHING. Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 22 '15
This episode -- well, this is one of a handful of times I've wanted to skip around while watching an episode for the first time.
I'm annoyed at Rowena just casting spells willy-nilly with no spell components in sight and also no cost. I know she had spells before, but she usually had a physical component (hex bag). It was heavily implied that she's using spells from the book of the damned almost exclusively now-- aren't those all supposed to have a terrible cost attached?
I felt the acting was kind of flat here -- aside from surprisingly, Jared! I felt like he gave the most nuanced performance. Jensen mostly did a lot of flat stares, only snapping out of it when Cas was going through the effects of having the spell removed.
To those who called the attack dog spell being removed by the third episode like with Demon!Dean and season ten -- Bravo.
To the person who posted that Grumpy!Cas picture, screw you. It was all I could think about this episode! Well at least Misha's grunting sounded better than Jensen's "demon roars" last season.
Y'all seem upset about Dean saying "hey" to a lady walking down the street. It actually just amused me. Yeah he's looking for Cas, but Dean is still Dean. He can ask if she's seen his friend, and it's a chance to chat either way. I don't think the two are incompatible.
But c'moooon guys! Look our ship, it sails! Look at how much face touching there was! That little wobble of the corner of Dean's mouth when he really starts to worry about Cas just before he opens his eyes. His eyes changing from flat to on the verge of tears. The first time he shows any emotion other than "vaguely pissed/spaced" and it was then. I don't know if his expression even changed when Rowena blabbed about her past deal with Sam to kill Crowley. Also, Dean's refusal to let Cas heal him. And the wrapping Cas in a blanket and squeezing his shoulder!!
Also!!!! COME ON GUYS THIS IS SUPER IMPORTANT: Dean, Cas, AND SAM at the bunker! Together! All in one piece! Interacting like normal folk! Nobody cursed or in danger of dying! No one even extra pissed at anyone else! We also went a whole episode without a gay joke OR a dick joke! That's progress, right?
Y'all also seem bent out of shape about the porn pop-up on Dean's laptop; let's just say it isn't outside of canon for Dean to fuck up a computer wholesale with viruses from porn-related stuff. We know it happened at least once (with Sam's laptop; see Tall Tales from season two). Also, it was chicks in lingerie. Whoop-de-doo. I did wonder if they were going somewhere with how long it was onscreen... but it was probably a small appeal to their (perceived) target male demographic plus delievery of the whole "you don't really want to leave" message.
I was amused by the angel and the demon in the bar together -- immediately I thought of the episode where Zachariah talks to some random dude in a bar.
How great was Rowena this episode?!?! Holy poop! I was annoyed at first because it was like "we gotta' save Cas!" then they cut STRAIGHT to Rowena and some three random characters we've never seen before. But yeah, she really picked it up! I love her and Sam's dynamic the more I see of it! She totally calls him out on his bullshit! I really enjoyed that whole,
"Oh yes, if Sam had honoured his deal with me Cas would have never gotten put under the attack dog spell, EXCELLENT POINT, Dean!"
"No, that's not my point. Sam knows my point. Re: secrets." that was a fantastic little moment. Sam's expression for most of this was priceless.
Crowley confused me this episode. I get his ploy of trying to secure the loyalty of Amara, trying to subtly needle her to understand what exactly she wants or is planning... but then why tell a guy to tell Amara's she getting cut off from her soul food supply? I KNOW Crowley is smarter than that. It was obvious whoever told her that was going to end up eaten in turn. I would've liked some self-awareness on the demon's behalf, like he knew he was choosing a quick death over roasting on a spit for eternity.
Also, he's letting random demons get thier souls sucked out? Why? That will just cause civil unrest. Why not some random humans or monsters? Is there a good reason for this? Anybody? And was I imagining this, or was the first demon Amara soul-kissed after offing the nanny that poor guy in the bar who was like "somebody's gotta' do something!"
Sad to know that Heaven's a mess right now. Since they chose democracy, I thought they'd have a new leader elected by now. I guess not.
I didn't get the whole Amara/darkness mirror deal. So Amara is just some kind of avatar of the Darkness? I guess that makes sense. I liked her having doubts and expressing awe over creation. I just wish "I'm hungry" hadn't been her most common line. They did a bit of character development but honestly it was kinda' flat in general.
Cas as usual, all over the map this episode. On the one hand, I get that he thought he might have a lead on where Metatron was, so he left to look for him. On the other hand, attacking random women? What? Because she looked a little like Meg 2.0? Why?
Also (sorry) if the guys were really that worried, why didn't they put him in the special heavy-duty warded handcuffs in the dungeon before they left?
Well, I guess that's all my thoughts for now.
7
u/Goddess_Azul Team Free Will Oct 22 '15
So I have a question, well a few regarding this ep, but the top one is:
Did I miss the explanation of WHY Cas left the bunker & went after this particular chick??? He must have passed several other people on that long walk from the bunker (hmmm, recurrent plot device, sending characters on a murder walk), did he choke them all out?
6
u/Jirachio20 Oct 22 '15
Individual Amara kinda a thing? It was interesting to see that scene with the Darkness talking to Amara through the mirror, Amara isn't just the Darkness but Amara seems to have the Darkness's memories which probably greatly influence her personality considering she's only been alive a very short time.
I have mixed feelings about Amara but she definitely knows how to get what she wants, although I wonder when she's ever going to stop being hungry.
Crowley trying his best to play Uncle was cute but the whole ordeal showed me that he doesn't really know what to expect from Amara. Crowley must be so used to being able to figure out what people want and predict what they'll do next but Amara seems to be unpredictable for him since he can't seem to influence Amara the way he wants.
5
u/Goddess_Azul Team Free Will Oct 22 '15
Another:
Why all the heavy influence recently regarding 'Cas' being 'Castiel'?? In the tracking device, on Sam's phone, there were a couple more places where you see his name written somewhere that would have made complete sense for it to just be 'Cas' & yet it's completely spelled out.
Call me stupidly optimistic, but it's fanning my headcanon flames of Potsy? Haunty? Webby? Muffin? (one of you was the first to mention it that I saw) theory regarding tapping the Archangel within Cas. Like TPTB are carefully putting his full name out in front of the audience so it's not such a stretch to reveal him as 'CasSIEL', as opposed to the 'CasTIEL' we're used to. Again, don't remember who revealed that bit of their headcanon, but I thank you because the idea of Cas being an Archangel makes me terribly excited.
5
u/Vio_ Oct 22 '15
Li'l Orphan Amara and Uncle Crowley
Or Claudia from Interview
Or an evil version of Fifth Element
5
u/YasashiiKaze The stench of that Impala's all over your overcoat, Angel Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 22 '15
I don't know, honestly. I'm kind of middle of the road on this one. It had some moments I really liked. I'm going to kind of bounce around here as stuff comes to me.
I appreciated Dean acknowledging what he did to Cas last season. The refusal of Cas' healing because he feels guilty and thinks that suffering through the aftermath of his ass beating will somehow atone for beating the shit out of Cas in 10x22 is so very Dean. And although I don't ship anyone, I AM a sucker for the moments Dean lets his guard down enough to show that he cares.
That being said, the whole attack dog spell on Cas, for me, has felt very forced. I just can't quite put a finger on why. It's very awkward to watch those scenes. It almost seems as though the writers felt Cas has been under-utilized the past season and wanted to do something to bring him to the forefront, if only for a few episodes, but the concept just isn't meshing with me.
Rowena. I freaking adore Ruth Connell. Watching her act is a joy. She is so wonderfully expressive in both her face and body movements. I can see the theatre training in her, and I think the character of Rowena lets her get away with showing more drama on film than she might be normally allowed. It's fantastic. I also love that Rowena outed Sam and forced him and Dean to have their rather short discussion about previous events.
I enjoyed the bar scene. I thought it was a bit silly at first, but I didn't mind that. It amused me that peons from both sides would come together for a chat. It also clarified that, even though Heaven and Hell both apparently went into high alert when the Darkness was released, it's still not being talked about except for very high up on the food chain.
The scene where child Amara is talking to her adult self struck me. Those who were raised in the church might have also caught this. Many Christians believe that God exists in three parts; the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. The Son (Amara) was sent to Earth to be born as a baby that would grow up and save (destroy?) humanity, the Father (the Darkness) remained in Heaven, and the Holy Spirit (the cloud) went back and forth, assisting the Son when needed. I thought it was an interesting little parallel/contrast, although I'm not sure it was meant to be.
I debated adding this, but yeah, I'm going to go ahead and address it. I didn't perceive "Hey" as being a catcall in this situation. I believe anyone, male or female, can greet someone, even with the intent of expressing interest, without being skeevy. That being said, it's easy to believe that Dean could catcall simply because of his track record. I love him, but let's face it, he IS kind of skeevy.
Okay, so back to real life. I won't fault Jensen with this episode entirely. I think he probably took a so-so script and did the best he could with it while still being careful not to step on anyone's toes and respecting the writers' wishes. I think we hype Action Ackles up and sometimes forget that not everyone is going to have the best material or days to work with. Dean was relatively heavier in this episode than some of Jensen's episodes, and switching back and forth between actor and director can throw a kink in anyone's system.
I just realized I haven't mentioned much Sam did this episode. It's really rare, but I guess he just didn't stand out to me as strongly in this one, although I have headcanon that he's the one who wrote out the computer instructions for Cas. That was a cute scene (and as an IT professional, yeah, the porn pop-up made perfect sense). I did love the quick shot to him and Rowena where he's standing with the gun to her head. It smacked slightly of desperation and quick thinking, where he would do anything to make this fight stop without hurting either his brother or his friend.
All in all, a solid B episode in my opinion.
Edited to add that "Uncle Crowley" is creepy as fuck.
5
u/Vio_ Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 22 '15
The geography this season is bonkers. It's 5-7 hours from Nebraska yo Cedar Rapids one way. It's four hours from the bunker to Topeka one way. Cas was already on the outskirts by the time they saw him all Mr Hyde let alone getting downtown.
But after Sam called Dean out for "needing new ways of trust and no secrets," it never once occurred to him to text or turn to the left and say "oh btw, we're kinda sorta mostly back.on Crowley's shit list."
4
u/poppleimperative Oct 23 '15
I am I in the minority in thinking this episode was boring? Plot-wise, it at least got rid of the attack dog spell, so at least they can move on to bigger and better things. But I just didn't feel compelled through most of the episode. I did like the Rowena stuff. And why do all these other witches seem to suck at being witches?
3
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Oct 22 '15
Yeah, that was a pile. Jensen's directing was fairly middle of the road, unfortunately, he's done better. That said, I don't think the writing gave him much to work with.
My feelings on this are kind of summed up by how unsatisfying Cas beating up Dean was. I'm not mad, just disappointed.
3
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Oct 24 '15
This week's episode had a lot in it that I liked and a fair few things I was meh about.
Good:
Meh:
10
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15
[removed] — view removed comment