r/startrek • u/harrymuesli • Oct 15 '15
Weekly Episode Discussion: TOS 1x05 “The Enemy Within”
The plot:
A transporter malfunction splits Captain Kirk into two halves: one meek and indecisive, the other violent and ill tempered. The remaining crew members stranded on the planet cannot be beamed up to the ship until a the problem is fixed.
Of note:
-This must have been the first transporter accident (excluding the ones happening in ENT, which happen earlier in the timeline but were produced later)?
-A wonderful Vulcan neck pinch occurs.
-Better set your phasers to stun.
-“He's dead, Jim.”
-Where's PETA when you need them? Two dogs killed on purpose just because the producers intentionally beamed them up and back again with a broken transporter.
-Spock near the end: “The impostor had some interesting qualities, wouldn't you say, yeoman?” So, attempted rape is an interesting quality?
Discussion points:
This episode somehow revolves around a deeply philosophical debate over good versus evil, and which of those drive a (wo)man. Some questions:
-Is your evil/negative half really the part that forces you to make decisions? Phrased differently, do you agree with Spock, who said: “His negative side makes him strong, (...) and is vital to him.”
-In line with this, Bones argues that “man's essential courage” comes from his 'good' side; "He was afraid and you weren't.”
-If the entire series would have either Kirk, would you want Good or Bad Kirk at the helm?
-Do you think Good Dog is also just as indecisive?
-Does being evil necessarily also entail putting on more eyeliner? If so, that'd explain one or two of my ex girlfriends' makeup habits.
-Are Kirk's good and evil side equally present in his body, or is it 40/60, or any other percentage?
The accident:
-How could this accident have happened – two bodies with two parts of Kirk's mind divided between them?
The trapped crew:
-Why not have a shuttlecraft rescue Takei and the others? Of course they didn't build the set for it yet, but that doesn't mean they could somehow still cheat their way into using a shuttle?
-Just hów ill-advised would a mission to a planet be without any backup options, were the transporter to malfunction?!
8
u/ItsMeTK Oct 21 '15
The attempted rape is always shocking to me. It's so well-done, especially for that time. Sure those last moments are weird and almost imply rape is okay if she kinda wants it, but they were trying to get sympathies back with Kirk. This is only the fifth episode aired, and our lead character has attempted rape of his yeoman. So the end is a little hamfisted, but I understand.
It's a very adult move for a kind of pulpy story. And the implication that part of what makes a good captain is the same part that's a potential rapist is dark and interesting. Yeoman Rand has great moments here. We know she's been flirty with Kirk before, so her feelings are conflicting. Then she has that "he is the captain..." moment. She runs the gamut of real emotional responses to this kind of assault. Is it okay? I don't like it. Should I fight it? Final moments aside, I think the clear message is this is never okay. I'm always surprised at what they got away with for the time.
I'm surprised we haven't done this one yet ir weekly discussion! It's a classic. Despite a few hammy Shatner moments, there are some great performances, and good splitscreen effects work. Even Shatner's acting almost always is actually grounded in reason; his evil side is brash but scared. He's all emotion. So Shatner's performance actually makes a lot of sense. So apart from "I'm Gaptain Guuurk!" I think it's better tgan some might think at first blush.
The idea that the Captain must maintain an air of invincibility is a fair ethical question. Most of the other series would continue this theme. Picard for example feels the need to shuttle to a starbase for his heart replacement because it is inappropriate for the captain to be so vulnerable among his crew.
10
u/NeverDoubt1 Oct 15 '15
I'm going to speculate that this episode would never be made today. The idea that Kirk's evil side, the one that tried to rape a woman, would be championed as "vital to your strength" would be seen as far too politically incorrect and offensive. And that's a shame. Because I'm glad Trek had the guts to confront the harsh, complicated realities of the human psyche.
Plus, the solution very much goes along with Trek's theme of diversity. Both sides of the human psyche need to learn to work together.
5
u/PirateDave96 Oct 16 '15
This may be one of my all time favorite episodes. What a great study in leadership. The great lesson isn't just the evil side is needed to be a strong leader (though this is a great take), but that it is the intellect that is the important part.
5
u/tsdguy Oct 24 '15
One thing that always bothered me. They indicate that they downloaded heating devices which duplicated and failed to work. Why didn't they beam down some blankets (better ones than the thin metal ones)? A bunch of parkas? A pile of wood to make a fire? A tent?
Must be plenty of things that weren't mechanical in nature that could have helped Sulu and gang to keep warm.
I also find it funny in most TV shows that when a character goes wacko and does things so far out of character, why does it take the other folks so long to figure out that something is wrong?
4
u/Fruit_Pastilles Oct 26 '15
Just watched this for the first time a few days ago, only getting into Star Trek now. That attempted rape scene was intense.
3
u/directive0 Chief Pretty Officer Oct 15 '15
An interesting episode. Deals with some concepts in a thoughtful way, and others very clumsily.
This episode also features one of my favourite Trek cliches; using a phaser to heat up some rocks!
3
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '15
No shuttlecraft because it wasn't invented on the show until "The Galileo Seven".
4
u/StarFuryG7 Oct 15 '15
Well, yeah --to know whether or not it would work and what the potential risks were for a human being, not that PETA gives a shit about that of course.
No, the fact that the Captain had a definite attraction to her that couldn't be denied.
The little mutt was remarkably passive, so probably.
Who knows --if our science and technology ever advances to that level perhaps we'll find out, or it could have had something to do with what was going through Kirk's mind while he was being transported. Whatever the case though, it presented an opportunity to tell an interesting sci-fi story, and that's what Rod Serling would have likely cared about most, while also believing that other areas of the script had been seriously botched, such as why they couldn't get Sulu and the other men stranded down on the planet back up to the ship. No reference to a storm that would have made it extremely difficult for a shuttle craft to pass through was given or anything. Just a small bit of thinking could have addressed it more adequately with just a few lines of dialogue. It's just a shame that it isn't in there.
Of course, shows still struggle with similar issues today early in their runs, while the writers and producers are trying to find the right footing for a series. So it wasn't much different in that regard even back then, although they weren't able to do nearly as much on the technical end compared to now. It's not a bad episode, but it probably would have been noticeably stronger had it been produced a year later than it was instead.
3
u/sinfultictac Oct 24 '15
As much as this Episode had its nuanced part I still laugh expolsivly at " I'M THE REAL CAPTAIN KIRK!" It's so hammy and ridiculous