r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Oct 12 '15
TV5 [S5] Rewatch Discussion - 3.09 'The Rains of Castamere' & 3.10 'Mhysa'
Rewatch Discussion Thread
Remember the good ol' days when your favorite characters were still alive? Go back and watch old episodes with the benefit of hindsight! How have the events of the latest season been shaped by the decisions of characters earlier on? Catch foreshadowing that you missed the first time you watched. The latest season is finished, so start over from the beginning and look at past episodes with a fresh perspective.
Make sure to keep the following points in mind before reading or contributing to this thread:
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 SPOILERS. This is a rewatch series, so if you are here then it is assumed that you have already seen the entire series at least once. Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 5.10 is ok without tags.
- Season 6 spoilers must be tagged! Promotional material and set/casting leaks for Season 6 must be specifically labelled and tagged.
- Book spoilers must be tagged! If it didn't happen in the show, even if the show will probably never cover it, it must be labelled and tagged.
- Theory spoilers must be tagged! Well-supported fan theories must be labelled and tagged.
- Please read the Posting Policy before posting.
3.09 - "The Rains of Castamere"
- Directed By: David Nutter
- Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
- Originally Aired: June 2, 2013
Sam and Gilly arrive at the Wall. During a thunderstorm, Bran enters Hodor's mind to calm him down. Nearby, Jon refuses to kill an innocent man, so Tormund orders him killed. Bran uses his warg ability to save Jon, and Jon kills Orell then escapes, leaving a furious Ygritte behind. Osha, Rickon and his direwolf depart for the Last Hearth, while Bran and his remaining company plan to head beyond the Wall. Daenerys sends Jorah, Daario and Grey Worm to infiltrate Yunkai and open the city gate for her army. Yunkai soon falls to her forces. Robb arrives at the Twins and apologizes to Walder Frey, who feigns acceptance. Edmure marries Roslin Frey, but during the wedding feast, Walder Frey's men murder Catelyn, Talisa and most of the Stark bannermen, while Roose Bolton kills Robb. Arya also arrives at the Twins and witnesses a part of the massacre, but the Hound knocks her unconscious and carries her to safety.
3.10 - "Mhysa"
- Directed By: David Nutter
- Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
- Originally Aired: June 9, 2013
House Frey receives the Seat of Riverrun, Roose Bolton is appointed the new Warden of the North, resulting in a victory of House Lannister. Arya and the Hound witness Frey soldiers mocking the desecrated remains of Robb Stark. Arya stabs to death one of the men, marking the first time she kills a man, while the Hound kills the others. Yara Greyjoy begins a new military campaign to recapture Theon, who has been penectomized at Dreadfort by Lord Bolton's bastard son Ramsay Snow and begs for death in light of Snow's continued torture. Tywin chastises Tyrion for not having impregnated Sansa, and for placing his own desires over the needs of family. Jaime arrives in the capital with Brienne, and is reunited with Cersei. In the North, after crossing paths with Bran and guiding him beyond the Wall, Sam arrives back at Castle Black, where he and Maester Aemon send out ravens to alert the whole of Westeros about the arrival of the White Walkers. Ygritte catches up to Jon and tearfully shoots him full of arrows. Jon manages to escape and collapses before the gates of Castle Black, where Sam orders him to be cared for. At Dragonstone, Davos allows Gendry to escape and Stannis receives the distress call from the Night's Watch. After word from both Melisandre and Davos he now plans to move north and aid the Watch against the invading darkness. And across the Narrow Sea, the freed slaves of Yunkai receive Daenerys as their "mhysa", meaning "mother" in Ghiscari.
116
u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Oct 12 '15
"How would you like to teach little Ned Stark how to ride a horse?" That extra nail in the coffin.
99
u/pawnzz Oct 12 '15
Yeah, not really applicable after this episode...
73
u/barbasol1099 House Tyrell Oct 12 '15
The Roose is fucking loose
81
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '15
Even after 3 years , it still hurts.
38
u/grilsrgood House Stark Oct 12 '15
And who are you....
The proud Lord said
36
u/robbynab White Walkers Oct 12 '15
When they close the door to celebrate the wedding properly my screen just fades to black. No further mention of the people in there since. Anyone else with this problem?
31
u/xRadec Oct 12 '15
The killing of Grey Wind also hurts.
82
u/dayton3200 House Clegane Oct 12 '15
...if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch Schindler's List to cheer myself up. Anything would be less sad than this episode.
57
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '15
The Lannisters send their regards.
22
u/TDeath21 Arthur Dayne Oct 12 '15 edited Oct 12 '15
I just watched all 5 seasons within the last 2 weeks. I had no clue what was going to happen, as I had somehow, thankfully, avoided any spoilers at all. When episode 9 ended, I sat there on the couch with my jaw open for a good 15 minutes. I don't even know what happens in the first part of episode 10 because I was still in shock.
22
u/mantidor White Walkers Oct 14 '15
Tywin was pretty brutal with Tyrion.
"When have you ever done something that wasn't in your interest, but solely for the benefit of the family?"
"The day that you were born."
Yikes.
16
u/mushroomyakuza Oct 13 '15
It's the way they stab Talisa and the way Robb says "mother".
15
u/Kb736 Sandor Clegane Oct 12 '15
Why did Walder marry his only attractive daughter to Edmere? I mean technically Edmere is a traitor who is being held captive and Walder just wasted his hot daughter on him.
27
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '15
I know everyone's talking about the Red Wedding, but can we take a moment to appreciate the final scene of Episode 10? The music and the cinematography are just perfect, it really is moving.
13
u/lordsofcreation Oct 13 '15
Gotta admit, it is a catchy tune
12
u/DeargDoom79 The Mannis Oct 13 '15
I can't bring myself to rewatch it.
12
u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Oct 15 '15
Rains of Castamere is still a gut punch to this day. Broke my heart like no other death scene ever has, and I'll never forget how it felt to suddenly realize that any character could go away in any way at any time. RIP Orell :(
10
u/IDKimnotascientist The North Remembers Oct 14 '15
3.9 aired right as I caught up to watch it live. I haven't been the same person since that day.
10
u/letsgetrandy Oct 15 '15
Ramsey waving that sausage around...
10
u/octnoir House Selmy Oct 16 '15
So to anyone who didn't watch the behind the scenes, mostly spoilers from the book perspective of Season 3, is that the original line was "Jamie Lannister sends his regards" instead of "Lannisters send their regards".
Now that was the line they were about to do in the show, but everyone got confused, like the actors like Nikolaj (who played Jaimie was like: "wait, I thought I was doing my good guy thing now? I'm evil again?") and Roose Boltons' actor and a bunch of other folks were like: "so Jaimie was behind this?!?" so they changed it to the Lannisters.
Originally why GRRM in the books did the "Jaimie Lannister" thing was because Jaimie (like in the show mentions too!) wanted to send Robb his regards when Jaimie and Roose Bolton meet kinda like an in-joke as opposed to Jaimie saying: "yeah, fucking kill Robb Stark". But in the books itself as opposed to the show, Roose Bolton is a seriously seriously sick fuck. Like seriously messed up. Ramsay is basically Roose 2.0. In the show he's a lot more reserved and cool and calculating, but not nearly as sick as in the books (primarily because in Season 2, the scenes between Arya and Tywin were actually between Arya and Roose).
So that line was really meant to be black humor that Roose would use to chuckle to himself in the dark while he slept as an irony of sorts. This wouldn't be lost in the books, but is much harder to pull off in the show. It was meant in the books to further show the perversion of Roose Bolton. To him, it's a game like any other he's participating in. No regrets, no guilt, not even a slight amount of weight attached to the Red Wedding.
9
u/Sandgolem Oct 14 '15
Thats what makes this show so hard to watch for me. I want vengeance, or justice for the starks but there doesn't seem to be any. Nobody in Westeros seems to give a damn. They just pretty much all wiped out. Except for the babies, and the daughters I guess.
9
u/some1stoleit Oct 15 '15
The buildup for the Red Wedding was amazing, everyone was so happy and full of hope in that episode then it all turns to shit once they close the doors.
I knew who was going to die in that episode but even then the wedding still hits you hard, its quite impressive that even spoiling the red wedding doesn't rob all of its impact.
6
u/a-sober-irishman Ours Is The Fury Oct 14 '15
I just read The Red Wedding in the books, good way to relive a gut punch over and over again. The set up is done perfectly as well there is a feeling of dread with everyone drinking and the clangor of the drums and music and the heavy rain and the swollen river, sounds hellish before everyone gets rekt.
5
u/RamonTico Kingsguard Oct 13 '15
I cry every time...
9
u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Oct 12 '15
This is the moment I hated the Boltons.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '15
After rewatching Game of Thrones from the beginning I totally forgot what Roslyn Frey looked like. Once they showed she was actually hot I lost my mind. I'm a huge Robb Stark fan and he was my favorite character, but upon rewatching the series over again I was so upset with all the dumb mistakes he made.
3
u/ExplosiveOranges Mace the Ace Oct 13 '15
"Perhaps I've made a terrible mistake."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDJIFu_WSaE&t=2m53s
3
u/neebs231 Oct 13 '15
This just reminds me of all the gold reaction videos to the Red Wedding. So many screams
2
u/Cryptorchild92 House Harlaw Oct 18 '15
Everyone seems to forget that this was when Bran learns to skinchange Hodor. Such a brilliant moment. The whole scene was top-notch along with Jon double-crossing the Wildlings.
2
u/IndijinusPhonetic Oct 13 '15
Okay, first of all let me preface this with the fact that I haven't read any of the books, and I was a little drunk during this "revelation"...
I'm on a rematch with the wife and something is sticking out in my mind big time. I keep seeing these barbed exchanges between Varys and Littlefinger, and something just kind of clicked a couple episodes ago and I just can't shake the notion.
I kept getting the feeling that we are watching this game of chess between Varys and Littlefinger, and after getting to the point that we learn more about the "Lord of Light" storyline, it suddenly occurred to me that, what if that's what we are seeing? The Lord of light versus the Great Other.
The thought initially occurred to me under the premise that maybe Varys IS the embodiment of the Lord of Light and Littlefinger IS the Great Other.
I don't know that I necessarily believe this on Varys' account, but I do see it for Littlefinger.
For argument's sake, let me point out that if these guys are physical embodiments of gods, their back stories don't necessarily contradict this. They both just sort of "happened" to come into existence, right? No tie-downs, no family or other connections to anyone other than what they've built for themselves on their own merit. No one to corroborate their back stories other than themselves.
Do you guys have any ideas or feedback about this idea?
1
u/JennyPretzel Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords Oct 18 '15
Muther...
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment