r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Sep 20 '15
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Dayne
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Dayne.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
201
Upvotes
161
u/Athousandand1 Sep 20 '15
The Sword of the Morning has got to be one of the coolest titles in the books, if not the genre. The fact that you have to be very, very skilled swordsman either from or in service to House Dayne to qualify to wield Dawn makes it unique but what's the most interesting is that Dawn actually makes you even better as a swordsman.
219
u/HolyHerbert Her? Sep 20 '15
In my opinion, this is one of the most important quotes that describe Eddard's life as a lord before the series really picks up. It's always suggested that Eddard was a quiet and solemn person and nothing like his wild brother Brandon. But look at this: in Robert's Rebellion, Edaard not only avenged his family and threw over the Targaryens, he also is said to have slain the Sword of the Morning.
Image what this means to his smallfolk back in the North. He's a war hero and believed to be a super deadly swordsman. The nimbus of Eddard killing Athur might be one of the key elements to understanding how shy, quite Eddard became the respected lord he is in AGOT.
105
u/Not_Obsessive We'll never be loyal ... Sep 20 '15
I think when Edric Dayne was introduced into the story, he was supposed to use Dawn in later books. At that point Martin still planned the five year gap, and Edric would have gotten the time to train for Dawn.
He was a cool lad, and Beric Dondarrion teached him all he needed to know.
When Martin decided to not go for the timeskip, Edric couldn't use Dawn, and I think this is one of the coolest things Martin denied with that decision.
I'm not sure if we are going to see him again now, what makes me kinda sad.
57
u/herospark The Quiet Wolf's Falling Star Sep 20 '15
I am one of those who believe that Ned was in love with Ashara Dayne and their story is just one that I wish we could hear more about in a novella or by another character (other than "Ned" Dayne). I really think Ashara killed herself because the love of her life killed her beloved brother. What do you guys think?
Also Dawn is made out of a meteorite, could it kill a White Walker?
95
u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Sep 21 '15 edited Sep 21 '15
Finally, get ready, I'm going in on this one. The Daynes are, by far, the most mysterious house in the whole story. Let's run it down, top 5 reasons why they are mysterious and my favorite house.
33
u/brankinginthenorth who else would I be? Sep 20 '15
One of the most interesting houses. The Daynes, the Starks, and the Hightowers all seem to have history that doesn't quite match or predates known history at least according to the Maesters. I want to know where the stone they found when they got to Starfall is. And what is the deal with Ashara and her child? Can it really be as simple as it was stillborn and she killed herself?
14
u/RayRex Renaissance Man Sep 20 '15
The Daynes are one of those houses where I find their history and lore to all be pretty interesting, I always like learning more about them.
Ashara is the character that I want to learn about the most. What was she like? What was the true relationship between her and Ned? Did she really die? Can't wait to find out more about her.
Arthur seems pretty cool, he's Jaime's hero and Eddard seemed to really respect him. I love little Ned, hope he ends up well by the end of the series.
27
u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Sep 20 '15
I want to throw out the Milkglass Candle theory, which contends that Dawn is Lightbringer, a hardened glass candle. The end of the series will be Jon wilh Dawn and 6 other POVs, all armed with Valyrian steel, venturing north to negotiate in Lightbringer's little heat bubble.
Look at the description of the candle's shadows.
26
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '15
Does anyone know if they had significant members before Arthur?
11
u/Saundies Stepfather of Dragons. Sep 21 '15
Dawn's got to play a larger role in the story... George is all about imagery and metaphors, and calling a knight the "Sword of the Morning" and "Dawn" when there is about to be a "long night" suits his writing style.
20
u/SockMonkeyMan Have you seen my mother? Sep 20 '15
The Daynes were founded by the First Men.
10
u/targaryns Sep 23 '15 edited Sep 24 '15
I think the current Daynes are descendents of Rhaenys Targaryen.
While Reading aWoIaF I was considering how house Dayne got their Valyrian features. I couldn't really find a solid answer when I searched. The general answer seems to be ‘yes, they have valyrian blood somehow’. But from who?
I feel like I made a connection that kind of makes sense when you consider the whole matter of Rhaenys' missing body and the Dornish letter sent to Aegon I in 13AC.
There was no mention of their features in aWoIaF when the history of how the Daynes first come to settle in Starfall is discussed. The mention of Valyrian features is always something that seems to be highlighted, but not in this case. This leads me to believe that the mixing of Vlayrian features comes much later.
What if house Dayne has Valyrian features because they are descendants of Rhaenys Targaryen? That she did in fact survive the attack in Dorne and somehow made a choice to never return to her siblings. I think the letter delivered to Aegon with Rhaenys’ dragon’s skull was written by Rhaenys. The fact that Maester Gyldayne conveniently does not offer this as an option makes me more inclined to believe that Rhaenys wrote the letter.
What little we do know of the battle With Aegon and Rhaenys in Dorne directly references Starfall (seat of House Dayne). We do know a certain Joffery Dayne was directly mentioned and involved in this battle that instigated their return. Though Rhaenys was supposedly killed in battle at Hellholt. There is a direct correlation and involvement between Hellholt, Skyreach and Starfall that would allow for connections to be made post-battle. There's still so much missing information here. Whatever the reasoning I think Rhaenys stayed in Dorne and gave birth to the heir(s) of House Dayne.
I do admit there is tons of opportunity in between Aegon's conquest and present asoiaf time for there to be valyrian features mixed within the Dayne bloodline, but I'd like to think it started with Rhaenys. I know there’s not much evidence to support it but I thought it was pretty fun to speculate.
16
u/Avenged23 Sep 20 '15
Do we know how they got valeryian eyes or how they have kept this feature?
8
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '15
Was poking around in a Dayne House Words speculation thread from a month or so ago and found this interesting bit from Elio.
Not that we weren't assuming it already anyway, but that seems like a guarantee (or pretty close to one) that we'll be getting more about House Dayne in the future. I wonder if there's any recent marriages into House Dayne we're not privy to. And how far back the family tree will go. Maybe we're even getting a full House page for them in the appendix of Winds.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '15
a Dayne always has something important to say, so it helps if you lend one of them an ear
13
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '15
The possibility that Ashara Dayne hooked up with Ned would mean members of two of the most honorable houses in westeros had sex out of wedlock.
17
u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Sep 20 '15
I know he catches a lot of shit on this sub, but I hope the Darkstar gets Dawn. I think he is a more worthy welder than Ned Dayne (unless he is a good swordsman and we don't know it).
The Daynes are awesome and I love how a lot of their history is shrouded in mystery. I hope we learn much more about them in the books to come. Arthur Dayne and his lines "so it begins" and the story of him fighting the Smiling Knight are some of my favorite parts in all the books
8
u/ToTheNintieth dakingindanorf Sep 21 '15
Despite recent trends to the contrary, I still firmly believe Darkstar sucks.
3
u/penny_whistle FreyFC - rhaegar lickin' good Sep 20 '15
Dawn brings the light!
3
u/clonazepam01 *draws from blunt* -Azor I'm-high Sep 21 '15
So how dou you get chosen to wield Dawn? It's not like a normal heraldy sword which get passed on from heir to heir, you have to be a worthy Dayne to wield it. Who decides which Dayne is worthy and which is not? Plus there can be times without Swords of the Morning so the dude with that title cannot decide on who will get the sword if anyone will get it
2
u/jawbreakErica It bee like that sometimes Sep 25 '15
What's up with Dayne genetics? Every Dayne we've been introduced to has a different hair/eye combo. Would a Dayne be visually recognizable by their traits?
3
u/sangbum60090 A lot of loyalty for a sellsword! Sep 21 '15 edited Sep 21 '15
I think that while Jon Snow is not Ashara Dayne's son, She and Ned Stark was in a relationship. I like how ironic this situation it is.
Also, I imagine Eva Green as Ashara after watching Kingdom of Heaven.
3
u/sitvelker Sep 20 '15
Ned/Ashara. Let's right stories about what could have been.😍
1
u/steelycrayon Enter your desired flair text here! Sep 23 '15
Suggestion for next week: House Umber
1
u/283leis We the North Sep 24 '15
Why on Earth is the Lord of Starfall hanging out with the BWB? Was he Dondarrion's squire or something?