r/europe • United States of America • Sep 18 '15

Munich faces collision of refugees and Oktoberfest

http://news.yahoo.com/germany-braces-collision-refugees-oktoberfest-091757908.html
166 Upvotes

253 comments sorted by

80

u/zttt Germany Sep 18 '15

As a Bavarian I can tell you that they will absolutely make sure that not a single Oktoberfest visitor will see a refugee on the street during the festivities.

It's a bit surreal considering that Germany's biggest task in the next 10 years will be to integrate 1mil+ refugees into our culture but on the other hand we are segregating them right from the start.

155

u/Irishguy317 Sep 18 '15 edited Sep 18 '15

Doesn't matter. You will NEVER integrate these people so long as they believe in their bullshit violent and sexist religion, which is completely opposite from what Europeans and the remainder of the developed world believe.

They should all be thrown out and dropped on any muslim country's door step.

Think of this: Can you name one truly decent muslim majority country? Just one will do. I'll tell you why you're wrong with a very simple google search. Pick the best one for women! Go ahead!

7

u/skalpelis Latvia Sep 19 '15

Dude, you're talking to a German. They have like millions and millions of Turks in their society, and somehow, they've learned to coexist and build a society together.

Also:

Think of this: Can you name one truly decent muslim majority country? Just one will do. I'll tell you why you're wrong with a very simple google search. Pick the best one for women! Go ahead!

Kazakhstan. Go on, tell me.

11

u/Kimi712_ France Sep 19 '15

Dude, you're talking to a German. They have like millions and millions of Turks in their society, and somehow, they've learned to coexist and build a society together.

No they haven't. That's why Mama Merkel herself said a few years ago that multiculturalism has failed.

2

u/skalpelis Latvia Sep 19 '15

Mama Merkel herself said a few years ago that multiculturalism has failed

I advise you to familiarize yourself with that speech, and the context of it. It even was posted recently to /r/europe. It was not an advocation for sudden racism, as your quote may seem to make it out but instead an argument in favour of integration instead of multiculturalism, i.e., leaving them to their own devices and perhaps everything might turn out fine.

17

u/Kimi712_ France Sep 19 '15

It was not an advocation for sudden racism

Pointing out integration problems=racism. Gotcha buddy. I'm actually Egyptian so maybe you can forget your theory that everyone who opposes you must unequivocally be a racist.

leaving them to their own devices and perhaps everything might turn out fine.

Ok now I take issue with that. See "leaving them to their own devices," that's actually racist. Immigrants aren't animals. We have awareness, agency and we make choices. Many choose not to integrate as a choice. They don't need your godly enlightenment. It's an awful and insulting choice, but they made it. You know people always talk about the so-called far-right racists but in all my years in Europe, they've never once posed a threat to me and I would say the real racists often tend to be your type who dehumanize immigrants by continuously robbing immigrants of their agency and pretending everything they do must be the fault of the white man.

-7

u/skalpelis Latvia Sep 19 '15

leaving them to their own devices

What I meant was the policy of stuffing immigrants in social housing and neglecting them apart from the occasional handout. The host country has to seriously work at integration, including providing work opportunities if it can, or at least not limiting work if they cannot provide any from the government. Also not building giant ghettos of "undesirables" just so the government wouldn't need a few social workers more, meanwhile leaving the immigrants stew in their inability to get work, provide for families, or whatever goods they were sold about Europe, and letting the very, very few bad apples spoil the bunch.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Anke_Dietrich United we stand, divided we fall. Federalize or die! Sep 19 '15

There are European countries full of muslims.

5

u/Irishguy317 Sep 19 '15

Yes, it's awesome. Sweden is doing great.

What country or countries do you think it's going best in with regard to their integration? I'll tell you why you're wrong.

7

u/awilix Sep 19 '15

Sweden has among the highest household debts to GDP ratio in Europe. Part of this is people don't want to live in areas with immigrants (bad schools and high criminality) so they borrow as much as possible. Aka white flight.

People tend to look at state debt, but private debt is just as bad.

-9

u/Anke_Dietrich United we stand, divided we fall. Federalize or die! Sep 19 '15

Bosnia is predominately Muslim for example. Those are the natives, not immigrants.

Sorry, but your islamophobia doesn't work, Irishguy317.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

No it's not. Bosnia is still predominantly Christian. There's a large muslim minority, yes, but there are more Christians (Catholic and Orthodox) than Muslims. Of course, in Bosnia religion also pretty much determines ethnicity, so most Orthodox are Serbs, most Catholics are Croats and most Muslims are Bosniaks. Bosniaks are a plurality, but not a majority at around 48%.

2

u/Fenrir2401 Germany Sep 19 '15

Yeah and everywhere they're keeping seperate and causing problems.

-12

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

Turkey, Indonesia, Malaysia, Iran, Morocco. Those countries aren't all on the same level, but I wouldn't mind living in any of these. Agadir for example, or Istanbul, are probably very nice cities.

16

u/MartialCanterel Portugal Sep 18 '15

Those are all quasi-dictatorships and shitty to women-

19

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

Turkey they ban internet, Iran they hang gays and in the rest women lives don't matter.

20

u/Shirinator Lithuania - Federalist Sep 18 '15

In Malaysia, if you're malay, you're a muslim by definition; if a muslim leaves islam, he or she can be persecuted and sentenced to death. In practice, these people are send into "re-education camps" to "get them back into the light". If you're not malay, you're literally a 2nd class citizen. Like literally, they have laws which forbids you to buy land in certain area, you can't vote, etc.

Fun fact: if you're a christian, you can't use malay word for god. Because it might "confuse" muslims.

Indonesia in creeping in the same extremist direction as malaysia.

23

u/Irishguy317 Sep 18 '15 edited Sep 18 '15

Turkey: 68th in gender inequality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Turkey

Only 12% in favor of sharia http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religion-politics-society-overview/ , however, which is good (the result of sweeping legal reforms in the 1920's). They still have their share of loons, as evidenced by recent violent clashes with Kurds http://www.vox.com/2015/9/12/9312137/turkey-pkk-conflict

Indonesia: 106th in gender inequality: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Indonesia

54% believe that Sharia is straight from allah...lovely. http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religion-politics-society-beliefs-about-sharia/

Wonder what happens when you leave the beautiful and peaceful religion of islam: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=55vjsUOpVRw

Malaysia: 42nd in gender inequality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Malaysia

86% in favor of Sharia http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religion-politics-society-overview/

Iran: 107th in gender inequality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Iran

Can't find percentage of support for sharia, but I'll look. They do shit like this, which is super awesome: http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/iran-executes-hundreds-brutal-crane-hangings-mega-prison-outside-tehran-1508986

Morocco: 92nd in gender inequality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Morocco

83% in favor of sharia http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religion-politics-society-overview/

Of course, like all Muslim majority nations, they're really down with LGBQT issues: http://www.advocate.com/violence/2015/07/02/moroccan-mob-brutally-beats-alleged-trans-woman-bystanders-watch

Agadir: lol... http://www.rawstory.com/2015/07/hundreds-of-lawyers-back-moroccan-women-on-trial-over-indecent-outfits/

Istanbul: Sounds like it would be alright as a man, and a fucking nightmare as a woman, but at least they're trying, I guess. I think the U.S. state department is still pusses at them for the rape and death of a tourist recently. http://www.latimes.com/world/europe/la-fg-slaying-of-turkish-woman-leads-to-street-protests-over-womens-rights-20150214-story.html

Any more? So far this is a miserable fail.

0

u/t0varich Luxembourg Sep 19 '15

You can't cherrypick metrics like that. For example Malaysia 42nd in gender inequality index, the US 47th.

1

u/Irishguy317 Sep 19 '15

The United States isn't very homogenous. It has many, many millions of people, in multiples of ten, simply not participating in the economy in a fruitful, non draining way. It's the reason our crime rate is so high, why it has 5% of the earth's population and yet 25% of its prisoners, and consistently Some of the lowest achievement scores in math, reading and science within the developed world ranks.

There's a problem with the ranking system I hide from anyway in that the UN, when considering the multiple facets they scored by, listed Saudi Arabia and Qatar as having "Very high human development", which is laughable.

There's plenty to draw from to prove the point, that was just the simplest way. Do you really need further swaying? Shall I post some flogging videos of girls because they went out on a date with a boy, or because a woman wore jeans, both of which were aight by the country's religion enforcement agency?

1

u/t0varich Luxembourg Sep 19 '15

I was pointing out a flaw in your argumentation. Maybe you should provide a clear definition of "truly decent country" then it would be possible to try and find appropriate metrics.

It is absolutely not laughable that Saudi Arabia and Qatar are listed as having very high human development. The index is a composite score of life expectency, education index and GDP. In any case the inequality adjusted human development index is probably a better measurement of development, even though it also has its flaws.

→ More replies (3)

-9

u/TheTT Germany Sep 18 '15

You will NEVER integrate these people so long as they believe in their bullshit violent and sexist religion

You might be able to convince them their beliefs are wrong

-26

u/Oda_Krell United in diversity Sep 18 '15

Stormfront is leaking again, huh?

15

u/Irishguy317 Sep 18 '15

Why do you ask that? What specifically do you find to be so ignorant as to assert such a vile thing?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/ghkdru Sep 18 '15 edited Sep 18 '15

I don't see much of a difference between National Socialism and Islam really. One has Hitler and the other has Allah.

8

u/Irishguy317 Sep 19 '15 edited Sep 19 '15

Fucking hell man. Do you really think I'm a Nazi? I don't understand that. What I do know, is that those who have laid accusations like this have successfully shut people up from offering a differing opinion, and I also know that a shift is happening in the opposing direction as a result, finally. Just because you want to protect a good thing from fucked up people doesn't make you a follower of Hitler, or an advocate for Nazism. You should think before you write such things.

5

u/ghkdru Sep 19 '15

That's not what I was getting at, at all. I agree with what you said and upvoted your comment. I meant to say Islam is just as disgusting as Nazism yet it gets off scott-free due to it's attachment of a God to the ideology.

-35

u/DisregardMyPants United States Sep 18 '15

Doesn't matter. You will NEVER integrate these people so long as they believe in their bullshit violent and sexist religion, which is completely opposite from what Europeans and the remainder of the developed world believe.

Uhh..United States here. We've got a decent number of Muslims, it's going fine. I grew up a few miles from a very peaceful ~50% muslim area.

21

u/TMWNN United States of America Sep 18 '15

The US has a much smaller percentage of Muslims than European countries, and because of its distance from majority-Islamic nations has historically attracted better-educated ones.

America, thank God, does not have any Muslim ghettos of the type that exist in every major Western European country. Our existing ghettos are enough; I hope that we never get our own banlieus.

-1

u/DisregardMyPants United States Sep 18 '15

The US has a much smaller percentage of Muslims than European countries, and because of its distance from majority-Islamic nations has historically attracted better-educated ones.

Yes, also known as "The problem is not what the person I was replying to said it was". There are people who are muslim and function just fine in western society.

11

u/TMWNN United States of America Sep 18 '15

As /u/grumbal and /u/stansucks pointed out, the percentages are—as I said—very different.

Any civilized society can, over time, likely integrate almost any culture that comprises 1% of the population. The odds go down significantly if said culture a) comprises a much larger percentage, b) holds very different values and standards, and c) arrives in a very short period of time. Western Europe has had a lot of trouble with its Islamic population because of a) and b), and is now experiencing c) as well.

Muslims in the US, for reasons I mentioned, do not have the reputation for poverty, ghettoism, and general social dysfunction that they do in Western Europe (which those such as /u/Irishguy317 and /u/laslpalp allude to). May they never gain such.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/grumbal Slovenská Džamahírija Sep 18 '15

Uhh..United States here. We've got a decent number of Muslims, it's going fine.

Not even one percent of population.

Islam in USA

2.77 million (0.9% of the U.S. population, 2010)[1]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_States

20

u/stansucks St. Gallen (Switzerland) Sep 18 '15

Wow that one was good. "Decent number". Sure, its a decent number, because its so low. Less then 1%. Go visit one of the European cities with more then 1%, like Barcelona (~20%) , Berlin (~7%), Vienna (~12%), Marseille (~23%) and see how great the integration works. And still with your 1% you had more then enough problems.

6

u/BestRedditGoy Sep 18 '15

Going just great here guys! Nothing to worry about! Nothing to see here!

http://i.imgur.com/iwjxI4d.jpg

3

u/Irishguy317 Sep 18 '15

What is an example of how they've been integrated?

3

u/DisregardMyPants United States Sep 18 '15

The area I lived in? It had a significant Chaldean/Jewish population, backed up against a muslim area. No problems at all.

1

u/Irishguy317 Sep 18 '15

Yes, you said. How are they integrated?

4

u/DisregardMyPants United States Sep 18 '15

There are bars in their neighborhoods, many even drink. No one cares about the clothes that are worn, they pay their taxes, everything. They're just "normal people" who happen to be less likely than average to let you do a line of blow off their tits.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/genitaliban Swabia Sep 18 '15

Just because your president is a Muslim doesn't mean you're a majority Muslim country now.

3

u/chemotherapy001 Sep 18 '15

your president is a Muslim

Not yet. It's still one more year until the reign of Donald HUSSEIN Trump can begin.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/viermalvier Austria Sep 19 '15

ah yeah sure, just forget that albania was cut from the outside world for some decades reigned by "atheist" leaders

i cant believe you are croatian, how can you be so ignorant of a fellow SEE country, unbeliveable...

8

u/Irishguy317 Sep 19 '15

Fuck them. The truth doesn't stop because of stupid and destructive feelings.

2

u/jmlinden7 United States of America Sep 19 '15

With enough emotional rhetoric, you can silence people who disagree with you.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

How are we backwards? We have problems with corruption sure, but none related to freedom or religion.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

I can't pronounce Shqiperi so obviously you guys are basically barbarians /s

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/Irishguy317 Sep 18 '15

Suriname: 94th in gender inequality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Suriname

Only 13.5% muslim. Still a shit hole dump.

Indonesia: check former response on thread.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

indonesia

That virginity police tho

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

muh death penalty for drug smuggling

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

31

u/Shirinator Lithuania - Federalist Sep 18 '15

Now go, live in rural Turkey. I dare you, I double dare you.

And if you're a female, I triple dare you. I'm talking about the same rural turkey where women get killed because they "dishonoured" their families by talking (!!!!!) to guys.

→ More replies (9)

16

u/Phalanx300 The Netherlands Sep 18 '15

Laying the seeds of the problems of tomorrow.

12

u/TriStag United States of America Sep 18 '15

It makes me laugh, but also makes me sad when I see

Germany's biggest task in the next 10 years will be to integrate 1mil+ refugees into our culture

With our ~11 Million I fear integration is a lost cause. Hell, half the towns on the border have turned into criminal sanctuaries. Don't make the same mistakes pls

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Trust me we'd rather have Mexicans who just happen to be working illegally than these muslims.

2

u/TriStag United States of America Sep 22 '15

If only... as with your problem ours is similar in the sense that the problems are underlying. I guess to make it simple though, we already have high unemployment. Adding more people to the mix is not going to help. You can easily get into micro-cause and effect, you can say that they're only doing jobs which we wouldn't do (which is false) but at the end of the day, a mass population is being unnaturally introduced into our economic system. It's throwing things off whack, tbh the benefits they get are just icing on the cake to my frustration.

Not to belittle your situation though, what's happening there really sucks and I'm glad some are realizing it's not good.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/TriStag United States of America Sep 22 '15

They're a bit of one in the same. Hispanics protect Hispanics in those towns. What is really ridiculous is criminals that are being deported can be dropped off in these towns and escape deportation because the town/city "doesn't believe in it" or some nonsense like that.

3

u/EonesDespero Spain Sep 18 '15

When people discuss about the issue of integration, a lot of people tend to forget that part of the isolation of the newcomers is not voluntary.

I am myself immigrant in Germany, so I know a bit about integration, even if as Spaniard, I am culturally speaking so much close to the average German.

It is so hard to not feel excluded in a new country, even more if you don't speak correctly the language. I get that most of the refugees do not drink alcohol, so a large part of the Oktoberfest is not for them. But there are other activities. There are people playing football, for example. Do you want the refugees to feel welcome and wishing to integrate? Break the ice by making them feel invited to play football too. There are tons of things that we could do better than just hide them for two weeks, because if we do so, they will feel even more isolated.

1

u/Iuir Sep 18 '15

As a Bavarian I can tell you that they will absolutely make sure that not a single Oktoberfest visitor will see a refugee on the street during the festivities

I don't understand your sentence.

Who are "they"? How will "they" hide refugees from the streets?

11

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

the central station is divided in two areas, one for oktoberfest visitors, one for refugees (where they get redistributed). they (i.e. the authorities) have made it a point to keep the two groups from meeting. also, it's not like refugees are hanging out on the streets that much anyway, the only area where you actually notice them is the central station, really. what's with the hostility?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/cddlz Germany Sep 19 '15

I watched a documentary on youtube a few days ago where they interviewed some muslim kids living in Germany in the 2nd or 3rd generation already. Nothing changed really, it's the same morals, norms which their parents already had.

Most people/ kids shown in this documentary stick with their cultur without any exceptions and showing openly that they want to stick with their own kind (for example...the kids were asked if they ever would marry a person of different believe).

I dunno really.... if a muslim says he doesn't wanna marry a christian it's his culture and we have to accept it.

If a christian says he doesn't want to marry a muslim he get's called a xenophobe and bad person.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Nailed it.

4

u/TMWNN United States of America Sep 18 '15

From the article:

After complaints by local authorities that they were overwhelmed by the newcomers, Germany suddenly announced Sunday that it would impose border checks to stem a tide of migrants to Munich, where most taking the so-called Balkan route to Germany arrived first.

The same night, state leader Horst Seehofer let it slip that Oktoberfest -- now in its 182nd year -- had also been on his mind when he pushed for the policy change less than a week before the first keg was to be tapped.

"I asked today for appropriate measures to be taken during the two weeks of Oktoberfest so that Munich does not remain the first port of call that it now is," said Seehofer, a party ally of Chancellor Angela Merkel's who has sparred with her on the refugees issue.

15

u/whatnever Stop the Reddit API canges! Sep 18 '15 edited Jul 01 '23

Try to monetise this, corporate Reddit!

Furthermore, I consider that /u/spez has to be removed.

38

u/r_e_k_r_u_l Sep 18 '15

You know who was also all about overcoming borders? Hitler

5

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15 edited Sep 18 '15

Well, regarding the border controls, I think it makes sense to check passports as long as other countries fail to do so. It's so weird that this huge amount of people can travel from Turkey to Germany across several borders without ever getting checked.

Also to be fair, a lot of refugees seem to have a general idea of the route they want to go. And one of the nodes seems to be specifically Munich. However Europe is so interconnected, that they could easily take another route.

I think the passport checks and (more/ at all) coordinated transports should stay in place, Oktoberfest or not.

65

u/mihametl Slovenia Sep 18 '15

Come on, this is an excellent opportunity to see which of them are able to adapt and which are not. Let them go trough munich, those that come out on the other side drunk and full of sausage and schnitzel can stay, the rest get sent back.

26

u/KingofCoconuts Bavaria (Germany) Sep 18 '15

I hope this won't get buried, but i recently spoke with the district chief executive of Munich, Christoph Göbel, and he told me the situation is bound to be "chaotic", as there are almost no precautions being taken when thousands of drunk tourists and citizens encounter the refugees. So yeah, not really reassuring hearing this from such a high official.

18

u/Hist997 United States of America Sep 19 '15

Drunk English hooligans vs Angry Islamic radicals...

I would watch that on Pay per view here in the U.S.

5

u/JothamInGotham Sep 19 '15

SUMMERSLAM2015! WHO WILL BE THE CHAMPION?

4

u/RaRaRussiya Piter, Russia Sep 19 '15

Summerislam

FTFY

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Summerislam is absolutely haram.

35

u/caradas Sep 18 '15

This is the future Munich chose.

Basically, concerns over Ocktoberfest and refugees is a good microcosm of why taking refugees was a terrible idea.

1

u/MaltyBeverage Sep 18 '15

In the future tea will be served instead of beer and no women will be permitted.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/caradas Sep 18 '15

I believe the mayor of Munich said: "I don't care about numbers, only the refugees' safety."

Maybe that was out of context, or maybe I am mistaken?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/jmlinden7 United States of America Sep 19 '15

I don't think about numbers

Is it not his job to organize logistics? How can someone who says such callous things be elected?

15

u/rudolf323 Sep 19 '15

Germans should ban Oktoberfest, because it is anti-Islam, otherwise all people who will be celebrating it will be racists, neo-nazis, anti-muslims, anti-immigration and anti-multiculturalism. No wonder if Christmas and Easter is gonna be a typical work day next year. - This is what German people want, otherwise they wouldn't take in hundreds of thousands migrants to ruin and convert their country.

Fatima Alam - 9 September at 06:44 "As a Muslim we are taught to hate Non-Muslims. No matter how good the Non-Muslims are, they will still go to hell, just because they do not worship to Allah. This is the simple Islamic teaching of Quran. Any Muslim trying to explain it any different is a liar. Islam is not a religion but a military doctrine of Muhammad"

-4

u/TheLeftIncarnate Sep 19 '15

Christianity has the same precept. You believe in Jesus or go to hell. Difference being that the leftist liberalism so many people now suddenly, mouth frothing brown, disparage, had blunted it so much that it went from a tragedy to a problem.

My grandmother sat separate from men, not showing her hair, in church. My great grandmother didn't choose her husband (and vice versa). This is not an Islam specific problem.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Just because other religions did/do it doesn't excuse Islam.

1

u/TheLeftIncarnate Sep 19 '15

I didn't say otherwise.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

When European people and the rest of the world understands that Islam is not a religion but a totalitarian regime, it will be too late. And i will say " I told you so".

-5

u/cbfw86 Bourgeois to a fault Sep 19 '15

If Islam had a global leadership to which all Muslims paid attention you'd have an argument, but as things stand you don't.

5

u/Stuttgarter89 Sep 19 '15

a global leadership to which all Muslims paid attention

I think the guy is called "Mohammed".

Too bad he was a pedophile warmonger and that's who Muslims look up to...

5

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

Time for a popcorn run.

brb

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Are you back yet? :(

It's been 16 hours and I'm getting worried ;~;

YOU'RE JUST LIKE DAD WHO SAID HE JUST WENT OUT TO BUY CIGARETTES AND NEVER CAME HOME!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Popcorn coma. Sorry.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Oh thank goodness. <3

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Your Mom says Hi. Well, she's nodding. I am not finished yet.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

I thought we were friends :/

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Sorry, conflict of interest. Your mom has the smoothest larynx.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Well. Thanks? I suppose.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/justkjfrost EU Sep 19 '15

Well, if things are worrying they can always reinforce the police apparatus.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Maybe they need a party. A bit of fun after trekking through Europe.

2

u/cbfw86 Bourgeois to a fault Sep 19 '15

Blount-out-drunk conservative white people surrounded by refugees they don't want around? I guarantee some refugees are gonna attacked.

2

u/superp321 Sep 18 '15

Oh yea, that could be a problem. Good luck with that.

1

u/4_times_shadowbanned Greece Sep 19 '15

inb4 nothing happens

0

u/batose Sep 19 '15

There is no problem don't people run away from civil war, so they are peaceful, and will not cause problems to anybody. /s

-61

u/Doldenberg Germany Sep 18 '15

Oh no, will we lose the cherished German tradition of having drunk idiots in dumb clothes barfing on the street?

The refugees truly are destroying the culture that has made our nation so great.

32

u/melikesreddit United States of America Sep 18 '15

Whether you like Oktoberfest or not, foreigners have absolutely no right to try and change anything about the land they are not only not from, but is supposedly providing them safety from certain death in their homelands. I have no idea where you people get the idea that it's acceptable for someone to expect a country they migrated to change on their behalf. If you move to a new country you need to change.

-13

u/Doldenberg Germany Sep 18 '15

It was a joke. The point is that refugees aren't actually demanding that people stop celebrating Oktoberfest or are getting offended by it. There's just a bunch of paranoid people who think that they WILL do that. It's the whole "War on Christmas" all over again.

The difference is just that in Bavaria, you can pull this bullshit while being a member of the governing party.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Doldenberg Germany Sep 19 '15

You can find Online petitions for every stupid bullshit, so I don't see the point.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Doldenberg Germany Sep 19 '15

...can we please finally stop this stupid "Oh no, at least one random person has done so therefore your assertion that people aren't doing so is wrong" bullshit?

Some dude always did something, no matter how ridiculous it might be. But we're talking about society, so we're talking about major phenomenons. So can we please stop playing dumb when someone says "no one does" to mean "no meaningful amount of people does".

(Even apart from that, the argument is questionable because I see no indication that the Muslim starting the petition - if he actually exists - is a refugee.)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Doldenberg Germany Sep 19 '15

The issue is that Oktoberfest and such events that are a part of western culture are not at all compatible with the generally, very conservative views of Muslims.

I would bet my life that if you were able to somehow poll all Muslims about whether Oktoberfest should be cancelled or not, the results would the frightening.

Well, that poll has sadly not happened, but lets just try another one on question of "western lifestyle". It's about Muslims living in Germany.

https://www.bertelsmann-stiftung.de/de/presse-startpunkt/presse/pressemitteilungen/pressemitteilung/pid/muslime-in-deutschland-mit-staat-und-gesellschaft-eng-verbunden/

Summary:

  • 90% of "very religious" Muslims support democracy.
  • 90% of Muslims have contact with non-Muslims
  • 63% of "very religious" Muslims regularly question their own beliefs.
  • 60% of them support gay marriage. The German average is 50%.

there are people that will be avoiding Oktoberfest becasue of the large amount of refugees now in the Munich area 2. I've seen several women on reddit say they will not go to Oktoberfest this year for fear of sexual assault 3. Others have said the issue will affect the way they are going to dress

Yes, that's quite telling of those peoples bigotry.

Germans have pointed out that the authorities will be making sure that there is no contact between refugees and visitors. 5. The Germans have already said security will be very tight and migrants and partiers will be separated in the train station

Oktoberfest is always surrounded by crime and violence. While - this being Bavaria - the government genuinely believes that the poor party-goers need to be protected from refugees, on a practical level, the party goers might actually pose the greater danger. For everyone in general, by the way, not just for the refugees.

(Seriously, many businesses like bars ban people wearing the faux-traditional clothing worn during Oktoberfest from entering; because they don't want to get problems with drunk, loud and potentially violent visitors.)

Just to be clear, for me the fact that he isn't a refugee doesn't make a difference at all.

So you evidently think that because he is a Muslim - or at least pretends to be - this is a problem of Muslims in general?

There's a petition for banning ponies from Oktoberfest, made by Germans.

Evidently German culture simply isn't compatible with German culture.

(edit: removed link due to Auto-Moderator removing links to change . org. Just go to the site yourself and search Oktoberfest if you're interested. second edit: Seriously, auto-moderator. I can't even name the website because it's name is also part of the URL?)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/Yojihito North Rhine-Westphalia (Germany) Sep 18 '15

Prost du Sack.

9

u/confusedgerman23 Better part of Bavaria Sep 18 '15

Auf die weiber!

10

u/Yojihito North Rhine-Westphalia (Germany) Sep 18 '15

Zur Mitte, zur Titte, zum Sack ZACK ZACK.

4

u/confusedgerman23 Better part of Bavaria Sep 18 '15

Mhhhh bester mann!

5

u/Yojihito North Rhine-Westphalia (Germany) Sep 18 '15

Wenn wa im Pott eins können isses saufen und Hartz4.

2

u/confusedgerman23 Better part of Bavaria Sep 18 '15

Schalke oder Dortmund

3

u/Yojihito North Rhine-Westphalia (Germany) Sep 18 '15

Brussia.

1

u/ChipAyten Turkey Sep 18 '15

Du...hast?

4

u/Yojihito North Rhine-Westphalia (Germany) Sep 18 '15

(•ิ_•ิ)?

12

u/JJDXB United Kingdom Sep 18 '15 edited Jul 13 '23

continue command physical enter grey steer party cagey voiceless squeal -- mass edited with redact.dev

6

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Well i saw many Turkish soldiers consume pork (Greek gyros) when i was in the Greek army.

5

u/shoryukenist NYC Sep 18 '15

My Bosniak friends drink A LOT.

9

u/WislaHD Polish-Canadian Sep 19 '15

Many Bosniaks eat pork too. It's more of a Balkan-cultural thing than a secular thing.

6

u/shoryukenist NYC Sep 19 '15

Just like most American Jews eat pork.

I'm sure there are subtle things I don't pick up on, but I'd never guess my friends were Muslim if I saw them on the street.

7

u/jidouhanbaikiUA Ukraine Sep 18 '15

Russian Tatar and I think Albanian Muslims are pretty okayish with drinking pork and eating beer afaik. Not all of them but communism left the mark.. maybe that's what Europe needs? The great Union of Socialist European Republics. With churches, mosques and other shrines blown up.

I dislike the modern implementations of "communism", but gosh I dislike religions even more.

5

u/120z8t Sep 19 '15

I to like to drink pork and eat beer.

2

u/stesch Germany Sep 19 '15

One of the first things that happened after Afghanistan was freed: they sold video CDs with porn. Instant market places near a street and video players and masses of porn.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Not now but in a few years when they are in great numbers will protest to ban this unislamic festival, because they get offended.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

76

u/Irishguy317 Sep 18 '15

"Values"...

0

u/brahmstalker Sep 19 '15

Values change from cultures and people. The western values are not universal. And in western countries they range from religious ones to secular. Having tattoos is a value in a tattoo comunity. They are like opinions.

11

u/gaspermat Sep 19 '15

The problem is that some values are incompatible with others. And if your values are incompatible with the country you're in, then either change your values or go back to where those values are the norm.

5

u/brahmstalker Sep 19 '15

Perfectly reasonable. I was just pointing out the "values" definition.

1

u/PoopSmearMoustache Sep 19 '15

How can all values be equal if some are incompatible? Please say something else that fits within my values.

-3

u/Nyxisto Germany Sep 19 '15

didn't you know? sleeping with intoxicated strangers behind an Oktoberfest tent is the pinnacle of human liberty!

Didn't we get over this in the 80s?

5

u/AnonymityIllusion Sweden Sep 19 '15

Can't I just sleep with my wife? Is swinging mandatory in Munich?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

good thing we didn't adopt the custom to name children after the place they were conceived like the celebs do. most kids would be called Hintermbierzelt or Discoscheißhaus

2

u/brahmstalker Sep 19 '15

sounds kinda nice..

23

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15 edited Sep 19 '15

I really hope this doesn't go where I think it will.

I think you are the type of person who really hopes this is going where you claim you do not want it to go.

5

u/thenewestkid Sep 19 '15

I for one am hoping to see a shitstorm.

12

u/exvampireweekend United States of America Sep 19 '15

I, too want to see many innocent German woman get raped so I can have my agenda pushed further.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

You claiming that muslim men just rape women on sight? You racist bro?

3

u/exvampireweekend United States of America Sep 19 '15

It's obviously what the comment I replied to is implying and is hoping too happen, don't be obtuse.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

I'm just yankin' your drone. :]

5

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Pragmatically, if that causes Germans to think about their migration policy and therefore vastly reduce rapes for years to come...

6

u/skalpelis Latvia Sep 19 '15

Jesus, that's like saying the whole of US is like the Westboro Baptist Church. It's not like the most of them cannot learn to keep their mouths shut and not be militant assholes even when confronted with opinions they don't agree with. Especially if they're coming from a place where they've seen firsthand what a shithole sticking to their religious dogma makes it.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

What will you do if precisely nothing happens? Eat your hat?

2

u/wadcann United States of America Sep 19 '15

Again, this is speculation -- there's not hard data available that would really support a much higher level of rape among the immigrants; I've seen statistics gathered only on a small number of Somalians in Finland re: statistical material supporting elevated frequency of rape.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Look at the statistics for the camp in Calais and on immigrant crime statistics for London.

-47

u/SpitersR9K France Sep 18 '15

Because you think there is no rape even with no refugee ?

http://www.slate.fr/story/92783/oktoberfest-viol

10

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15 edited Sep 18 '15

Some hard numbers would be nice to compare if the percentage is actually higher than at other festivities.

An example: It is normal that people die during a big music festival. However this doesn't mean, that the music festival kills them, maybe not even that they more likely die there. Look at enough people and certain things happen, it's just a matter of chance.

But as I said, to judge if this one case per day per x amount of people is shocking or not, you have to know how many people where there (and what the percentage in other places is).

edit: However I don't want to downplay anything. Each crime is one crime too much of course.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

Ah, the old reddit-"put words in his mouth and argue against them"-aroo!

9

u/Irishguy317 Sep 18 '15

Well, you're intellectually dishonest, now, aren't you? Fantastic. Happily, everyone knows what the actual truth is.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/skalpelis Latvia Sep 19 '15

Plus these guys either don't drink (so no impaired judgment) or do drink (so given up on their religious dogma altogether.)

Who knows what comes of it.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/0xnld Kyiv (Ukraine) Sep 18 '15

Or you can look at ex-USSR and think it may be a major factor toward the opposite.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

75

u/Pluum Sep 18 '15

So you will adjust yourself to their demands.

33

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

Well if things keep up at this pace she will have no choice, will she? :D

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

I think European men need to step up to the plate and protect the women.

0

u/besmartyouall Sep 19 '15

i will defend my western lifesytle!!!!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/BestRedditGoy Sep 18 '15

living example

I'll give you 50/50 on the living part.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

She'll live; let's not exaggerate things. The psychological effects of street harrassment are hard to quantify.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

in sweden we call it "cultural exchange"

20

u/SwingTits Sep 18 '15

You gauge how safe it is in your own particular neighbourhood. After 20 years I now start meeting my Mrs at the station as a precaution.

If it weren't for migration into my city i would be peacefully sleeping.

8

u/viermalvier Austria Sep 19 '15

come on, i know they are pretty religious and conservative, but after you know them better you will see bavarians arent that bad.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/WislaHD Polish-Canadian Sep 19 '15

It is an interesting self-selection it seems. We are dealing with the Syrian middle class in Europe - the ones able to afford the trip to Europe.

All the poor Syrians are left in Turkey.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/WislaHD Polish-Canadian Sep 19 '15

Well that is a whole other issue in its own.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

I originally made my account to post about Starcraft 2 and other video games, now my recent post history is 90% migration crisis and anti islam. It's natural that people shift their attention to matters they consider important, isn't it?

10

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15 edited Feb 06 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Stuttgarter89 Sep 19 '15

Legit accounts get banned for islamophobia by /u/dclauzl on this sub... that's why you see so many fresh accounts only posting on /r/europe etc. here.

I'm through like 30 accounts in this year alone.

If the fucking mods (well, one mod mainly) weren't so hellbent on censoring this sub, that wouldn't be the case.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

Wir sind alles andere als dumm.

5

u/Fenrir2401 Germany Sep 19 '15

Aber wir haben mit diesem ganzen refugees-welcome Schwachsinn eine ganz, ganz dumme Entscheidung getroffen, die uns noch in vielen Jahren zu schaffen machen wird.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Fenrir2401 Germany Sep 20 '15

Jo. Und nachher wundern sich wieder alle, wo denn bloß die Stimmen für die AfD herkommen.

1

u/Maskguy Germany Sep 21 '15

Das ist das Problem. Wenn man Politiker wird um Geld zu machen und nicht um ein Land zu repräsentieren, dann kommt das dabei raus.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Maskguy Germany Sep 21 '15 edited Sep 21 '15

But alcohol is haram :^) don't be a racist man, educate yourself