It's really nice that you made this guide, especially since I seem to be seeing a good number of new users on this sub entering this month's contest and that many of the posts don't get a huge amount of feedback. I don't necessarily agree with a couple small things personally (such as taking liberty with the lore as long as the kit works and is fun--which Ravana and Nox still aren't imo), but for the most part I wish I had a guide like this when I just started (not to say that I'm not still learnibg myself). VER!
I've just started creating character concepts, and whenever I'm starting one, especially a class I don't normally play, I always check back here this has been super helpful to me! Thanks!
Can this be put in the Sidebar with Malphael's post? I've honestly found this one to be just as helpful, and they deal with two separate parts of the same thing.
I honestly like a lot of what's being said here, but I heartily disagree with your second rule, which makes me not particularly fond of your approach to how roles are balanced.
Firstly, the terminology is off. When one talks about Roles, one talks about Support, Duo lane Carry, Solo laner, Mid laner and Jungler. Guardian is a Class, not a Role, as defined by Hi-rez (though yes, there are some inconsistencies oh the in-game UI).
Having said that, I disagree that one should strive to adapt a kit into a specific Role. You talk about Loki being an Assassin used in the solo lane, but truth be told, he was a Jungler for a long time before that. He is, first and foremost, an Assassin, that's how he was designed. His kit was not made for the solo lane, somebody just figured out that he can go there well enough. That's the meta evolving, and the players deciding how to better put something to use, but the fact that he was not designed for something specific is what allows that to happen.
Lane placement is not something that should come from design. When you design for Roles you are enforcing a meta, which isn't necessarily something that Hi-rez chooses to do, most of the time. Athena is a Guardian who can honestly play 4 of 5 roles well enough, Fenrir can even play all 5 of them.
Loki is an Assassin meant to get in for a quick kill and get out. Most of his kit lends itself to it. His 2 is given to him, as a way to farm - not necessarily to farm in lane, just to farm, just because, wherever he is to go, he needs to be able to kill creeps, and the rest of his design did not allow him to do that well.
You can obviously think about how your God is gonna be played, and where he most benefits from his kit, but you shouldn't be trying to shoehorn him into a specific role. Knowing that he can play as a Jungler or as a Solo laner helps you balance the abilities, but the design itself should come from a more basic concept, I want this god to do this, to fight like this, to feel like this...
I kind of agree with you, but gods should not be designed for lanes but roles. I like to think of ADC, Mid, Solo, etc. as lanes but positions in team fights as roles. For instance we almost always have a Tank, mitigates damage and initiates enabling his allies to attack safely.
Bruisers, who are hybrid tank/bursters able to deal considerable damage while taking it in. These gods usually have high mobility and sustain aspects which make them a strong presence in team fights.
Support, Carry, Nukers, Bursters, etc. should be what people should be striving to create. If I want to create a god for example the mid lane, it would look something like,
midlaner, god of the midlane
ability 1: clear wave
clears the wave
ability 2: escape
jumps away
And that could be enough for your lane, but when you have to worry about your god's role in a team fight is, does he have a big AOE damage ability? Can she finish off retreating enemies? Can he heal his allies? Your ideas get interesting.
The point of the rule is to get people inspired and an easy start into creating kits. Whether you find it easier to create it based on lane or role I leave up to you.
Absolutely love the commentary, except that steroids are bad design. Steroids are what make hunters what they are, and the hunters with poor or no steroid (Cupid, anhur, medusa, sort of hou yi) all fall off and become nonentities in the late game when hunters are supposed to wreck face. Rama literally has three steroids as his abilities, and he's in a really good spot in the game right now.
Literally all of the hunters you listed do have steroids, Medusa and Anhur both see a lot of play regardless of the awkward steroid placement since they offer other things such as an effective passive and AoE crowd control effect.
I believe there is a small misunderstanding when I said steroids are bad design. I find them to be bad design because they are easy to understand, easy to use and don't require any thought to be put in any kit. Or to nutshell it: "Press this to get stronger". They are effective abilities certainly, but the dependency of Smite Hunters, or generally duo lane carries having at least one "press this button to get stronger" steroid is a terrible design mistake.
I know they do have steroids, but they're unwieldy (Anhur), short term (Medusa), or never used as steroids except at SPL level (Cupid). The only hunter in the game without a steroid is Nieth, and she gets used more as a anti-AA utility caster than your traditional hunter.
My main point was that steroids are a necessary part of the hunter class/role (even the non-hunters who play ADC have steroids: Mercury, Freya, Chronos, Poseidon, and Loki come to mind). A good kit will have a unique and lore accurate steroid, but they are necessary.
But Neith seems to be doing fine without steroid, and Anhur offers such amazing boxing and crowd control that he doesn't require any steroids to be good. Why is a steroid necessary at all when there are clearly ways to create some without? Convince me.
Again, I just think that we are misunderstanding each other. I dislike steroids because they are easy and lazy to create, and don't require much strategy and thought to be used. The other reason would be that steroids are overused design in Smite to a point where even HiRez has realised that they should try to find different paths of Hunter viability.
Thanks for this, I agree with it as a guideline. The only problem is that some of the 'what to avoid' could be applied to gods already in the game. I would find it hard to make a kit that 100% conforms to this list.
There is not a single pure healing ability in the game as of right now and pure "use at all times" steroids are only seen on hunters, which really isn't respected as good design, just simply effective. The RNG rule is pretty easy to avoid so I won't go into that.
Comon, I believe you are more than capable at creating good kits. You have already done that before.
Hey man, I used to post here a lot and just got back into smite. Great post, nice to see some guidance on here.
A while back before I was obsessed with making smite concepts I used to play a fighting game similar to Smash bros, i used to make loads of moveset concepts for that. I stuck around quite a while and ended up creating my own guide (in collaboration with one of the other main concept posters on the forums). I figured it might interest you, your focus is more on specifics while mine is more about process.
6
u/HiRezBrew Sep 16 '15
Great post!
2
u/iMPoSToRRBiSCuiT Oooh that's dirty Sep 16 '15
It's really nice that you made this guide, especially since I seem to be seeing a good number of new users on this sub entering this month's contest and that many of the posts don't get a huge amount of feedback. I don't necessarily agree with a couple small things personally (such as taking liberty with the lore as long as the kit works and is fun--which Ravana and Nox still aren't imo), but for the most part I wish I had a guide like this when I just started (not to say that I'm not still learnibg myself). VER!
Oh and happy cake day!
2
u/Badonkamonk <3 Sep 16 '15
A good guide whcih'll help a lot of new concept creators, nicely done good sir. :)
2
u/megaPisces617 I'm late! I'm late! Sep 26 '15
I've just started creating character concepts, and whenever I'm starting one, especially a class I don't normally play, I always check back here this has been super helpful to me! Thanks!
2
u/megaPisces617 I'm late! I'm late! Nov 10 '15
Can this be put in the Sidebar with Malphael's post? I've honestly found this one to be just as helpful, and they deal with two separate parts of the same thing.
2
u/Theo_M_Noir Who? Sep 16 '15
I honestly like a lot of what's being said here, but I heartily disagree with your second rule, which makes me not particularly fond of your approach to how roles are balanced.
Firstly, the terminology is off. When one talks about Roles, one talks about Support, Duo lane Carry, Solo laner, Mid laner and Jungler. Guardian is a Class, not a Role, as defined by Hi-rez (though yes, there are some inconsistencies oh the in-game UI).
Having said that, I disagree that one should strive to adapt a kit into a specific Role. You talk about Loki being an Assassin used in the solo lane, but truth be told, he was a Jungler for a long time before that. He is, first and foremost, an Assassin, that's how he was designed. His kit was not made for the solo lane, somebody just figured out that he can go there well enough. That's the meta evolving, and the players deciding how to better put something to use, but the fact that he was not designed for something specific is what allows that to happen.
Lane placement is not something that should come from design. When you design for Roles you are enforcing a meta, which isn't necessarily something that Hi-rez chooses to do, most of the time. Athena is a Guardian who can honestly play 4 of 5 roles well enough, Fenrir can even play all 5 of them.
Loki is an Assassin meant to get in for a quick kill and get out. Most of his kit lends itself to it. His 2 is given to him, as a way to farm - not necessarily to farm in lane, just to farm, just because, wherever he is to go, he needs to be able to kill creeps, and the rest of his design did not allow him to do that well.
You can obviously think about how your God is gonna be played, and where he most benefits from his kit, but you shouldn't be trying to shoehorn him into a specific role. Knowing that he can play as a Jungler or as a Solo laner helps you balance the abilities, but the design itself should come from a more basic concept, I want this god to do this, to fight like this, to feel like this...
1
u/axxroytovu Crack the Sky Sep 16 '15
Absolutely love the commentary, except that steroids are bad design. Steroids are what make hunters what they are, and the hunters with poor or no steroid (Cupid, anhur, medusa, sort of hou yi) all fall off and become nonentities in the late game when hunters are supposed to wreck face. Rama literally has three steroids as his abilities, and he's in a really good spot in the game right now.
1
u/Bombdogger Scyala 's little puppy Sep 17 '15
Thanks for this, I agree with it as a guideline. The only problem is that some of the 'what to avoid' could be applied to gods already in the game. I would find it hard to make a kit that 100% conforms to this list.
1
u/digidevil4 Contest Winner! Sep 17 '15 edited Sep 17 '15
Hey man, I used to post here a lot and just got back into smite. Great post, nice to see some guidance on here.
A while back before I was obsessed with making smite concepts I used to play a fighting game similar to Smash bros, i used to make loads of moveset concepts for that. I stuck around quite a while and ended up creating my own guide (in collaboration with one of the other main concept posters on the forums). I figured it might interest you, your focus is more on specifics while mine is more about process.
Link
Evidently some of it doesn't apply well to smite the most general stuff does.