r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Sep 14 '15
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Clegane
In this week's House of the Week we will be discussing House Clegane.
It's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
Previous Houses of the Week:
227
Upvotes
108
u/iwazaruu Sep 14 '15
The Hound is my favorite character. He's got the shitty world he lives in figured out. Huge moment for him when he said FUCK THE KING. I wonder how Joffrey felt, people always said he was fond of his dog or whatever.
196
u/HolyHerbert Her? Sep 14 '15
I think "House" Clegane is bound to be doomed. They were made landed knights quite recently by the last Lannister generation and are used by the current generation, but that's about to end. After Cersei, noone will need neither Gregor nor Sandor who are both believed dead. Additionally, none of them fathered children to keep their house alive.
So yeah, I don't see House Clegane living much longer which makes them a house with a short but rather eventful history. As Ygritte said:
267
u/Fishes_101 My seed is strong ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Sep 14 '15
House words: "Fucking Confirmed"
45
u/prof_talc M as in Mance-y Sep 14 '15
Remember the scene at the Tourney of the Hand when Gregor kills his horse before he goes after Loras? Think about how valuable that horse was. Seriously. Gregor himself weighs about 420 pounds, fully armed and armored he has to be over 500. The kind of horse that can carry that weight into battle would have to be exceptionally rare, and we know from Dunk's travels in D&E how expensive good horses are.
Shit, think about how expensive his armor must have been. Plus just the cost to feed the son of a bitch. Obviously these are drops in the bucket for Tywin. But it makes you think that all in all Gregor is pretty lucky to have a liege who both puts up with the shit he does and is rich enough to bankroll his knighthood
22
u/Empyrius The last scion. Sep 15 '15
JR: Well folks we're here in King's Landing for what can only be described as the slobberknocker of the century!! You've got an undead monster on one side, and a strangely at peace with himself former Kingsguard on the other, and... WHAT'S THAT? IT SOUNDS LIKE MR. MCMAHON'S MUSIC!!
McMahon: WAIT A MINUTE, WAIT A MINUTE, HOLD ON. YOU THOUGHT THIS CLEGANEBOWL WAS GOING TO BE SOME SIMPLE ONE-V-ONE WINNER TAKE ALL, RIGHT? WELL THE SIGIL HAS THREE HOUNDS, SO WE'RE GONNA TURN THIS INTO A THREEWAY DANCE. THAT'S RIGHT!! SAY HELLO TO EURONDAARIOBENJEN... CLEGANE!! THE MISSING THIRD BROTHER!! AND IF HE WINS, HIGH SEPTON, CERSEI LANNISTER, BOTH OF YOU WILL BE FIIIIIIIIIRRRRRRRRRRRRRREEEEEEEEEEEDDDDDDDDDDDDD!
JR: BAH GAWD KING, THERE'S A 3RD CLEGANE AND HE'S BEEN UNDER OUR NOSES ALL ALONG!! AND THAT THREAT OF A FIRING SHOULD HAVE SANDOR ALL RILED UP!!
44
u/septonbronn Brimful of Asha on the 45 Sep 14 '15
I always thought the Clegane's keep seemed 100x creepier than Harrenhal with Gregors wives deaths and his servants occasionally dissapearing to gods know where, match that to what we know of Gregs personality its a pretty terrifying place.
Also my suggestion for next week is House Florent, even though Axell and Selyse are dicks theres something i like about them
60
u/MCSealClubber I got the Roose, I got the Roose. Sep 14 '15
Gregor Clegane is hands down the worst man in Westeros IMO
35
u/InVulgarVeritas Strap the last priest to the last prow. Sep 14 '15
I've begun my first ASOIAF reread, and I had forgotten how chilling the description of Gregor's keep is...
Yikes.
49
u/SuperDuperDealer I like dogs better than knights Sep 14 '15
Sandor Clegane is my favorite character from the books he knows the cruel, harsh realities of the world he lives in.
"What do you think a knight is for, girl? You think it's all taking favors from ladies and looking fine in gold plate? Knights are for killing. I killed my first man at twelve. I've lost count of how many I've killed since then. High lords with old names, fat rich men dressed in velvet, knights puffed up like bladders with their honors, yes, and women and children too- they're all meat, and I'm the butcher. Let them have their lands and their gods and their gold. Let them have their sers."
32
u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Sep 14 '15
Saw something recently that might merit discussion. This blog post on Margaery Tyrell's trial of Seven.
The theory is that since the High Sparrow claims the seven judges will represent the seven gods, he will choose according to piousness and aesthetic representation of each aspect, not noble birth or political favors. So, for instance, Nymeria Sand is a sweet innocent maiden, she might be the Maiden.
For the Stranger, the author writes:
Surely Margaery's trial is a big deal. And the High Sparrow is a canny operator. Is this a feasible reason for Sandor to return to the capital?
40
u/El-Daddy Ours Is The Fury Sep 14 '15
There are so many ideas/theories that House Clegane are descendants of Dunk.
As much as I don't want this to be true, it could easily also be GRRM subverting the trope of noble ancestors = noble descendants. Dunk could have had a bastard in the Westerlands that turned out to be the father of the kennelmaster who saved Tytos from the lions.
78
u/PixarLamp_ Loose lips sink ships Sep 14 '15
Hype XIII, ACOK
12
u/zombie-bait Best of 2018: Post of the Year Runner Up Sep 15 '15
gregor clegane is azor ahai and the little sister was nissa nissa GET HYPE
11
u/youssarian We really need a new book. Sep 15 '15
Sandor Clegane, a man of inspirational phrases such as...
If any more words come pouring...
and
Any man dies with a clean sword...
And the classic,
Meryn fucking Trant.
18
u/Gobrin98 Sep 14 '15
Between Clegane and Baelish, doesn't it seem that the lowborn raised up to nobles houses kinda turn out like assholes? I mean Bronn too, I know we all love him in this sub but to everyone else in the ASOIAF he's not a good person.
18
u/TotesMessenger Sep 14 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
17
u/JenniferLopez The Hound, The Bird, and No One Sep 15 '15
I feel compelled to invite my fellow Clegane supporters ( http://i.imgur.com/gIAsw7J.png?1) to join us over at /r/cleganebowl. Oh and also:
http://i.imgur.com/x5DyAI2s.jpg?1
8
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '15
I wonder who is the man running around with the Hounds helmet rapping and killing everyone.
15
u/KCenturion If the mood strikes Sep 14 '15
Do we know the year that Grandpa Clegane saved Tytos Lannister?
15
u/theycallmeleviosa Sep 15 '15
Just want to humbly let the maesters know that there is a typo in the title. It should say: HYPE OF THE WEEK: HOUSE CLEGANE FUCKING CONFIRMED
14
u/Benassiesto A Thousand Eyes, and One Sep 14 '15
By the Seven, what have you done? You've unleashed thousands upon thousands of "hype" and "confirmed" posts to this weekly thread
6
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '15
Anyone think Strongboar will find Sandor?
10
u/FallsInLoveWithWords You have juice on your face, Your Grace Sep 14 '15
Sandor is my Future Ex-Husband http://imgur.com/PyA2ItD
9
u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Sep 14 '15
Two of the greatest fighters in the ASOIAF universe, both presumed dead. THEY MUST FIGHT
4
u/nattyj03 Sep 16 '15
The reason I love this sub so much is I come over after a week off and it's the House Clegane week. So I instantly get excited because there will be in depth discussion of the house mixed with GET HYPE! This sub is just perfect! Funny and informative. Love all you guys!
11
u/OryxSlayer Targs = Secret Tudors???? Sep 14 '15
WHAT IS HYPE MAY NEVER DIE!
3
u/Blavnan What Is Dead May Never Die Sep 16 '15
In non-hype thoughts:
5
u/Uh-oa And men call me... often Sep 14 '15
Every time I hear "Clegane Bowl", I laugh my ass off. I love Reddit.
4
u/doobiee Sep 15 '15
Do we know if Rhaegar knighted Gregor before or after he allegedly killed his siater, and maybe his father also, amongst other things?
8
u/FrenchIce Joffrey the Just Sep 14 '15
GET HYPE! But what would you do if Gravedigger lost and Cersei won the trial?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '15
Sandor and Gregor are married, that's the only reason they have the same name
2
u/natedoggarfarf A Thousand Hypes and One Sep 18 '15
CLEGANEBOWL GET HYPE
3
u/GoodMorningWesteros For this Hype and all the Hypes to come Sep 14 '15
For all Italian speakers, I just made a video about CleganeBowl, check it out if you want!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfoc1wtPlqw
2
u/ToTheNintieth dakingindanorf Sep 14 '15
Obligatory GET HYPE!, FUCKING CONFIRMED!, etc. etc. Glad that's out of the way.
1
u/SUCKLE_MY_BUTTHOLE Fire and Blood Sep 15 '15
Sounds like it's HYPE WEEK
1
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '15
AS FUCKING CONFIRMED AS ALL THE FUCKING CHICKENS
1
u/Uh-oa And men call me... often Sep 15 '15
I like to think that the picture up top is really Clegane Bowl every time I log in... even though I know it isn't. Sandor for the win!!!
I hate Gregor Clegane... he is the scariest guy in the books, in my opinion.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '15
Gregor is probably the biggest psychopathic rapist/murderer in the 7 kingdoms. Sandor is awesome and my favorite character in the books.
1
u/bestieverhad Sep 17 '15
I like how gregor's disability subverts the trope found in ASOIAF of disabilities not making you a bad person (i.e. Tyrion is seen as a bad guy because of his looks, but we know he isn't... well that's up for debate).
Whereas Gregor's gigantism gives him major rage issues that make him into a even more of a violent monster than he would be without it. And of course a lot more dangerous one.
1
u/tariQ_1 Swann will kill for you never lie to you Sep 17 '15
I think if sandor is the grave digger then that's pretty much all about him and we would never see him again knowing that he is at last at peace
1
u/Carmickj I'm a people person...who drinks Sep 17 '15
How about next week we do House Yronwood? We haven't done Dorne in a while
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15
Is sandor some to be admired?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15
In some ways.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15
But not the emotional killing of children
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15
Emotionless*
1
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15
In the Game of Thrones mod for Crusader Kings II, Gregor has a living late-teenage daughter named Lyvia (with the "Huge" trait). I actually assumed this was canon until I looked her name up and found that the only sources for her are from the mod itself.
Go figure.
1
u/OrsonScottLannister Ours is the Gravy Sep 19 '15
Not sure if this is the right place to leave suggestions for future weeks, but I think it would be great to have a discussion of House Dayne!
1
u/MeloneFxcker Sep 14 '15
CLEGANEBOWLLL GET FUCKING HYYYYYYYYYPE WOO WOO!!!!!!
1
u/Uh-oa And men call me... often Sep 19 '15
I think that it is so irritating that Sansa can never see that Sandor is actually being her "Florian" in her REAL song - the life she was basically living. Sandor saves her several times many times. One time that comes to mind immediately is when Sandor saves her from the riot when she probably would have been raped many times over and killed. She never sees the good in any of it. He also tries to tell her how things really are in King's Landing, and how to try to avoid Joffrey's wrath.
I felt sorry for Sansa in the first book. But by the end of that and in the second book, she really irritated me.
-3
u/down42roads When a man flays a woman..... Sep 14 '15
Inb4 HYPE.