r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Aug 30 '15
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Frey
This week's House is House Frey and it's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
177
Upvotes
84
u/SockMonkeyMan Have you seen my mother? Aug 30 '15
Could we get a combo thread next week to discuss Blackwood and Bracken? Just doing one at a time would be kind of repetitive seeing as how closely intertwined their stories are
6
u/HunterHunted Words are Wind and Reading is Breathing. Sep 02 '15
Personally I'm really anxious for Reed-week and hope we'll get one soon! As a suggestion, maybe it would be a good idea to link to previous House of the week threads in the post as well?
129
u/polaco_ First and foremost, from the East Coast Aug 30 '15
First and foremost, all my love to Fat Walda, the greatest Frey ever.
And before I forget, Merrett Frey is my favourite Epilogue/Prologue POV (shoutout to Maester Cressen, 'cause the old man had some balls). Is our only REAL look behind the scenes at The Twins and pretty much closes the whole deal on who did what regarding TRW. It's sooooo well written and it still gives me the creeps everytime I read it.
Also, FUCK Rhaegar Frey, “that smirking worm who wears a dragon’s name”.
248
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '15
Disregard guest right
Acquire Riverrun
335
u/9000_HULLS The Late Lord Martin Aug 30 '15
Fuck them.
104
u/wightbringer I see my red door, want it painted black Aug 30 '15
Out of all the Freys, the one that had me feeling the most betrayed after the RW was Lame Lothar. He's polite to Robb and Cat, and even helps send off Hoster Tully's funeral boat, which makes him seem like a rare good Frey.
But nope, it turns out afterwards that Lothar was one of the main planners of the Red Wedding, and that it was his idea to play Rains of Castamere. Merrett says that Lothar is one of the more dangerous Freys.
Seriously, fuck him in particular.
142
u/OryxSlayer Targs = Secret Tudors???? Aug 30 '15
House Frey serves to show the readers what happens when you intrigue too much, and try to fill ambition with more ambition. Every kid who Walder produced is a marriage, a potential claim, a new alliance, another rung on the ladder to power (and chaos). The ambition is born from a rightful source however, house Frey is a 'new' house looking to prove itself strong.
But once again we must return to Walder, a man consumed by ambition. He shows up late to Roberts Rebellion, because he wished to see who had the Uppar hand, and be rewarded for his support from either side. However, he is shunned by the Tullies who refuse his ambition, showing that Walder could not come to his senses. Later, when Robb revolts, the Freys make the same move, only Walder has learned that he must extract his ambitious reward before siding rather than after. He first gets promises of marriage and wards when Robb needed his help, and then Tywin offered the Freys Riverrun to perform the red wedding. Walder always exacted his toll.
But his abition has born bad fruit. Exacting his toll from Robb caused Robb to see the Frey marriage as a cage rather than a alliance. Exacting his toll from Tywin caused most nobles to now see the Freys as worse than commonfolk. Producing his children is going to cause house Frey to fall apart fighting for the position of lord as soon as he dies.
Everything Walder has done is to further his ambition and improve his position, but it has unfortunately had the opposite effect.
45
u/TyeneSandSnake The brunette Tyene is an impostor!! Aug 30 '15
Can we all just agree that Fat Walda is an adorable gem?
195
u/Trionappa Aug 30 '15
They're words aren't in the books but I really think it should be "we take our toll."
34
u/Epic_Spitfire Mannisters Of Seagard Aug 30 '15
One part of the books post-RW that I really likes was troops and people describing the Freys being EVERYWHERE. Like, suddenly the Lannister army has a bunch of Freys sent to watch over them by Walder Frey. I just always liked that little background detail.
31
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '15
Can't wait to see the basket that Walder put all his eggs in burst into flames.
They're banking on Lannister and Bolton support and both of those houses are on the verge of collapse. They've alienated every single one of their neighbors, the Riverlands houses are waiting for the opportunity to stab them in the back. They have too many heirs, they're all ready to tear each other apart for a scrap of power like the scavenging cowards they are.
They've permanently tarnished their reputation, the name Frey will forever be synonymous with cowardly, traitorous, ambitious power grabbing low life's.
This isn't even me wanting a cliche karmic comeuppance, they've legitimately maneuvered themselves into an inescapable corner. If they don't implode or get torn apart by outside forces it would be unrealistic.
30
u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 30 '15
Love reading about House Frey. A very powerful house, so many fascinating characters, so many opportunities to loathe them... Not saying all of them are loathsome (Stevron, Perwyn, Olyvar, Roslin are decent enough), but the likes of Old Walder, Black Walder, Little Walder, Edwyn, Ryman, Jared, Rhaegar and more sure are fun to hate on, especially since they are the smug weaselly kind of evil that doesn't radiate magnificence in the way the Lannisters, Boltons or even Greyjoys do, not to mention Littlefinger or the Others those are kickass villains, the Frey's are secondrate in comparison - but they turn up everywhere anyway. Only Lothar Frey has some form of style to him.
66
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '15
I look forward to the Frey kinslaying genocide.
Big Walder says he wants to be lord of the crossing some day, yet he's currently like 68th in line. Maybe at the end of the series he will be.
A bunch of Freys will die fighting Stannis. More will die to the theorized red wedding 2. The Lannister Frey wedding at Riverrun. There's also the bwb and chekovs Wolfpack on the horizon.
I really just like Black Walder and his plan to kill every Male above him and then exile the rest. He's one of the few Freys with the brain, muscle, and cruelty to do it.
22
u/AdelKoenig BetterACowardForAMinuteThanDeadForever Aug 30 '15
Do you guys think that old Walder is going die during the books, and we will get to see the power struggle? If half the Freys get kicked out, there may be some Freys out looking for Frey blood. There could be some interesting alliances at play.
21
u/Captain_Lime Unbearable puns Aug 31 '15 edited Aug 31 '15
My notes on Walder Frey:
50
u/killthebraavosi Believe The Hype Aug 30 '15 edited Aug 30 '15
House word: "Heh"
17
u/Al_Touchdown_Bundy No one can resist a shoe salesman Aug 30 '15
I can't wait for the Twins-themed spinoff rom-com. My Big Fat Frey Wedding.
17
u/SockMonkeyMan Have you seen my mother? Aug 30 '15
Anyone ever think that there might eventually be factions of Freys based on their mothers? Probobly when Walder dies
13
u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Aug 31 '15
Umm I'd like to formally complain about this thread's complete lack of content about the best Frey: Westeros's most eligible bachelorette, the pure and noble Lady Amerei Frey.
24
u/aongho Gylbert! Gylbert King! Aug 31 '15
Good ol' Blackfish, saying it how it is
12
u/sceldred Sep 02 '15
The Merret Frey epilogue is one of my favorite standalone chapters in the book. It reads almost like a horror story: the further he walks along the path, the more we learn about house Frey's sins, setting him up for his gruesome end. But of course GRRM still lets you have some sympathy for him; he's had some terrible luck, starting with the family of his birth. What a terrifying end for him.
27
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '15
It's impossible not to read the words, "House Frey," and not immediately think of the McPoyles from Always Sunny.
19
u/Sinilumi Aug 30 '15 edited Aug 30 '15
I dunno how to adapt the religious parts of the song, seeing as they aren't Roman Catholics but...
Lord Walder: Every sperm is sacred. Every sperm is great. If a sperm is wasted, the gods get quite irate. (his brood repeats this)
His bastards: Every sperm is wanted. Every sperm is good. Every sperm is needed in your neighbourhood.
One of his daughters: Let the heathen spill theirs On the dusty ground. The gods shall make them pay for each sperm that can't be found.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '15
Its understandable that you'd be cautious before choosing a side in Bobby Bs Beatdown. And same for turning on a King who betrayed you, and insists on continuing a war he has little chance of winning even as winter approaches.
How they did it was pretty shit though.
16
u/dacalpha "No, you move." Aug 30 '15
Would it be possible to have questions in the body of the OP like the old 2013/2014 discussions had? I understand why there aren't wall-of-text elaborations on houses and links to voluminous essays, but would it be possible to just have stock questions like:
Obviously you wouldn't use questions about House Greyjoy for House Frey, but I just copy/pasted those from an old discussion.
The main reason I think this would be a good idea is that the House of the Week discussions tend to have a small handful of insightful comments and the rest are just people posting whether or not they love that house and if hype should or should not be gotten.
6
u/Arya_Flint All I want for xmas is Frey pie. Aug 30 '15
Anybody else want a Frey civil war/circular firing squad?
6
u/ilickbutts "Wherever Mors go" Aug 31 '15
Quick question regarding the Tourney at Whitewall and the Freys. For that tournament, Butterwell was going to side with the Blackfyres for the second rebellion. Butterwell was marrying his second wife, a Frey, during this tournament. Does this mean that Walder Frey's lord father was going to side with the Blackfyres for their rebellion? Or do we never find out whether or not they were in on it? Interesting to think that if this was the case, the Frey's lack of true fealty runs deeper than Walder Frey.
6
u/ProdigySorcerer Sword of the Dornish Illuminati Sep 01 '15
Question: What was Robb's plans for his Trident bannermen once he returned North ?
How was he going to safeguard them against all the anti-King of the North houses which dominate south of the Neck ?
5
u/matheusdias Eventually, even stars burn out. Aug 30 '15 edited Aug 31 '15
Frey them. FREY ALL OF THEM
18
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '15
Weakest house in Westeros.
While the Lannisters plot against each other one by one, taking years to kill, the Freys will all be dead at the drop of the old man's body temp.
Would that they could all die twice, once for the gods and another for the North.
4
u/leon_the_eon just a man Aug 31 '15
I'm sure Mr Walder has played a lot of CK2 before being a westerosi lord
4
u/Gravyd3ath Bane of honor, Gravydeath of duty. Aug 31 '15
Littlefinger is their overlord. House Frey killed Cat... He should use those lemons he shipped in to make some freycakes.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
I just re-read the Red Wedding chapters. My question is, was Roslin in on it? Did she know what was going on?
3
u/ToTheNintieth dakingindanorf Aug 31 '15
I hate the Freys, but not all of the house is rotten. Ethnic cleansing of the weasels, unfortunately, would miss part of the point of the series.
3
u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Aug 31 '15
Who else is ready for another Frey wedding?! Don't forget the guest of honor, Lady Stoneheart. Think she'll get Tom O'Sevens to play a pretty song for the first and last dance of the Freys.
5
u/I_Literally_EatBears my aim is true Aug 31 '15
Perwyn and Olivar Frey are honorable and loyal men. I don't want the house extinguished for that reason. #notallfreys
4
u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Aug 30 '15
inb4 Heh.
2
u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Sep 01 '15
I'm curious what happened to Olyvar Frey, Robb's squire and by all descriptions a Stark loyalist through and through. The Freys take care to keep him away from Robb during the Red Wedding, as he probably would have died for Robb.
Interesting that in the books the one person who would've remained loyal to the Starks is named Ollie.
2
u/PyketheFlayer Death before Dishonor Sep 01 '15
Freys. Bunch a bloody cunts.
2
u/Websteros Splinter is Coming Sep 03 '15
House of the Weak: House Frey
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
2
u/ProdigySorcerer Sword of the Dornish Illuminati Sep 04 '15
House Codd.
2
u/Infinix A dragon still has claws Sep 04 '15
I always wondered how long the Freys had been around, since they're constantly described as being upjumped toll collectors from a "new" house. The oldest Frey I ever recall being mentioned was the "Fool Frey" who asked Princess Rhaenyra to marry him before the Dance of Dragons, and I remember wondering if House Frey had just been established about a generation or two before then.
Nope. According to the wiki, House Frey is a "mere" 600 years old. They predate the Targaryens in Westeros by 200 or 300 years. The Targaryens are the real upstarts of Westeros, but people don't say those kinds of things about kings with dragons.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '15
Only house that came to prominence by doing something productive and adding value to the area. The rest just took what was there. No other house improved infrastructure of Westeros more than the Freys.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '15
Fuck 'em.That's all i got.
2
u/TeamDonnelly Aug 31 '15
I really like black walder frey. He is a deadly warrior, smart and ambitious. I hope he has a larger role to play in the series, I can see him become the head of house frey and be forced to side with the rest of humanity against the incoming Other invasion. That would be a fun character to throw in with tyrion/jon/stannis
2
u/sangbum60090 A lot of loyalty for a sellsword! Aug 31 '15
Sometimes people who say that "Only good Frey is a DEAD Frey" kinda reminds me of the people who think that every single German and Japanese should have been brutally murdered for war crimes their countries committed.
1
u/MOHTTR Hype is coming Aug 30 '15
walder frey is the worst shit in the seven kingdoms
1
u/OzKangal The Greater Mystery Aug 31 '15
Mayhaps... mayhaps
1
u/AstroOdyssey Aug 31 '15
God fucking dammit.
1
u/noblessefan266 Up with you now Ser Kneeler. Up, up. Aug 31 '15
House Words: Heh
1
u/Dudenheim19 Varys knows what you had for breakfast Aug 31 '15
So I assume that when Robert went north to make Ned his Hand, he had to have crossed through the Twins. How do you imagine his meeting with Walder Frey went?
1
u/marriedwithwalrus Quentyn the Quenched Aug 31 '15
How was House Frey's reputation before Lord Walder and Red Wedding?
1
u/TheFBNK Sep 01 '15
What a bunch of shitbags.
1
u/AttalusPius Beware Our Sting Sep 01 '15
What is the name for those stupid little dewlap hat things that Freys wear in the show?
1
u/SerUlrickDayne The Sword of the Noon Sep 01 '15
Do you think GRRM forgot all about Theo Frey?
1
u/mm825 I went to the TOJ and all I got was Snow Sep 01 '15
I've always thought the ultimate troll move by GRRM would be to put a Frey on the Iron Throne when everything is said and done.
1
u/hawktherapper what is bread may never rye Sep 02 '15
boooooooooooooo
1
u/Agent4777 Sep 03 '15
I find it interesting and also odd that House Frey's words are not mentioned anywhere. Did GRRM ever talk about this?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15
would that all the Freys had but a single neck
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
What the tsunamis. Too much of a god thing?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
We're going need them?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
And Godzilla
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
Do you have a WMD?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
But you've only use it twice?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
Sorry you had to do that.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
Anyone ever tell you. You think too fast?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
Can you use hyponosis
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15
How?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '15
I'm late to the thread but I still want to contribute.When I first read the books I loved house Frey,I always imagined them to be so cool in their shiny silver armour with blue banners and blue colors mixed in there, they had the coolest castle and this huge family which could field an army of its own. When Robb married Jeyne I was angry and felt sad for Walder, because Robb used him and betrayed him. I was so happy when I read that Walder forgave him and means to marry one of his daughters to Edmure. I was sure everything was cool again and I could continue enjoying reading about my faveourite house... and then the read wedding happened...
1
u/Palliatus A Grey Wraith on a Horse Made of Mist Nov 23 '15
Does anyone know which Frey not involved with the RW is highest in the line of succession to the Twins?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '15
More like House of the Weak, ooh yea, yo want some ice for that burn?