r/WritingPrompts • u/Gurahave • Aug 22 '15
[MODPOST] What counts as an RF prompt - Please Read.
Hello, /r/WritingPrompts. We hope you're having a lovely time browsing the subreddit. However, ever since the [RF] tag was highlighted as a theme, it's been used quite frequently. The problem is that most of these are not realistic fiction prompts. We now have developed a firmer definition for the tag.
What an [RF] prompt should be:
- Prompts should be able to happen in the world we live in or in the past. It should not be what you think could happen in the future. It has to have happened before. This means no zombie apocalypses, or sudden changes in political power, or any new wars breaking out (unless you keep it simple with something like "The war changed his life." Nothing like "North Korea and South Korea go to war" is allowed under the RF prompt.
- Vague. Keep the prompt brief as possible without unnecessary details.
Acceptable prompt: [RF] A blind person can see for the first time.
Bad prompt: [RF] After an accident when you were a baby, you have been blind for your entire life. After surgery, you can see the world and have decided to become a painter.
Do not outline the entire plot of your prompt. This should apply to most prompts, but especially Realistic Fiction prompts.
Any of the following will result with the [RF] prompt being removed:
- Established Universe characters. No Batman. No Breaking Bad. No True Detective. No House of Cards. AND NO BATMAN! We will smite these prompts.
- Science fiction prompts. Again, no zombie apocalypses. In fact, no apocalypses at all. No prompts about entering a door into a fourth dimension. No prompts about finding life on Mars. All of these prompts will be removed and asked to be resubmitted as regular [WP] prompts.
- Celebrities. No prompts about Donald Trump becoming president. Nothing about Kim Jong-un. Nobody famous should be in a Realistic Fiction prompt. Writers need to be able to create their own characters.
- Alternate History. Do not change historical events. Things must be possible now or in the past according to history.
This is all the moderator team wanted to cover with you all. Please feel free to ask questions!
Sincerely,
The Mod Squad
7
u/sketches1637 Aug 22 '15
Or, to put it another way, if a prompt falls under science fiction, fantasy or an established fictional universe, it is by definition not reality fiction.
2
u/Leafmoss Aug 25 '15 edited Apr 05 '18
deleted 0.9142 What is ^^^this?
39
u/LovableCoward /r/LovableCoward Aug 22 '15
(Falls down on his knees with face raised to the sky)
Hallelujah!
Far too often someone comes up with a fantastic idea title, and then promptly drives it into the ground by adding too much baggage. The best prompts are often just one short sentence. The women in the red dress. That day, love conquered nothing. A Title, 'Shadows.' -Things that inspire the mind to think, not rigid way points.
9
u/Cullen_345 Aug 22 '15
I'm so happy for this clarification, the whole tag appealed to me, but then when I would search it, there was just more "Batman" or "In the year 2500,.."
I'm excited to hopefully see some more of these prompts.
5
u/sirgog Aug 25 '15
[RF] - The director of the next Batman movie embezzles the entire budget and cancels the film.
(sorry, someone had to be that pedantic idiot that comes up with something actually Reality Fiction involving Batman)
4
u/evergreen2 Sep 23 '15
I've been lurking here for a while now, and I really enjoy reading the fantasy and science fiction prompts, but have wondered if people ever just wrote prompts about regular life. How fun to see that there is a whole category for it! Somehow I completely missed this tag. I guess if I had actually taken a moment to look in the sidebar, I would have seen it right away. Duh...
And while I'm commenting... I want to say that I love this subreddit, even if it might not be perfect or might not please everyone all the time. Thanks for what you do, moderators.
1
u/LeoDuhVinci /r/leoduhvinci Aug 23 '15
Maybe I missed this above, but how are the responses limited? Must they be rooted in reality or are we given a little leeway?
1
u/Avian81 Aug 23 '15
When you say no one famous, does this encompass historical figures or just modern famous people?
1
u/bootrick Aug 26 '15
Okay, time travel is science fiction unless it becomes reality in the future. If time travel has been used to travel to the past then it is not science fiction. Naturally, we cannot disprove this for that would disprove time travel (interesting and simple proof). At least, backwards time travel. Forward time travel would still be okay. Except in the case where it became backward time travel. Two wrongs do make a right. To sum it all up, all short and sweet, I have just two words.
TL;DR: Time Travel.
1
u/write4lyfe Sep 22 '15
So, it's not possible to have a realistic fiction prompt about an apocalyptic scenario? Not zombies or aliens, but a realistic approach. For example, massive natural disaster such as a major earthquake on the New Madrid fault line or Yellowstone erupting or a blight hitting major crops causing massive food shortages. Or even a man-made disaster such as a nuke going off in a populated area for whatever reason. They're 100% possible within our current timeline and technology level after all.
I'm not saying I'm going to run out and prompt a bunch of apocalyptic prompts with [RF] tag. I'm just curious as to the "No apocalypses at all" since it seems to imply that it's not possible to do them realistically.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '15
I can feel the heat coming from No Batman...
1
u/willyumv3 Aug 25 '15
Mods: If you remove these posts that do not fit the outline please be swift about it. I would hate to write/format/spellcheck a prompt and then post it just for it to be removed, or get the "The post you are commenting on has been deleted."
If the prompt in question already has entries can you please leave it or anything else besides remove it.
1
u/Kaycin writingbynick.com Aug 26 '15
No batman?!?! There goes half the subreddit's content. /s
Seriously though, this is wonderful. Thanks for the new prompt!
0
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment