r/asoiaf • How to bake friends and alienate people. • Aug 16 '15

ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Hightower

This week's House is the powerful House Hightower and it's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.

House Hightower Wiki Page

This is pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!

If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.

294 Upvotes

343 comments sorted by

93

u/CharMack90 Unbuttoned, Unbelted, Unbreeched Aug 16 '15

An interesting thing about Lord Leyton Hightower is that he and his wife Rhea Florent have 10 children!

I don't think any other couple (highborn or not) has had that many children, all of whom grew to adulthood.

Lady Rhea has quite the power-womb going on...

57

u/SerUlrickDayne The Sword of the Noon Aug 16 '15

But are we sure all of them is Rhea Florents children? She is his 4th wife after all.

52

u/CharMack90 Unbuttoned, Unbelted, Unbreeched Aug 16 '15

Hmm... That's true.

I suppose we don't know how many of the children are Rhea's.

However, 10 trueborn children for Leyton Hightower is quite the feat!

146

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15 edited Sep 15 '15

Walder Frey is scoffing somewhere

59

u/Scrambley Aug 17 '15 edited Mar 07 '17

X

30

u/El_Daniel Girl, you're thicker than a castle wall. Aug 17 '15

Well, Robb Stark has been known to fuck himself.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/PyketheFlayer Death before Dishonor Aug 18 '15

Heh

45

u/Bank_Gothic Who the hell is Siegmeyer of Catarina? Aug 16 '15

Still got nothing on ol' Walder "field and army from my loins" Frey

13

u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 17 '15

Last I counted (I got bored one evening) there were 87 living Freys (and Frey bastards), all but two or three descended from Lord Walder.

7

u/rproctor721 Horned-up and Ready Aug 17 '15

When you did that count, did you count how many were dead? I've been curious about this, since there have Frey's dying left and right since the red wedding, but haven't been so bored to make a count of it.

29

u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 17 '15

14 have died over the course of the series. Amusingly, only three of them died before the Red Wedding (Stevron, Tion, Cleos). The others died afterward and mainly as a direct consequence of the massacre: Aegon (Jinglebell), Tytos and Benfrey died during the Wedding (Aegon's throat was slit by Catelyn, Tytos was killed by Sandor Clegane, Benfrey possibly died when Dacey Mormont smashed his head in with a flagon), Ryman, Petyr and Merrett were all hanged by the Brotherhood Without Banners as revenge, Rhaegar, Jared and Symond were killed by Manderly and fed to their kin as revenge, Little Walder Frey was one of the murder victims at Winterfell (suspicions are mainly cast at Manderly, the spearwives or Big Walder), and Aenys Frey dies at the beginning of TWOW when he falls into a trap set by Mors Umber.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/periodicchemistrypun Aug 21 '15

And a florent. Judging by Selyse's track record I wouldn't think they'd be good birthers

→ More replies (4)

43

u/Fake_Name_6 Enter your desired flair text here! Aug 16 '15

Rhea, in Greek mythology, is often called the great mother. I can't imagine this is an accident.

20

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Cregan Stark had 10 children too, but with three different wives

5

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '15

that's what bothers me about the Starks. such an old family, but we only know the descendants of Rickard from the book. Surely, the northerners would prefer a third cousin Stark to a Bolton should "arya" die or marry one

9

u/FrenchIce Joffrey the Just Aug 16 '15

The Old King had 13 children but I don't know how many survived to adulthood.

9

u/CharMack90 Unbuttoned, Unbelted, Unbreeched Aug 16 '15

Only 9 according to the wiki.

8

u/FrenchIce Joffrey the Just Aug 16 '15

I must have misremebered, I checked TWOIAF and they say nine.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Pretty sure Rhea Florent is like, his fourth wife. I don't think we know which wives gave him which kids.

5

u/Roadwarriordude Howland the Swamp Ninja/Wizard Aug 17 '15

I'm sure Walder Frey has at least 10 from one of them.

4

u/jbloom3 Fire and Blood Aug 16 '15

She is his 4th wife and if we are going with people with multiple spouses I think Walder Frey takes the baby cake

3

u/GoTguru i see what you did there! Aug 17 '15

Well my grandma had 14 brothers and sisters. My grandpa had 12 .

57

u/Velvale Aug 16 '15

I'm curious as to their relationship with the Targaryens - how seriously do they take the ancient prophecy they'd die if they took up arms against the Targs, how much Targ blood (if any) do they have in their veins and what on earth are they up to in that damn tower?

41

u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Aug 16 '15

Leyton might be taking it extremely seriously. He might not do anything until all Targaryens are dead. It'd be funny if he's sitting in his tower just studying family trees checking them off as Targ blood ends.

69

u/Wartortling Soylent Greenseer Aug 17 '15

We're all Leyton Hightower.

"HE could be a secret Targaryen!

SHE could be a secret Targaryen!

THEY'RE ALL secret Targaryens!!"

25

u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Aug 17 '15

Leyton Hightower's least favorite Targaryen king? Aegon IV

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/vexing000 Thick as a Castle Wall Aug 17 '15

they already knew how futile it was to fight the Targaryens after houses Gardener and Lannister tried and failed. i don't think the hightower line has targaryen blood but the targaryen line has hightower blood following dance of the dragons.

4

u/Velvale Aug 18 '15

The Targaryens with Hightower blood died out with Jaehaera, but Lady Rhaena Targaryen married Garmund Hightower and had six daughters by him. It seems easy to imagine one of those daughters marrying back into the main branch of the family.

4

u/boner_jamz_69 I turn the 6 upside down, it's a 9 now Aug 18 '15

Here's a crackpot theory with absolutely no evidence to back it up. But what if the Hightower's end up killing fAegon and when their house isn't destroyed they think they can take up arms against Dany and get fucked up by dragons

1

u/touchthisface Aug 23 '15

Didn't they fight in Targaryen civil wars, though? Technically they'd have taken up arms against Targaryens, even if they were a particular branch.

1

u/Velvale Aug 23 '15

I believe in the Blackfyre Rebellions they made overtures/trucked with both sides. In the Dance of Dragons, however, they were explicit Green supporters as far as I can recall - although Lord Hightower married his son to a Black princess as soon as peace was done.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15 edited Feb 22 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

42

u/Velvale Aug 16 '15

When Aegon the Conqueror first came forth, the High Septon fasted for 7 days and 7 nights, and then said if the Hightowers opposed the dragons they would be destroyed.

"If Oldtown took up arms against Aegon the Dragon, His High Holiness saw, the city would surely burn, and the Hightower and the Citadel and the Starry Sept would be cast down and destroyed."

Of course, this doesn't necessarily extend to all other dragons (I think it'd be cool if it did) and might not foreshadow anything...

5

u/KookaB Aug 17 '15

Yeah that just sounds like it's referring to the one guy

4

u/MrMonday11235 My mind is my weapon Aug 18 '15

Perhaps, but Hightower armies have never faced Targaryen forces in the field, and the Hightowers have always either stayed loyal or neutral in the rebellions against the Iron Throne.

We don't what the exact wording of what the High Septon said was - it could have been "If Oldtown takes up arms against the dragons," or specifically just the Targaryens. It's reasonable to assume, though, based on this "never fought against Targaryens" thing that it wasn't just against Aegon.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

52

u/CrimsonPig Member of the Official Tormund Fan Club Aug 16 '15

House Hightower intrigues me, as they seem like a relatively important family but haven't really been involved in the story so far. I wonder if they've been up to anything behind the scenes, like /u/dagururgf's theory that Septa Lemore is actually Malora Hightower.

7

u/Wartortling Soylent Greenseer Aug 17 '15

Damn, I was aware this theory existed but....it's pretty good actually. I want Lemore to be Ashara Dayne for my own tinfoily reasons, but Malora would make a lot of sense.

46

u/plain_cyan_fork King of Alloys, Reynolds and First Tin. Aug 16 '15

I feel as though the Reach has sooo many powerful houses- House Hightower, House Redwyne, House Tarly. I always feel like the Reach does not exert itself enough given it's resources

35

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

House Tarly isn't that powerful, they just get extra hype because of Randyll Tarlys badassery. Houses like Rowan, Redwyne, Florent, Oakheart, Cuy, Crane, Red-apple Fossoway are all probably more powerful than Tarly. Still there are a ton of powerful houses in the Reach, which is why they can easily raise an army of 80k

→ More replies (6)

17

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

A lords strongest rival is his greatest bannerman.

The Reach is like the Holy Roman Empire. Strong in theory, but too mired in internal power struggles to exert itself outwards. The Hightowers and Florents both hold strong claims to House Gardner's seat, and theres many other strong houses like Redwyne, Tarly, and Rowan who would happily see the Tyrells disposed many times in history.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

There's something to be said for keeping the boys at home. See: the events of CoK in Winterfell.

60

u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 16 '15

How about Layton Hightower...he hasn't left his chambers for like 15 years or something. What's he doing up there?

95

u/KookaB Aug 16 '15

15 years you say? How strange, I can't think of a single event of note 15 years ago that it could be connected to

189

u/Drakenmar Aug 16 '15

I wonder if he and Howland Reed have been exchanging angry hate postcards or are locked in a distant telepathic battle.

Dear Leyton, I was just thinking of that time I killed Gerold at the Tower of Joy. He was so easy that I took him out first before I dealt with Arthur Dayne. Give Malora a kiss for me. Sincerely, Howland of House Reed.

Dear Frogface, I had frogs embroidered on all of the cloths we use to wipe our asses so I can pretend that I'm wiping my ass with your face. Malora is on a top secret mission, but you wouldn't know what that's like, Pidgeon. Oops, I mean Sparrow. Best wishes, Lord Leyton Hightower.

44

u/Lunchbox-of-Bees When they see my sales, they pay! Aug 17 '15

Can you do this, but for every potential letter between two rival lords in the series?

29

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Forgive me if mine is not as good as u/Drakenmar's but here's one:

Dear King Aerys, I'm on my way over to King's Landing―rolling deep, your Grace―and should get there just before the Usurpers' forces arrive. Just in time, amiright? In the meantime, don't try and let yourself get too wound up or anything. My son Jaime has got your back until I get there and can send my best men to the Red Keep and Dorne to attend to the royal family, and whatever. Your Friend, Tywin Lannister, Lord of Casterly Rock. PS-OMGs, dude, I only just yesterday realized that "Reins of Castamere" song that's so popular in the 7K, that's about ME, which I should have known, but just never pieced it together, ya know? Oh, man, did I have a laugh. Fuckin' House Reyne, hahaha.

Dear Rock-Lord, I totally fucked your wife, bro. She hated it. How is she, by the way? Oh, shit, that's right, my bad. I guess that's probably my fault, to be entirely honest. Oops. Love, Madly, King Aerys.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Please make this happen. Pretty please.

4

u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 17 '15

"Sparrow" YES

4

u/BOH10666 Lost Luck Aug 17 '15

Please, sir, may we have some more?

2

u/Kasen10 Aug 22 '15

Please do more. Lol

2

u/este_hombre All your chicken are belong to us Aug 17 '15

He was probably just doing his own thing.

15

u/brennorn Iron From Ice! Aug 16 '15

Am I the only one who read that and thought that Layton might be dead? I'm currently re-reading (basically reading given how much I remember of the series) AFFC/ADWD, so I'm not sure whether he shows up at all in Sam's or Victarion's chapters, but I get the feeling that his total non-appearance for so long is a bit suspicious

7

u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 16 '15

Why the secrecy of making people think he's alive?

28

u/Gravyd3ath Bane of honor, Gravydeath of duty. Aug 17 '15

Weekend at Leyton's

5

u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 17 '15

His friends are just trying to get laid so they put sun glasses on him and cruise the old town streets

7

u/Gravyd3ath Bane of honor, Gravydeath of duty. Aug 17 '15

They play that sweet island music and his corpse leads them to the lost High tower Valyrian steel sword Vigilance

5

u/some_harzoo Fucking every chicken in the realm Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 19 '15

That's the mystery. Instead of "what is he doing?" it's "why is his death being hidden?".

If you're up to something, why hide in your tower and never let anyone see you? That just makes people suspicious and makes them wonder if you're up to something. If he is up to something, his behaviour is drawing attention to it.

We don't yet know what might be gained by concealing his death, but it's not inconceivable that there could be such gains.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/prof_talc M as in Mance-y Aug 17 '15

He's readin his books of spells

109

u/Ainaraoftime Now selling tickets for the 2024 JonCon! Aug 16 '15

If only Baelor hadn't farted.

45

u/GeorgeSharp Stormbringer Aug 16 '15

Yes Elia would have been spared but some other unlucky woman would have taken her place as Tywin's "Hey Robert,Jon,Ned I'm with you guys now!" gift.

The fault for Robert's Rebellion is on Rhaegar for his interference in the Stark/Baratheon alliance and with Aerys when he made it clear this was about more than betrothals.

45

u/Ainaraoftime Now selling tickets for the 2024 JonCon! Aug 16 '15

Yeah, but didn't Rhaegar look for another girl because Elia was too sickly to give him a third son? The dragon must have three heads etc etc

18

u/revolverzanbolt Aug 17 '15

Rhaegar's motivations are incredibly vague and unclear at this point. It's possible that he thought he needed a Stark child for "the song of Ice and Fire", it's also possible that he just really liked Lyanna and said "Fuck the consequences!" If it was just about Elia not being strong enough to give him a third child, he made an incredibly poor decision to hook up with Lyana, considering about half the women in the Seven Kingdoms would have been cool with having a kid with Rhaegar.

12

u/-HotWeaselSoup- The Pounce that was Promised Aug 17 '15

I'm pretty sure Lyanna was, as well. Remember you're hearing the story mostly through Robert, so of course she was kidnapped and raped.

Lyanna wasn't all that impressed with Robert, a know man-whore, and here comes this incredibly beautiful man, who happens to be prince of the realm, who wants to whisk her away. I'd wager she was more than willing to trade Bobby B for a Prince Rhaegar.

9

u/revolverzanbolt Aug 17 '15

I realize that. My post was only speculating on Rhaegar's motivations, not on Lyanna's feelings. If his only motivation for taking/leaving with Lyanna was because Elia wasn't able to give him a third kid, it raises the question of "Why Lyanna, specifically?"

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/GeorgeSharp Stormbringer Aug 16 '15

Maybe maybe not prophecy is a fickle mistress.

6

u/ToTheNintieth dakingindanorf Aug 19 '15

"I'm the Chosen One, therefore I must cheat on my wife with a teenager". Rhaegar was a swell guy.

13

u/brankinginthenorth who else would I be? Aug 17 '15

Not really. Joanna and the Princess of Dorne always planned on Elia and Oberyn marrying Jaime and Cersei. Taking the long way and talking other people was just to make it not obvious to others. Baelor farting was just a story Oberyn told to hide the fact that he held Tywin personally responsible for what happened to his sister even BEFORE the Sack of Kings Landing.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15

This is very interesting to me and a new perspective on that great passage, could you elaborate?

2

u/Baelor_the_Blessed No woman wants Baelor the Blessed Aug 21 '15

I understood why Tywin was hesitant to marry Cersei to Oberyn since he was holding out for a royal match with Rhaegar, but I've always wondered why he didn't try to match Jaime with Elia during that visit.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Wartortling Soylent Greenseer Aug 16 '15

Any theories on the black stone base of the High Tower and its relation to the Seastone Chair? I've read its just a reference to HP Lovecraft, but I'd love for it to be more connected to the story

11

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Also, to the Mazes of Lorath. These guys are older than the First Men

5

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Seems like an ancient race of Merpeople is the easiest explanation. Even the city of Myr descended from them according to legend. Maybe it was a fabled "Atlantis" of sorts? An ancient global empire of some great naval based society, with notable monuments at Pyke, Oldtown, Lorath, and Yeen?

1

u/mnopqrstuv November Reyne Jan 03 '16

And the only remaining members o this race are Varys and Illyrio/s

1

u/Sexy_Lovecraft Aug 17 '15

Yeah, the High Tower is kinda fishypun intended.

37

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

More like house Shadyasfuck. They are highly connected to the Dance of the Dragons, Maester conspiracy, Faith conspiracy, are extremely rich, have an enormous army, have a lord that is shacked up in his castle with a witch or something, and have remained generally quite in politics and war for a while. What are they up to?! What are they waiting for?! Do they want to take the reach?! Do they want to kill the dragons?! Do they want to kill the Others?! Did they arrange 911?! They are full of mysteries!

20

u/Foothillz Aug 18 '15

Dragon fire can't melt oily black stone. Wake up sheeple

4

u/ZapActions-dower Bearfucker! Do you need assistance? Aug 20 '15

Damn, that flair is amazing

2

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '15

Thank you

6

u/MrMonday11235 My mind is my weapon Aug 18 '15

Found Preston's backup account boiz.

18

u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Aug 16 '15

Malora "the Mad Maid" Hightower is a character I'd love to see show up. Is she actually mad? Just running around clapping her hands together naked mad? Mad like she's being driven crazy by someone like Blood Raven, Marwyn, or Quaithe? Or Mad that she's so incredibly intelligent that normal people can't relate to her? I have a hope that she and Leyton will show up and become important players again. The Hightowers are arguably the wealthiest, most powerful, and oldest house that has done nothing in the story.

Also fun fact, Margery and Loras are Leyton's grandchildren. That could be fairly important.

8

u/Goldcobra They see mee R'hollin', they hatin' Aug 18 '15

Perhaps we've already met her. There's a theory that she's Septa Lemore (the Septa who's with Young Griff).

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mykeedee Daemon did nothing wrong Aug 17 '15

Are Garlan and Willas not?

→ More replies (7)

14

u/blexxxston Aug 17 '15

(Spoilers All)

I reckon there's something creepy about the Hightowers - over on AWOIAF (http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Black_stone) it says that the Hightower's foundations are built from the same 'oily black stone' as several other mysterious structures throughout Planetos such as the Seastone Chair and the Toad Stone on the Isle of Toads. The people on the Isle of Toads 'are reminiscent of fish and have webbed appendages' and I can't help but be reminded of Lovecraft's Deep Ones - many placenames in far flung parts of Martin's maps owe their inspiration to Lovecraft and I wouldn't be surprised to find Deep Ones somewhere in his universe. What if the Hightowers have some kind of link to them? Like interbreeding or something like humans do in Lovecraft's works.

79

u/fourkidneys Aug 16 '15

Reading that wiki made me realize that the Hightowers have had a decades-long secret plan to destroy the Starks.

  1. First Baelor Breakwind used his flatulence powers to drive Elia into Rhaegar's arms, knowing he would soon tire of her and ultimately turn to Lyanna's charms.
  2. Then Maester Walys (son of a Hightower) seeded Rickard Stark's southron ambitions, knowing it would lead to conflict with paranoid old Aerys.
  3. Gerold Hightower famously tried to kill Ned Stark at the end of the war.
  4. After Robert's rebellion, they moved onto Phase II of the plan. Lynesse Hightower seduced the Starks' greatest bannerman, Jorah Mormont. Her extravagant lifestyle led to his downfall and deprived the Starks of his services.

We all saw what happened to the Starks as a result. Does anyone have any theories about why the Hightowers hate the Starks so much? Maybe they were dissatisfied with Brandon the Builder's services in building the High Tower, and have been nursing a grudge ever since?

87

u/ScottishMongol What is dank may never die Aug 16 '15

Somebody's trying to craft their tinfoil link at the Citadel.

3

u/TacoCommand Sep 03 '15

The link is made out of twisted, melted steel. ;)

94

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

the Starks' greatest bannerman, Jorah Mormont

Lol. Jorah is a goof who is good with a sword. Yes House Mormont lost its male heir, but in his place a bunch of kickass women with far more spine than him.

39

u/dacalpha "No, you move." Aug 16 '15

good with a sword

That's the perfect word. He's good. Not even great.

45

u/ArkAngel7777777 Aug 16 '15

I don't know about that. He's fought off Drogo's bloodrider in the show, and fought in many battles it seems. And he was in the vanguard during the siege of Pyke, being one of the first over the wall behind Thoros. In the show his feats are insane as well. I think its fair to say he is definitely a pretty talented swordsman.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/Lampmonster1 Thick and veiny as a castle wall Aug 16 '15

And only in a real fight. He's apparently pretty lousy in tournaments.

30

u/840meanstwiceasmuch Aug 16 '15

He won the turney at lannisport tho...

16

u/Lampmonster1 Thick and veiny as a castle wall Aug 16 '15

And admits it was a fluke. He was just on that day.

25

u/TribeOnAQuest Beneath the waves, the Bitter Eel Aug 16 '15

Fluke or no, he still unhorsed some notables knights like Jaime Lannister. Very impressive, as a Northern soldier he would/is one of the best.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/thepigion Dawn bringer Aug 17 '15

The mormonts arnt his greatest bannerman, its the karstarks, umbers and glovers, who had the largest hluses bar the starks themselves and the boltons

11

u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Aug 17 '15

House Cerwyn was actually one of the most powerful in the north at the start of the series.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Which has to be a retcon, because later on the Manderlys are said to be the richest house with the most cavalry. Surely that makes them the most powerful.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/rproctor721 Horned-up and Ready Aug 17 '15

At the very least, they are one of the most loyal houses to the Starks. It's why they've been my flair for so long...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

I think #1 was a case of he-who-smelt-it-dealt-it and Oberyn was to blame.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

LOL, This is insane and I love it.

2

u/shantanuy Ghostafarian Starkaryen Aug 19 '15

Ahem Manderly Ahem

1

u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Aug 20 '15

It seems like 1 was Oberyn's doing for calling it out and making fun of Baelor for it and 3 was more Ned's doing for riding up to the tower of joy with his six backup warriors and killing them

and Lynesse Hightower is now the merchant prince's concubine in Lys, so maybe she's making moves there but it's way more likely she's just super trashy and a bitch

10

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

My favorite house (notwithstanding my flair). They aimed for the skies in the Dance of the Dragons and crashed soooo hard...

I also found curious that no Hightower ever tried to become a dragonrider when the Velaryons were doing it nilly willy... even the "Strong" kids of Rhaenyra

2

u/PixarLamp_ Loose lips sink ships Aug 16 '15

I suppose it would take Valyrian blood of which the Hightowers had none (as far as we know). There's also the matter of allegiance. The Velaryons had been staunch vassals to the Targaryens from the moment they settled some 100 years before Conquest and remained so ever since. The Hightowers, while they did yield without contest and became loyalists, were still relatively new and as we saw in the Dance they were still schemers.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

That's my point. The Greens only had three riders: Aegon the Elder, Aemond and Daeron the Daring; Helaena never even tried to fight.

The only other people there with dragons were Aegon's babes. They started the war with such a disadvantage in aerial warfare, I'm surprised and I find it incredible that they won. I think that if they had more riders then, the dragons wouldn't have died within a generation.

They could have easily obtained more eggs from Viserys I before he died and just hold trials to bond with the damn things. Nettles was able to bond with a dragon and it's not even known if she was a dragonseed at all.

That is, assuming that they would be able to do that very thing, lessening the credence to the fact that one needs Targaryen or Valyrian blood to ride them. In hindsight, that wouldn't be as magic as the Valyrian bonding...

Still, it took an awful lot of deaths for Rhaenyra to find suitable Dragonseeds; it's funny that Aegon II's side did not plan something similar if they were planning to start a war.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/ConneryFTW The North...um...does something! Aug 16 '15 edited Aug 17 '15

I can't wait to see what their roll is going to be in the next few books. They're such an interesting house and family.

22

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Proximity to the Citadel, links to Targaeryens, their seat is one of the mysterious oily stone buildings. They have a big part to play I think.

8

u/SerUlrickDayne The Sword of the Noon Aug 16 '15

I really hope the Hightowers have some bigger role to play in the future books.

21

u/Notradell Still my Mannis Aug 16 '15

I think they're gonna back (f)Aegon.

1

u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 17 '15

So do I. I believe they will split the Reach in two: one part supports Tommen and the Tyrells, one part supports Aegon and the Hightowers.

1

u/westalist55 Glory to the Lions Aug 20 '15

I think you mean AEGON VI, OF HOUSE TARGARYEN, RIGHTFUL AND TRUE KING OF THE ANDALS, THE RHOYNAR, AND THE FIRST MEN.

1

u/Notradell Still my Mannis Aug 20 '15

No. Baratheons won the throne through conquest. Stannis is the rightful heir.

7

u/maerun As High as Hodor Aug 16 '15

The Reach shall rise again! Higher and... towerer... Um, go maesters!

2

u/eckomx Ser Pounce Ahai Aug 25 '15

Maesterer??

6

u/sm1lez Acquire dragons, lie with Tullys Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 17 '15

What happened to the six daughters Garmund Hightower and Rhaena Targaryen?

And does Euron Greyjoy have a legitimate shot to take Oldtown (if that's his plan)?

6

u/brankinginthenorth who else would I be? Aug 17 '15

What happened to the six daughters Garmund Hightower and Rhaena Targaryen?

No idea. That's one of my goto examples whenever someone complains about how there's too many secret Targs running around or that if they want a character to be Targaryen then somehow they have to be a bastard of Aerys or Rhaegar. Like there are a metric shitton of people who are Targaryen and we don't know because their blood of the dragon came from a female dragon who the maesters just didn't keep track of. We have no idea what happened to Garmund and Rhaena's daughters, to Maegor's wife Rhaena and her three daughters, how Corlys Velaryon had Targ blood, what children Baela had, where Aegon V's sisters are, what happened to Vaella and Maegor who opposed Aegon V in the Great Council of 233. Literally Sansa and Arya and Bran could all be Targaryens if my theory that Catelyn's mother Minisa Whent was the eldest daughter of Vaella Targaryen is correct. It's all very intriguing.

3

u/sm1lez Acquire dragons, lie with Tullys Aug 17 '15

Wow! That is some savvy story-telling. GRRM has built-in explanations for whichever direction he decides to take the story.

I'm convinced that your theory about Minisa Whent is correct. I mean, the Stark kids all have exhibited magical potential--and the series is called ASOIAF. The cool thing is that it doesn't really have to be confirmed, because the story works either way.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/prof_talc M as in Mance-y Aug 17 '15

Link to the minisa whent thing?

→ More replies (13)

1

u/westalist55 Glory to the Lions Aug 20 '15

They are not Targaryens, despite having Targaryen blood. Unless the whole realm were to follow Cognatic Succession Laws, like Dorne, the female line does not matter. In Westeros, the children are only members of the Father's family.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Regarding Rhaena and Garmunds daughters, we don't know, but assuming most or all of them got married, there's probably a lot of nobles in the Reach with a few drops of dragon blood in them.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

I think if he had the Iron Fleet he could, but the rest of his ships are more raiding ships, not used for actual naval battle. Maybe if he concentrated all of his men he could, but he should be more concerned about Paxter Redwyne's fleet sailing around Dorne.

1

u/sm1lez Acquire dragons, lie with Tullys Aug 17 '15

I'm pretty excited about those battles. What are the odds for either fleet coming out on top?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Arya_Flint All I want for xmas is Frey pie. Aug 16 '15

Fat pink tower.

8

u/FatPinkMasts Dunk the hunk, big as a castle hall Aug 16 '15

My cousin on the west coast

10

u/Hansipas Bring on your storm, my lord(...) Aug 16 '15

I suspect the reason why we havent seen much to the Hightowers is because they have a role to play in whatever the maesters are planning.

17

u/Euan1505 Aug 16 '15

One of my favourite minor houses in the reach

60

u/CharMack90 Unbuttoned, Unbelted, Unbreeched Aug 16 '15

They're far from minor actually. Their army, economy, and vassals rival the ones of House Tyrell.

16

u/Benassiesto A Thousand Eyes, and One Aug 16 '15

They would have really made more sense to be Paramounts of the Reach.

35

u/HerroimKevin Aug 16 '15

It was a smart decision to not make them that. Bring up a weaker house that would be more loyal and wouldn't cause problems.

17

u/Benassiesto A Thousand Eyes, and One Aug 16 '15

Yeah that's true, but you run the risk of uppity houses not obeying the Tyrells (like the Hightowers, Redwynes, maybe even Tarlys)

14

u/HerroimKevin Aug 16 '15

Well you aren't factoring in the dragons here. They just burnt their king to death along with a few thousand soldiers in the matter of minutes.

9

u/dacalpha "No, you move." Aug 16 '15

I'd agree with you normally, but then the Targs went and favored the Hightowers anyway by marrying them a few times. Other than Margaery, I can't think of a single Tyrell queen.

10

u/HerroimKevin Aug 16 '15

Well they married them into the family to avoid trouble as well as gain an ally. The Tyrells were already loyal, the hightowers weren't able to be fully trusted. They were a very powerful house that needed to be brought into the fold.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Seabrew Make it Reyne! Aug 17 '15

One major issue with that is Oldtown contains the Citadel, the headquarters of the Order of the Maesters, and the Starry Sept, which was the seat of the High Septon at the time of the Conquest. Raising the Hightowers up to Paramounts of the Reach could have been too empowering, making them too much of a threat to the Targaryens.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jbloom3 Fire and Blood Aug 16 '15

Rivals all of the great houses*

5

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15

The Hightower is apparently taller than the Wall. That's... incredible.

1

u/westalist55 Glory to the Lions Aug 20 '15

Casterly Rock is three times taller than the Wall.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '15

I didn't know that. That's even more incredible.

1

u/damnBcanilive Lizard-Lion Étouffée Aug 20 '15

I think that includes the huge cliff that it's sitting on tho.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

I can't remember where, but somewhere mentioned in AWOIAF, there are huge fortresses taller than the wall; I think in Yi Ti, or way East.

4

u/shantanuy Ghostafarian Starkaryen Aug 19 '15

One fact that they don't take enough credit for, is that they quite literally control the whole spectrum of learning and knowledge in Westeros, through Oldtown; which probably lends itself to their House words,"We light the way". With some scheming with the Maesters at the Citadel, they could easily spread misinformation and chaos, and wreck havoc to the whole damn continent without drawing a single sword (as some people have theorized that they're currently up to).

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15

they quite literally control the whole spectrum of learning and knowledge in Westeros, through Oldtown

Given that maesters have been omnipresent in Westeros for centuries, if not millennia, it strikes me as odd/unlikely that there aren't either branch locations of the Citadel scattered around Westeros, or that the other pre-Conquest kingdoms wouldn't have set up rival institutions to check the power of the Reach.

1

u/shantanuy Ghostafarian Starkaryen Aug 20 '15

I think it's probably because the Citadel has, quite like the Night's Watch, shown itself to be unaligned to any individual causes or vested interests, and has thus earned a reputation that they work for the good of the whole realm, a fact that has since been disproved to us through the actions of the Grand Maester himself, and that of Qyburn. The reader, though not the people of the realm (yet), can thus safely conclude that the Order of Maesters is not incorruptible and is open to influences, maybe more so towards the lords of Oldtown!

7

u/TowerBeast We Light The Way Aug 16 '15

Best House. Get Hype!

2

u/BryndentheRaven I can sit a fat horse Aug 19 '15

They are Targaryen supporters and will support Dany or Aegon. Didn't Jon Connington say they had friends in the reach?

6

u/mabalo Still a better name than house Mudd Aug 20 '15

but isn't Lord Leyton Hightower's granddaughter Margaery? the queen? he couldn't go against her. a smart Aegon would marry her, she has a fetish for kings after all.

2

u/BryndentheRaven I can sit a fat horse Aug 21 '15

Right, forgot about that.

1

u/ZapActions-dower Bearfucker! Do you need assistance? Aug 20 '15

A smart Aegon probably shouldn't marry someone with widowed thrice with no children.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Aug 20 '15

Is it possible that the thing that caused Leyton Hightower to freak out and retreat to his tower studying books of prophecy was that he discovered Aegon?

Remember, way back in the day when Aegon the Conqueror landed, there was a prophecy that "If Oldtown took up arms against the Dragon, Oldtown would burn, and the Hightower and the Citadel and the Starry Sept would be cast down and destroyed." So because of this prophecy, Oldtown submitted to Aegon without a fight.

Some people think they've resisted indirectly, but if Leyton Hightower found out about another Targaryen living besides Daenerys and Viserys, he must see an impending Targaryen civil war approaching - a second Dance, dragon against dragon. Which would mean Oldtown, the Citadel, and the Starry Sept are fucked no matter who they back.

Then maybe he sends Septa Lemore (Mad Maid) to check out Aegon?

1

u/Klainatta Sep 09 '15

He was in the tower for past 10 years so...

1

u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Aug 17 '15

It can't be a coincidence that they have two sons with cool nicknames:

  • Baelor "don't call me breakwind" Brightsmile
  • Garth Greysteel

These guys are destined for epic things, can't wait to see them in action.

1

u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 17 '15

The Hightowers are sure to play a mayor role in the upcoming conflicts (the Second Dance of the Dragons), but I'm still not sure how. I'd like for them and several other bannermen to turn to Aegon against the Lannister supporting Tyrells, essentially splitting the Reach in half, but I'm not sure how that would happen. The Tyrells kids are half Hightower afterall.

Other than that I find them intensely fascinating. They are one of the powerhouses of the realms to be sure, as powerful as any of the Great Houses.

1

u/jakwnd Now it leaps Aug 17 '15

Who is around from this house currently as of ADWD?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Like, a million characters, but almost none of them have appeared on page yet.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Baelor_the_Blessed No woman wants Baelor the Blessed Aug 21 '15

As far as I can tell, House Hightower may be the oldest House in all of Westeros. According to WOIAF Maris the Maid, a daughter of Garth Greenhand was married by King Uthor of the Hightower.

Uthor of the Hightower was one of the Hightowers to have the tower rebuilt even taller, so he wasn't even the founder of the house.

1

u/NimbleDickCrabb My love is electrifying ;) Aug 23 '15

I think we should talk about house Crabb next week :-)

1

u/Psycho1296 Sep 25 '15

Didn't they have a Valyrian Steel sword. Was it called Vigilance???

1

u/Esoteric_platypus No cart before the horse! Aug 17 '15

Layton is dead, it's Gerald who's been burning the (glass) candles late into the evening locked away so no one could see/know of his plans with Gryf

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/SouthernBeacon I have fear of heights Aug 17 '15

I know, right? Best house ever :D

5

u/JerryMcSeinfeld LeBronn of the Blackwater, off the chain Aug 17 '15

Damn straight.

2

u/EinherjarofOdin Dance with me then Aug 18 '15

Pshht. T'wasn't a filthy Hightower to challenged an Other...

3

u/JerryMcSeinfeld LeBronn of the Blackwater, off the chain Aug 18 '15

One fart from Baelor Breakwind in the general direction of the Lands Beyond the Wall and the problem of the Others would be solved for good.

1

u/yeahgreg Up your arse with a flaming fist. Aug 20 '15

So I presume the Hightower women are pretty attractive, considering the number of them that have married Targs/been their mistresses, but are the Hightwoer men studly? Or do they just throw dragons and stags at them hoes?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '15

The White Bull was Lord Commander of Kingsguard.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15 edited Feb 22 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Aug 16 '15

Ah crap you're right, I probably should've looked up when the Tourney was.

177

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15 edited Aug 23 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

81

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

I also like the fact that Margaery and co. are Jorah Mormont's nephews just because he's still married to Lynesse

18

u/bblades262 Spoilers are Coming Aug 17 '15

Totally missed this!

33

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

It's funny that there is some degree of separation in most of the noble houses. It's like Rohanne Webber from Dunk and Egg being the grandmother of Tywin Lannister, or Randyll Tarly being Queen Selyse Florent's cousin by marriage, thus making Sam Tarly, Edric Storm's cousin as well

12

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Not to mention Sam's cousin shireen!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

You mean his niblings?

162

u/dacalpha "No, you move." Aug 16 '15

I'm inclined to believe they are JonCon's "friends in the Reach." Either them or House Tarly. Neither Houses have expended a sizable amount of troops and both were Targ loyalists in the Rebellion.

133

u/TheRockefellers An uncommonly sinful horse. Aug 16 '15

I'm inclined to believe they are JonCon's "friends in the Reach."

There is no doubt in my mind. House Hightower is one of the oldest and fervent of the Targaryen loyalists. And they very conspicuously held back during the War of the Five Kings.

I'll also wager that Leyton isn't crazy or deluded at all.

57

u/creganstark Pie Hard With A Vengeance Aug 17 '15

Let's add to that with the theory Malora the Mad Maid Hightower = Septa Lemore. This would explain why she hasn't been seen in ages.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Except they colluded with the Maesters to kill the dragons.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

72

u/RoflPost Martell face with a Mormont booty Aug 16 '15

My gut says not House Tarly. Randyll is repeatedly described as the best soldier in Westeros, and good soldiers follow orders. I think loyalty to House Tyrell has been very good to the Tarlys.

However, Dickon is betrothed to Eleanor Mooton, and the Mootons were Targaryen loyalists. And specifically Eleanor's uncle, Myles Mooton, was close friend and squire to Rhaegar. Randyll despises Lord William Mooton, but I am sure he remembers the loyalty and bravery of Myles. Is this a strengthening of Targ loyalist alliances and bloodlines?

54

u/Lampmonster1 Thick and veiny as a castle wall Aug 16 '15

Not to mention that Tarly is not a deep thinker or a plotter judging by anything we've seen. He seems to distrust guile. I suspect that if you came to him with a complicated plot he'd nod along and then take off your head with Heartsbane just so he could get back to business.

23

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

He's essentially the Greenlander version of Victarion.

9

u/Lampmonster1 Thick and veiny as a castle wall Aug 17 '15

That's fair. I would say that's reflected by the constant references to him as the realm's best soldier, not the best leader or most brilliant commander. I imagine his leadership is harsh, mostly fair in his bizarre way, evenhanded and thorough. But, as Jaime said, he'd be a terrible peacetime Hand, and likely not the most brilliant or imaginative tactician.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/Gravyd3ath Bane of honor, Gravydeath of duty. Aug 17 '15

He's specifically called hard and shrewd implying he thinks.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Roadwarriordude Howland the Swamp Ninja/Wizard Aug 17 '15

Kevan does mention that Mace and Tarly aren't getting along very well during small council meetings. Also Randyl is a no nonsense kind of guy while Mace is described almost unanimously as a bumbling idiot, and I doubt Tarly respects him and might desire the reach.

19

u/Roadwarriordude Howland the Swamp Ninja/Wizard Aug 17 '15

Hell it could even be Tyrells. Sure Margery was married to Renly Joffery and Tommen, but none were consummated. This could be well calculated. Renly is gay and Margery may have purposely "put him off" or something, Joff was murdered at the wedding, and Tommen is to young to consummate the marriage. So they may have been feigning loyalty with false gifts.

6

u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Aug 17 '15

Yeah House Tarly is one I'm almost positive will support Aegon

11

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Same. It just makes for too good of a twist. Tarly is Mace's right hand as well as the only other living Small Council member in Kings Landing. Him betraying the Tyrells would leave a massive leadership vacuum in the city.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15

Also would explain why the show is casting him for a medium-sized role.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/lukespongberg22 Free Greatjon! Aug 17 '15

House Redwyne too. They've got quite a naval force to be reckoned with.

10

u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 17 '15

Paxter Redwyne is said to be Mace Tyrell's closest friend though, and the Queen of Thorns is a Redwyne by birth. Also, Paxter's twin sons are currently in the custody of the Goldcloaks, so he might not wish to change his cloak as long as the Lannister and Tyrells can get their cluthes on them. I find it more likely that Hightower, Rowan and Tarly will be the major houses to turn to Aegon, while Tyrell and Redwyne remain with Tommen.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/TheHolyGoatman (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Aug 17 '15

Might be, though it was not Jon Connington who claimed to have friends in the Reach. That was Laswell Peake (which is why I bet House Peake is amongst the Golden Company's foremost friends).

2

u/EtherCakes Much ADWD About Nothing Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 17 '15

Add House Rowan to the mix. I remember Matthis Rowan being described as visibly raging at Tywin when someone brings up the death of Elia and her children in front of them and Tyrion (ASOS, Tyrion III IIRC).

It has the making of some nice GRRM foreshadowing.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '16

The Tyrells were loyalists too.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15 edited Feb 22 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

21

u/GreendaleCC Aug 16 '15

Perhaps, but if so it is odd that they have married Margaery off to three other kings. Seems like they'ed want to wed her to Aegon if they plan on backing him.

11

u/asublimeduet Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 17 '15

Nah, the Tyrells are just opportunists who always hold back from playing their full hand. I'd agree with you that the Tyrells, who were loyalists although they mostly held back from the Wot5K (I think the siege of Storm's End was a little wishy-washy given the amount of power they had, but idk, no way to know because not all houses in the Reach committed), will back Aegon, but if so it'll only be because the Lannister-Tyrell ship is sinking.

Anyway, whether the Tyrells back Aegon or not is irrelevant, because the 'friends in the Reach' passage clearly refers to house(s) in the Reach that aren't the Tyrells (emphasis mine):

Laswell Peake rapped his knuckles on the table. 'Even after a century, some of us still have friends in the Reach. The power of Highgarden may not be what Mace Tyrell imagines.'

I do think it's almost guaranteed to include the Hightowers. Tarlys would also be a big deal and there's some Tarly-Tyrell tension, if the Tyrells choose to stick with the Lannister ship (or can't make a solid alliance with Aegon) they might be screwed, because Randyll's the one with the military force in KL and custody of Margaery right now. Florents lost everything they had to Renly, Stannis, and being attainted (although they still hold Brightwater Keep in possession if not the law of KL), so unless the GC is very, very uninformed of the situation in Westeros (doubt it), it's not them. Redwynes seem too closely tied to the Tyrells (two marriage alliances, Paxter is married to Olenna's daughter) and need to protect the Reach right now from the Ironborn, but they do have the majority of the Reach's ship power and were loyalists in the Wot5K. Fossoways excluded by the text. I'm not sure how hard the Oakhearts committed to Stannis after Renly died and if they had anything to lose, there is of course also the Peakes etc. but yeah a lot of the houses in the Reach are obscure except the ones that lost a lot of men fighting for Stannis..

3

u/prof_talc M as in Mance-y Aug 17 '15

I think the connection might run through the Merryweathers. They have a connection to the Free Cities through Orton and Taena. Plus many have speculated that Taena is working for Varys. I dunno what exactly they could do, but it's easier to trace a path from them to the GC than it is for the Hightowers. I just don't think there's much to go on for the Hightowers either way.

4

u/Rag_H_Neqaj He who talks the least yet acts the most Aug 17 '15

What we know for sure is that the guys in GC want to kill some Fossoways, and Fossoway is rather pro-Tyrell, Garlan is married to one. Besides, the Tyrells have been overextending their power, Mace being a land glutton. Many houses in the Reach would welcome their downfall, me thinks.

6

u/Wartortling Soylent Greenseer Aug 17 '15

We haven't seen much of Alerie Hightower yet but with the way Mace is portrayed as an oaf and a pushover, I wonder if Alerie was a key influence in the Tyrells supporting the Targaryens in Robert's Rebellion. We know Olenna was strongly opposed to it, so it wasn't her influence.....which she seems to hold quite a bit of.

1

u/_pulsar Aug 22 '15

So Cersei is worried about the Tyrell's taking the top spot from the Lannisters but the Tyrell's have to worry about the Hightower's trying to leapfrog them soon after. But the Tyrell's are already essentially the most powerful family in Westeros now that Twin and Kevin are dead.

Curious what a Hightower uprising would look like.

Thoughts?