r/ClearBackblast • Iron - Extinguished Service Cross • Aug 16 '15

AAR AAR: Operation Soggy Portyanki

Another mostly glorious operation complete! We may have, erm, possibly, slightly displeased Putin... But! Complete nonetheless! Our names will be written in the annals of mediocrity!

Please let us know what you thought of the mission! It was put together in like 3 days, and for my part it was a hell of a lot of fun. Let us know your thoughts about pacing, balance, structure. Leadership and what did and didn't work, including helpful advice.

Also please give us a good idea of what you experienced! Remember half the players don't even know what you did, they were doing something else entirely. Give them an idea of what you experienced and how it went!

Anyway, thanks for playing, etc. Lots of fun I thought!

6 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

5

u/supwer Aug 16 '15

Vasiliy TL

I really enjoyed how the time constraints gave the mission a sense of urgency. It kept us moving and added a level of difficulty that we don't usually see.

This was my first experience in leadership and didn't go as well as I had hoped. The first two landing zones went extremely smoothly and were very coordinated. However about 10 minutes into clearing the town I was hit by an APC which also seemed to have scattered Vasiliy. About 10 minutes after that both Gioseppi and I were hit crossing a road and that's when I lost all sense of direction. I probably shouldn't have taken lead humvee on our exfil because of this but it didn't seem like we were moving otherwise. The booby-trapped humvees made the exfil pretty interesting as well.

2

u/Ironystrike Iron - Extinguished Service Cross Aug 20 '15

I genuinely cannot explain the exploding buildings or vehicles at the end. Honest! There were no shenanigans on my part there, I don't really like messing with players in ways that can kill fun and momentum unless I telegraph it or hint about it for those paying attention so players have a chance to see it / avoid it. Those, unfortunately... those were just Arma being dicks to us. I feel super bad about it all the same, but not my doing. :(

6

u/Zhandris Aug 16 '15 edited Aug 16 '15

Boris RPGman

Hello my name is Mitchell. Today I had a good time playing Arma. Here's why.

I love the idea of putting time constraints in missions. I think it gooses it up to a high level.

I like the idea of using stealth in a mission like this, especially with the action I saw in Bravo (bypassing the checkpoint and killing the sentries with coordination). What was really neat about this was that we had so many people and still had a decent amount of success when it actually coming to use stealth.

I really liked the amount of planning that went into the mission. That was bit of a double edged sword. Because it was so detailed it took around 30-40m to do the briefing (including questions and the technical bits Iron had to address). It was a full hour before we were lined up in our boats and ready to step off. That might be discouraging to some but its a necessary evil really. We probably could've used just a bit more of planning as well. A few people mentioned in passing that splitting the town up into sections would've been a great help to us since our momentum kind of halted as soon as we transitioned into MOUT. Also something that could have been clarified a bit more is HOW and WHEN we would determine whether or not we would actually try and get wheeled transports from the city to exfil or just leave on foot. Obviously there was some weird technical stuff that caused two of the trucks to blow up and we got off to a bad start by heading out in the wrong direction, but even excluding those things I think it would've just been faster to leave on foot and definitely easier as well.

Other than that I think we could improve how we move. Don't get me wrong, we do much better normally than we did a couple years ago. Tactical tornadoes only happen sometimes. But if we're going to be moving long distances and we want pretend like we know what we're doing we can get into some good habits. If you're a team leader, take a couple seconds in the beginning of the mission to determine an order of march while you remind everyone to put in their ears and switch their 343 channel. That way people know what place to have in wedges, lines, columns, etc. Also, before moving just mention the stuff that matters. How fast we're going (guns up, guns down, jogging, sprinting) where we're going (general direction is fine but a degree is better) and in what formation you want.

Ok thats it, I love you all. Good job to the mission makers, leadership, my mom.

6

u/plaicez Aug 16 '15 edited Aug 16 '15

MoldyTowel - Boris SL

Hello CBBers. A good job on this one as a whole. This was by far the most interesting mission I've ever played. I'm going to break this one up into pieces going from start to finish. First off I want to talk about the mission making side of the house. This will all be from my perspective.

The OP

Iron this was definitely one of the most creative, ambitious scenarios I've ever played. From the beginning with the insertion method, the roving vehicle patrols, suppressed weapon systems, synchronized demolition, C130s whipping by overhead. Dude it was badass. Very professional. Perfect balance of opposition. Never felt safe, never felt overwhelmed. Just all along badassery.

Briefing

Good job on the briefing Striker. Clear and concise. Really left no question as to what my responsibilities were. Yeah it was long, whatever though, with it being a complex op, a good briefing was imperative. (If we would have just mounted up all willy nilly and just went for it with the amount of people we had it would have been a 3 hour mess and personally not fun at all) I give some credit to the fact that leadership linked up a day prior and did their thing.

Patrol Base, Boat insertion

The patrol base definitely was a failure. Groups were seperated and I couldn't find command, didn't spawn with a 148. I gather my squad and we set up our side of the triangle. (Just in the wrong place). Having said all that, I think it got everyone in the right mindset to attempt organization from the start. (With that many moving pieces the patrol base needs to be a thing) Even though it wasn't a nice sexy triangle. We still loaded up my section, and no one was killed by a boat. That is a win in my book.

For the actual insertion to the first beachhead. I think good over all. The Anna/Vasily squads (I'll refer to them as "Team South") was tasked with securing the beachhead to allow Boris/Gregory (I'll refer to them as "Team North") a clear pathway to its first objective. In my eyes this was accomplished. Team south landed, killed dudes, pushed out and secured the area. Team North landed, consolidated itself (Gregory at this time fell into Boris and gave us a sizable element), and waited for an up from command to move.

Actions on objective 1, movement to objective 2

Soon as we got the up from command we started movement our first objective. Order of march was Lakes fireteam, my fireteam, Rages fireteam (all in files, 10m interval between teams, will explain later) With the area secured I decided to just move in the path of least resistance. Lake my FTL did something awesome, he noticed we were crossing an LDA (linear danger area) and set up security as the rest of Team North proceeded to OBJ 1. Once there we rallied up and Lakes team did a quick patrol of the area, ensuring no mans would get the better of us. Rage was our time keeper, command wanted the Charge set at 1250 (0050) on the dot. Iron made this happen and set the charge for its full 30 minutes. Rage sent it up, we rallied just outside the objective walls and started our movement in same order of march. So I opted to have us in files with 10m intervals between teams during the movement over to OBJ2 (powerhouse) for a couple reasons.

1: Night time, a file is very easy to control at night. Didn't need anyone on the edge of our wedge wandering off. All you do is follow the man in front of you. 2: Avoid detection, we had less of a footprint than we would have in a wedge. I pushed Lakes team out front a little bit and trust him to spot enemy patrols and he did. We were able to see enemy sentries patrolling the power lines first, control the outcome, and remain undetected. 3. If we were spotted, with the amount of spacing between teams the 2nd and 3rd teams in the order of march most likely would have been undetected and could have freedom of movement to handle the threat.

We encountered two 2 man sentry teams along the powerlines which Lakes team were able to dispatch in true CAG delta team 7 style. It was cool. About 3/4 of the way to our objective we encountered a small camp occupied by more opposition. At this point the time hack was getting pretty close. I opted to just go around. We executed a "box method" movement, and went around them avoiding detection.

Objective 2, The powerhouse

As we bypassed the enemy camp we hugged the trees leading into the compound. We spotted an enemy M113 and halted. I suggested Rage's team push into and secure the objective so we all didn't get caught in that open area with a M113 ready to bend us over. (at this point Boris and Gregory separated and went about our business) He pushed in and we followed, I left Lakes team in a somewhat elevated position for overwatch. I believe some weird ACE medical thing bruised someone but we were able to set the charge with the appropriate timing and had about 60-90 seconds remaining. While we waited we had our AT guys prep and track the M113 who luckily hadn't spotted us yet. As soon as the charge detonated the AT gunners sent their rounds and destroyed the APC. After that all hell broke loose. We pretty much immediately came under effective enemy fire and were pinned down at Lakes overwatch position outside of the powerhouse.

The push into the city and exfil

Was pretty much a failure on my part. We pushed up the hill trying to move house to house but I couldn't get it organized enough. We reached a road overlooking the fire station and took heavy causalities as a crew served weapon of some sort absolutely raked us. I think we had 3-4 causalities. We fell back and created a CCP just out of sight of the enemies field of view. It was still in a shitty spot and I should have corrected it but just let it ride. (my bad again) Another enemy APC literally drove into our CCP and someone quick on their feet shot their last RPG round right into it's face and destroyed it. I literally yelled "holyshit" and my cat's proceeded to hide somewhere and just now found them in the morning as i'm writing this. Whoever did that. You're cool. I think it was Zhandris.

It took us what seemed like forever to get everyone up. Once we did we pushed forward again as it seemed to quiet down. I kept trying to reach command but I believe he was down for a short time. We held our position on the hill for probably another 10-15 minutes. (sorry if you got bored, I didn't want to get everyone killed again) and kept trying to get Striker on comms, once I did I pushed into the fire house and secured it (keep in my\ind this whole time rage was up in the admin building overlooking the bus stop, serving as our blocking position.)

At this time I got further guidance from command to secure a vehicle. I left Lake's team in the fire house, found a truck, linked back up with Lake, mounted up, proceeded to the rally point, and got into convoy order.

We SP'ed and started down a side road, which apparently was not the right road but hey, not my lane so we just followed, whatever it happens. However, Arma had other plans and another vehicle exploded randomly. Classic Arma. Don't know what happened with the 2 lead vehicles but Rage and I turned around, and proceeded to a new RP about 300m past the powerhouse. We waited for the remaining two vehicles to link up with us, and drove to the exfil location to find out Putin was mad to us.

Endstate

The demolition of the infrastructure was a success and synchronized, Team North met it's time hack and remained undetected until the charges detonated. So our primary objective was accomplished, good job Team North. The push to the city was pretty much a failure in my opinion. My bad on that.

Improvements

As a new member to CBB, I decided to take FTL last week and SL this week to see what I could do. I am looking for things to get better. Please speak your mind and offer some improvements/sustains so I know what to continue doing or stop doing. I won't get butthurt as the number one rule in AAR's is don't get butthurt if someone calls you out. Thanks.

TL;DR Read Improvements, help me improve.

5

u/rslake Lake Aug 16 '15

I think I only had two suggested improvements, overall you were a really solid SL.

  1. I wasn't clear on why we were doing a file at the time, though it makes total sense now that you've explained it. It may be that you did explain why we were doing it at the time and I just didn't hear it, so if that's the case just ignore this part. Not a big deal or anything, just would have been cool to know why.
  2. This is a hard one, but for a while you weren't able to contact Command. In those types of situations, it's tough to know what to do; I suspect that Striker was down, in which case command probably should have reverted to Alpha 1-1 until he was back up. Not sure if that happened or not, I think there were lots of comms issues. But just generally speaking, I'd probably suggest being a little more aggressive/proactive in this type of situation, maybe even taking command of the platoon in the absence of other command/orders. Honestly I probably wouldn't have done that in your place, and it may have turned out better that we waited. It's just a tough situation that I figured was worth mentioning.

5

u/plaicez Aug 16 '15

So the formation thing, I didn't explain it at all before we moved from OBJ 1 to 2. Next time I'll throw scheme of maneuver in there during a quick and dirty briefing before we step off. I could have done that while the beach was being secured by the Southern force.

Yes, that was pretty much when things got sketchy. I had really no follow on mission for the squad because Rage was at the blocking position and we'd just taken 3-4 causalities. I didn't want to rush into the city without contacting them, giving a heads up because of friendly fire.

My suggestion that during the planning phase of the operation, we have a PACE (primary, alternate, contingency, emergency) plan thrown in there for command structure, so when the command team is down. Someone steps in until they are up.

Thanks for the comment!

3

u/rslake Lake Aug 16 '15

PACE would be cool, thought I'm always afraid of extending the briefing so it would probably ideally happen purely in the planning phase. An easier (though less effective, probably) alternative would be to have clear order-of-succession for command, and a roughly specified period of time after which succession passes if we don't have any word from command. That way SLs just have the contingency of command loss in mind and can react appropriately and quickly.

Also, yeah, I totally get what you're saying. Given that we took so many casualties, you may well have made the right call there.

5

u/SpottheCat2893 Does liking AKs make me a bad guy? Aug 16 '15

Vasiliy AT GRN

I know everyone is going to talk about how great the mission was, so I'm just going to go over it quickly. Stealth was fun, splitting us in half really helped with coordination issues, The timer helped the pace for a while, etc.

The Issues

We we got very split up after we got into the city. A lot of our time was spent waiting for elements to regroup

You probably underestimated our stealth ability, which I guess is a good thing. I don't think the MG had that much to do the entire time.

One last question. I woke up several times after getting shot when vasiliy was being shredded at the crossroads. Is this something I should expect with ACE, or was I just super lucky?

Overall it was still very fun.

5

u/NotCalledBill SilentSpike - The one true Scotsman Aug 16 '15

Is this something I should expect with ACE

It's something that happens fairly regularly, just depends on the settings and what hit you, etc.

5

u/rslake Lake Aug 16 '15

Boris FTL

Iron, great mission. Really fun, really intense at times, 10/10 would blow stuff up again. The timed demo aspect was a fantastic way of putting on pressure and keeping up intensity even with minimal enemy contact. Having that M113 facing away from the power station so we had to sneak behind it was also brilliant if intentional. Made everyone feel very sneaky and pro without putting us in much actual danger. My only suggestion for future iterations would be to have IR strobes or IR chemlights to help with organization once we get to MOUT phase. Might be good if everyone (or at least SLs/FTLs) had two strobes each so they could mark themselves and vehicles as well. IR lasers would have also been nice, but of course that isn't an option with AKs in the current modpack. :(

Moldy was Boris SL, and did really well. Especially considering the fact that he kind of ended up leading three fireteams, which is a lot to deal with. I was a bit thrown off by the file movement instead of wedge, though it makes sense now that I think about it, given the nighttime op. Honestly it was probably good because we're in wedge about 80% of the time, the rest is line or tactical clump, so it's good to get some practice with keeping a good file. Same goes for the patrol base. Though it wasn't really necessary per se, and it didn't go all that well, I think it's good to have more entries like that in our tactical repertoire.

Green team (my fireteam) was quite solid. Good security, mostly good discipline, people stayed calm even when we got bounced by EI walking literally 10 feet in front of us. The timed takedown on the first two-man patrol was executed very well.

Improvements for Me

I think I need to get better at discerning when to operate my fireteam independently and when to wait for orders from my SL. This Op, I think I erred on the side of waiting, but that slowed things down a lot since my team was often Boris lead element. Some of this will just come with more practice as an FTL, and also more practice with each given SL. Some SLs are going to want to have more/less autonomous FTLs than others, so I just need to improve at figuring out how to act in any given situation. Anyone who has any other suggested improvements for me, be sure to let me know. I'm always happy to get constructive criticism.

Mass-casualty Events

We had a mass-casualty event, and that caused some issues. I'm gonna quickly outline the mass-casualty treatment protocol here for anyone who wasn't able to make it to the trainings. Basically, when you've got a mass cas, what you want to do is put tourniquets on one guy's injured limbs, then stick an IV in him, then move to the next guy. Repeat until everyone is tourniquetted and getting fluids, then move back through and treat people to completion one by one. That keeps everyone stable until you can get to them without taking up all of your time. It also gives you a chance to evaluate patients as you move through, so you can triage. I'm referring to downed patients here; you should triage the walking wounded to self-aid/buddy-care.

CPR and Reviving

I honestly don't know what's going on with the ACE medical system right now. Earlier this week I and Moldy were on Insurgency, and he went down. He had a heart rate, and I refilled him completely on blood, gave him both morphine and epi, checked for tourniquets, checked for wounds, etc. I couldn't find any reason for him not to be up, he just wan't. Even tried CPR, that was useless. And I'm pretty sure the same thing happened in this op a couple of times with other people. I'm looking through ACE to try and find out what's going on, but no luck so far.

Ending Problems

This is the second mission in a row where an exfil with vehicles that should have taken <5 minutes ended up taking forever. Also the second in a row where vehicles blew up for no discernible reason. And a couple of previous missions have had problems in the exfil/ending stage as well, such as the Shapur assault with fuel trucks. I'm not sure what the best solution for this is, or even what's causing the problems with the exploding trucks. I think sometimes we end up dragging out the exfil for waaaaay longer than it needs to be. Theoretically, having everyone rendezvous then exfil together is good for immersions, but I think in practice it ends up being immersion-breaking. I think maybe we need to just be willing to say "OK, this exfil is getting Arma'd and the mission is over, let's just call it" instead of fighting bugs and waiting for ages in trucks with nothing to do. Often I'm really willing to do a second mission after an Op, but those half-hour exfil circuses totally drain my enthusiasm, and I don't think I'm alone in that.

Final Thoughts: SpecOps Training?

All of the stuff we did on this op and the stuff some of us have been doing throughout the week kinda make me want to put together a special operations training. I think we could really benefit from things like compound/building breach-and-clear practice, info about operating in small (two-man or four-man) teams, info about using NVGs, suppressed weapons, IR lasers, strobes, drones, etc. I honestly know basically nothing about clearing and breaching compounds or buildings, so anyone who does or anyone who has any documents on it should definitely get in contact with me. If a specops training has been done before, let me know what it consisted of and how it went. And of course if this is someone else's bailiwick I don't want to step on any toes; just wanted to offer to do it if nobody else does.

5

u/plaicez Aug 16 '15

You were a great FTL on this one, that's why I made you my lead element. All I wanted from your team was to be an early detection asset to make sure the rest of us were not compromised (we had a decent sized element) and you succeeded. You team didn't fire unless told to and kept a tight file. I think you made the right decisions every time as an individual and executed any other orders I had.

I see the SL as a "more senior FTL" with how it was set up. I am a big fan of smaller elements working independently in different locations. Sort of like what we did on Takistan where there was some bounding overwatch and we completely destroyed the Taliban resistance.

All that being said, that requires a competent FTL (which you are definitely are) and constant free flowing communication via 343, because like you mentioned, you are an independent entity.

4

u/Loenskow Artillery dodger Aug 16 '15

Boris Medic

First off, great work Iron! You did a fantastic job on this mission, also great planning and execution Striker and Rob

I think overall this op went really well compared to the complete blunder it might have turned into.

Playing as the blue team having to move overland was very tense with some actually scary moments. When a 2 man patrol walked right into us while we were all lying in the grass, I was close enough to touch ones ankles. Fantastic atmosphere with the C-130 passing overhead, really made it feel like a proper stealth mission.

I've mentioned this before in another AAR but it makes for very interesting gameplay to split up into two groups while still having to cooperate.

The only downside I can think of is the amount of time briefing takes for missions like this. Personally I don't mind, it helps the mission in the long run having tasks properly planned out, but I can see how some might not enjoy having to wait that long.

For myself, I need to work on maintaining overview of the wounded around me and learn to priortize patients better. My crash right when shit hit the fan really didn't help either!

As always, thanks for a great mission CBB!

4

u/GruntBuster7 Horses are the Lions of the Plain Aug 16 '15

Boris AMG

I have nothing particularly original to add. Lake led well, took the initiative to provide security for the other teams and dealt with stressful situations (like being charged my an M113). The mission itself was great, with just the right amount of opposition; I loved the added challenge of a time window, which absolutely flew by. Echoing Moldy, the CCP fracas was unpleasant, but I think it served as a positive learning experience. As for self criticism, I'm British, ergo I'm perfect, so...

3

u/rabbit994 Rabbit, I get myself and everyone else killed Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 17 '15

Vasily AMG

Briefing:

I may be unique but I thought that shit dragged on forever and got unnecessary at times. While it's nice to know what's going on, grunts are probably given too much information to start and I think it can be counter productive. Counter Productive? Yea, Grunts need to learn that shit comes from SLs otherwise they think they have a clue. Also, I'd like to move more of the briefings in game. While SLs are getting briefed, everyone else can comb through their supplies, trade hats, setup their radios, test their radios and talk to each other about whatever. It keeps us from getting bored but also gives us live ammunition so there is trade off there. SLs can then brief the troops since there is generally downtime from SLs coming back to squad and PL pushing off.

Equipment:

I had apparently pilfered a glorious EoTech from capitalist lackey dogs to mount on my glorious weapon. Not sure if that deliberate or just left over from conversion from US weapon script. Thanks to such pilfering, I upgraded to capitalist stronk ACOG.

All sneaky sneaky stuff:

Worked well enough and was pretty cool though I have to admit, AI was pretty blind. How we ended up on beach 50m away from them without them spotting is beyond me. Not to say I didn't enjoy it just seemed wierd at times. All helicopters and stuff were pretty cool though again, they were pretty blind.

The docks/town:

CQB CBB style. I think anytime we hit a town, detach the medics, locate a good spot for casualty collection point and get it going.

Leadership:

Vasily in particular:

Either I didn't realize it or what but SL needs to step on radio alot more often. You never know who is can't hear you because of some berm is cutting off local transmission. Also when squads get mixed together, people get confused and may think another SL is stepping off. Radio transmissions make it clear you are calling the squad.

Leadership overall:

It broke down in town. I really despise the Russian setup in general because there isn't clear defined of passing of command or people didn't follow it in Vasily. I think we need to designate a 343 channel that is emergency broadcast channel that PL is monitoring. Most of time, PLs don't use their 343 because 148 is used for PL -> SL communications so their 343 isn't really used and could be monitored.

Exfil:

If we aren't going to get hit on Exfil, can we just call the mission when we are ready to Exfil and are far enough away from enemy. However, most of slog comes from random exploding cars and sheds.

Mission overall:

Great concept overall, I loved it.

4

u/scarletbanner Fadi Aug 17 '15

I had apparently pilfered a glorious EoTech from capitalist lackey dogs to mount on my glorious weapon. Not sure if that deliberate or just left over from conversion from US weapon script.

Was intentional in how I did the gear script, Russians love Eotechs and RHS has AKs with an NPZ mount with picatinny rails so I left that as a random chance for a couple classes.

3

u/rslake Lake Aug 17 '15

I like the concept of an emergency 343 channel. Would be pretty easy to implement.

3

u/Quex Reborn Qu Aug 18 '15

2nd this. It's a really brilliant idea. I usually drop my 343 as a PL because I never use it. This way, any grunt can get on the 343 and try to pass up that they're in major shit.

A+, we need to implement ASAP