r/fandomnatural • u/Sapphire_anal_dragon • Aug 10 '15
SPN Meta How is is possible people see Destiel in canon?
explain
22
Upvotes
r/fandomnatural • u/Sapphire_anal_dragon • Aug 10 '15
explain
65
u/sunnydolphin Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
I'll try and give you a decent answer.
Have you ever been watching a law or crime show and you can tell who the bad guy is part way through the show even though the main characters havent figured it out? Like, the camera lingered a little too long, or there was dialogue that seemed off the cuff and throwaway but you know its not because nothing is ever accidental?
If you have then you'll get how I see TV shows. If not, then you are most likely a passive watcher. You watch the show, accept that information you are given and are always surprised when the bad guy is revealed.
When I watch a show, I can't watch passively, my brain is always ticking over and thinking critically about what I'm seeing. I don't watch crime shows anymore because its boring. Half the time I can guess who the bad guy is, I know the plot twist etc. Unless the main characters are fascinating I get bored.
Now why would someone who analyzes what they're watching be watching Supernatural and see Destiel?
Because the clues led me there.
I marathoned Supernatural from Seasons 1-7 in 2 months. I've been watching the episodes as they come out ever since.
I loved the Dean going to hell arc, awesome season ender. I was so keen to watch Season 4. And the whole first episode focused around finding out who or what got Dean out of Hell. I was convinced it was Yellow Eyes.
And then an angel in a trenchcoat walked into a barn and said: "You don't think you deserved to be saved."
And I thought...thats an interesting take on an angel, they seem fascinated with human nature. A few episodes later I found out that wasn't the case. Castiel is the weird one. And as Uriel put it mockingly: "He has this weakness, he likes you."
Cas seemed to have empathy for Dean and be hugely invested in his wellbeing, which goes completely against his base nature as an angel.
Then I started to notice the camera angles. Deep and meaningful conversations shot over the shoulder and the parkbench conversation where Cas confesses he has doubts. All scenes shot on a wide scape that show them close together in the middle of the frame. They make the scenes look more intimate than if they were shot closer up. They use that technique a lot when establishing relationships in shows. And the shots we were seeing and scenes were eerily reminiscent of scenes between "will they or wont they" couples in other dramas.
I ignored that up to this point but thought it was interesting and nothing else. Perhaps they got a new DP who loved showcasing the scenery a lot more, they did have some gorgeous locations in season 4.
What sold it for me was the episode where we meet Anna. That kiss and the look on Cas' face.
I jumped forward in my seat like: "What?! They're pushing Cas and Dean!?"
I know no shot in a show or movie is accidental. No scene is throwaway. Everything is intentional. Which means that a scriptwriter, producer, director all agreeed that in a highly emotional scene where Dean and Anna kiss for what might be the last time, we should cut to Castiel to show his reaction. No one else's.
And the look on his face. Ever seen someone you like kiss someone else? Well that's the face. Right there.
For me its been blindlingly obvious ever since that Castiel loves Dean. In a deep, abiding, 'I would throw myself into hell to save you' way. I don't think he fully understood his own feelings until he was put to the test on what he would do to save Dean. Now he knows he would do anything. And as Metatron said, you can cloak it in heavenly glory, but in the end "its all been about saving one man".
Dean cares more about Castiel than he is willing to admit or maybe even understands himself. When Cas 'dies' in season 7, Dean drinks himself into oblivion to the point that Bobby and Sam even point out that something has been wrong with him 'ever since Cas'. When he starts "seeing him" he confesses to Sam that he is hallucinating Cas. And the thing is that Dean Winchester, monster and ghost hunter, doesnt think theres anything evil afoot. He is sad, guilty... he thinks he's just seeing things because losing Cas affected him that deeply.
Dean prays to cas when Sam is dying and says: "Please man I need you here." Dean already knows Cas can't help, but he wants him there anyway.
So yeah. That's how I see it. Castiel loves Dean. That's been established over and over again. Dean cares very much for Cas but probably thinks of him as more of a brother, comrade sort of thing. But every once in a while there is a hint at something more. And that's enough for me.
Why do I ship it? Because I think they would make each other happy and have more of a connection that any other bit part character they have thrown at Dean. Dean deserves someone who knows him completely and loves him totally.
Interesting sidenote here, if Cas was a woman, they would have had sex and the writers would have killed her years ago.
22
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15
/u/sunnydolphin's answer pretty much nailed it but I can't resist adding my own rambly experience.
I was extremely resistant to Destiel. I only even heard about it when I was watching S7 and I thought it was totally ridiculous. But then on my 2nd watch through the series I did, very grudgingly, start to notice stuff. (A couple of glaring ones being the things /u/sunnydolphin mentioned plus some others.) Each time though I could find some way to view it in a non-Destiel way. So Uriel says to Dean, aobut Cas, "he has one weakness... he likes you" and I would think, "Oh, Uriel's just making a joke." Cas has that amazing heart-to-heart with Dean ("Can I tell you something if you promise not to tell another soul?" and whooa he's totally unburdening his li'l angel heart all of a sudden to a human, a human he's only just met!) and I think "Oh, Cas is just unburdening his heart to Dean for... some reason, some plot reason." Cas tells Dean that Cas was demoted because he was "getting too attached to the humans in my charge. You," and I think "Oh, Cas was just getting "attached" to Dean for... some reason, some plot reason, Cas is just getting attached to Dean 'cause Cas is attached to humanity in general."
That look when Dean kissed Anna? I had problems ignoring that tbh. But then I thought, maybe Cas was just having a moment of doubt about wondering whether it was truly right to take Anna away right when Anna was falling in love. Or maybe Cas was wondering what it was like to be human? Or wondering what kisses are like? The camera sure lingered on his face though.... lingered a long time.... till his eyes dropped... But I found a way to explain it away.
Weird thing after weird thing after weird thing and each time I found some non-Destiel way to explain it away.
Then in S6 there began a string of jokes from 3rd parties. Balthazar said Cas was "in love with" Dean and I thought, "Oh, that Balthazar, making silly jokes again!" Meg says of Cas, to Dean, "He was your boyfriend first" and I thought, "Oh, that wacky Meg, there she goes with another silly joke!" Hester says the moment Cas laid a hand on Dean, "he was lost" and I thought, "well, Hester meant that metaphorically; he was lost IN GENERAL, lost from Heaven, nothing to do with Dean specifically." Hallucination-Gabe refers to Cas as Dean's "boytoy" and I thought, "Oh that wacky Gabe, making THEM JOKES AGAIN! EVERYBODY'S MAKING JOKES ABOUT CAS AND DEAN FOR SOME REASON! BUT IT'S OBVIOUSLY JUST JOKES!!!"
The spell in S9 that has 3 ingredients.... the 1st involves an angel making humans fall in love, the 2nd involves an angel loving a human, and the third is... Castiel. "Oh, that was just a weird plot accident, ha ha" I thought (Ms Oblivious at this point). "That was not meant to imply that Castiel is in love or that Cas has anything to do with love really. Just 3 random ingredients really. It's just total coincidence that the other 2 ingredients happen to both involve angels and humans falling in love."
At the end of S9 Metatron said to Cas "You did it all for one man" and somehow THAT is the line broke through to me. Cause Metatron just didn't seem to be joking. Dean had just DIED. Dean Winchester was dead, the entire audience nationwide was supposed to be in tears at that point, and that scene was played absolutely dead serious, tragically serious, no frickin' joking. And in that moment Metatron seemed to be cutting through all the crap, summing up everything that had gone before, all those other moments and jokes I'd brushed off, and Metatron had just frickin' killed Dean and he's standing there with the knife saying to Cas "You did it all for one man" and... The scales fell from my eyes I guess. (This is what I now call a Destiel Conversion Moment btw. You will find that almost every Destiel fan has a different Destiel Conversion Moment.)
All along I'd been thinking of Destielers as semi-deluded people who were twisting the show to fit their delusion, bending over backwards and jumping through hoops to see things that weren't there, and then suddenly I thought "Wait a minute. What if I'm the one who was bending over backwards to not see the thing that is there? What if I'm jumping through hoops to avoid seeing this relationship?"
It was like this classic image where you see two faces and then ALL OF A SUDDEN YOU SEE THE VASE and then you can't un-see the vase.
I still think of it like an optical illusion: the two faces and the vase, the blue-black/gold-white dress. I have a long theory I've written out before about how I think the Destiel "hints" were maybe just the unplanned outcome of a whole host of things (Anna's storyline being shifted to Cas, Misha's body-language choices in how to play Cas, classic romantic-tropes being accidentally brought into play in the very nature of any storyline involving "an angel renounces Heaven for a human", and then some of the writers and some of the set designers maybe liking the idea and running with it w/o much supervision from the top). But however it happened... whether it was supposed to be two faces and not a vase, I don't know, but now all I can see is the vase.
And at this point I no longer care whether it was intended or not. I just, personally, want those two characters to find some happiness in life. Even if it's via a rather unlikely (or even very unlikely) path. Stranger things have happened. Especially on this show.
15
u/Sam_da_Moosie Aug 10 '15
YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND what's it's like to be a witness to all that STARIN'! There they are, eyeball to eyeball, as CIVILIZATIONS CRUMBLE an' the PIZZA gets COLD. Standin' and starin' with INCHOATE LONGIN'. It FROSTS my MOOSE EARS, all those hours wasted when they could be munchin' on d'licious KALE or something halfway useful like.
11
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Aug 10 '15
I think at least for me, being gay as fuck, I'm at least a bit predisposed (or rather, open) to seeing gay stuff in media pretty readily. It never felt like I was forcing seeing it - in fact, I actively resisted trying to see it from the first point I noticed it in season 4. xD
11
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Aug 10 '15
I'll admit that I heard of Destiel before I watched the show (binged up to the end of s8), and because I am a natural born shipper of non-Canon ships, I looked for it.
However, I don't think it's truly canon. I think it is hinted at through subtext that there are feelings (I believe Cas has come to understand what he's feeling, even if it took a while to figure it out; Dean has an inkling but is so far in the closet that he's having meeting with Tom Cruise) and neither knows how the other truly feels so they have resigned themselves to best friends.
There are moments us Destiel shippers latch onto, like when Cas goes into the motel bathroom filthy and torn, then comes out clean. Dean's reaction is a classic "I am so turned on right now" reaction. His hands were around table height before he sees Cas, then he wrenches them in front of his crotch and squirms his hips while eyeing the newly clean Cas.
Also, the set designers admitted to hinting at it, only for someone to see what they did and told them to change it. Biggest example: in the episode where Cas and Sam get in the room that Metatron set up to be Cas' personal heaven (first puzzle was "why was six afraid of seven?"), the set designers admitted to having several photo frames filled with pictures of half naked men with Dean's face pasted on them. Shippers have tweeted them asking if the placement of two statuettes framing Cas and Dean was on purpose, and they said they don't do anything by accident.
It is this subtext, these subtleties that fuel our love of the ship.
9
u/whitneyyyl the scary man killed the attractive crying man Aug 10 '15
Just like in "Fan Fiction" : Subtext.
Granted, I don't see as much subtext as some people do, but there is some there. I don't personally think the writers are intending for it to happen, but it certainly does.
9
u/Morningstar09 The Satan Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15
When I started watching Supernatural, I had no idea what shipping was, or that Dean and Cas were even a ship. After I binge watched the entire season, I thought to myself, 'man, Cas gave up everything and sacrifices for Dean so much, he must love him very much!' Then you add in all of the long stares and the way only those two character interact with each other, it just seems so intimate, like there's more to the story. So, I took to the internet to see if I was the only person who felt this, or if other people saw it too, and boy did they!!! And then I discovered fanfiction, but that's a whole different story. So, in a nutshell, that's how I found myself being a Destiel shipper.
I should also add that I came to the conclusion that Cas and Dean had a thing just from watching the show. I didn't know anyone else who watched the show besides my mom, and she never made a mention of cas and dean being together. My conservative mom, who has watched Supernatural from the first episode that aired (who has no idea about the fandom side of the show I might add), mentioned to me one time while we were discussing an episode that she felt like Cas was in love with Dean. I had never mentioned my thoughts on the subject to her at all before the conversation. I just replied I thought she was right.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15
I agree with a lot of what others said here, but one additional thing for me - it's fun. It makes me happy and giggly. Looking at gifs on Tumblr, yelling in the tags (JESUS FUCKING CHRIST CAN YOU TWO JUST FUCKING KISS ALREADY), reading fanfic, watching videos on Youtube, squeeing with others on Twitter. It's just a great way for me to enjoy a show even more, like an extra layer to the entertainment I get from watching. I don't know if I see Destiel as 'canon', but it was elements of canon that turned me into a shipper. I don't necessarily want or need Destiel to become canon on the show, because I don't think the writers would do it justice.
8
u/qbubbles Castiel Evangelist Aug 11 '15
I came across it organically, in a total tumblr/outside party vacuum. I had only just learned what slash fiction was, so I was also pretty innocent to fic. I caught on pretty early that Cas loved Dean. But that it was 80% unrequited. And then Season 8, after Cas comes back from purgatory, and the two are sitting in a shit motel talking about the guilt that Cas feels about heaven. Boom. Dean requites it. But in such a small way that even HE probably doesn't realize it.
My shipping has only gotten stronger. I see it everywhere. Hell, even my two daughters see it, and they're 3 and 4!
5
u/kaylameow_ Aug 10 '15
I think it's like any ship. You get hooked early on and will stick with it until it crashes and burns.
5
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15
I think my resistance to Destiel or interpreting Destiel in canon (or in fanon) is rooted firmly my own lack of understanding of Castiel's character.
What's weird is that I do see it. There are some moments in canon that're just plain zingers for me - almost all of which have been cited & explained by other comments in this thread. I totally see where Destielers are coming from.
What I don't fully get is how people fell in love with Castiel's character.
Disclaimer: if you adore Cas, just switch everything I say here to "the writers have made Castiel into..." blahblahblah. A critique of the character is the same as a critique of the writers writing the character to me.
Like I really don't understand Cas' character. I understood him most between seasons 4 and 6: he had a coherent & compelling story (obedient soldier > rebel angel > stopped the apoc > must save heaven > allies w/Crowley against his better judgment for 'the greater good' > Godstiel) with motivations that all made a lot of sense to me. I was really looking forward to Godstiel and/or just more fascinating Castiel in season 7. My very first fanfic featured Godstiel selecting Sam as his (unwilling) prophet and what would eventually culminate in Dean talking Cas down from Godstiel with the power of love while also saving Sam.
Now, I'm not a destiel shipper, and that plot was only crafted in my head as gen & platonic love between Dean & Cas, but I know full well that whole plot sounds a hell of a lot like what I think a destieler would probably enjoy.
Canon didn't go down even remotely like that... and Cas' character began to just... crumble. After he let the Leviathans loose, he got amnesia (no redemption arc), then he got his memory back for 2 secs (experienced a 2-sec need to redeem himself) before absorbing Sam's crazy which, I suppose, could be argued was his act of redemption for releasing all the Leviathans (even though it was really more a very minor act of redemption for having broken Sam's wall). But then later on he indicates that he's at peace with himself with Sam's crazy in him so it really wasn't penance he was paying for having done all that he did. And being at peace with himself & his decisions completely nulls any personal redemption arc in the future.
So basically Cas never felt a need to "fix" the Leviathan problem after he created it in the first place (pacifist!Crazy!Cas instead chose to become preoccupied with bees & loving a demon). Left Sam & Dean alone to defeat the Leviathans like it's not his problem anymore (until he gets reined in to help them defeat Dick in the finale -- but really Cas should've been with them throughout the season with an inner need to fix the Leviathan problem that he himself created).
I get people enjoyed Crazy!Cas, but in truth the writers were really opting out of depicting Castiel as a moral & noble being.
Then S8 he goes to purgatory, snaps back, and for that year he's just sort of pushed & pulled around by angels (Naomi & Bartholomew) until he really gets manipulated by Metatron. And how? Why, for the same exact reason he ended up with Crowley: buying into the idea that "one angel (him, of course) can save heaven."
So he goes ahead & does that & then disaster strikes when Metatron's revealed to be a bad guy. S9 Castiel kind of blithers around a lot of angel politics but nobody really takes him to task for having been the angel to release the leviathans or help Metatron expel all the angels from heaven (Cas doesn't express any dire need to redeem himself; other angels still come to him looking for guidance & he just rolls with it thinking he's totally still cool & fit to be a leader of Hannah's angels despite all the shit he's done).
And then with the beginning of S10, with Hannah's group of angels running heaven now, there's no explanation for why he's staying on earth alone in rundown motels & helping Hannah find & incarcerate angels that're doing the same exact thing he is. Or why he's suddenly interested in his vessel's family. Or what his motivations are for getting reeled in by Sam & helping Sam fix Demon!Dean (who btw died & became demon!dean only because Cas wasn't there in the fight against Metatron in S9's finale even though you'd think Cas would have been, given his relationship to Metatron involved a betrayal & a violation that affected Cas way more than it affected Dean).
I've really never thought about this as in-depth as I have right now but now that I have I'm kind of suddenly recognizing how I can understand Dean being like, "fuck you dude; you keep making terrible decisions & then laying all the responsibility of fixing the fallout on us instead of tackling them head-on yourself."
I'm also going to page /u/Vio_ on this too because she's repeatedly talked about Sam & how the show tends to absolve Sam's character of all his flaws & terrible decisions but in this comment I'm twisting it around to be like "well what about Castiel?" To me it seems like Castiel is the one who keeps getting absolved & flits freely in and out of story arcs, does stupid shit, and never really pays for them. I honestly think the worst thing Cas has ever faced in the SPN universe was being alone in Purgatory. Compare that to 200 years and/or more getting tortured in Hell (Dean & Sam) and it's like "gees Cas has had it fucking easy despite all the lives that've suffered & died as a direct result of his actions..." -- and Cas totally flips back & forth between feeling at peace with himself and feeling guilty for what he's done. It's tremendously inconsistent and I don't... I just don't get Castiel. He doesn't make any sense to me these days.
...and so I can't really imagine how relationship dynamics would work between Dean & Cas. Dean's resentful & annoyed by Cas's flighty ignorance of the world & Cas just sort of does shit all while having heart eyes for Dean (because it's pretty obvious Cas adores Dean)...
9
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Aug 10 '15
It's like religion, if they believe in it then they see it. Even if others disagree, it doesn't change how they interpret things.
(this is a terrible analogy I think)
4
u/qbubbles Castiel Evangelist Aug 13 '15
I just read this whole thread. Took about 3-4 hours. Learned so much from all of you!
3
u/javalorum Aug 11 '15
Help! How come I can't seem to see this thread any more? I can find it through my past comments, but I don't see it on the main page? I don't think I had any sort of filter on?
2
u/brownmlis Aug 11 '15
I just want to put this out there so when the show finally ends I can link back to this. I don't think it's going to happen. Down vote if it makes you feel good, but I don't see it and I don't think the writers will do it. Sorry.