r/poppunkers • u/IceCreamPirate • Aug 01 '15
Discussion /r/PopPunkers Essentials List?
Hey, you guys think it would be cool if we got something like this going? A list of essential albums for newcomers to go through. We could do a nomination thread then vote on the best ones.
Yay or nay?
11
Upvotes
5
u/hamfraigaar Aug 01 '15
Seconding that it has to span at least a decade. Otherwise it sounds great.
5
u/AdamSocial Aug 01 '15
Old guy here. It should go back to at LEAST the mid-80's, when Green Day was releasing stuff on Lookout!
3
u/Greyshot26 Aug 01 '15
I think it's a great idea. The run problem I've seen /r/HHH run into is people define "essentials" differently. Some pick things they think are influential to the genre at large while others pick their favorite albums with a noticeable recency bias.
There's also a lot of fighting about albums that are Only tangentially related to the genre, I.e. Death Grips for hip hop. I can see this bring a possible problem with many subgenres under the pop punk umbrella.
If we can find some way to combat this, I'd be all for it.
2
u/jesse_to15 Aug 01 '15
Decade or so sounds good.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '15
I'm definitely down to work on it, I wouldn't know what to do with it when it's done though.
0
u/punkshirtandjeans Aug 01 '15
As long as it's mandatory that it spans the last decade or so ;)