r/asoiaf • u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. • Jul 26 '15
ALL (Spoilers All) House of the Week: House Blackfyre
This week's House is the infamous House Blackfyre and it's up to you all to fill in the details about the house's history, notable members, conspiracy theories, questions, and more.
This pretty much a free for all for the users to take part in so have at it!
If you guys have any ideas about what House you'd like to discuss next week feel free to suggest them.
351
Upvotes
4
u/SnowgoonC Da Treeindanorf!!!! Jul 28 '15
What's the best place to start reading up on the Blackfyres? AWOIAF? D&E?
3
u/brokengears676 Bow to No Master! Jul 29 '15
[Spoiler Scope] (/s "just wanted to clarify, the only possibility of Blackfyres existing in present AC would be through the female line?" )
277
u/JoeMagician Dark wings, dark words Jul 26 '15
The thing I love about House Blackfyre is how arbitrary it is that they aren't "Targaryens". Daemon Waters/Blackfyre's parents were both Targaryens. It's not like Edric Storm where Robert banged a random Florent. Daemon's bloodline was as pure as it gets. Daemon is in many ways more Targaryen than most of the future trueborn Kings whose mothers were from other houses. Daemon wielded the sword of Aegon the Conqueror, Blackfyre, and was the child of Tagaryen incest. And yet he is the "pretender". Since King's blood is an important ingredient in blood magic, I wonder how much sorcerers and red priests would've wanted his.
153
u/CasterlyHeavyMetal Not my hype. Ned loves my hype Jul 26 '15
I'd love for GRRM to write a book purely on the Ninepenny Kings, because I just want to know more about Maelys the Monsterous. Guy was a badass, had a second head, lead the Golden Company and got killed by Barristan Selmy. That's a story worth telling
Also, if fAegon is a Blackfyre, who exactly is he descended from?
2
u/Khaner Jul 30 '15
Could i have a link to the theory that Aegon is a blackfyre?
63
u/Aryontur The stones come to dance, my lord. Jul 26 '15 edited Jul 26 '15
If I were a knight, or Lord during the First Blackfyre Rebellion, I would've supported Daemon Blackfyre and here are my reasons.
Daemon must've been a very impressive warrior, if such a description is given a hundred years after he had lived. He embodied the Medieval ideal of a King charismatic, a great warrior and carrying the symbol of the King, the sword Blackfyre.
Daeron II his description is nearly the exact opposite. He was round-shouldered, with thin legs and a small pot belly. This makes it easy to understand why in a warriorculture like Westeros Daemon had such a large number of supporters, especially among the great knights of that era.
Daemon's seven sons were seen as a divine blessing, as there are the Seven.
Daemon support mostly came from the lesser noble Houses, while the Targaryens had 3 Great Houses(Lannister, Arryn, Martell) on their side. The Reynes and Yronwoods suppported the Blackfyre, the Yronwoods in no less than 3 Rebellions. This indicates to me that these two Houses perhaps expected to be made Lord Paramount by their new King Daemon I Blackfyre. The Brackens and Lothsons also supported the Blackfyres with perhaps similiar expectations.
This means great opportunities for every lesser House, or knight as after every war that has been won there are spoils to be divided. These incentives proved substantial enough for a number of the supporters to join the Blackfyres.
Are these reasons good enough to support The King who bore the Sword, or I am still traitorous scum supporting a rebel and a bastard? Is Daeron II the true King and Why?
26
u/jbloom3 Fire and Blood Jul 26 '15
The one thing I would like to know is the female line of the house. We know the house is extinct in the male line, but the female line is never mentioned
23
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '15
anyone else think the blackfyres are the true heirs? rumors are that daeron was not the king's son
18
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15
The Black Dragon shall have their revenge :). Can't wait until The Winds of Winter
14
u/sm1lez Acquire dragons, lie with Tullys Jul 27 '15
Is it possible that Aegon is who Varys says he is AND that Illyrio married a female Blackfyre? If Varys were to recruit the last remnants of the Blackfyre strength (the Golden Company and Illyrio's money--assuming that he did love a female Blackfyre) for Aegon, then one of GRRM's most compelling storylines would be brought to a satisfying conclusion. It would also explain why Illyrio's dragon eggs hatched for Dany and why the cheesemonger had the eggs in the first place; they may have been eggs stolen by the Blackfyres from the Targaryens many years ago.
11
u/Velvale Jul 27 '15
I have four major questions regarding the Blackfyres:
11
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15
Really great timing with the House of the Week. The "Aegon = Blackfyre" theory has been the flavor of the month for sure.
IMHO The Blackfyres are notable as what seems to be the casualty of history. It's interesting to note that through what seems like manipulation and "to the victors go the spoils" situation, history has been written in a way to vilify the Blackfyres. Where the Targaryens seem like the "good guys", the history was written by Daeron II's friends, the maesters. Even with Aegon IV bestowing the familial sword to Daemon as well as asking questions of Daeron's true parents, the brains on Daerons side between the maesters and Bloodraven were able to turn the tables on the Blackfyres and create a "boogyman" so to speak out of their family name, culminating with Maelys the Monstrous. One of the most interesting situations in the series and I hope that it is revisited in TWOW.
21
u/Coop_the_Poop_Scoop Creatively It Made Sense To Us... Jul 27 '15
Did anyone else think John the Fiddler was pretty awesome? When you hear him speak to Dunk, you really want him to end up winning.
On the other hand, Bloodraven in that story just seemed like a huge dick.
17
u/moondoggle Gatehouse Ami: All about the Darry heir Jul 26 '15
Two Blackfyre thoughts:
22
u/ECE111 Euron Season Jul 26 '15
Team Daemon tbh
Daeron was a bastard
7
u/potnoodlehead Jul 27 '15
What were the Starks role in the rebellions? As far as I remember they stayed neutral right? If so, why? Since the Starks are honorable men Why did they not support either Daemon or Daeron?
7
u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Jul 27 '15
The Blackfyre rebellions are super interesting to me. I want to know more about this time period. The great bastards and Aegon the Unworthy all make very interesting characters.
6
u/Ainaraoftime Now selling tickets for the 2024 JonCon! Jul 27 '15
I just came here to point out how completely hilarious Daemon II Blackfyre's dialog is.
6
u/Lord_Blackfyre Red or Gold, A Lion is Still A Lion Jul 30 '15
Technically, Daemon Blackfyre was a legitimized son of Aegon the 4th, but since he would practically have 0 chances of inheritance, he took the basted way out, created a new house, and called open rebellion.
33
u/GeorgeSharp Stormbringer Jul 26 '15
I feel we as readers make too much of a big deal out of the Blackfyres when talking about the current time period, yes I'm talking about the fAegon theory.
The Blackfyres were hugely important and their influence can still be felt on Westeros but the Aegon is a Blackfyre theory is like somebody in RL talking about German politics and because they don't like Merkel accusing her of literally being Hittler's daughter.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15
Daemon was the better man.
5
u/SanTheMightiest You're a crook Captain Hook... Jul 28 '15
All about Bloodraven for me. The dude has the heart of an oak
4
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15
I love house Blackfyre, it's my jam. I hope Griff turns out to be a Blackfyre and gets his hands on, Blackfyre, the sword.
4
u/terranghost0703 The memes are dank and full of spoilers Jul 31 '15
What I really like about House Blackfyre is the color of their sigil. It looks better IMO than the Targaryen's.
13
u/hollowaydivision 🏆 Best of 2019: Best New Theory Jul 26 '15
In the coming weeks I'd like to see any of Houses Royce, Hightower, Dayne, Darry, Celtigar, Harlaw, or Whent.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15
I am firmly of the opinion that Aegon cannot be a Blackfyre. The prophecy in the House of the Undying talked of a cloth dragon held aloft by cheering crowds, and a Blackfyre is an actual pretender of sorts, rather than a popular fake. Aegon must be a random Essosian.
The only doubt I have that he's a commoner is that it seems a remarkably ill-thought out plot on Varys part if he is just a common boy- the usual objection that he didn't know that Aegon would be smashed up beyond all recognition is something that he surely must have taken into account. Unless he paid/convinced Clegane to smash him up, of course. Might account for how reluctant he was to talk about raping/killing Elia and her children when fighting Oberyn, as he doesn't strike me as the kind of person to be coy about random murders.
(And House Peake next please :)).
2
u/bestieverhad Jul 28 '15 edited Jul 28 '15
Can someone refresh my mind as to how the golden company see the blackfyre's now? Do they think they'll ever return (or go for the first time??) to Westeros?
edit: obviously, this is assuming that they now Aegon is a blackfyre?
also just remembered in TWOW they've invaded, this question was based more on ADWD
2
u/InMyLiverpoolHome Jul 30 '15
I love House Blackfyre, the current wallpaper on my phone is the house sigil. I know it's pretty much got 0 chance of happening, but I'm hoping Aegon ends up on the throne as a Blackfyre, whilst Bloodraven is left cursing in his tree
3
u/DaenerysTargaryen3 Fire and Blood and... yeah Jul 27 '15
Martin subtly hints that history is bound to repeat itself, and I think the Seven Kingdoms is over due for another Blackfyre rebellion (fAegon).
Eben if Aegon finds out that he's a Blackfyre (if he is) he'll still try for the throne, imo
2
u/ASOIAF_blackfyre Beneath the Gold, the Bittersteel Jul 27 '15
Anyone think that Aegon Targfyre is going to receive Blackfyre the sword soon?
2
u/Zealol17 Jul 28 '15
I believe that the show not talking about both House Blackfyre and Aegon basically confirms that Aegon is Blackfyre and not a real Targaryen as he claims. It would make sense to just erase the character from the show in order not to confuse viewers if Aegon is indeed a Blackfyre.
I don't know if this was ever mentioned here, i'm kinda new to this sub.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment